Published on BigCloset TopShelf (http://vfront05.qnez.net/topshelf)

Home > Maryanne Peters > Countering Celibacy

Countering Celibacy

Author: 

  • Maryanne Peters

Audience Rating: 

  • Mature Subjects (pg15)

Publication: 

  • Short-short < 500 words

Genre: 

  • Transgender

Character Age: 

  • Teenage or High School

TG Themes: 

  • Reluctant

TG Elements: 

  • Estrogen / Hormones

Permission: 

  • Posted by author(s)

Countering Celibacy
The Short Story
By Maryanne Peters

It all started in school, when I transferred to High School a little too young. It is a time when all boys are just becoming men, and when it is becoming apparent what kind of man you are likely to become. It is a terrible time for young men, which is what we are supposed to be, rather than children. I think that it is fair to say that it is made much worse the internet and by social media.

I am not even sure where the concept of “Incels” came from, but I have heard that it was first coined by a woman to describe pathetic men. That makes it even worse, because almost every man would be horrified by the idea of being pathetic or doomed to be “involuntarily celibate”.

The crazy thing is that the notion hits people before they even know what celibacy means. Boys around the age of 13 or 14 are not sexually active, even though they are of an age to know a lot about it. How can you even determine who will be unable to find a sexual partner?

But, we live in an age of bullying. Social media is great at building groups, and having people included or excluded. Most boys crave inclusion, and exclusion can drive them to depression and much worse. But to say that you are doomed to a life of loneliness and zero sex is an even bigger blow.

The whole idea is fueled by the idea that only a small number of men are sexually desirable to most women. I have heard that the idea comes from nature. Most mammals live in herds or packs, with a dominant male mating with a group of females. That means that animal incels roam the wilderness waiting for a chance to dominate that will never come.

This is the notion of the alpha male - sexually confident, dominant and attractive to women. Other males are submissive or thrown out, or both. They are the beta males. As children, young males may remain within the herd but then they must be chased out so as not to interfere with the alpha.

We can all think of alpha males, or those who aspire to be one. The internet is full of images of what a real man looks like, and how any man can be one by exercising with weights and consuming supplements. It was not for me, or at least not then. I was the youngest in my class because I was too clever to be with kids my age. Even for the age I was, I was a late developer physically. I was small and slightly built. But I was a thinker. I was left to think about where I could fit into the world. It seemed doubtful that I would ever be an alpha male.

For others in my class, to be told by trolls, or worse still, by the prettiest girls in class, that you would never have a girlfriend, was more than they could bear. Even before a boy is sexually active, he knows the social consequences of being an incel, doomed to jack off over porn and lead a sad and sorry life without the female partner he desires. For some of these incels it has led to hate for women – perhaps even thoughts of violence. For others it led to a crushing depression. It seemed that so many young men were being criticized for not living up to a masculine ideal. The internet can be a curse for the victims of these kinds of pressures, but I was different.

As a thinker, rather than seeking inclusion, I understood the benefits of isolation. For thinkers being alone can be productive and the internet is not the enemy, but a resource. I needed to understand the problem and look for solutions.

Quite by chance I discovered an article called “Why are Incels turning themselves into women?” I was not even aware that anybody was doing that, but I went through the material and followed all the links that supported what might be called “The Transmaxxing Thesis”. It is a very simple proposition – women don’t want you, so if you can’t beat ‘em, join ‘em.

There were examples of successful transmaxxers to be found – men like me, slightly built and not at all masculine, who could through drugs and behavior modification, become women (of a sort) and enjoy all the pleasures that real women might, including being admired and desired, but not necessarily by women. Even a thinker wants that – to be admired and desired. Does it really matter who does the admiring and desiring.

It was not that I was transgender, but as one of the transmaxxers pointed out, it was better to be transgender than to be a failed male. Failed males just face derision on all sides, where people who suffer from gender dysphoria evoke sympathy in the main. In many ways, attractive trans-people can enjoy all the benefits of being female while avoiding some of the less appealing consequences, meaning menstruation and pregnancy. As infertile women, that can even be an advantage for some men.

So, there was still the question of sex. Transmaxxers spoke about “extracting resources from men” meaning receiving gifts for favors, and that presumed one of those favors might be sexual intercourse. Their answer was simple – what is wrong with receiving anal sex? It can be rewarding for both parties, so it was said, once the body is prepared.

I read all of this with wry interest, but I was not about to do any of it, right up until Carl Harper killed himself. Carl was a lot like me in many ways – small and gentle, shy and quiet, but bullied mercilessly. Perhaps it will be clear to you that I was too busy or too analytical to be affected, but Carl was kind and sensitive. He was a good person. He felt things. He decided that he could not face the joyless life that the bullies told him was inevitable. Carl genuinely believed what the bullies said about him – that no girl would ever be interested in a loser, so he was doomed to be alone – looked over in favor of alpha males.

From the moment of his death, I decided to become a girl, not just for my own future, but to show those around me that there was another way out of this oppression by worthier men. Perhaps there was another motivation as well, to say something to the bullies who had effectively killed Carl, but that only really came into focus later.

When you think about it, what is the downside for a so-called beta man choosing a new gender? You are still you, even if you present as a woman. You still have your mind, but you now have a chance ti share it with somebody who cares about you. You don’t even have to have relationships with men, if you prefer being a lesbian. The key is that you are no longer competing with the alphas, so (unless they want to date you) they can leave you alone. Even if you are not a winner like them, you are no longer a loser. If alphas want women, then a beta living as a woman is not competition, and may even be of passing sexual interest. If not, then there is nothing to be gained in attacking “her” – alphas ought toi be indifferent.

I had to explain my actions to my parents. I simply told them that I was “exploring gender fluidity” and referred them to material on that. It seemed unnecessary to even mention incels or transmaxxers. My parents never really tried to understand me, but my father always said that he thought that I was smart enough to make it in the world, however I decided to do that.

I decided that I would give myself a feminine name and I chose Elizabeth so that I could be Beth or Bette, in a nod to being beta. I was quite prepared to be an ordinary looking girl, so I guess that I was a bit surprised when I followed all the feminizing tips on the internet only to discover that I could actually be very pretty.

When I first searched for “feminization” online I was simply staggered by the quantity of material available. It seemed as if half the planet wanted to know how a man could successfully pass as a woman. There was certainly more than I needed to get started.

Being slow to puberty I had little body hair and what I had could easily be dealt with by plucking or waxing. My own hair could be easily grown, and I would need to adopt a good skin regime, but first I had to face the decision about hormones. I researched it and I decided that I would take the estrogen and the androgen blockers that I could acquire through the dark web. It seemed that I was uniquely advantaged in having reached the junction of secondary sexual characteristics and I could choose to pull the lever and change track to the female line. The male line would still be open to me, at least for a while.

When I first came out at school I decided to disclose that I was “probably transgender and transtioning to female”. I toyed with the idea of disclosing my true status as a transmaxxer, but it seemed to me that I opened myself up to abuse if I did. Instead, I only disclosed that to a few friends of Carl Harper – people that I thought might be similarly distressed by their situation. It was my way of showing them that there was a way out – a strange one perhaps, but better than self-harm.

I asked everybody to call me “Beth” and refer to me as she or her. I got some abuse, but somehow it was nothing quite as bad as the selected incels would get. That would be their lot for their entire time at school, but for me things changed as I got prettier.

I assiduously followed all those feminizing tips about the way I behaved and how I presented myself. I took care of my growing hair and my changing body, and I put these things on display. I learned about makeup, and I also learned that I quite liked playing around with it, just as I did with clothing. There is something about letting your mood choose your color scheme and building just the right look, even if it takes some time in the morning. I guess that I discovered an artistic outlet in self-adornment.

I started on female hormones that I obtained after just one therapy session where I parroted the classic symptoms of gender dysphoria. I soon noticed the effect on my body. The Transmaxxer thesis put some stock in the value in acquiring feminine sexual sensitivity - the idea is that you lose potency but acquire more points of stimulation. As I had never been interested in masturbation in the past, I certainly felt sexual arousal happening more regularly, not just from my nipples but from my smooth and softer skin.

I had heard that transmaxxers might enjoy better treatment socially as women, or even just as transwomen. I certainly hoped to receive better treatment (or preferably no treatment at all) from the alpha male bullies, but I did notice that attitudes towards me became more positive. I had always adopted the nerd strategy of staying under the radar, but now as a student in transition to female that was no longer possible. I was “out there” and I was surprised at the level of sympathetic support I received from teachers and other staff, and from female students and even from a large number of male students. Some even called me “true to yourself” or even “courageous”. This kind of admiration I had never experienced before. It made me feel positive about myself, and it seemed to affirm the decision that I had made.

One other person fingered as an incel decided to follow my lead, but I suspected that he might be gay so perhaps it would be easier for him. For myself, I had always assumed that I would be heterosexual so that receiving sex from a male would be unpleasant if it proved necessary. The transmaxxing thesis simply assumes that we should be able to cope in that event. If not, then there are lesbians and translesbians out there.

But as I became friendly with supportive women, most of whom assumed that I would be as interested in men as they were, it seemed as if I came to share their thoughts. I even found myself sharing their admiration for the very thing that I thought I despised - alpha males. It all seemed to prove the point that transmaxxers were making – desirable girls want alpha men. Lesser men are better off as girls.

Or perhaps it was a side effect of the hormones? I certainly felt different – more emotional perhaps, even to the extent of having quiet moments of happiness without any particular reason for feeling that way.

But the whole thing about men was difficult to understand. The so-called incels so wanted women that in being rejected they became women haters instead of hating the men who took all the women. I now found that in accepting that I could find a tolerable beta role in being at least the semblance of a woman, I was now attracted to the very people who had forced me into this situation.

One man in particular I found myself drawn to. He was one of those boys who had said that because it was accident birth that I was born male, post transition I deserved to be treated as female. As a joke I said – “Okay, if you mean that ask me out on a date!”

I was not really expecting him to do anything like that. He seemed like a nice guy who would say nice things but who could probably have had anybody in school if he wanted to – an alpha male but not an aggressive one. But he asked me out, right there on the spot.

I told myself that he was just being kind and that he could never be truly attracted to me, but I made a special effort to look really good for him, if only so that he would not be embarrassed to be seen with me.

As we sat across the table of a small restaurant I looked up and I could see him looking at me. I think that people just know what true desire looks like. I smiled and he smiled back. I think that he was as surprised as I was. I said something about knowing that I was “incomplete” and not being able to offer him everything that he wanted.

“There are surrogates and stuff, and even adoption,” he said.

I mean, I was talking about not having a vagina and he was talking about things that would assume that we were married and starting a family! I must have looked at him a little strangely because it seemed like he realized what he had said and muttered something to unwind it. I was not really listening. I had already heard his heart speak.

I told him that I would feel terrible if I was responsible for denying him everything a man should want, and he said that he already had what he wanted, and he reached out and took my hand. I just started to cry, and I am not even sure why.

I guess that I realized in that moment that I had become a woman. It seems so crazy to say that. Like I said, I had always regarded myself as a thinker. That was my defense against everything. That was where this whole transmaxxxing thing came from. It seemed to have worked, proving that my analysis of my situation and my radical solution, were both right. Now it seemed as if that solution had lost me my reason.

A male, presumably a heterosexual one, cannot simply become a heterosexual woman simply by choice and application of a few internet memes. But here I was, a girl in love.

It is even hard to think about it now. Thinking was what I did, but now I am more interested in feeling, and I was feeling things very deeply. I even started to wonder if I had lost my senses completely. All he needed to do was to hold me in a particular way and I felt as if nothing else mattered. And if he really wanted to thrill me, he just needed to put himself inside my body and I belonged to him.

I am not sure if this was what transmaxxing was supposed to be. It was phrased as a rational choice to overcome what might be called a disability – not being enough of a man to overcome involuntary celibacy. It was supposed to be a way of escaping the bull run by stopping being a bull.

Anyway, the surgery is all arranged, and he is paying. I supposed that means that from then on I will not be a transmaxxer, or perhaps I never was one? One thing is for sure and that is that I will never be celibate – not ever.

The End
2915

output (1).jpg

Author’s note: I wrote a short story on this subject called “Transmaxxing”, but I was concerned that not enough of it was about the pernicious thing in calling out pubescent boys as being Incels. That came to light when I watched a TV show exploring the subject, and prompted me to write this … with a happy ending.

(c) Maryanne Peters 2026


Source URL:http://vfront05.qnez.net/topshelf/fiction/112435/countering-celibacy