
Adrianna Moore writes bestselling erotica, which would be a lot more impressive if she could actually write anything at all right now. Months of staring at a blank page later, her editor ships her off to an island resort with one instruction: be a person, and the words will follow.

Before we get to the story, I want to take a moment to properly acknowledge the people who, in one form or another, have helped keep this story going. It's not entirely finished yet — I'm working hard to get there — but it wouldn't have made it this far without them.
Emma Anne Tate. You are one of the kindest people I have ever met in my life. And I say that knowing that all I know you through is a tiny profile picture on BCTS and our numerous conversations via DM or via email, which somehow makes it more remarkable, not less. When I posted my first story on the site, you were the first person to leave a comment. Not just once — you kept going, every part, every chapter. Then the second story — which, for the record, I'm not entirely proud of right now — was something you responded to just as positively, and that meant more than I knew how to say at the time. And now here you are, beta reading for me, giving me feedback that is so generous and so encouraging that I keep asking myself whether I actually deserve all of this. I don't know how to thank you enough. I'm not sure enough exists. But I need you to know that your presence in this journey has been a gift, and I feel genuinely blessed to have met you.
Rachel Moore. You were one of the next people, after Ms. Tate, who made me feel like I actually belonged on BCTS. You and Ms. Tate are very different people, but you are just as warm, just as fun, and someone I could connect with on a personal level almost immediately. And you were the one who kept saying you'd happily beta read anything I sent your way. Not once — you kept offering, unprompted, until I finally took you up on it. I am so glad I did, because I need to be honest about something: I don't think this story survives without you. Not the way it is now. Your feedback, your energy, your willingness to show up and help when I wasn't sure the story was worth it — that is what kept me going when I was ready to quit. So thank you, so so much, chica.
Natasha Black. You've been through so much with me. We talk about stories constantly and it never stops being fun — the back and forth, the theory-crafting, the wild ideas for different kinds of stories I wanted to try and for your own series on FictionMania. You've been a sounding board, a co-conspirator, and a friend through all of it. I truly could not have asked for a better one.
Blake Ashford. You are forever my mentor and my dear friend. You have always been patient. You have always listened — whether it was about writing, about stories, or about the personal stuff that had nothing to do with either. You guided me and calmed me down when I really needed it, and you were the one who told me to push my first story, TGIU, out into the world after a six-year gap — the worst case of writer's block I wouldn't wish on anybody. That push changed everything. I wouldn't be writing this acknowledgement if you hadn't given me that one.
Thank you to all of you for being who you are, and for helping me through this journey of telling stories for someone — or, well, everyone — out there to enjoy.
This story almost didn't happen. Which, if you know anything about how my brain works, is probably not surprising.
I was working on something else — a slow-burn erotica piece that I'd even announced publicly. I was going to release it. It was going to be great. And then, the way these things sometimes go, it just… wasn't. The inspiration didn't fade gradually or give me a polite two-weeks' notice. It just packed its bags one morning and left without a forwarding address. I sat with it for a while, tried to resuscitate it, and eventually had to admit that the story wasn't broken — it was done. Not finished. Just done with me. So I shelved it and tried not to think about what that meant.
Then one day, uninvited and at the worst possible time, a new idea showed up.
Two characters. Complete opposites. The kind of dynamic that was dangerously close to romantic comedy territory, which was a problem because I had never written a romantic comedy in my life. Erotica was what I knew. Erotica was what I was comfortable with.
But the idea wouldn't leave. It started at a wedding — two people who couldn't stand each other, stuck in each other's orbit. The conflict was there, the chemistry was there, but the main character was just… someone with an ordinary job, and I couldn't figure out what made her tick. I had a meet-cute that kept replaying in my head — this one specific moment that I knew had to be in the story — but it wasn't clicking with the setting. The pieces were all on the table and none of them fit together.
Then — and I genuinely cannot tell you how this happened — my brain, which has a well-documented history of going completely off the rails, asked: What if she's an erotica author?
The wedding setting didn't survive the revelation. My brain, having already committed to chaos, went further: What if it's a vacation? An island resort? What if she doesn't even want to go?
And that was it. That was the story.
Except — and I cannot stress this enough — knowing what the story was did not mean I was confident I could actually go through with it. I wanted it to be funny. Not just warm or charming, but genuinely funny. And that terrified me.
I'm going to be honest with you: I gave up on this story more than once. I hit walls. I got sick in the middle of drafting. It wasn't anything serious, just enough to knock the momentum out from under me, and once you stop moving it's dangerously easy to start wondering whether the whole thing was a mistake.
But somehow, chapter by chapter, it kept going. And when I had enough of it written to feel like it might actually be something, I did the scariest thing a writer can do — I gave it to other people to read.
Ms. Emma Anne Tate and Ms. Rachel Moore, my beta readers, are the reason this story made it as far as it has. Though it's still not finished. Their feedback gave me the confidence to believe the story was worth improving. I owe them more than I can put into words.
So here it is. Plot Twist in Paradise. A story I almost didn't write, in a genre I'd never tried, about a character who can't write — which, in hindsight, feels like exactly the kind of irony my brain would find hilarious.
I hope you give it a chance. I hope it makes you laugh. I hope it makes you feel something. And I would love to hear what you think. Stories don't really exist until someone reads them, and I'm grateful you're all here.
Thank you for everything.
P.S. Chapter 1 drops tomorrow. Saturday. And I'm nervous as f—
*play funny instrumental theme song*

This one is for everyone who's ever had the whole story living rent-free in their head — every scene, every line, every beat — and then opened a blank document and suddenly couldn't remember a single word of it.
For those of you who've been having a rough go of it lately. And for those of you who've been on the shit end of the stick long enough to start wondering if maybe the stick only has the one end. It doesn't. The other end is coming. It's just taking the scenic route.
This is for you.
I woke up the way I always did — badly.
Not dramatically. No nightmares, no cold sweats, no falling off the bed in a tangle of sheets like some romantic comedy protagonist who was about to meet the love of their life at a farmers' market. Just the slow, grinding return to consciousness that came from staying up until 3 a.m., staring at an empty Word document, and then lying in bed for another hour thinking about all the words you didn't put in it.
My phone said almost ten. The sun was doing its best to get through the blinds, which I'd bought specifically because the listing said "total blackout" and which had never, not once, blacked out a single thing. Fraudulent blinds. I should have left a review.
I sat up, scrubbed a hand over my face, and caught a glimpse of myself in the mirror across the room. Adrian Moore, ladies and gentlemen. Twenty-eight years old. Hair doing something unfortunate from the pillow. Old t-shirt with a coffee stain that I was fairly sure was from two days ago but might have been from last week — the full portrait of a bestselling author at the height of their creative powers.
I padded to the kitchen in boxers and that same stained shirt, because mornings didn't require dignity, and started the coffee machine. My apartment was a study in contradictions — or, less charitably, a mess with good taste. The living room had a velvet loveseat I'd spent way too much money on, positioned next to a side table currently buried under unopened mail, three empty La Croix cans, and a paperback I'd been "almost finished with" for six weeks. The bookshelves were styled — genuinely styled, I'd spent a whole Sunday on them — but the kitchen counter looked like a crime scene if the crime was "person who keeps buying groceries and then ordering Thai food instead."
I leaned against the counter while the coffee machine did its thing and scrolled my phone with the glazed focus of someone who wasn't really awake yet but needed the simulation of activity.
Fourteen new emails. Most of them from my publisher's mailing list, a couple from brands wanting to know if I'd be interested in "a collaboration opportunity" which was corporate speak for "post about our product for less money than you'd think." One from my aunt Karen with the subject line "Saw your book mentioned on the internet!!" — two exclamation marks, which for Aunt Karen was practically a standing ovation. I'd read that one later. Or possibly never.
The coffee machine beeped. I poured a cup, added enough cream to make a barista cry, and took the first sip standing up because sitting down felt like a commitment to the day that I wasn't ready to make.
I ate breakfast the way I ate most meals alone — standing at the counter, scrolling my phone, consuming something that technically qualified as food. Today it was toast with peanut butter, because I'd forgotten to buy eggs again. I'd also forgotten to buy milk, dish soap, and the specific brand of conditioner that my hair had decided was the only acceptable option after I'd made the mistake of buying it once. My grocery list existed as a note on my phone that I updated religiously and then left at home every single time I went to the store. The system was flawless.
The toast was slightly burnt on one side because the toaster had a personal vendetta against even browning, and the peanut butter was the fancy kind that separated if you looked at it wrong, so the first bite was mostly oil and sadness. I ate it anyway, standing at the counter in my boxers with one hip against the edge, scrolling through Twitter with the specific posture of someone who knew they looked like a disaster and was choosing not to care. Fine. It was fine. I wasn't performing for anyone.
This was what I looked like when no one was around. Adrian. Not in some grand philosophical sense — I didn't wake up and think ah yes, now I am in my masculine presentation, how fascinating for my sense of self. It wasn't that deliberate. It was just that alone, with nowhere to be and no one to see me, this was where I started. Hair unbrushed, jaw rough, body moving through the apartment in a way that was functional rather than considered. Not thinking about how I looked or how I carried myself because the only audience was the toaster, and it already hated me.
I finished the toast, washed it down with coffee, and headed for the shower.
The bathroom mirror was fogged by the time I got out, which was a kindness I hadn't asked for. I wiped a stripe through the condensation with my palm and looked at the face underneath. Same face. Always the same face. It was just a question of what I was going to do with it.
Some days the answer was "nothing." Some days Adrian stuck around, and that was fine — jeans, a plain tee, minimal effort, maximum comfort. Those days had their own ease to them, a kind of off-duty looseness that I genuinely liked. But today wasn't one of those days. Today I could feel it — that particular itch at the back of my brain, the one that wasn't about dysphoria and everything to do with wanting. Wanting to be seen a certain way. Wanting the mirror to show me the version of myself that felt most like the point.
I wrapped the towel around myself, wiped the rest of the mirror clear, and got to work.
I had a system. Not the kind of system you see in YouTube tutorials with seventeen steps and a ring light — just a routine that I'd built over years of practice, trial and error, a brief and regrettable period of orange foundation, and the slow accumulation of products that actually worked versus products that were beautiful in the store and betrayed me at home.
Foundation first. I'd been doing this long enough that the steps were automatic — primer, a light-coverage foundation because I wasn't building a mask; I was just evening the terrain. Concealer under the eyes because 3 a.m. had opinions about my under-eye situation, and I was overruling them. I worked it in with a sponge, blending at the jawline with the focused calm of someone defusing a bomb. This part was meditative. No music, no podcast, just the quiet focus of turning raw material into something deliberate.
Eyebrows next. Mine were decent on their own — one of the few genetic gifts I wasn't going to argue with — but a little pencil work gave them the kind of arch that said I have thoughts and they're sharper than yours. Eyeshadow was minimal today, just a wash of warm bronze across the lids and a thin line of brown along the lash line. Not dramatic. Not yet. The day hadn't earned dramatic.
Mascara. Blush — just a touch, swept across the cheekbones and blended up toward the temples so it looked like I'd been mildly complimented rather than painted. Lips were a tinted balm in a shade the brand called "Desert Rose" which was a very poetic way of describing "your lips but like they've been gently bitten."
I looked at the mirror. Getting there.
The hair took longer than any of it. I had good hair — thick, cooperative when it wanted to be, a length that sat just past my shoulders and could be convinced into a few different shapes depending on the day. Today I worked some product through it, let it fall into loose waves, and pinned one side back with a clip that was subtle enough to not look like a statement but intentional enough to not look accidental. The kind of thing where if someone said "I like your hair clip" you could say "oh, this?" as if you hadn't spent four minutes placing it.
Then the clothes. This was the part people assumed was frivolous, and maybe it was, but it was also the part where everything clicked. I stood in front of the closet — which was organized by color because I was that person and I was not apologizing for it — and let the day tell me what it wanted.
The rust-colored silk blouse first — the one with a neckline that showed collarbone without trying too hard — and the cream wide-legs that made my legs look like they went on for longer than they strictly did. A thin gold chain, lying flat. Small gold hoops, the pair I reached for when I wanted to feel put together without announcing it.
I slid into all of it like stepping into a warmer room. It wasn't that Adrian was cold. It was just that Adrianna was the temperature I wanted to be today.
I looked at the mirror one final time. She looked back. Same eyes, same bone structure, same person who'd been eating sad toast in boxers forty-five minutes ago. But settled. Like everything that had been slightly out of focus had sharpened into place.
"Morning, gorgeous," I said to my reflection, because if you couldn't gas yourself up in your own bedroom, what was the point of anything?
Then I walked to my desk, sat down, opened my laptop, and watched the cursor blink at me like it had been waiting.
I should have been used to this by now. The empty page. The blinking cursor. The quiet little standoff between me and a document that had nothing in it because I had put nothing in it. But the thing was — and here was where it got stupid — it hadn't always been like this.
The thing about being a writer that no one told you, or rather, everyone told you but you didn't believe it until it was happening to you: success made the next page harder, not easier. You'd think selling well would be a confidence boost. You'd think having actual readers — people who bought your book with money they earned at real jobs and then spent hours of their limited time on earth reading words you arranged — would make you think I can do this. And it did, briefly, in the way that a shot of espresso made you think you could reorganize your entire apartment. The feeling was real and it was lying to you.
My Husband, My Bride was my fourth book. Not my first. That was an important distinction because people kept treating the viral moment like a debut, like I'd stumbled out of nowhere with one lucky manuscript. I had three other books. Three perfectly decent, modestly selling erotica novels that had paid my rent and earned me a small, loyal readership of people who liked kinky stories with teeth. I was proud of those books. They hadn't set the world on fire, but they'd kept the lights on, and there was a specific kind of pride in that — the pride of someone who's been doing the work for years without anyone making a fuss about it.
Then My Husband, My Bride happened.
I still wasn't entirely sure why it happened. The book wasn't fundamentally different from my others — same genre, same voice, same me. But something about it caught. Maybe it was the title, which people kept screenshotting and posting with captions like "EXCUSE ME?" and "I need to read this immediately." Maybe it was the cover, which my publisher had actually invested in this time — a striking image that managed to be tasteful and provocative in exactly the right proportions. Maybe it was just timing. The internet was hungry for bold, kinky erotica that didn't apologize for itself, and my book walked into the room at exactly the right moment wearing exactly the right outfit.
Whatever the reason, it took off. Not gradually. Not in the slow, building way that my publisher's sales projections had optimistically suggested. It just — went. One week I was checking my royalty dashboard and doing mental math about whether I could afford to replace my spiteful toaster, and the next week I was watching numbers climb in a way that made me refresh the page three times because I was sure it was a glitch.
It was not a glitch.
I opened my browser, because that was what I did every morning instead of writing. The ritual. The procrastination liturgy. Step one: check email. Step two: check sales dashboard. Step three: check social media. Step four: feel a complex cocktail of emotions. Step five: fail to write.
The sales dashboard loaded and the numbers were still good. Not launch week good — that particular surge had settled into something steadier — but good. Solidly, undeniably good. Good enough where my accountant had recently used the phrase "you might want to think about quarterly estimated taxes" which was apparently what happened when you made enough money for the government to start paying personal attention to you. Wonderful. I'd always wanted a closer relationship with the IRS.
I closed the dashboard and opened Instagram.
New followers overnight. Not the tidal wave of the first few weeks, but a steady trickle that showed no signs of stopping. I scrolled through the notifications with the detached compulsion of someone checking a weather app — I wasn't going to do anything about what I found, but I needed to know.
DMs first.
@sapphicreads_maya: OMG I just finished My Husband My Bride and I am DESTROYED. The scene in chapter 14?? I had to put my phone down and stare at the wall for ten minutes. You are an evil genius and I mean that as the highest compliment.
I smiled. That was a good one. Chapter fourteen was the scene where the husband stopped pretending submission was something being done to him and started admitting it was something he wanted. The pegging scene. The one where he asked for it — where he'd finally stopped performing reluctance and let himself want what he wanted. I'd rewritten it four times because getting that moment right meant walking the line between vulnerability and eroticism without letting either one swallow the other. Hearing that it worked felt like being told the parachute opened.
@book.boyfriend.energy: Hi Adrianna! I run a book blog with 40k followers and would love to feature an interview with you. We focus on diverse voices in romance and erotica. DM me if interested!
Maybe. I starred it for later, which was what I did with things I was probably never going to respond to but felt guilty about ignoring.
@lena_k_writes: Your book made me feel seen in a way I wasn't expecting. I don't want to get too personal in a DM but just — thank you. The feminization scenes were handled with so much care and honesty. It mattered to me.
That one stayed with me for a moment. Those were the messages that made the whole thing feel worth it — the ones where someone wasn't just saying they liked the book, they were saying it meant something. I wanted to respond with something worthy of what they'd shared, which meant I'd probably spend twenty minutes drafting a reply that still didn't feel adequate. I starred that one too, but differently.
Then I made the mistake of checking the comments on my latest post.
Mostly good. Mostly enthusiastic, generous engagement that I was still getting used to — heart emojis, people tagging friends with "you NEED to read this," the occasional comment in all caps that I chose to interpret as affection rather than aggression. I scrolled through them feeling something warm and unfamiliar, a feeling that wasn't quite satisfaction but was in the same neighborhood.
@realtalk_brenda: Am I the only one who thinks this is just smut dressed up as literature? Like congrats on writing about sex I guess but let's not pretend this is actual writing.
I stared at that one.
I stared at it the way you stare at a parking ticket — you knew getting angry wouldn't undo it, you knew engaging was pointless, you knew the correct response was to take a breath and move on with your day. You knew all of this. You knew it with the full weight of your rational adult mind.
And yet… Smut dressed up as literature. As if those were mutually exclusive categories. As if writing about desire and power and vulnerability and the messy complicated ways people want each other was somehow less valid than writing about — what, exactly? What was @realtalk_brenda reading that was so elevated? What literary high ground was she standing on while typing that comment with her whole chest?
I scrolled down.
@j_marcus_74: Not my thing personally but the writing quality is undeniable. The prose style alone puts most "serious" fiction to shame.
Thank you, @j_marcus_74. A measured take. A reasonable human being. I appreciated you.
@dirtypageturner: The way she writes submission is SO good like it's not just about sex it's about trust and identity and I am UNWELL
I appreciated you too, @dirtypageturner. Unwell in the best way.
@keepitclean_karen: This is what passes for "empowering" now? Writing graphic sexual content? Sorry but I don't see how this helps anyone.
Oh, for fuck's sake.
Two of them. Two in one scroll. I could feel the irritation building, a small, hot coal that wasn't going to become a fire but was going to sit there and smolder all morning anyway. The rational part of my brain — the part that had read every article about not engaging with negative comments, the part that understood these people represented a tiny fraction of my readership, the part that could deliver a perfectly calm TED Talk about the validity of erotica as a literary form — that part of my brain was fully operational and completely irrelevant.
Because the irrational part of my brain, the part that wrote the books in the first place, was busy composing a twelve-paragraph response that I was never going to send, explaining in devastating detail exactly why @keepitclean_karen's reductive understanding of sexual expression in literature revealed more about her own discomfort than it did about my work.
I did not send it. I did not even type it. But I composed it, mentally, in its entirety, and it was magnificent.
Then I closed Instagram, because I was a grown-ass adult with self-control and also because continuing to scroll was going to ruin my whole morning.
I took a breath. I took a sip of coffee that had gone lukewarm while I was busy having a parasocial argument with strangers. I set the mug down, positioned my fingers over the keyboard, and looked at the document I'd opened before I'd fallen into the social media vortex.
The cursor blinked at me.
I'd been looking at variations of this same empty page for three weeks now. Three weeks of opening the document, staring at it, and closing it again like I was checking on a patient who was never going to improve. The document had a title — "Untitled" — which felt like it was mocking me. I'd tried giving it a real title once, thinking that might help, like naming a plant to make yourself more committed to watering it. It had not helped. The plant was still dead.
I typed a sentence.
She walked into the room with the kind of confidence that—
Delete.
No. Absolutely not. That was the opening line of every book I'd ever read that I didn't finish. "She walked into the room with the kind of confidence that—" that what? That made people notice? That hid her insecurity? That the author couldn't think of a better way to introduce a character? Garbage. Into the trash.
I tried again.
The first time I saw her, I—
Delete.
Worse. Now I was writing a prologue, which was the literary equivalent of clearing your throat before saying something and then not saying it. Nobody wanted a prologue. I didn't want a prologue. I didn't even want a "first time I saw her." I wanted to be past the seeing and into the feeling but I couldn't get to the feeling because the feeling required a character and the character required a first line and the first line required me to commit to something and committing to something required — what? Confidence? Certainty? The knowledge that the sentence I chose was the right one and not a waste of everyone's time?
I typed again.
She had the kind of mouth that made you—
No. No, no, no. I was not starting a book with a mouth. I wasn't starting a book with any body part. That was the kind of opening that made people think erotica writers couldn't construct a sentence that wasn't about anatomy, and I had spent four books proving that I could, even if the anatomy eventually showed up and had a great time.
Delete.
I sat back in my chair and stared at the screen.
The problem wasn't that I didn't have ideas. I had ideas. I had a notes app full of them — half-formed concepts, character sketches, scenes that had arrived fully formed at 2 a.m. and looked completely incoherent by morning. "Woman discovers her ex is dating her dentist — explore power dynamics." What power dynamics? Whose power? The ex? The dentist? The woman in the chair with her mouth open while someone she's not speaking to is spoken about? I'd written that note three weeks ago and I still had no idea what I'd meant by it.
The real problem was that none of the ideas felt like the idea. The one that would justify sitting down every day for six months — that would prove My Husband, My Bride wasn't the ceiling — that there was another book in me that was just as honest, just as sharp, just as willing to go to the places that made readers put their phones down and stare at walls. Every idea I had felt thin next to that standard. Every opening line felt like it was trying to audition for a role it wasn't right for.
The cursor blinked. Blink. Blink. Blink. Patient. Unhurried. Taking absolutely no responsibility for the fact that the page was empty. That was the cursor's whole deal — just standing there, blinking, like a very passive-aggressive personal assistant waiting for you to dictate a letter. I'm ready whenever you are. Well, I wasn't. Clearly. I had been not-ready for three weeks and the cursor didn't seem to be taking it personally, which was somehow worse than if it had.
I typed one more time.
Chapter One.
I looked at it. Two words. The most generic, zero-commitment two words in the English language. I couldn't even get past the heading.
I deleted them.
I closed the laptop.
Not gently. Not with the measured calm of someone who was going to come back to it later with fresh eyes and a positive attitude. I closed it the way you would close a door on a conversation you were losing — firmly, with just enough force to communicate that you were choosing to leave and not being driven out, even though everyone in the room knew the truth.
Then I sat there, in my beautiful rust-colored blouse and my cream trousers and my carefully placed hair clip, looking like a woman who had her entire life together, and I thought about how I was going to explain to my editor that the new book was going great when the new book was not going at all.
Three weeks. Twenty-one days of this. I'd rearranged my desk twice, convinced that the problem was environmental. I'd bought a new candle — cedar and bergamot, because apparently creativity smelled like an expensive man — and burned it every writing session, accomplishing nothing except making my apartment smell like a spa that was closed for renovations. I'd tried writing in coffee shops, which had worked exactly once and produced a single paragraph that I'd deleted the next morning. I'd tried writing at night, in the afternoon, first thing in the morning before the coffee. I'd tried writing longhand in a notebook like some kind of Brontë sister, and all I'd gotten out of it was a hand cramp and the realization that my handwriting had deteriorated to the point of being genuinely illegible.
The tools were fine. The desk was fine. The candle was fine. The problem was the person sitting at the desk, and she was rapidly running out of things to rearrange.
As if the universe had been listening — and the universe, in my experience, had terrible comedic timing — my phone rang.
The screen said MARIBEL GRANT with a contact photo from two years ago in which Maribel was pointing at me across a restaurant table with a breadstick, mid-sentence, looking exactly the way Maribel always looked: like she had a plan and you were already part of it whether you'd agreed or not.
I considered not answering. I considered it the way you would consider jaywalking when you could already see the cop — technically an option, practically suicidal.
I picked up.
"Adrianna." Not a greeting. A statement of fact. Maribel didn't greet people, she acknowledged their existence and then got to work.
"Maribel. Hi. Hello. Good morning."
"It's almost twelve."
"Good late morning."
"How's the writing?"
And there it was. Three words, delivered with the casual precision of someone who already knew the answer but was going to make you say it anyway. How's the writing. The question I'd been dreading from the one person I couldn't bullshit, delivered on a random Tuesday with no warning, as if she'd been monitoring my laptop activity and had timed the call to the exact moment I'd slammed it shut.
"Great," I said. "Really, really great. Flowing. Words are just — flowing."
"Flowing."
"Like a river."
"Which river?"
"I — what?"
"Because some rivers are wide and powerful and some rivers are mostly mud. I'm trying to gauge which type of flowing we're talking about."
I pinched the bridge of my nose. "Maribel."
"Adrianna."
"The writing is going fine."
"The writing is going fine," she repeated, in the same tone a doctor might use when a patient says they've been "basically" taking their medication. "That's wonderful to hear. I'm so glad. In that case, you won't mind telling me what the new book is about."
Silence. Heavy, textured silence that was doing more work than any sentence could.
"It's still... taking shape," I said.
"Taking shape."
"Things are in the early stages."
"Ade." The nickname landed with the gentle thud of someone setting down something heavy. "You haven't written a word, have you?"
I opened my mouth to deny it. I really did. I had a whole defense prepared — I'd been doing research, I'd been brainstorming, I'd been letting ideas marinate, which was a real and valid part of the creative process and not, despite how it looked, the same thing as doing nothing. But Maribel had this quality — this deeply inconvenient quality — where lying to her felt like lying to someone who was holding a printout of the truth. Not because she was intimidating, exactly, but because she cared enough to actually listen, which meant she would actually hear the lie, and then she would wait, and the waiting would be worse than whatever she was going to say next.
"I've written several words," I said. "I've just also deleted them."
"All of them?"
"To date, yes."
I heard her exhale. Not a sigh — Maribel didn't sigh, sighing was for people who hadn't already moved on to solutions — but a measured breath that said okay, this is what we're working with.
"We need to talk," she said.
"We're talking right now."
"We need to talk in person. Over food. Somewhere I can see your face while you explain to me how a woman who wrote four books is suddenly incapable of writing a fifth."
"That feels aggressive."
"That feels like lunch. Are you free at one?"
"I might have plans."
"You don't have plans."
She was right. I didn't have plans. My plans for the day had been: wake up, fail to write, spiral quietly, and possibly order Thai food for the third time this week. Maribel slotting herself into that schedule was, if anything, an improvement, though I wasn't going to give her the satisfaction of saying so.
"Fine," I said. "One o'clock. Where?"
"Sorrentino's. I'll get us the corner booth."
"The corner booth is for when you're about to say something I don't want to hear."
"The corner booth is for when I want to have a conversation without your face being visible to the entire restaurant in case you get dramatic."
"I don't get dramatic."
"You once knocked over a water glass because I suggested a title change."
"That was an involuntary physical response to a bad idea."
"One o'clock, Ade. Eat something before you come, you get prickly when you're hungry."
She hung up. No goodbye, because Maribel didn't do goodbyes, she did conclusions. The conversation was concluded. The plan was in motion. My attendance was not optional.
I set the phone down and looked at my closed laptop and then at my apartment and then at the mirror by the door, where Adrianna Moore looked back at me — perfectly dressed, impeccably made up, absolutely killing it in the earrings department, and completely, comprehensively unable to write a single sentence that she was willing to let live.
"Great," I said to no one. "This is going to be fun."
I grabbed my bag, checked my reflection one more time — because even creative despair didn't excuse leaving the house without confirming the eyeliner was still sharp — and headed for the door.
Lunch with Maribel. A conversation about the book that didn't exist. A cheerful interrogation over Italian food in a corner booth specifically chosen so no one could see me when I inevitably got dramatic about it.
Just another Tuesday in the glamorous life of a writer who couldn't write.
I locked the door behind me and walked toward the elevator, already composing the version of "it's going great" that I was going to try on Maribel next, knowing full well she was going to see through it in under thirty seconds.
She always did.

Day two at Coral Key, and something had happened to my standards overnight. I, who once spent forty-five minutes selecting earrings for a trip to the bodega, put on a bikini top and cut-off shorts without consulting a mirror, an opinion, or a single one of the fourteen getting-ready steps that Sasha had once timed and described as 'clinically fascinating.' I looked like someone on vacation. The concept was still new enough to feel borrowed, like I was wearing someone else's ease and hoping nobody asked for it back.
Milo was already at the restaurant when I arrived. I could see him from the path — tropical shirt that looked like a sunset and a pineapple had gotten into a fight and both lost, coffee in hand, gesturing at a server about something that absolutely did not require that level of hand involvement. The sight of him sitting there in full daylight, clearly visible and not concealed behind plant life, was a genuine comfort. A girl could get used to breakfasts that didn't begin with a cardiac event.
"Morning," I said, pulling out the chair across from him.
"There she is." He looked up from his coffee and immediately gave me a head-to-toe sweep that was more approving than appraising. "Look at you. Very island casual. Very I might just sit here looking effortless."
"It's clothes, Milo."
"It's a vibe. Don't ruin it for me."
I got my coffee — which at this point in the trip had replaced both ambition and personality as my primary motivating force — and a stack of French toast that had no business looking that good at a resort buffet, which I fully intended to eat without performing a single creative thought. The morning air was warm and soft and smelled like salt and something floral I couldn't name. A bird I didn't recognize was doing something complicated in a palm tree near our table. I watched it for a moment and felt absolutely nothing productive. No itch to describe it. No instinct to turn it into a sentence. Just a bird doing bird things in a tree, and me watching, and the complete absence of the voice that usually asked what I was going to do with the observation. It was, if I was being honest, wonderful.
Talia and Cass arrived together. Talia had a sundress that was at least three patterns too many, and it worked, because of course it did. At this point I was starting to suspect she did it on purpose just to prove the rest of us were overthinking getting dressed. Cass was in linen and quiet self-possession, carrying her plate like she'd already decided what she was going to eat before she entered the building.
"Good morning, good morning," Talia said, sitting down with the energy of someone who had been awake since dawn and was furious that the rest of the world hadn't matched her enthusiasm. "How did everyone sleep?"
"Like the dead," Milo said.
"Like someone whose wife didn't set an alarm for sunrise yoga and then hit snooze four times," Cass said.
"That was a scheduling error. I have grown from it."
"It was two hours ago."
"Growth can be fast."
The conversation drifted to last night, the way mornings after good evenings always do — someone mentions one moment, and suddenly everyone's talking over each other to get to the best part first.
"I still can't believe the waiter's face," Talia said, grinning into her coffee. "When you told him the wine tasted like ambition."
"It did," Milo said. "It was trying too hard. There was an aggressive oakiness. Like it had something to prove."
"You sent it back."
"I sent it back with notes. I'm not an animal."
"Debatable," I said.
Milo put a hand over his heart like I'd personally wounded him.
"And then you tried to send the fish back," Talia said.
"I did not try to send it back. I suggested, politely, that it could have been more ambitious. The mahi-mahi was competent. It was not inspired."
"It's a fish, Milo. It's dead."
"That's no excuse."
"The fish was incredible, for the record," Talia said. "That sauce? Cass, back me up. The sauce."
Cass took a sip of her coffee. "Adequate."
Talia stared at her. "You ate every bite. You asked for more of the sauce. You used bread to get the rest of it off the plate."
"It was adequate bread."
"I threw a napkin at you."
"I remember. It was a linen napkin. Good weight. Adequate throw."
Milo was already laughing. I was holding it together until Talia turned to me for backup and I saw her face — genuine outrage over a fish review — and lost it.
I was mid-sip when I saw her. Renee had come into the restaurant from the beach side, which meant she'd already been up and out and doing something — walking, maybe, or swimming, or just standing somewhere being unreasonably composed at an hour when most people were still negotiating consciousness. She was at the buffet, her back to us, plate in hand. White tank top. Hair down. Already halfway done, picking things without hesitation, no hovering, no second-guessing.
I watched her for a second longer than the situation required. I was thinking about the beach. Last night, walking to dinner with the group, I'd looked out toward the water and Renee had been standing at the edge of it. Alone. Still. The sun had been turning everything copper and ridiculous, and she'd been in the middle of it like she'd been placed there by someone with a very specific aesthetic vision. I'd kept walking. But the image had stayed, and I hadn't been able to figure out why. She hadn't been performing it for anyone, and it had felt like seeing a room in someone's house I hadn't been invited into.
"What's that face?" Milo said.
I looked back at the table. "What face?"
"That one. The one you're making right now. The one that says your brain went somewhere and didn't file a travel itinerary."
"I don't have a face."
"You absolutely have a face. It's a very specific face. Cass, does she have a face?"
Cass glanced at me over her coffee. "You have a face."
"Thank you for that incisive contribution," I said, turning back to my French toast like it owed me an explanation.
"Anytime," Cass said, already back to her coffee.
Talia was already looking in the direction I'd been looking. "Oh. Renee's here."
There was a brief collective silence at the table, which I chose to interpret as coincidence, even though every pair of eyes at the table had simultaneously arrived at a conclusion I hadn't authorized.
"Last night," I said, because apparently my mouth had decided to participate in this conversation without consulting the rest of me. "After the mixology class, when we were heading to dinner. She was out by the water."
"Okay," Milo said, leaning forward with the posture of someone settling in for a story.
"That's it. She was just out there. By herself. Watching the sunset."
"And?"
"And nothing. I just — I don't know. It was — " I stalled. The thing about it was that I genuinely didn't know what it was. She'd been alone, and it had looked like something, and I couldn't get the image to resolve into a sentence that made sense. "I don't know. It just stuck."
Milo looked at Talia. Talia looked at Cass. Cass drank her coffee.
"I'm getting her," Milo said, and pushed his chair back.
"Milo, don't — you don't need to — "
He was already gone. I watched him cross the restaurant with the focused determination of a man on a humanitarian mission, which, in his mind, he probably was. He reached Renee at the buffet. I could see his mouth moving. I could see her turn to look at him. I could see her glance — briefly, so briefly I might have imagined it — toward our table.
She didn't fight it. That was the thing. The Renee from two days ago would have given him the look, the one that said she was evaluating whether he was worth the energy of a full sentence and deciding the answer was no. This Renee listened to whatever he was saying, finished filling her plate, and walked back with him. She didn't look thrilled about it. She didn't look reluctant either. She looked like she'd quietly decided that resistance required more effort than participation, and the math had shifted.
She sat down next to Milo, across from Talia. One seat away from me.
"Good morning," she said.
"Morning," Talia said, beaming.
"Good morning, Renee," Cass said, with a warmth that sounded like it had been there all along, just waiting for the opportunity.
"Hi," I said, and added absolutely nothing else, because my contribution to the social fabric of this table was apparently going to be monosyllabic today.
But then Renee looked at me — a look with no history in it, direct and simple, no particular agenda. "Hi," she said back.
"So what have you been up to this morning?" Talia asked, turning to Renee with the full force of her attention.
"Swimming," Renee said.
"Before nine a.m.?" Milo pressed a hand to his chest. "Voluntarily? My therapist would be so proud of you. She'd be furious with me, but so proud of you."
"How was the water?" Cass asked.
Renee set down her coffee. "Perfect, actually. Still and warm and completely empty. I had the whole beach to myself."
She said it like the answer had slipped out before the part of her that usually edited these things could get to it. I looked at her for a second too long, and she caught me, and I redirected my attention to my French toast with the subtlety of a woman knocking over a lamp while trying to be invisible.
"You should hang out with us more," Talia said, as though this were a casual observation and not the opening move in a campaign she'd clearly been planning since the catamaran. "Last night was fun. The cocktail class, dinner, the bar after — the whole thing. You missed a good time."
"I'm sure it was," Renee said.
"So come next time," Talia said. "The mixer was fun, right? Even you stayed for the whole thing."
Renee's mouth did something that in low light and with generous interpretation could have been the beginning of amusement.
"Please, just — come do things with us. We're going kayaking this afternoon. Lyle organised it. It'll be ridiculous."
"I'll think about it."
"That means no," Milo said.
"It means I'll think about it."
"It means no, and I won't accept it. Talia, back me up."
"Absolutely not accepting it," Talia confirmed. Then she turned to me, and I knew before she opened her mouth what was coming, the way you know a train is about to hit you even when you're standing perfectly still on the tracks. "Ade. Tell her she should come."
I looked up from my coffee. I looked at Talia. I looked at Renee. Renee was watching me with an expression I couldn't read, which was becoming her signature move, and which I was becoming increasingly annoyed to find that I wanted to learn to read.
"You should come," I said.
Renee picked up her coffee.
"So kayaking," Talia said. "Two o'clock. Lyle said to meet at the dock. Apparently there's a safety briefing."
"Of course there's a safety briefing," Cass said.
"What kind of kayaks?" Renee asked.
Talia's hand froze halfway to her juice. Milo looked at Cass. Cass looked at her coffee. I suddenly needed to adjust my napkin.
"Singles, I think," Talia said, recovering fast. "Why, do you have a preference?"
"Singles are better. More control."
"You've kayaked before," I said.
"A few times."
"She's kayaked before," Milo said to no one in particular, grinning like he'd been handed a gift.
"You know what else happened last night that we haven't fully discussed?" Talia said, clearly pleased with herself.
"Don't," Milo said.
"After my very effective conversation with a certain bartender — "
"It was not effective. It was mortifying."
" — he had your drink ready before you even got to the bar. You're welcome."
Milo started to argue, then stopped. "He did have my drink ready. He knows my order. That is not a bartender being efficient. That is a bartender who has memorized what I like. That is a choice."
"He's a bartender," Cass said. "Memorizing drinks is his job."
"It's not just the order. It's the eye contact when he handed it to me. He looked at me while I took the glass. Held it for a second. That is not standard. You don't maintain eye contact during a handoff unless you're trying to communicate something."
"Or he was just handing you a drink," I said.
"You're all so cynical. This is a man who works in a building that serves thousands of drinks a week, and he has memorized mine. He has given me a standing order. In the language of bartenders, that is essentially a marriage proposal."
"In the language of bartenders," Cass said, "that is a regular customer."
"The eye contact, Cass. The eye contact."
"Was prolonged and deeply meaningful, yes, you mentioned. I would like to offer a counterpoint, which is that he might have been looking in your direction and you happened to be standing there."
Milo clutched his chest. Talia was already laughing. Renee was watching the exchange with something dangerously close to enjoyment — sitting at a table with people being ridiculous, and not calculating her exit.
"What do you think?" Milo said, turning to Renee, apparently having decided that the newest member of the jury hadn't yet been polled.
Renee considered this. "How many other guests does he have their drink memorized for?"
Milo blinked. "That's — that's not the point."
"That's exactly the point. If he does it for everyone, it's professionalism. If he does it for you and one or two other people, it's attention. If he does it only for you, then you can build your case."
"I am going to investigate this immediately."
"Please don't interrogate the bartender about his pour patterns," Cass said.
"I'm going to be subtle."
"Milo, I've known you for two days and even I know subtle isn't in your range," I said.
"First of all, how dare you. Second of all, you're right, but I'm going to try."
"Can we circle back to the kayaking?" Cass said. "We were having a perfectly functional conversation about an afternoon activity and somehow ended up dissecting a bartender's eye movements."
"That was important," Milo said.
"That was Talia's fault," Cass said.
"Excuse me?" Talia sat up straight. "I was celebrating a win. I got him the drink. I got him the eye contact. I am a hero of this story."
"You derailed a logistics conversation."
"I enhanced it."
"So — two o'clock," Cass said, ignoring her entirely. "Lyle has the session at the dock. Lunch first? Twelve-thirty?"
"I'm in," Milo said.
"Obviously we're in," Talia said, still visibly offended.
Cass looked at me.
"Fine," I said.
Talia and Milo both looked at Renee.
Renee looked at me. I don't know why. She just looked at me, and I looked back, and for about two seconds neither of us said anything, and the silence was the specific kind of silence that is louder than whatever words it replaced.
"I'll be there," Renee said.
"Great," I said. Then, because my mouth apparently needed to justify its existence: "Good. That's — yeah. Good."
Good. That's — yeah. Good. I was a bestselling author. I had been reviewed by people who got paid to have opinions about prose. My command of the English language was, at this moment, genuinely humiliating.
Milo's grin was wide and obvious. Talia's was wider. Cass didn't smile at all, which was worse — she just raised one eyebrow at Talia in a microexpression that communicated an entire paragraph of commentary without producing a single sound.
I caught all of it. "What."
"Hm?" Talia said, rearranging her face into something innocent.
"Nothing," Milo said.
"Eat your french toast," Cass said.
Nobody seemed in a rush to leave. Talia ordered a second coffee. Milo stole the last piece of fruit off my plate without asking, which I allowed because I was in a generous mood and also because he'd already eaten it before I could object. Talia was showing him something on her phone that was making him gasp at a volume the neighbouring tables didn't appreciate.
"Pool?" Talia said eventually, collecting her plate.
"Pool," Milo confirmed.
"I could be persuaded," Cass said, which probably meant yes.
Renee stood, collected her plate. "I'll see you later," she said. Casual. Easy. Like it was already a given that later would involve us.
We walked down to the pool — Milo and Talia ahead arguing about sunscreen brands, Cass with her book already in hand, me trailing behind thinking about how "I'll see you later" hadn't sounded like a maybe.
Talia dropped her bag on the nearest lounger and claimed it like a flag in conquered territory. Cass took the one beside her. Milo spread across his like he was posing for a magazine cover nobody had commissioned. I found a lounger half in the shade of a palm tree, put my sunglasses on, and closed my eyes.
The morning was warm and slow and tasted like salt. I lay there and let the sun do whatever it was going to do to my skin and thought about nothing, which was harder than it sounded for someone whose brain had been running a constant internal monologue since approximately birth. But the pool was doing something to me. The heat, the water, the sound of Milo arguing with Talia about whether SPF 50 was overkill or a bare minimum — it was all conspiring to sand down whatever sharp edge I usually carried into the day. I hadn't looked at my laptop since yesterday. I hadn't thought about looking at my laptop. That second part was new.
"Ade," Talia called from two loungers over. "Do you burn or tan?"
"I burn, peel, and then tell people I tanned."
"Relatable. Milo, give her the sunscreen."
"I'm not done with it. I'm doing my shoulders."
"You've been doing your shoulders for ten minutes. You have the shoulders of a normal-sized man, Milo, not a wingspan."
I took the sunscreen when Milo eventually surrendered it, applied it without urgency, and lay back down. Cass had her book open and hadn't looked up since she sat down. Talia was on her phone, presumably planning something for the group that none of us had consented to yet. Milo had his eyes closed and his face turned directly into the sun like a plant that had recently developed self-esteem.
This was good. I could admit that now without it feeling like a concession. The island was already doing something to me. Whatever engine had been running nonstop in my head since the block started had quieted to an idle, and I couldn't tell if that was progress or surrender. I wasn't writing. I wasn't trying to write. For the first time in months, that felt like something other than failure — something I hadn't found the right word for yet.
I opened my eyes at the sound of footsteps. Renee was standing at the edge of the pool, still in her tank top and shorts from breakfast. She pulled the tank top over her head, stepped out of her shorts, and underneath was a black two-piece with gold rings where the strings met — at the neck, at both hips. A swimsuit that looked simple until you noticed the details.
"I thought you were going back to your bungalow," I said.
"Changed my mind."
She walked to the edge of the pool and dove in. She surfaced, pushed her hair back, and started swimming laps — clean strokes, no wasted movement. I watched her reach the far end and turn and come back, and closed my eyes again.
By the time lunch arrived, we'd all gone back to the bungalows and changed into something that said casual but could survive a kayak — shorts, tank tops, the kind of clothes you didn't mind getting wet. Talia arrived at the restaurant first, which meant she'd chosen the table before anyone else had a say in it.
Milo appeared with wet hair from a post-pool shower and a shirt that featured what I think were flamingos, though they could have been abstract art that had given up on itself. Cass followed in linen that defied wrinkles through what I assumed was sheer force of personality. I sat down. We ordered drinks.
Renee was not there.
"Where's your girl?" Milo asked.
"She's not my — how the hell would I know where she is?"
"You seemed very invested in her attendance this morning."
"I told her to come kayaking because you all put me on the spot. That's not investment. That's peer pressure."
"Mhm," Talia said.
"Ade has driven off her nemesis," Cass said, with the delivery of someone reading a headline.
"She's not my nemesis. She was never my — would you all stop trying to make this into something? She's a person I met three days ago who happened to be annoying on a plane."
"Three days," Milo said. "And how many of those three days have you not talked about her?"
I tried to come up with something, but Milo's grin was insufferable.
"I think Ade's warming up to Renee," Talia said.
"Maybe warming up is the wrong word," Milo said, examining his menu with theatrical nonchalance. "Maybe it's more like... defrosting. Slowly. Like a steak you left on the counter."
"Did you just compare my interpersonal dynamics to a steak?"
"A high-quality steak. I'm not insulting you."
"I'm not defrosting toward anyone. I'm a normal person having a normal vacation, and the fact that you three have apparently formed some kind of surveillance operation around my social interactions is — "
"What's going on?"
I looked up. Renee was standing at the end of the table, looking at the four of us with an expression that suggested she'd arrived at the precise moment guaranteed to cause me the maximum amount of inconvenience. Because of course she had.
Renee sat down. She didn't push it. She just sat down, picked up the menu, and said nothing about whatever she'd walked into.
I went quiet. My mouth, which had been moving at full speed approximately half a second ago, simply stopped, as if someone had pulled out the plug.
"Nothing," I said.
Milo's grin intensified. Talia pressed her lips together. Cass didn't even look up from her menu, but something shifted in her expression — a micro-adjustment that, if I'd had a microscope and a grudge, I could have classified as amusement.
"Have you guys ordered?" she asked.
"We were waiting," Talia said, and then looked at me with complete innocence, as though the last three minutes of my life hadn't happened.
The waiter came over with a notepad and the patient smile of someone who'd seen this before.
"The grilled fish," Talia said, then watched the rest of the table like she was already reconsidering.
Cass handed her menu to the waiter without looking at it. "Caesar salad. Thank you."
"Can I get the grilled chicken," Milo said, "but, like, more interesting?"
The waiter blinked. "More interesting how?"
"I don't know. Surprise me. Chef's discretion. Make it a journey."
"I'll see what I can do," the waiter said, in a tone that suggested he absolutely would not.
Renee glanced at the menu for approximately three seconds. "The garden salad, please. Dressing on the side."
I ordered a wrap because it was the first thing my eyes landed on and my brain was still recovering from the ambush.
"A wrap," Milo said, looking at me. "You can get a wrap anywhere."
"I like wraps."
"We're at an island restaurant and you ordered a wrap."
"Leave her alone," Talia said, swatting his arm. "You just asked a man to make your chicken more interesting. You don't get to judge."
"That was aspirational ordering. That was giving the kitchen an opportunity to shine."
"That was annoying a waiter," Cass said, straightening her silverware without looking up. "Trust me. I know the look."
"He didn't seem annoyed," Milo said, completely unconvinced.
Cass looked up from her silverware. "He was professionally tolerating you."
Milo put his hand flat on the table. "Cass, I need you to understand something. When you order food, it's a transaction. When I order food, it's an experience."
"It's a kitchen," Renee said. "They have a menu. You pick something off it."
Milo turned to her, wounded. "You're supposed to be on my side. I pulled you into this group."
"You pulled me into breakfast," Renee said. She left it there.
Talia laughed and knocked her knee against Cass's under the table. Cass didn't react, but she didn't move her knee away either.
"Nobody appreciates the art of dining," Milo said, shaking his head.
"The rest of us ordered food," I said. "You submitted a creative brief."
"Please don't model your behavior after me," Renee said, but there was something at the edge of it that wasn't quite a smile and wasn't trying to be.
The waiter returned with plates balanced up his arm in a way that looked impressive right up until you imagined the alternative, setting them down one at a time. Talia leaned sideways to see if anyone else's order looked better than hers. Milo tracked his chicken's arrival like a verdict he wasn't confident about. Renee received her salad, moved the dressing to exactly where she wanted it, and started eating without commentary, which at this table was practically a revolutionary act.
Milo stared at his chicken.
"Is it interesting enough?" Cass asked, not looking up from her salad.
"It has a sauce I didn't ask for," Milo said, poking at it with his fork.
"That's the interesting part."
"The interesting part is uninvited."
Cass speared a piece of lettuce. "Eat your uninvited sauce, Milo."
I was halfway through my wrap and still quietly irritated about the group's earlier performance when Talia sat up straighter. "Oh — Ade, isn't that the woman from the mixer? The one you were talking to at the bar."
I looked. Alina Ortega was crossing the restaurant with a notebook tucked under one arm and her hair pulled back loosely. She was heading for a table near the railing, alone.
"Yeah, that's Alina," I said.
"You should invite her over," Talia said.
I didn't need to be told twice. This one I could do without the existential crisis. "Alina!" I called across the patio.
She looked up, clocked me, and smiled. She said something to the waiter near the railing and then made her way over.
"Adrianna," she said, stopping at the edge of the table. "Good to see you again."
"Hey. Everyone, this is Alina — we met at the mixer. Alina, these are my friends. Talia, Cass, Milo, and Renee."
"Hi," Alina said, with a wave around the table.
"Sit down," Talia said immediately, already pulling out the empty chair next to her.
"I don't want to intrude — "
"You're not intruding. Sit."
Alina slid into the empty chair, glanced around the table with an easy curiosity, then flagged down a passing waiter and ordered a grilled fish and a sparkling water without looking at the menu.
"How's the inspiration coming?" Alina asked me. "Has the island delivered?"
"The island has delivered several excellent cocktails and a deeply committed activities coordinator. Inspiration is pending."
"That's the thing about places like this. You come for the material and the material ends up being the people you didn't expect to meet." She said it lightly, but her eyes moved around the table as she said it, cataloging. Writer's habit. I recognized it because I had the same one.
Lunch stretched in a way that felt earned. Alina had the kind of observational humour that came from spending her life in unfamiliar places and learning to make quick reads of the people in them. She told a story about a resort in Portugal where she'd accidentally joined a silent meditation retreat because the brochure was in Portuguese and she'd thought it said "sunset social." Three days of silence. She'd filed six hundred words on it and her editor had called it the funniest thing she'd ever written. "Turns out I'm hilarious when I can't talk," she said, and Milo laughed so hard he knocked over his water glass.
Renee was quiet during the Alina portion of lunch, but it was a different quiet than her usual one. She was listening. Following the conversation closely enough that it was clear she was present rather than enduring. At one point Alina said something about the challenge of writing about a place while you were still inside it — the gap between experiencing something and describing it — and Renee looked at me. Just for a second. Just long enough for me to notice and to feel, absurdly, like I'd been caught at something.
Cass checked her watch. "It's one-thirty. We need to move."
"I haven't finished eating," Talia said, gesturing at her plate.
"You've been picking at the same piece of fish for ten minutes."
"I'm savouring."
"You're stalling."
"You're very bossy when you're in charge."
"I'm always in charge. You just don't usually notice."
Talia looked at Milo for support. Milo raised both hands. "I'm not getting in the middle of this."
Renee was holding her water glass very close to her face, and she was losing a fight with her own composure. Milo caught my eye across the table and we both looked away fast, because if either of us cracked, Cass and Talia would stop arguing, and the argument was too good to interrupt.
"Alina, you should come," Talia said, pivoting with the speed of someone who could sustain a marital dispute and social planning simultaneously.
Alina held up her notebook. "I'd love to, but I'm on a deadline. This piece isn't writing itself — trust me, I've been waiting." She smiled. "Next time."
We left Alina to her deadline. The walk from the restaurant to the dock took about ten minutes along a sandy path that cut through the palm trees, Talia and Milo ahead debating whether life jackets were flattering on anyone, Cass walking beside me in silence, and Renee a step behind, close enough to be part of the group and far enough to still have her own air.
The dock was at the far end of the beach, where the sand gave way to a wooden platform and a row of single kayaks lined up like bright plastic soldiers. Lyle was already there, clipboard in one hand, whistle around his neck, zinc so thick on his nose it looked like a commitment to a bit rather than sun protection.
"Welcome, welcome, welcome!" he said, clapping his hands together as we approached. "The afternoon paddlers! I love the afternoon group. The afternoon group always has the best energy."
"Does he say that to every group?" I murmured to Cass.
"Almost certainly."
"Great to see familiar faces," Lyle continued, either not hearing us or choosing to power through. "We've got calm water, clear skies, and a two o'clock current that's going to make the south side of the reef absolutely beautiful. Before we get out there, though — safety first."
"Of course," Cass said, in a tone that could have meant anything.
"Now, I know what you're thinking. I know some of you are looking at these kayaks and thinking, I've done this before, I don't need a briefing." He looked directly at Milo, who was already reaching for a paddle. "Everyone needs a briefing."
"I wasn't thinking that," Milo said, putting the paddle back.
"Right. So." Lyle held up his paddle like he was about to deliver a sermon. "Grip. Both hands. Shoulder-width apart. Knuckles aligned with the blade. If you're death-gripping, you're doing it wrong. Loose hands, relaxed shoulders, let the rotation come from your core."
He demonstrated. It was a very thorough demonstration. Talia whispered something to me about his core rotation being surprisingly impressive, and I told her to focus.
"If you capsize — and I'm not saying you will, but if you do — stay with the kayak. Don't try to swim after a paddle. Paddles float. You might not. Questions?"
"What if someone else capsizes and I want to help?" Renee asked.
Lyle pointed at her. "Excellent question. Approach from the side, stabilize their kayak with your paddle across both bows, and help them back in. Do not approach from behind. That's how we get double capsizes and incident reports." He paused. "I hate incident reports."
"Nobody wants an incident report, Lyle," Talia said.
"You'd be surprised." He blew his whistle once, short and sharp. A pelican about six feet away launched itself off a post in a flurry of wings and offended dignity. "That means stop. If you hear the whistle, you stop paddling and look at me. Even if you're having the time of your life. Even if you've found a turtle. Especially if you've found a turtle. Last week someone chased one past the buoys and I had to paddle out there myself to bring them back."
"Someone chased a turtle?" Milo said, with the expression of a man who'd just found his role model.
"Don't chase the turtle, Milo," I said.
"I'm not saying I'd chase a turtle. I'm saying I understand the impulse."
Lyle looked at our group for a long moment, as if assessing the likelihood of an incident report. Whatever he concluded, he kept to himself.
"Alright. Grab a paddle, pick a kayak. Life jackets are in the bin. Mandatory, no exceptions, I don't care how good a swimmer you are." He blew the whistle again. The pelican, who had just resettled, left with even more indignation than the first time.
I steadied myself, found the rhythm, and pushed off from the dock. The water was shallow and clear enough that I could see the sandy bottom and the occasional fish darting underneath.
"This is amazing!" Talia called out from somewhere to my left, already veering off course.
"You're paddling in a circle," Cass said, pulling up beside her.
"I'm paddling in a scenic route."
"You're paddling in a circle, Talia."
"How are you going straight? How is everyone going straight?"
"Left, right, left, right. It's not complicated."
"It's very complicated when the water is doing things."
Renee was ahead of us, steady and straight. She looked back over her shoulder at Talia's spiralling trajectory. "Shorter strokes," she called out. "You're pulling too deep."
Talia adjusted. The circle tightened into something that was almost a line. "Oh my God. That actually worked."
"She's a natural instructor," Milo said, paddling past me with aggressive enthusiasm in a direction that had nothing to do with where the rest of us were going.
"Milo, the group is this way," Lyle called from behind us.
"I'm exploring!"
"You're drifting."
"Exploring and drifting are the same thing with different attitudes."
I caught up to Renee without entirely meaning to. She glanced over as I pulled alongside her.
"You're not bad at this," she said.
"I'm terrible at this. I'm just hiding it well."
"You're not hiding it that well."
"Very encouraging."
Renee smiled, and I realized it was the first time I'd seen her do it without catching herself halfway through. We paddled alongside each other for a stretch after that, neither of us talking, and the silence felt easier than silence between us had any right to feel.
"Hey — hey, something's — I think I'm stuck."
Milo. Of course it was Milo. He'd drifted wide of the group and his kayak had found a shallow patch of reef, and he was now sitting perfectly still with the expression of a man who'd been betrayed by the ocean.
"Don't rock it," Renee called out. She'd already turned, paddling back toward him with clean, quick strokes.
I turned too. We reached him at the same time, coming in from opposite sides, and without either of us saying a word we fell into a rhythm — Renee stabilizing his kayak from the left while I pushed from the right, both of us angling our paddles to lever him free without tipping anyone. Milo sat very still and said nothing, which was possibly the first time in his life he'd been both stationary and silent for more than four consecutive seconds.
"Push when I push," Renee said to me. A statement of coordination — and I matched her timing without thinking about it, and together we eased the kayak off the reef and back into deeper water.
"Thank you," Milo said. Deeply, profoundly sincere. "That was harrowing."
"You were stuck," Renee said. "In two feet of water."
"The emotional depth was greater than the physical depth."
I laughed. Renee almost did. We were still floating close to each other, paddles resting, and for a moment we were just two people in kayaks on a clear afternoon who had done a small, coordinated thing together and it had worked. It was nothing. I narrated it to myself as nothing.
Cass, paddling past at a measured distance, looked at me and then at Renee and said absolutely nothing, which, coming from Cass, was a full paragraph.
We paddled back as the afternoon started to soften. Lyle was waiting on the dock with his whistle and his clipboard, herding us in one by one.
"Excellent work, everyone. Excellent. One of the best groups I've had all season."
"You say that to every group," I said, pulling up to the dock.
"I do," Lyle admitted. "But this time I mean it. Nobody followed a turtle. That's a win."
We climbed out in various states of grace — Cass stepped onto the dock like she was exiting a town car, Renee pulled herself up without breaking stride, and Talia needed a hand from both of them while Milo managed on his own and then immediately looked like he regretted not asking for help. I made it up barely, and stood there dripping and sunburned in places I'd missed with the sunscreen.
"Dinner," Talia said, wringing out her hair. "Seven-thirty. I'm starving already and I just ate three hours ago."
"Seven-thirty works," Milo said.
"I'm in," I said.
Cass nodded.
Talia looked at Renee. "You're coming, right?"
Renee was pulling off her life jacket, folding it neatly because of course she folded a life jacket. She looked up. "Yeah," she said. "I'll be there."
The walk back was slow and loose, the five of us spread across the sandy path in a staggered line that Lyle would have found organizationally distressing. Milo was retelling the reef rescue to Talia.
"I was completely calm," he said.
"You said 'I think I'm stuck' in a voice that could have shattered glass," I said.
"That was controlled urgency."
"Fine. Controlled urgency."
"Renee and Ade saved me," he continued, undeterred. "It was very coordinated. Very professional. Almost like they'd practised."
"We hadn't practised," Renee said, from somewhere behind me.
"That makes it more impressive. That's instinct. That's chemistry."
"That's two people pushing a kayak off a rock," Cass said.
The path forked near the bungalows and the group started to scatter.
"I need a shower that lasts approximately forty-five minutes," Talia said, already pulling Cass by the hand toward the left path.
"Thirty," Cass said.
"Forty-five."
"Thirty, Talia. Dinner is at seven-thirty."
"Thirty-five and I won't change outfits more than twice."
"Deal."
They disappeared around the bend, still negotiating.
"Nap time," Milo said, waving as he headed off. "See everyone at dinner."
Renee and I walked the same stretch of path without talking.
I reached my door first. "See you at dinner," I said.
"See you at dinner," Renee said, and kept walking.
I watched her for a second, then went inside.
The bungalow was cool and quiet after the heat of the afternoon. I kicked off my shoes, walked straight to the bed, and dropped face-first onto the mattress like someone had cut my strings. My arms ached from paddling. My hair smelled like salt and was doing things I was choosing not to investigate. I lay there for a while with my face in the pillow, making a long, muffled sound into the pillow. It covered everything.
I reached for my phone without lifting my head, which took some maneuvering and resulted in knocking over a water bottle on the nightstand. Worth it.
Me: Are you alive
Sasha: Barely. Meetings all day. My brain has left my body. Hows paradise
Me: I went kayaking today
Sasha: Voluntarily??
Me: With the group. And Renee
Sasha: Wait. Renee is hanging out with you now??
Me: The group invited her
Sasha: You hated this woman three days ago
Me: I didnt hate her. She was annoying
Sasha: And now shes not annoying?
Me: Shes just. I dont know. Shes different than I thought
Sasha: Oh honey
Me: Dont
Sasha: OH HONEY
Me: Im done with this conversation
Sasha: Youre texting me from an island. Where are you going
Me: GOODBYE SASHA
I put the phone face-down on the nightstand and stared at the ceiling. Different than I thought. I'd typed it without thinking, and now it was sitting there in the conversation, true and unexplained, and Sasha had seen it before I had.
I lay there for a while. The light outside the window was going gold, the afternoon giving way to evening in that gradual, unhurried way the island had. Through the open window I could hear the ocean and someone laughing somewhere down the path.
I thought about the day. How full it had been without a single moment of it feeling forced. How easily the group had carried Renee along with them — and how easily she'd let them.
Something was forming at the edge of my thoughts. The shape of a sentence before the sentence itself. The feeling that comes before writing — the pre-verbal hum that means something is organizing itself in a part of my brain I don't have direct access to. I hadn't felt it in months. I noticed it and was careful not to look at it directly, the way you avoid staring at something in your peripheral vision because the moment you turn your head it disappears.
Eventually I peeled myself off the bed and got in the shower, standing under the hot water longer than I needed to while the salt and the sunscreen and the day rinsed off my skin. When I stepped out the mirror was fogged and the bathroom smelled like the resort shampoo, which was coconut and something else I couldn't name and which I was developing an unreasonable attachment to.
Getting ready for dinner took longer than breakfast. I stood in front of my suitcase in a towel, pulled out a green sundress, held it up, put it back. Tried a black one. Too much. Back to the green. I put it on and stood in front of the mirror, turning once, adjusting the straps. Then I opened the small pouch where I kept my jewellery and found myself holding two pairs of earrings up to the fogged glass — the gold hoops I'd packed for going out and the silver ones I usually saved for days when I wanted to feel like I'd made an effort.
I put the silver ones on and left it at that.
The walk to the restaurant was quiet. The path was lit with low solar lights, and the air smelled like jasmine and grilled something, and the sound of the ocean was there underneath everything the way it always was. I could see the string lights of the outdoor dining area through the trees before I reached it, warm and golden against the darkening sky.
Milo was the first one I saw, already at the table with a drink in front of him. He waved me over.
"Green looks good on you," he said.
"Thank you, Milo."
"I'm serious. Very dinner-with-intent."
"Please stop talking."
Talia and Cass came up the path together, and something was different. Talia had her arm looped through Cass's, leaning into her, murmuring something close to her ear that made Cass — composed, immovable Cass — actually smile. Not her usual controlled acknowledgment. An unguarded one. Talia pressed a kiss to Cass's shoulder as they reached the table.
"Well," Milo said, watching them sit down. "Hello."
"Hi," Talia said, radiating.
Cass picked up a menu and opened it without making eye contact with anyone.
I looked at the two of them. "Look at you. I was starting to think you only communicated through arguments."
"Oh the bickering never stops," Talia said. "It just leads somewhere more interesting."
Milo gasped. Actually gasped. He put both hands flat on the table. "You had sex."
"Milo," Cass said, still looking at the menu.
"You absolutely had sex. Look at her face. Look at YOUR face. Cass, you're glowing."
"We are in a restaurant," Cass said.
"We're adults," Talia said, pouring herself a glass of water. "It happens. It's natural."
"Nobody is arguing that. I'm asking you to stop talking about it."
"I'm not talking about it. I'm acknowledging it. It's completely —"
"Don't."
"I'm just saying, you don't need to be so uptight about — "
"I'm not uptight. I'm appropriate."
"You're a little uptight," Milo said.
"Thank you, Milo," Talia said.
"I'm not uptight," Cass said. "I just have boundaries about what gets discussed at dinner."
"You always have boundaries," Talia said. "You have boundaries about everything. You're the most in-control person I've ever met. About everything. Always in charge. Always on top of every situation."
"Someone has to be."
"Hey," Renee said, pulling out the empty chair directly across from me and sitting down. "Evening."
"Hey," I said.
"Well," Talia said, looking at Cass with a grin that was pure trouble, "not every situation. Not always on top."
It took a second to land. Then Milo's jaw dropped. My hand went to my mouth.
"Talia, I swear to God," Cass said.
"What? It's normal. Grow up."
"I have grown up. That's why I don't share bedroom details at dinner."
"They're our friends. Friends share."
"You shared. I didn't consent to sharing."
Talia took a long, unbothered sip of her water. "You consented to plenty earlier."
Cass closed her menu hard enough to startle the salt shaker. Milo was doubled over. I had my hand over my mouth and my shoulders were shaking.
"What just happened?" Renee said, looking around the table.
"Talia has no boundaries," I managed.
"I have excellent boundaries. They're just in different places than yours."
"I can't even get a bartender to acknowledge me," Milo said, still wheezing, "and Talia's out here giving a full press conference about her marriage."
"I am sitting right here," Cass said. "And I am choosing peace."
"No you're not," Talia said, completely unbothered.
"That is currently under review."
"Nothing wrong with knowing what you like," Renee said, and she was looking directly at me when she said it.
I became very interested in my water glass. Picked it up, drank more than I needed to, and kept my eyes firmly on the table while the conversation carried on around me, because looking at Renee after that would have required answering a question I hadn't finished forming yet.
Talia was now trying to win Cass back, leaning into her and saying something about making it up to her that made Cass swat her hand away without any real conviction. Milo was helping by offering increasingly unhelpful suggestions — "Flowers, Talia. Grand gestures. Maybe a public apology" — which Talia was ignoring and Cass was pretending not to find funny. The three of them had drifted into their own orbit, voices overlapping, Talia's laugh cutting through Cass's protests, Milo narrating the whole thing like a commentator at a sporting event.
I looked across the table. Renee was watching them too, something soft and amused in her expression that she wasn't bothering to hide. Then she looked at me. The laughter from the other end of the table kept going, but I stopped hearing it.
"You're different here," I said.
Renee tilted her head. "Different how?"
"Different from the airport. Different from the plane. Different from the woman who told me I type like I'm punishing a keyboard."
"I stand by that observation."
"I know you do. But you said it like I was the last person on earth you wanted to be sitting next to. Tonight you're — " I gestured, inadequately. "Here."
She was quiet for a moment. "There was a lot on my mind that day. I wasn't at my best."
"You were pretty effective, for someone not at her best."
Renee smiled. Small, but she let it stay.
"I'm nearly finished with your book," she said.
I waited.
"Most people would write those scenes as performance. That's what the genre does — it gives people something to watch. But you wrote them as conversations. The sex in that book is two people talking to each other with their bodies, and neither of them is performing for an audience. They're just — there. With each other." She paused. "That's a hard thing to pull off. Making intimacy feel private in something that's written to be read."
I didn't say anything for a long moment. The thing about writing a book is that you put everything into it and then people read it and mostly they see the surface — the plot, the heat, the things you assembled for public consumption. And every once in a while someone walks into the room you built underneath all that, the one you didn't put a door on because you weren't sure you wanted anyone to find it, and they describe the furniture.
"That's — yeah," I said. "That's exactly what I was trying to do."
"You sound surprised."
"I am surprised. Most people talk about the other stuff. The heat. The explicit parts."
"I noticed those too." She said it simply. Without edge. "But that's not what made me keep reading."
I held her gaze longer than I should have and forgot what I was going to say next.
"So you know what I do for a living," I said eventually. "And apparently better than most people. What about you? Physical therapy — what does that actually look like?"
"Post-surgical recovery, mostly. Knees, shoulders, spines. People come in after an operation expecting to be fixed and I'm the one who has to tell them we're nowhere close yet."
"How do they take that?"
"Badly. They want the timeline. They want me to tell them exactly when it'll be over. And I can't give them that because healing doesn't work on a schedule."
"So what do you tell them?"
"That they have to trust the process even when it feels like nothing is happening. That's the hardest part. They come in every week and do the same exercises and they can't feel the progress and they start thinking it's not working. That maybe they're broken in a way that won't get better."
"Are they? Sometimes?"
Renee shook her head. "No. Almost never. What's actually happening is they're healing and they can't see it yet because they're too close to it. They're measuring themselves against where they were before the injury, and every day they're not back to that, they think they've failed."
"That sounds exhausting. For them."
"It's exhausting for everyone. But the ones who struggle the most are the ones who were really good at something before. Athletes, dancers, people who used their body at a high level. They have this memory of what they could do, and the gap between that and where they are now is unbearable. So they try to force it. They push too hard, they skip ahead, they do too much too fast because they can't stand sitting in the in-between."
"And that makes it worse."
"Every time. The body can't be bullied into recovery. It shuts down. It protects itself. The more you force it, the more it resists, and then you're further back than when you started."
She turned her water glass a slow quarter-turn on the table. Behind me, Talia laughed at something. I didn't look away.
"So what's the answer? Just wait?"
"Not wait. That's what people get wrong. It's not about doing nothing. It's about doing the small, boring, unglamorous work that doesn't feel like it counts. The stretches that seem pointless. The exercises that feel too easy. The days where all you did was show up and go through the motions and it felt like nothing. Those are the days that matter the most. You just can't see it until later."
I realized I'd stopped breathing. She was talking about patients. About knees and spines and people who couldn't walk. And she had no idea she'd just described the last three months of my life.
"What happens when someone can't do that?" I said. "When they can't do the small boring work. When they just — can't."
Renee was quiet for a second. "Then I sit with them. I don't make them do anything. I just stay in the room and let them be stuck. And eventually, sometimes not that day, sometimes not that week, they try again. Something in them remembers what it felt like to move."
The table was still going around us. Talia was laughing about something. Milo was talking. Glasses were clinking. And I was sitting across from a woman who had just found something I hadn't shown anyone.
"So is this your version of a break from all that?" I asked. "Sun and kayaks and people arguing about bartenders?"
She was quiet for a moment, looking at the ocean, and when she spoke her voice was the same as it always was — level and precise and utterly without self-pity.
"My mother was sick. I was visiting her — she was in a hospital about twenty minutes from where I'd been staying. She died about a week before I was supposed to come here." She said it and left it there. "I'd already booked it. I thought about cancelling. And then I thought I didn't know what I'd do with the time if I stayed. So."
I didn't say anything.
We looked at each other across the table, and neither of us spoke, and neither of us looked away, and the silence between us held everything she'd just said without either of us needing to add anything to it.
"Okay," Milo called from the other end of the table. "Talia says she could outlast Renee in a breath-holding contest and I need this resolved before anyone's allowed to order."
"I said probably," Talia said.
"You said definitely."
"I said probably definitely —"
"That's not a real modifier," Cass said.
Renee looked up. I turned a second later, and the whole table was watching us.
"You two went quiet," Talia said, eyes moving between us.
"Very quiet," Milo added. "Conspicuously quiet."
I opened my mouth, and Renee got there first.
"Just talking about life off the island," she said. Simple. Already past it. "The boring stuff."
She didn't glance at me. Didn't check. Just handled it the way she handled everything — clean, private, without making it anyone else's weight to carry.
"Life off the island is banned," Milo said. "I'm pretty sure it's in the welcome packet."
"There's no welcome packet, Milo," Cass said.
"There should be."
The waiter appeared at the edge of the table, and the evening took over.
"What's the risotto?" Talia asked, leaning forward like the answer might change her life.
"Mushroom and truffle," the waiter said.
"Oh. That changes things." She looked at Cass. "That changes things."
"Order whatever you want, Talia."
"The risotto. Yes. The risotto."
"Grilled salmon," Cass said. "Thank you."
Milo closed his menu and handed it over. "The lamb, please. And can I get extra of whatever sauce it comes with? I don't know what it is yet but I already know I'll want more."
"The grilled fish," Renee said, without looking at the menu.
"The carbonara," I said.
The waiter collected the menus and left. Talia launched into tomorrow — the nature trail, maybe snorkelling, maybe both, because for Talia, an itinerary was never a suggestion. Milo was lobbying for another evening at the bar. Cass was offering logistical corrections nobody had requested.
And Renee was in it. Talking to Cass about the trail. Saying something to Milo about the snorkelling that made him lean forward with interest. Her shoulders were lower than I'd seen them. Her hands were still. She wasn't watching the evening from the outside anymore.
I thought about the woman at the airport curb. How immediately I'd known what I was dealing with. How confident that read had been, and how easy.
Renee caught my eye across the table — brief, already turning back to something Talia was saying — and I held it a second longer than I meant to.
The food hadn't arrived. The evening was just getting started. And the woman sitting across from me was someone I was only beginning to see.

I'd been awake for twenty minutes and hadn't moved.
Not because anything was wrong. The opposite, actually, which was somehow more confusing. I was lying there in the ridiculous cloud mattress with the sheet twisted around one leg and my arm draped over the pillow like I'd been reaching for something in my sleep, and I just didn't want to get up. Not in the way I hadn't wanted to get up two days ago, when the prospect of being here at all felt like a punishment dressed up as self-care. This was different. I didn't want to get up because I was comfortable. Because the morning felt quiet and unhurried and mine, and I couldn't remember the last time a morning had felt like that.
Three days. That's all it had taken for the resort to stop feeling like a sentence and start feeling like a place I was actually staying. I had friends here, which was still a bizarre thing to think. Real ones, or at least the vacation equivalent — people who saved me a seat and yelled my name across dining rooms and debriefed bartender interactions with forensic intensity over breakfast. I had a table I sat at. I had Milo, who had somehow appointed himself my emotional support chaos agent, and Talia, who had folded me into the group before I'd had the chance to object, and Cass, who said things that landed like precision munitions and then went back to eating her eggs.
And then there was Renee.
That was the thought I kept circling back to, lying there with the fan clicking softly above me. Not Renee as the sharp-edged woman who'd called my book a blank page to my face, or the one I'd spent half the shuttle ride wanting to argue with. The Renee from last night. The one who sat across from me at dinner and talked about her patients — people relearning how to walk, how to trust a body that had stopped cooperating — with a kind of steady honesty that I hadn't expected from someone who'd spent most of our interactions being deliberately impossible. She hadn't been performing vulnerability. She'd just been talking, and the talking happened to be the most real thing anyone had said all day. And then, without any fanfare or preamble, she'd mentioned that her mother had died. A week before the trip. Said it like she was reading it off a list. And when the silence that followed could have gone in any direction — pity, awkwardness, someone saying something too gentle — she'd handled it. Redirected the table with a line so clean it barely left a mark. The woman I'd spent three days reading as blunt and closed off had simply been carrying something enormous and choosing not to make it anyone else's problem.
I rolled onto my side and stared at the desk by the window. The notebook was sitting there where I'd left it, the leather cover slightly curled at one corner, the pen still tucked between the pages. I hadn't touched it since that first night — the entry I'd written after the welcome drinks, sitting at that same desk, slightly buzzed and slightly disoriented and apparently compelled to catalogue the strangers I'd just met. I remembered closing it, opening it, rereading what I'd written about Renee, and closing it harder. Like that would help.
I sat up, swung my legs over the edge of the bed, and reached for it before I could talk myself out of it.
The old entry was right where I'd left it. One page, both sides, my handwriting getting looser toward the bottom. Quick sketches of the group — Milo, Talia, Cass — written with the confident detachment of someone who thought she was cataloguing strangers she'd never see again. And then the Renee section at the end. Short, controlled, trying too hard to sound casual, and ending with the line where I'd admitted I was writing about her like a lunatic and needed to stop.
I laughed, which I hadn't expected. The entry was barely three days old and it already read like someone else had written it — someone who liked these people but hadn't figured out yet how much they'd end up mattering.
I grabbed the pen and turned to a fresh page.
The thing about Milo is that he feels everything at full volume and doesn't see any reason to turn it down. He fell for a bartender who has spoken fewer words to him than most people use ordering lunch, and instead of taking that as information, he took it as a challenge. Not even a challenge. A sign. Milo doesn't just wear his heart on his sleeve — he wears it on his face, his hands, his posture, the way he leans forward when he's listening to you like what you're saying might actually be the most important thing he's heard all day. The terrifying part is that he means it. Every time. He is the most emotionally available person I have ever met, and he is directing all of that availability at a man who communicates primarily through cocktail garnishes. If this were fiction, I would cut him for being unrealistic. But he's real, and he's sitting at my breakfast table every morning in a shirt that could cause a migraine, and somehow I can't imagine this trip without him.
I stretched my neck, shifted the notebook to a more comfortable angle, and took a sip from the water glass on the nightstand that I didn't remember pouring.
Cass is the quietest person at the table and somehow the loudest presence in the room. Cass doesn't waste words. She doesn't waste gestures. She doesn't waste the effort it would take to look up from her book when she's about to say the thing that ends you. She just says it, and it lands, and then she goes back to whatever she was doing while you sit there reassessing your entire life. She told me, on my first day with the group, that I'd gotten off on the wrong foot with someone I'd been thinking about all day. She said it like she was noting the weather. I deflected. She didn't push. She didn't have to. Cass plants things and waits. It's the most lawyerly non-lawyer thing I've ever seen, and it's extremely unsettling when you're the one she's planted something in.
I set the pen down for a moment, flexed my writing hand, and stared out the window at the water. The morning light was doing its thing — bright, warm, completely indifferent to the fact that I was sitting here journaling like a college freshman on a study-abroad program. I picked the pen back up.
Talia decided we were friends somewhere between the dock and the boat, and I never got a vote. She pulled me into a golf cart, and by the end of the mixer I had a group and a standing breakfast seat I never agreed to. She is warm the way some people are tall — it's just there, it's just her, it's not something she puts on or adjusts depending on the audience. She tells the story of how she and Cass met differently, and Cass tracks the discrepancies like a court reporter. Talia does not care. Talia is telling a love story, and love stories are allowed to embellish.
Alina I met at the mixer — the kind of person who watches a room the way I do, with that specific professional attention that normal people don't have because normal people aren't always half-composing sentences about what they're seeing. She had a notebook in one hand and wine in the other, and she said something I haven't been able to shake — something about the describing getting in the way of the living. She was talking about herself. She might have also been talking about me. I've been turning it over since that night, the way you turn over a sentence you know is good but can't figure out where it goes yet — because she's right, and I know she's right, and I don't know what to do with that.
Lyle distributes the weekly activity schedule with the quiet intensity of a man who genuinely believes that sunrise yoga could change your life if you'd just commit. The schedule is printed in colour. Every hour is accounted for. I have never in my life met someone so personally invested in other people's leisure time, and I write characters for a living. He is either a visionary or clinically unable to sit still.
I was smiling by the time I finished the Lyle entry, which was not something I would have predicted. This was fun. Not fun like writing fiction was supposed to be fun — not the disciplined, deadline-driven, please-God-let-this-paragraph-work kind of fun. Just fun. Pen on paper, no stakes, no audience, no one waiting for a manuscript. I was just writing about people I'd met and things I'd noticed and none of it mattered and all of it was coming easily, which was such a foreign sensation that I almost didn't trust it.
I turned to a new page and kept writing.
The irony wasn't lost on me. I'd just written five entries about people who hadn't existed in my life a week ago, described with specificity, with something that if I were being generous I might even call voice. The words had come without resistance, without the usual negotiation between my brain and the page where every sentence gets interrogated before it's allowed to exist. I'd sat down and written about Milo's emotional bandwidth and Cass's precision and Talia's warmth and Lyle's unshakeable belief in structured leisure, and all of it had flowed like it was already there, just waiting for me to show up with a pen.
And yet I couldn't produce a single usable sentence of the thing I actually did for a living.
I sat with that for a moment, the pen resting against the page, and instead of closing the notebook and going to brush my teeth like a normal person, I kept going.
I don't understand why this works and that doesn't. I can write about everyone at that breakfast table — what they say, how they move, what they're hiding behind the things they choose to show — and it comes easily, like breathing. But the second I open the laptop and try to do the thing I'm supposed to be good at, the thing people pay me to do, the thing that used to feel as natural as any of this, there's nothing. Not bad writing. Not rough drafts. Nothing. The screen sits there and I sit there and we stare at each other and neither of us blinks. When did it become so hard to do the thing that used to define me? Is it still in there somewhere — the instinct, the muscle, whatever it was that made the sentences come — or did it leave and I just haven't accepted it yet? What happens to the person you were when the thing you built yourself around goes quiet?
The worst part isn't the silence. The worst part is showing up anyway. Sitting down every day in front of the same blank page and not knowing if today is the day it comes back or just another day you prove it won't. And you keep showing up, because what else are you going to do — stop? Admit it's gone? So you sit there, and the page sits there, and you do this quiet, stupid, stubborn thing where you refuse to be the one who leaves first. That's not discipline. I don't know what it is. Maybe it's just the only option that doesn't feel like giving up.
And the people around you — the ones who see you doing this — they split into two kinds. The ones who tell you it'll come back. Who say the right things, the encouraging things, the things that are supposed to help but mostly just remind you that they don't understand what it feels like to reach for something that used to be automatic and find nothing there. And then the other kind. The ones who don't say it'll be fine. The ones who just stay in the room. Who sit with you in the ugly, grinding middle of it without trying to fix it or rush you through it or tell you what the answer is. They just stay. And they're rarer than you'd think, and they're worth more than they'll ever know.
I put the pen down.
I read back what I'd written — and the uncomfortable thing sitting at the center of those last pages wasn't the block. It was what Renee had said. About her patients, about showing up, about staying through the hardest parts. She was somehow everywhere in it. The people who show up and stay. The stubborn, quiet refusal to leave someone alone in the middle of something hard. The ones who don't tell you it'll be fine. She'd talked about her patients at the mixer — what it takes to sit with someone relearning how to trust a body that stopped cooperating — and she hadn't framed it as advice or philosophy. She'd just been talking about her work. And apparently it had lodged somewhere in my brain and stayed there, rearranging things without my permission, because I'd taken her words and turned them inward without even realizing I was doing it.
I reread the pages, my hand aching from how fast I'd been writing. It was honest in a way that my fiction hadn't been in months. Maybe longer. The kind of writing where you look at what you've produced and feel slightly exposed, like you've accidentally left a door open that you normally keep locked. I hadn't sat down to write about Renee Miller. I'd sat down to write about why I couldn't write, and my brain had taken me directly to her without bothering to inform me first.
None of it was usable. It wasn't fiction, it wasn't a chapter, it wasn't something I could hand to Maribel and say "here, I'm not blocked anymore, look." But it was something. It was words that had come from somewhere real and landed on the page without me having to force them, and that hadn't happened since I got here. That hadn't happened in longer than I wanted to admit.
I closed the notebook. Gently, this time.
For a moment I just sat there with it in my lap, the weight of what I'd written still pressing against the inside of my skull, and then I set it on the desk and made a deliberate decision to stop thinking about it. About the block, about the words that had come anyway, about whose voice had apparently been living in my head rent-free since I wasn't paying attention. I could unpack all of that later, or never, or at a time when I wasn't still in my pajamas with unbrushed teeth and a day ahead of me that I was, against all odds, looking forward to.
The morning routine helped — brush teeth, wash face, pull my hair into something deliberate instead of chaotic. I picked out a pair of high-waisted olive shorts and a fitted white tank with a slightly scooped neckline, and then stood in front of the small mirror and applied a thin layer of tinted lip balm. A touch of mascara. Tiny gold studs in my ears. Nothing dramatic. Just enough that when I looked at my reflection, Adrianna was looking back instead of Adrian, and that felt right in the easy, unexamined way it had started to feel right this week — just a settling.
The restaurant was quieter this morning, the breakfast rush already thinned out by the time I got there. I was halfway through the buffet line, loading a plate with eggs and fruit and reaching for coffee, when Talia's voice cut across the room with the precision of someone who had been watching the entrance.
"Ade! Over here!"
The wave that accompanied it was unnecessary. So was the volume. But that was Talia — operating at a frequency that made subtlety physically impossible.
I grabbed my coffee and headed to the table, where the full group was already assembled. Milo in another shirt that looked like a tropical fever dream had been screen-printed onto cotton. Cass with a half-eaten plate and a book face-down beside it. And Renee, in a loose linen top with her hair pulled back, sitting at the end of the table with a cup of coffee and the kind of stillness that made everyone else look like they were trying too hard.
The open seat was next to Renee, so I took it.
"Hi," I said, setting my plate down and sliding into the chair with what I hoped was a normal amount of casualness.
Renee looked up at me and smiled — a real one, easy and unguarded in a way I hadn't seen from her before. "Hi," she said, and returned to her coffee.
I turned to face the table and found Milo and Talia staring at me with matching grins so wide they looked like they'd been surgically enhanced. Milo had his chin propped on both hands. Talia's eyebrows were approximately at her hairline. Cass, beside them, was methodically working through a piece of toast and paying attention to nothing and no one.
"What?" I asked.
"Nothing," Milo said, his grin not moving even slightly.
"Absolutely nothing," Talia confirmed, still beaming.
"You're both looking at me like I just walked in with a puppy."
"Are we?" Milo widened his eyes with theatrical innocence. "I didn't notice. Talia, were we looking at her?"
"I wasn't looking at anyone," Talia said, looking directly at me.
Cass took a bite of toast and didn't participate. Renee sipped her coffee. I decided the safest course of action was to eat my breakfast and stop making eye contact with people who clearly couldn't be trusted.
The grins faded once the table settled back into its natural rhythm, and within a few minutes breakfast was just breakfast again.
"I'm just saying, the breakfast buffet has six types of bread but no brioche," Milo was saying as I started on my eggs. "That's a choice. That's a deliberate omission. Someone in that kitchen looked at the bread lineup and said, 'this is fine,' and they were wrong."
"It's bread, Milo," Cass said, not looking up from her book.
"It's the principle, Cass. If you're going to commit to a spread, commit to the spread."
"I want you to stop talking about bread at breakfast."
Renee ate her food and stayed out of it, and Talia was scrolling through her phone, tilting the screen toward Cass every few seconds. Cass didn't bite once.
"Oh, did anyone see that couple at the pool yesterday?" Talia asked, leaning forward. "Matching swimsuits, matching cocktails — do you think that's love or a shared Instagram account?"
"Codependency," Cass said.
"You're no fun." Talia grinned. "We had matching outfits once. You cried in the fitting room at Nordstrom."
"I didn't cry. I got emotional. Not really the same thing."
"We looked incredible, Cass. Sometimes beauty moves you." Talia was smiling at the memory now, and it pulled her somewhere else. "God, remember our first anniversary? Tell them about the gifts."
"No," Cass said.
"Tell them."
"Absolutely not."
"Fine, I'll tell them." Talia turned to the rest of us, already delighted. "So for our first anniversary, we decided we were going to make each other gifts. Not buy — make."
"That was your idea," Cass said.
"It was a beautiful idea. So I made her this whole hand-lettered print — her favorite quote, custom frame, took me a week. Not to brag, but it was gorgeous. It's still on our bedroom wall."
"It is gorgeous," Cass confirmed, like she was entering evidence.
"And then Cass gives me hers." Talia paused for effect, pressing her lips together to keep from laughing. "She tried to hand-stitch a pouch for me. Like, a little fabric pouch for my earrings."
"It was supposed to be a clutch," Cass said quietly.
The table went very still. Milo's fork was frozen halfway to his mouth.
"A clutch," Talia repeated, and something in her voice cracked. "Babe, it looked like a sock that had been through something traumatic. The stitching was — I don't even know what direction it was going. One side was longer than the other. The fabric was inside out and she'd just committed to it anyway."
"I followed the instructions," Cass said, staring straight ahead with the composure of someone testifying under oath.
"There was a button on it. Just one. It didn't close anything. It was just there." Talia was wiping her eyes now, laughing so hard she could barely get the words out. "And the thing is, she spent three weeks on it. Three weeks, and she never once Googled whether she was doing it right because — and I quote — 'the instructions were clear.'"
Milo had put his fork down and was gripping the edge of the table. Even Renee was laughing — quietly, almost privately, but unmistakably.
"I still have it," Talia said, and the laughter softened into something else. "It's in my nightstand. I've kept it for seven years. It's the ugliest thing anyone has ever made me, and it's my favorite thing I own."
Cass didn't say anything for a moment. She just looked at Talia with an expression I hadn't seen from her before — unguarded, something that existed entirely between the two of them and had nothing to do with anyone else at the table. Then she leaned over and kissed Talia on the lips, brief and certain, the way you kiss someone you've been kissing for eight years and still mean it every time.
"The instructions were clear," Cass said when she pulled back, and Talia laughed.
Milo pressed his hand to his chest. "I need a moment. I am emotionally compromised."
"You seem to need a lot of moments," Cass said, but she was still half-smiling.
Milo leaned back in his chair and sighed. "Seven years and she still keeps the ugly clutch," he said, shaking his head. "I want someone who'd keep my ugly clutch. Is that too much to ask? A person. A real, actual person who talks to me. With words. Full sentences. Maybe even paragraphs, if we're being ambitious."
"So not Nico," Cass said.
"Nico talks," Milo protested, sitting up straighter. "He told me I'd muddled my daiquiri too aggressively. That's practically a sonnet from him."
"That's a workplace safety note, Milo."
"The way he said it was romantic."
"He was concerned about the mint."
Talia snorted into her juice. The Nico conversation had been funny at first, the way it always was, but there was a stretch in the middle where Milo's voice had shifted — not dramatically, not enough that anyone who wasn't paying attention would have clocked it, but the performance thinned out for a second and something more raw showed through. He genuinely wanted this. Not just Nico specifically, but the thing — the connection, the person, the reciprocity.
Renee caught it too. She didn't make a production of it. She waited until Cass and Talia had moved on to debating whether Nico's apparent stoicism was cultural or pathological, and then she turned to Milo and said, "You'll find someone who matches what you bring to the table."
Milo looked at her for a second, something shifting behind his expression before he caught it. "Well," he said, straightening up and clearing his throat, "I'm putting 'brings a lot to the table' on my dating profile. I have a witness now."
Renee didn't smile, but she didn't need to. She'd said what she meant and moved on, and Milo had heard her, and I sat there thinking about the fact that I'd spent the last three days joking and teasing and performing elaborate bits about Nico's communication style and none of it had landed the way that one sentence just did.
"What about you, Ade?" Talia asked. "Any great love waiting for you back home? Terrible love? Middling love with potential?"
"No love of any variety, actually." I speared a piece of mango with my fork and kept my voice light. "Last relationship ended about a year and a half ago. It fizzled — just slowly, like a tire losing air. One day you look over and realize you're both just sitting in a parked car."
"That's worse," Milo said, and for once he wasn't being dramatic.
"The ironic part," I continued, because I could already feel the table tilting toward sympathy and I needed to steer it somewhere else, "is that I write about passion for a living. Like, that's literally what I do. People falling into each other so hard they can't breathe. People saying the things you're supposed to be too scared to say. Wanting someone so badly it rearranges you. I write all of that, and apparently I cannot locate any of it in my actual life. Which is fine. It's fine. The shoemaker's kids go barefoot. The romance writer goes home alone. It's basically a proverb at this point."
The table softened without going mournful, which was all I needed. Talia made a sympathetic noise. Milo pointed his fork at me and said, "You're going to find someone ridiculous and perfect and completely wrong for you on paper, and it's going to be disgusting, and I'm going to take full credit."
And Renee was quiet. She just looked at me, steady and direct, with an expression I couldn't fully decode except that it had understanding in it. Like she'd heard everything I'd said and everything I hadn't, and the space between those two things was the part that mattered. Then she took a sip of her coffee and didn't look away, and I was the one who broke eye contact first, reaching for my own cup with slightly more urgency than the situation required.
"Okay, Renee," Milo said, pivoting with the subtlety of a man parallel-parking a freight train. "Your turn."
"My turn for what?" Renee set her cup down with the calm of someone who had already decided she wasn't answering.
"Relationship status. Love life. Emotional landscape." Milo leaned forward. "Are you single?"
The table went very still. Talia had stopped chewing. Cass was watching with an expression that said she already knew how this was going to go.
"Yes," Renee said, after a pause that made Talia hold her breath.
"Recently single?"
"Milo."
"That wasn't a no." Milo had the look of a man who smelled blood in the water and had no intention of swimming away from it.
"That was a tone."
"Was it a bad breakup?"
Renee picked up her coffee, took a slow sip, and set it back down. "Most of them are."
"So there was a breakup," Milo said, practically vibrating.
Renee sighed through her nose, the kind that meant she was deciding how much to give him. "I broke up with my girlfriend about a month ago," she said, with the clinical precision of someone reading lab results. "It wasn't amicable. She disagreed with the premise. I disagreed with continuing to pretend we were still working. We were not, in fact, still working. End of story."
Talia's face softened immediately. "I'm sorry, Renee. That's really—"
"It's done," Renee said, not unkindly but with a finality that closed the door on whatever Talia had been about to offer. "It's done. That's the whole update."
The silence that followed lasted about four seconds before Cass set her coffee cup down and surveyed the table with the measured disapproval of a woman who had watched her breakfast be slowly colonized by emotional confessions.
"So to be clear," Cass said, looking from Talia to Milo and back, "between the two of you, we've now covered unrequited bartender obsession, existential singledom, and a breakup that's still warm. Before nine-thirty. On vacation."
"We were sharing," Talia said, defensive and completely unapologetic.
"You were excavating."
"We were just talking! People talk at breakfast!"
"The conversation went there because you steered it there with both hands, Tal. I watched you do it."
"I'm being attacked," Talia said, turning to Milo for support.
"Viciously," Milo agreed, straightening in his chair despite having been entirely complicit. "We were having a beautiful moment of group vulnerability, and now it's being criminalized."
"I'm not criminalizing anything. I'm noting the pattern." Cass picked up her toast again. "You two are incapable of letting a breakfast pass without turning it into a support group."
"That is slander, Cassandra," Milo said, pressing a hand to the table.
"It's observation, Milo. I observe." Cass picked up her coffee. "It's what I do."
Milo pushed his chair back with theatrical affront. "I need more coffee," he announced, standing up and straightening his shirt. "Some of us process conflict through caffeine, Cass. Not everyone has your constitution."
"Enjoy your process," Cass said without looking up.
"I will." Milo turned on his heel and headed toward the counter, his posture radiating wounded nobility.
"I think I need more fruit," I said, grabbing my plate and standing up. Cass's eyes tracked both departures but she said nothing.
Milo was standing at the coffee station with his arms crossed, staring at the espresso machine like it owed him money.
"You're not actually upset," I said, pulling up beside him and reaching for the fruit display.
"I'm moderately upset," he corrected, uncrossing his arms to grab a cup. "Cass acts like emotional honesty is a public health violation."
"Cass made a fair point. You interrogated Renee like she was on the witness stand."
"I asked questions. That's how conversation works. People ask things, other people answer. It's a system."
"You asked a woman you've known for three days whether her breakup was bad."
"It's been an intense three days." He poured his coffee and turned to face me with the smile that meant he was about to pivot to something I wouldn't like.
"Speaking of which," he said.
"Whatever you're about to say, I already don't like your face," I told him, reaching for the fruit display.
"You haven't even heard it yet."
"I don't need to, Milo. That smile is doing all the talking."
"That little 'hi' at the table." He held up his fingers about an inch apart. "That tiny, adorable, completely loaded 'hi.' With the smile. Her smile, Ade. That was a real smile. I'm a medical professional. I can identify facial muscle groups."
"You're a nurse, Milo. You take blood pressure."
"I take blood pressure and I observe human behavior, and what I observed this morning was a very specific kind of 'hi' and a very specific kind of smile directed at a very specific person who is standing right in front of me pretending she didn't notice."
"I said hello to someone I know at a breakfast table. That's what people do."
"People don't blush when they do it."
"I didn't blush."
"Your ears went pink."
"My ears did not go—" I stopped, because I could feel them betraying me in real time. "She just told us she broke up with her girlfriend a month ago. That's not exactly an invitation to—"
"To what?" Milo's grin widened. "Finish that sentence. I want to hear where you were going with it."
"To nothing. I wasn't going anywhere with it."
"You were going somewhere very specific with it, and you stopped because you heard yourself."
I selected a piece of pineapple with a level of concentration it absolutely did not require and refused to look at him.
"She's single, Ade," Milo said..
"I heard."
"She smiled at you."
"She smiled at a person who sat down next to her," I said, stabbing a piece of pineapple. "It's called manners."
"She just told us she broke up with her girlfriend a month ago and she still smiled at you like that. That's not manners. That's—"
"Milo, I swear—"
"That's a choice," he finished, looking enormously pleased with himself.
Renee appeared at the counter before I could commit the homicide I was considering, reaching past us for the coffee carafe with the easy, unhurried movements of someone who hadn't been the subject of an unauthorized tactical analysis five seconds ago. She filled her cup, took a sip, and glanced between us with an expression that missed nothing.
"What are you two talking about?" she asked, her eyes settling on me.
I could feel the flush threatening to crawl up my neck and willed it into nonexistence through sheer force. "Milo's being absurd about things that aren't his business," I said, looking at him with an expression that, if he had any self-preservation instincts at all, he would interpret as a final warning.
Milo interpreted it perfectly and decided to ignore it. "I was simply observing—"
"He was simply leaving," I said.
Milo looked at me. Looked at Renee. Looked at me again with an expression of such transparent delight that I wanted to throw a piece of fruit at him. "Fine," he said, picking up his coffee with exaggerated care. "I'll be at the table. Where I will sit quietly. And observe nothing. Like a very handsome, very perceptive rock." He sauntered back toward the group without a shred of remorse.
Renee watched him go, then turned back to her coffee. "He's a lot."
"He's a natural disaster in a parrot shirt."
Renee huffed a small laugh, close to the real thing but not quite there, and we stood at the counter for a moment — me picking through the fruit display with no real purpose, Renee sipping her coffee and watching the room.
"I didn't know about the breakup," I said, after a moment. "On top of everything else."
Renee turned her cup slowly in her hands. "Yeah. The timing was pretty spectacular." There was no bitterness in it, or if there was, she'd already processed it and set it aside. "But what can you do. Life doesn't schedule these things with spacing in mind."
"I never actually said it properly," I said, and she looked at me. "About your mother. I'm sorry."
She held my gaze for a second, and I could tell it hadn't stopped hurting just because she'd stopped talking about it. "Thank you," she said, simply and sincerely. "It's okay. Really."
I nodded, and the conversation could have ended there, in that small, honest pocket of quiet between two people who were still learning each other's edges. The silence was comfortable, though, and maybe that's why I let the next thing out of my mouth instead of keeping it where it belonged.
"You know, you'd make a perfect muse," I said. "Tragic backstory, enigmatic personality, the whole thing. I could get three novels out of you, minimum."
Renee raised an eyebrow. "Is that your pitch?"
"That's my professional assessment. You're practically a character already."
"A character." Renee almost smiled. "Am I at least a main character?"
"You're too complicated for a supporting role."
"Do I get royalties?" She took a sip of her coffee, and when she lowered the cup she was smiling — a real one, warm and unguarded. "What's my arc?"
"Still figuring that out," I said, and it came out more honest than I'd intended.
"Well," Renee said, turning back toward the table, "let me know when you do."
I grabbed a piece of melon, mostly for credibility, and caught up to Renee before she reached the table.
We were a few steps away when I clocked Milo and Talia leaning together with their heads approximately three inches apart, whispering with the urgent intensity of two people planning a bank heist. Cass was next to them, rolling her eyes.
The whispering cut off the second we sat down. Milo straightened so fast he nearly knocked over his coffee. Talia produced a smile that was approximately forty percent too wide to be natural.
"What's going on?" I asked. Talia was suddenly fascinated by her juice glass. Milo had arranged his face into an expression so aggressively innocent he looked like a suspect who'd just swallowed the evidence.
"Nothing's going on," Milo said brightly. "We were just talking about — what were we talking about, Talia?"
"The weather," Talia said, at the exact same time Milo said, "Snorkeling."
They looked at each other.
"The weather for snorkeling," Talia corrected smoothly.
"Perfect conditions," Milo added, nodding vigorously.
I stared at Milo until I could feel the weight of it registering on his face. He shifted in his chair. Then he picked up his coffee cup and hid behind it.
Cass, who had been watching this entire performance with the resigned patience of a woman who had long ago accepted that her life would contain these moments, unfolded her arms. "What they're not telling you," she said, "is that they've been discussing how certain combinations of people seem to bring out the best in each other, and whether the group dynamic could benefit from some strategic activity planning. It's very altruistic."
I blinked, trying to figure out what Cass had just said and why it felt like it meant more than it sounded.
"What does that mean?" Renee asked, looking genuinely confused.
"Don't worry about it," Milo said, flashing a smile so polished and transparently fake that it practically came with a warranty. "We're just enthusiastic about group bonding."
"Group bonding," I repeated flatly, staring at Milo with the kind of look that, in a just world, would have caused physical discomfort.
Milo clocked the look. His eyes widened. He set down his coffee cup and held up both hands. "I think what Cass is trying to say—"
"I said exactly what I wanted to say," Cass interjected.
"— is that we all bring different energies to the table, and that's beautiful, and we should celebrate it."
"By doing what, exactly?" I asked.
"By enjoying each other's company! At various resort activities! That's what vacations are for, Ade." He spread his arms wide, nearly clipping Talia's juice glass. "Connection. Togetherness. Vitamin D."
"You're being very weird right now."
"I'm being passionate about friendship."
"You're being suspicious about something, and I don't know what it is, but I can see it on your face."
Milo pressed his hand to his chest. "This face has never been anything other than open and transparent."
"That face looks like it's hiding a body," I said, and Renee laughed — an actual laugh, short and surprised and warm — and Milo's eyes darted between us so fast I could practically hear the gears turning.
"So what are we doing this afternoon?" Talia asked, pivoting so smoothly it was almost professional. I made a mental note that this woman could change a subject the way other people changed lanes — no signal, no hesitation, already gone before you noticed.
"There's a volleyball net set up near the beach," Renee said, almost casually.
Milo nearly knocked his coffee over for the second time. "Volleyball. Yes. We're doing that. When?"
"I said there's a net, Milo. I didn't say—"
"After lunch. We'll go after lunch." He looked around the table like a man assembling a team for a mission. "Everyone in?"
"I didn't agree to anything," I said.
"You didn't say no," Talia pointed out.
"That's not the same as—"
"That's a yes," Milo confirmed, already moving on. "Renee's in. Cass?"
"I'll watch," Cass said.
"You'll play," Talia corrected.
Cass sighed. That was apparently also a yes.
"So are we actually playing competitively or is this more of a 'hit the ball and see what happens' situation?" Milo asked, already invested.
"It's vacation volleyball, Milo," Talia said. "Nobody's keeping score."
"I'm keeping score," Cass said, without looking up.
"Has anyone actually played volleyball recently?" Renee asked, and everyone looked at her because she'd been quiet for the last few minutes and had clearly been following every word regardless.
"I played in college," Talia said.
"I played at a barbecue once," Milo offered. "I was adequate. Mostly."
"That 'mostly' is doing a lot of work," Cass said.
"What about you, Ade?" Talia asked, turning to me. "Any volleyball experience?"
"I watched a game on TV once," I said. "Ate chips the entire time. That's the extent of my training."
"So we're all terrible," Milo said, looking genuinely delighted. "That's actually perfect. Nobody can be disappointed."
"I can," Cass said.
"Cass, respectfully, you're going to be keeping score from a lounge chair," Milo said. "Your expectations are irrelevant."
"My expectations are never irrelevant," Cass said, and Talia kissed her on the cheek and said, "She's right, they're not."
Milo turned to Renee. "Please tell me you're also terrible. I need solidarity."
Renee took a sip of her coffee. "I played in high school."
"Great," Milo groaned. "So Talia played in college, you played in high school, and I hit a ball at a barbecue. At least Ade and I can be terrible together."
"I didn't say I was good," Renee said.
"You didn't say you weren't," I pointed out, and Renee glanced at me with something close to amusement.
"I was okay," she said. "It's been a while."
"'It's been a while' from someone who actually played is still better than 'I ate chips,'" Milo said, pointing at me. "This is going to be fun."
"It's going to be something," Cass said, reaching for the last of her coffee, and the table dissolved into the kind of loose, overlapping laughter that didn't need a reason.
"So lunch first, then beach?" Milo said, stacking his plate on Talia's like she'd volunteered for cleanup duty.
"Lunch, then beach, then volleyball, then whatever happens after that," Talia said, ticking them off on her fingers.
"That's a whole itinerary," I said.
"That's a warm-up," Milo corrected.
Cass stood up, tucked her book under her arm, and looked at Talia. "I need to change if I'm being dragged into a sport."
"You're not being dragged. You volunteered."
"I sighed, Talia. That's not volunteering."
"It is in this marriage," Talia said, taking Cass's arm as they headed toward the path. Milo trailed after them, already debating whether board shorts counted as athletic wear.
Renee stood up. "I'm heading back," she said, glancing at me. "You coming?"
"Yeah," I said, grabbing my plate. "Same direction anyway."
We fell into step on the path that wound between the bungalows. The morning was warm without being aggressive about it, and the sounds from the restaurant faded quickly into the quieter rhythm of the grounds — birds, distant water, the crunch of our sandals on the gravel.
"So how bad are you actually going to be at this?" Renee asked, not looking at me.
"At volleyball? Genuinely terrible," I said. "I wasn't exaggerating about the chips. That's my entire athletic history."
"You were fine in the kayak," she said.
"You had to coach me through half of it."
"I gave you one tip. You figured out the rest."
"That's a generous read of what happened," I said, and Renee made a sound that was almost a laugh.
"Milo's going to be a problem out there," I said after a moment. "He's going to treat every point like a life event."
"He does seem like the type," Renee said.
"Him and Talia together are going to be chaos," I said. "They feed off each other's energy."
"Speaking of those two," Renee said, glancing at me, "what was all that whispering about? When we got back to the table."
"No idea," I said. "I asked and got a weather forecast that may or may not have involved snorkeling."
"Something was off there," Renee said.
"You noticed that too?" I shook my head. "Milo straightened up so fast he almost broke something, and Talia was suddenly fascinated by her juice glass."
"Weird," Renee said.
"That doesn't bother you?" I asked.
"Should it?" Renee asked.
"It bothers me," I said. "Milo had a face like he'd swallowed evidence."
Renee actually laughed at that — short, easy, her shoulders dropping a fraction. "He did look like that," she admitted. "But Talia had it worse. That juice glass fascination was criminal."
"Completely criminal," I agreed, and we were both smiling now, the kind of shared amusement that didn't need to be explained because we'd both been sitting at the same table watching the same two people act like complete idiots.
We reached my bungalow and I slowed, turning toward the door.
Renee kept walking, then half-turned. "See you at lunch?"
"See you at lunch," I said.
She raised a hand slightly — the closest thing to a wave Renee Miller would ever produce — and continued down the path toward bungalow 12.
I went inside and dropped my key on the side table. The notebook was still on the desk where I'd left it, closed.
I sat on the edge of the bed and kicked off my sandals.
I looked at the notebook for a moment, thinking about the pages inside — the first thing I'd written in months that hadn't felt like pulling teeth. Something about that was still warm, still close. And underneath it, faint but unmistakable, there was something else. Not a story, not yet. But the shape of one, maybe. A character who helps people put themselves back together while quietly falling apart herself. A woman who listens more than she speaks and says more in silence than most people say with words. It wasn't the kind of thing I wrote — not even close — and I had no idea what I'd do with it. But it was there, the first flicker of something that felt like it could become an idea if I let it.
And then, quietly, Renee's voice: Well, let me know when you do.

The path to the beach was warm and shaded, palm fronds cutting the afternoon sun into strips across the sand-dusted walkway.
I'd changed into a navy bikini top and denim shorts after lunch, thrown a towel over my shoulder, grabbed a water bottle I already knew I'd lose within the hour, and headed out before I could sit back down at the desk. The afternoon was waiting and for once I wanted to be in it.
The beach opened up through the last stretch of palm trees and it was, as usual, almost absurdly beautiful. White sand, calm turquoise water, the kind of postcard light that made everything look slightly unreal. Talia and Cass were already set up near the volleyball net — Talia in a bright coral one-piece that made her look like she was about to host a poolside talk show, Cass in a simple black swimsuit and sunglasses, reclining on a towel with the resigned grace of a woman whose afternoon had been volunteered without her consent.
Milo was standing at the net, shirtless, holding a volleyball above his head and squinting at it like it held the secrets of the universe.
"There she is!" Talia waved me over with both hands. "We were about to send a search party."
"I've been gone twenty minutes," I said, dropping my towel next to Cass's setup and kicking off my sandals.
"Twenty minutes is a long time when Milo's been holding that ball like it's an Oscar," Cass said.
Milo lowered the ball with dignity. "I was getting a feel for the equipment. That's what athletes do."
"You played at a barbecue," I reminded him.
"I was adequate at a barbecue. There's range in that word."
Renee appeared on the path behind me, and I only knew because Milo's face did something I was learning to recognize — a flicker of theatrical innocence that meant he was about to be strategic about something. She was wearing a simple white tank over a black bikini, her hair pulled back loose, a towel tucked under one arm. She looked good without looking like she'd tried, and I acknowledged that thought and moved on from it with practiced efficiency.
"Alright," Talia said, clapping her hands and standing. "Teams."
"Finally," Milo said, bouncing the ball against the sand — or trying to. It hit the ground and died. He picked it up like the sand owed him an apology.
"Renee and Ade," Talia said, pointing at us, "you take that side. Me, Milo, and Cass on this side."
I looked at her. Then at Milo. Then back at Talia.
"That's two against three," I said.
"You have Renee," Talia said, like this was a complete and self-evident argument.
"She played in high school. That was — Renee, how long ago was high school?"
"A while," Renee said, with a diplomatic vagueness.
"And I played in college," Talia added, "so it evens out."
"It doesn't even out. You have three people. We have two. That's math, Talia," I said, gesturing between the two sides of the net.
"Ade, Renee played in high school. Talia played in college. That's your ringer against ours," Milo said, tossing the ball from hand to hand. "And our third is Cass, who just told us she'd rather be reading. We're basically two and a hostage."
"Incredibly rude. And accurate, but still rude," Cass said from the towel, not opening her eyes.
"Get up," Talia said. "You're playing."
Cass removed her sunglasses, looked at the net, looked at Talia, and stood up with the energy of someone clocking in for a shift she hadn't volunteered for.
"So we're doing this," I said, still standing on what was apparently my side of the net with Renee.
"We're doing this," Talia confirmed, already bouncing on her toes with a focus that had shifted from casual organizer to someone who genuinely cared about winning a game of beach volleyball.
I turned to Renee. "Any strategy, or are we just hoping for the best?"
Renee was stretching her arms above her head, easy and unhurried. "Don't stand in the same spot. Move after every hit. And try to watch the ball, not the person hitting it."
"That sounds like actual strategy," I said.
Renee shrugged and walked to her position near the back of the court like she still remembered exactly where to stand.
I took my spot at the net and tried to look like someone who had any idea what they were doing. Across from me, Milo was stretching his hamstrings with the intensity of a man preparing for a triathlon, Talia was rolling her neck, and Cass was standing with her hands on her hips, radiating the energy of someone who would play competently and resent every second.
Milo served first. It went left.
Renee returned it cleanly — a smooth, practiced motion that sent the ball sailing back over the net with enough force and placement that Talia had to scramble for it. She got it, sent it to Milo, who launched it back toward our side with a grunt that was wildly disproportionate to the situation.
It came at me. I swung. I missed. The ball hit the sand approximately two feet from where my hand had been.
"Bold strategy," Cass observed from across the net.
"I'm warming up," I said, shaking out my wrists like that was the problem.
"To what?" Milo asked, genuinely curious.
"To being terrible. You can't rush these things." I got back into position, or what I assumed position looked like.
The next few rallies established the dynamic pretty clearly. Talia was competitive in a way that had been hiding behind her cheerful resort energy — she moved with real instinct, called shots, and made at least two saves that involved diving for the ball with a commitment that seemed medically inadvisable on sand. Milo played with maximum effort and moderate skill, celebrating every point their side scored with a fist pump and a "YES" that sent birds scattering from a nearby palm. Cass played like someone filling out a form — correctly, completely, without enthusiasm, and with a baseline competence that was somehow more annoying than if she'd been terrible.
On our side, Renee was good. Not "I played in high school" good. Actually good. She moved with the kind of fluid economy that meant her body remembered this even if it had been years, anticipated where the ball was going before it got there, and positioned herself to cover the gaps my incompetence kept creating. When she hit the ball, it went where she wanted it to go. When she set it up for me, she put it exactly where I needed it to be, which was generous given that I needed it approximately three inches from my hand and traveling at the speed of a gentle breeze.
"Nice one!" she said when I managed to return a serve that, in fairness, a reasonably coordinated child could have handled.
"I touched the ball and it went over the net. Is that really 'nice'?"
"For you? That's outstanding."
"I'm being patronized by my own teammate."
"You're being encouraged," Renee said, and she was smiling when she said it, and I hit the next ball into the net because apparently I couldn't receive a compliment and perform basic motor functions at the same time.
They were beating us, obviously. Talia was keeping a running score that she announced after every point, which Cass told her was unnecessary, which Talia ignored. Renee was returning serves I wouldn't have gotten near, covering ground with the kind of instinct that made "I played in high school" sound increasingly like the understatement of the century.
"Switch sides!" Talia called after a run of points that had put them firmly in the lead.
"Why?" I asked.
"Because the sun's in your eyes and I want a fair game," Talia said, already moving to the other side.
"Since when do you want a fair game?" I called after her. "You put two of us against three."
"The sun is a factor, Ade. Accept the courtesy."
We switched. Renee passed close to me on the rotation and said, low enough that only I could hear, "She doesn't care about the sun. She wants to serve from that side."
"Of course she does," I muttered, still catching my breath from the last few points I'd contributed nothing to.
"Watch. Her first serve from over there is going to have pace on it."
She'd given me three words of advice at the start and walked to her position like none of this mattered. Now she was reading Talia's strategy in real time. "You're enjoying this."
"A little," Renee said, already setting up on the new side.
What followed could only loosely be called volleyball. Talia disputed a line call with the conviction of someone who had studied the replay. Milo spiked the ball directly into the sand on his own side and then argued that the wind was responsible. Cass, in a moment that shocked everyone including herself, dove for a save, got it, rolled onto her back in the sand, and stayed there looking at the sky with an expression of profound disbelief.
"I just did that," Cass said, still on her back.
"You just did that!" Talia was already pulling her up, brushing sand off her back, kissing her on the cheek. "That was incredible."
"That was involuntary. My body did that without my consent."
"Your body is a hero, babe."
"My body is filing a complaint."
Renee and I were losing, but the gap was narrowing, mostly because Renee had figured out exactly how to set every ball for me so that all I had to do was make contact, and I was starting to actually make contact with something approaching regularity. At one point I returned a serve from Talia — a real one, with pace on it — and sent it back into an open patch of sand that nobody reached.
I stood there for a second, genuinely surprised.
"That counted, right?" I said, turning to Renee. "That was a real point?"
"That was a real point," Renee confirmed, and something in her expression — amusement, warmth, maybe even a little pride — made me feel like I'd just done something considerably more significant than hitting a volleyball.
"Okay, I need water," Milo announced, dropping to the sand and spreading out flat on his back. "I need water and I need someone to acknowledge that I gave everything out there."
"You gave everything," Talia said, dropping beside him. "I'll give you that."
"Thank you. That's all I ask." Milo lifted one hand from the sand in a solemn gesture. "Acknowledgment."
"You also served into the net four times," Renee said from our side, in the tone of someone providing a stat nobody had requested.
Milo lifted his head. "You were counting?"
"It was hard not to."
"You were counting my mistakes while we were playing. That's cold, Renee."
"You were on the other team, slugger."
"Betrayal," Milo said, putting his head back down. "Cold, calculated betrayal from a woman I've known for three days."
Cass was already back on her towel, sunglasses on, book out — she'd returned to her default state so fast it was like the volleyball had been a hallucination. Talia was chugging water. I dropped onto the sand next to Milo and tipped my head back. Everything hurt. My arms, my legs, muscles I was fairly certain hadn't existed an hour ago and would now be making themselves known for the rest of the trip. I was also smiling, which felt like a personal betrayal of everything I'd ever believed about physical activity.
Renee dropped down near us, pulled her hair loose, and finished half a water bottle in one go — somehow looking less wrecked than the rest of us.
"We should cool off," Talia said, standing up and brushing sand off her legs. "Come on, we're getting in the water."
"I just sat down," Milo protested.
"You can sit down in the ocean." She was already heading toward the water, not waiting for agreement. Cass sighed, set her book down, and followed — the eternal rhythm of that marriage.
Milo hauled himself up with a groan that belonged to a man twice his age and jogged after them, immediately yelping about the water temperature the second it touched his ankles. "It's freezing! Why is it freezing? It's a hundred degrees out here!"
"It's not freezing Milo,," Cass said, already waist-deep and looking unmoved.
"My body is in shock."
"Your body was in shock from the volleyball. Now it's in shock from the water. Your body has a flair for the dramatic."
"Thank you. I've been saying that for years."
Renee stood up, pulled her tank off over her head, and headed for the water. I watched her for a second, then got up and followed — denim shorts and all.
The water was perfect — warm at the surface, cooler underneath, the kind of temperature that made your whole body exhale. Talia and Cass were further out, Talia floating on her back while Cass treaded water beside her. Milo had adjusted to the temperature and was now fully committed, bobbing up to his chest.
"There's something down there," Milo said, peering into the water. "I think it's a jellyfish."
"It's seaweed," Cass called without looking.
"You didn't even look," Milo said, still peering into the water.
"I don't need to," Cass said from further out.
"That's exactly the attitude that gets people stung by jellyfish."
I waded in until the water was around my waist and stood there, letting the tension from the game dissolve into the gentle pull of the current. Renee was a few feet to my left, about the same depth, her shoulders just above the waterline.
A wave came in — bigger than the ones before, the kind that announces itself with a surge and then shoves. It caught me mid-stance and my footing went sideways on the sandy bottom, and for a graceless second I was tilting, arms pinwheeling, about to go under in the least dignified way possible.
Renee's hand caught my arm. Firm, quick, steadying me before I'd fully committed to the fall. Her grip was warm against my wet skin and she was close — closer than I'd registered, close enough that I could see the salt water beading along her collarbone and the way her hair had gone dark and heavy where the water had reached it.
"The ocean's also too much for you, apparently," she said, and she grinned — full and unguarded, her eyes crinkling at the edges, wide and easy and aimed directly at me.
My brain, which normally had a rebuttal queued up before the other person finished their sentence, produced nothing. Just a blank space where the words were supposed to go. Renee's hand was still on my arm. Her hair was wet and dark against her neck and she was close — close enough that the grin hadn't faded and the sun was making it impossible to think about anything else. I was suddenly conscious of my own skin, of exactly where her fingers met my forearm and the warm salt water between us that wasn't doing anything useful like creating distance.
I should have said something. Anything. Instead, what came out was: "I had it under control."
Renee let go of my arm, still grinning. "You were going down."
"I was recalibrating."
"You were drowning in three feet of water."
"I was doing it with intention."
She laughed and turned back toward the deeper water. Milo was shouting something at Cass from further out. The afternoon was still happening all around me and I was standing in waist-deep water with the ghost of her hand on my arm and no idea what to do with any of it.
The volleyball. The sun. The dehydration. There were explanations, and I was going to pick one and commit to it fully, and I was never going to think about the way she'd grinned at me like it was nothing or the way my pulse was doing something unhelpful behind my ears.
"Ade!" Milo shouted from further out. "Did you just almost drown?"
"No," I called back.
"She almost drowned," Renee said, loud enough for the whole group, not turning around.
"I did not almost drown." I waded deeper, mostly to have something to do with my legs. "I lost my balance for one second."
"In three feet of water," Renee added, and I could hear the smile in her voice even though she was facing away from me now, and I realized I was in trouble in a way that had absolutely nothing to do with the ocean.
We stayed in the water until the sun shifted and the afternoon went golden and lazy around us. When we finally waded back to shore, nobody was in a hurry to do anything about it.
"I'm starving," Milo announced, lying face-down on his towel.
"We had lunch," Cass said.
"That was ages ago. I've been through a war since then."
"You hit a ball around and went swimming."
"Exactly. A war."
"We should go to the bar," Talia said, already sitting up and toweling off her hair. "Get some food and drinks. They do snacks and light plates in the afternoon."
"The bar?" Milo lifted his head from the towel with the speed of a man who'd just heard a very specific word. His face was doing the thing it always did when the bar came up — a rapid internal calculation of whether Nico would be working, followed by an attempt to look like he wasn't making that calculation, followed by a complete failure to look like anything other than exactly what he was.
"The bar," Talia confirmed, and her smile was so casual and so perfectly calibrated that I almost admired the craft of it. "We can grab something to eat, have some drinks, enjoy the afternoon."
"Give Milo another shot at talking to Nico," I said, because someone had to.
"That is not why I—" Milo started.
"It is exactly why you're already sitting up."
Milo was, in fact, already sitting up. He looked down at his own body with what appeared to be genuine surprise, as though it had betrayed him by acting on information he hadn't officially released. "I'm sitting up because I'm hungry. Nico's presence at the bar is incidental."
"Incidental," Cass repeated, and somehow loaded enough skepticism into four syllables as if performing a cross examination..
We gathered our things and headed up the path. Milo pulled a fresh shirt from his bag and put it on somewhere between the beach and the bar — a linen button-down that had no business being in the same bag as a towel and sunscreen. Some things are best left unexamined.
The bar was quiet in the afternoon — a handful of guests reading or nursing drinks at the far end, the tables half-empty, the whole place running at a different speed than it did at night. And behind the bar, exactly where Milo had known he would be and would never admit he'd hoped, Nico was working.
He was doing the same thing he always seemed to be doing — moving between bottles and glasses with that practised, unhurried economy that made everything look like it had been choreographed. He looked up when we came in. His eyes tracked the group, paused on Milo for what might have been a fraction of a second longer than strictly necessary, and then he went back to the drink he was making.
Milo stopped walking. His jaw worked once, silently. Then he inhaled, straightened his clean shirt, and said, "I'm going to go order drinks."
"You do that," Talia said, the picture of supportive innocence.
"I'll go with him," Cass said, standing up. "Someone should be there for moral support. Or damage control."
"I don't need damage control," Milo said, straightening his collar.
"You changed your shirt to come to a bar."
"I changed my shirt because it was sandy."
"You brought a spare shirt to the beach, Milo," Cass said, already walking toward the counter.
They headed toward the counter together — Milo's posture shifting as he got closer, his shoulders pulling back a fraction, his stride developing a casualness so manufactured it could have come off an assembly line. Cass walked beside him with the steady, measured pace of a hostage negotiator approaching a delicate situation.
I sat down at a table with Talia and Renee, and we had a clear sightline to the bar.
"Okay," Talia said, leaning forward with her chin on her hand. "Here we go."
Milo reached the counter. He leaned on it — casually, except that the casual lean took approximately three adjustments to settle into a position that looked natural, and each adjustment was visible from where we were sitting.
"He's doing the lean," Talia narrated, her eyes locked on the bar. "Look at that lean."
"He leaned at the mixology class," Renee said.
"That was a different lean. That was a nervous lean. This is a confident lean."
"They look the same," Renee said.
"They are fundamentally different leans, Renee."
I watched Nico glance up from his work, register Milo's presence, and say something. From this distance I couldn't hear it, but it was short — two or three words at most. Milo's response was visibly longer. His hands were involved.
"He's using hand gestures," I said. "That's new."
"He always uses hand gestures," Talia said.
"Not like this. These are elaborate. He's explaining something."
"What could he possibly be explaining?" Renee asked, in the tone of someone who already knew the answer was going to be absurd.
Nico said something else. Milo laughed — too loud, we could hear it from the table, the kind of laugh that carried more enthusiasm than the joke probably warranted. Cass, standing a few feet to his left, rolled her eyes so hard we could see it from across the bar.
"Cass is dying," Talia said, grinning.
"Cass is regretting her choices," I said.
"Cass makes excellent choices. She chose me."
"She chose to walk up to that bar with Milo. That was not an excellent choice."
Nico was making drinks now — something with rum, from what I could tell. Milo was watching him work with the kind of focused attention most people reserve for surgery or oncoming traffic. At one point Nico looked up and said something directly to Milo — and whatever it was, it made Milo go very still.
"What just happened?" Talia sat up straighter. "Something just happened."
"He said something," I confirmed. "Directly to Milo."
"What did he say?" Talia was practically out of her chair.
"I can't hear from here, Talia. I'm not a bat," I said.
Renee had been watching with quiet amusement, her head tilted slightly. "Nico didn't wait for him to order," she said.
I looked at the bar. Nico was already building something — reaching for bottles, pouring, moving with the kind of focus that meant he wasn't improvising. And the drink taking shape on the counter looked familiar. Amber. Lime.
"That's the same drink," I said. "From the mixer. The one Nico made him that first night."
Talia's hand came down on the table. "He remembered. From the first night."
"Or he's a bartender with a decent memory," Renee offered.
"You take that back immediately."
"I'm presenting an alternative interpretation."
"Your interpretation is deeply unromantic and I refuse to acknowledge it," Talia said.
"Or just repeat customers," Renee said, leaning back in her chair.
"Renee, I need you to be on the right side of history here."
"I'm on the side of reality. It's less exciting but more structurally sound."
Milo and Cass returned with drinks and a plate of something that looked like chips and guacamole. Milo set the drinks down with hands that were slightly unsteady, which he covered by immediately sitting down and arranging things on the table with excessive precision.
"So," Talia said, at the exact pitch and frequency of a woman who was about to detonate something. "How'd it go?"
"Fine. Normal. We ordered drinks. That's what happened," Milo said, reaching for a chip without looking at anyone.
"Nico made you the drink from the mixer," Cass said, sitting down. "The same one. I watched him build it."
Talia's squeal was not quiet.
"Cass," Milo said, staring at her. "I told you that in confidence."
"We watched him make it from here." I said. "We saw the whole thing."
Milo looked at me. Then at Talia. Then at Renee. Then back at me. His mouth opened and closed once, and then he apparently decided he was already too far in to retreat. "I didn't order it. I didn't say anything. He just looked at me and started making it. The same one from that first night."
Talia let that sit for a second, savoring it.
"It's not a big deal," Milo said, in the voice of a man for whom it was clearly the biggest deal of his entire life.
"You're holding the glass like it's an engagement ring," Talia said, pointing.
Milo looked down at his hand. He was, in fact, cradling the drink with both palms like it might shatter.
"He's blushing," Cass observed, reaching for another chip.
"I am not blushing," Milo said. "It's the sun."
"We've been inside for a while now," I said.
"It's residual sun."
"Residual sun," Renee repeated quietly, almost smiling.
"So how do we order food here?" I asked. "Do we go up to the bar?"
"I'll sort it out," Talia said, already out of her chair and heading toward the counter. We watched her lean over the bar, exchange a few words with Nico, and gesture back toward our table. Nico nodded once and said something to a server near the far end.
Talia came back looking satisfied. "Someone's coming to take our order."
"You talked to Nico?" Milo asked, sitting up straighter.
"I asked about food, Milo. Not his intentions."
The server came over a few minutes later, a woman with a notepad and the easy patience of someone used to groups who hadn't looked at a menu yet.
"Do you have actual food or just bar snacks?" Talia asked, already scanning the menu.
"We do sandwiches, wraps, grilled fish plates, and a few appetizers," the server said.
"Grilled fish," Renee said, without looking at the menu.
"Guacamole and chips for the table," Talia said. "And the chicken wrap for me."
"I'll do the grilled fish too," I said.
Milo was looking at the bar. "Whatever's good."
"He'll have the wrap," Cass said. "And I'll take the club sandwich."
The server left with their orders and the table hit that lull where everyone's hungry and the food isn't there yet.
"What do we do now?" Milo asked, drumming his fingers on the table.
"We wait," Cass said. "Like adults."
"I hate waiting like an adult."
A woman at the far end of the bar laughed — loud, head tipped back, the kind of laugh that either meant she was genuinely delighted or wanted the whole bar to think she was. The woman next to her leaned closer and said something that set her off again.
"That laugh is performative," Talia said, watching them.
"That's harsh," Milo said.
"It's accurate. Nobody laughs like that at a bar in the middle of the afternoon unless they want the whole room to know they're having fun."
"Or she's just having fun," Renee said.
"There's a difference between having fun and broadcasting fun. She's broadcasting."
"How can you tell?" I asked, genuinely curious.
"Because she keeps checking to see who's watching," Talia said. "Every time she laughs, her eyes sweep. She's performing for an audience."
I looked. She was right. After the next laugh, the woman's gaze drifted sideways across the bar before settling back on her companion.
"Okay, that's impressive," I admitted.
"Talia does this everywhere we go," Cass said. "Restaurants. Airports. The dentist's waiting room."
"People are interesting," Talia said, eyes still on the couple.
"People are predictable," Cass said, stirring her drink.
"What about the other one?" Milo said, nodding toward the woman's companion. "What's her deal?"
"Trying too hard," Renee said, without hesitation. "She keeps touching her hair."
"She could just have bad hair," Milo offered.
"Nobody touches their hair that many times unless they're nervous," Renee said. "She's trying to impress and she's not sure it's working. That's why she keeps going for the jokes."
"She's a physical therapist and she reads body language for a living," Talia said to me, as if this explained everything.
"I read it because people lie with their mouths and tell the truth with their shoulders," Renee said. "Has nothing to do with my job."
"That might be the most intimidating thing you've ever said," I told her.
"What about those two?" Cass said, tilting her head toward a pair of guys at a table near the railing. Everyone turned, mildly surprised that Cass was playing.
"On a date," Milo said immediately. "The one facing us is doing the lean."
"You would know," I said.
"I am an expert on the lean. That man is leaning with intent."
"The other one's not into it," Renee said quietly.
We all looked more carefully.
"He's been staring at his phone for a while and the other guy has ordered two drinks without asking if he wanted one," Renee said.
"Oh," Talia said, looking more closely. "They're not on a date. They're fighting."
"Definitely fighting," I agreed.
"Brutal," Milo said, shaking his head. "He doesn't even see it."
"Most people don't," Renee said, and something in how she said it — matter-of-fact, no judgment — made me glance at her for a second longer than I meant to.
"Okay, solo guy at the end of the bar," Milo said, pointing with his chin. "Go."
"Business traveler," Cass said.
"International spy," Milo countered. "Look at the shoes."
"Those are loafers."
"Spy loafers."
"There's no such thing as spy loafers," Cass said, pinching the bridge of her nose.
"How would you know? That's exactly what a spy would want you to think."
"He's been nursing that drink for a while," Talia said, squinting at the solo guy. "That's suspicious, actually."
"That's frugal," Cass said.
"Nobody's frugal on vacation, Cass," Talia said. "He's watching the room. Look at his eyes."
"I'm not close enough to see his eyes," Cass said.
"Trust me," Talia said. "He's scanning."
"He's probably just bored and people-watching," I said. "Like us."
"Or that's his cover," Milo said. "Pretend to people-watch while actually gathering intelligence."
"We need to stop," Cass said.
"We can't stop," Milo said. "We're in too deep."
The server appeared with plates balanced along both arms, and we made room on the table between the drinks and Milo's conspiracy. "Grilled fish, grilled fish, two wraps, club sandwich, and the guacamole and chips," she said, setting everything down.
"Thank you," Talia said, already reaching for the guacamole before the server had finished putting plates down.
"Thanks," I said, pulling my plate closer.
Milo picked up his wrap without breaking stride. "Okay so the shoes are important because—"
"This fish is incredible," Renee said, after her first bite.
Milo looked at her, then at the rest of us, then at his abandoned spy theory. "I was mid-sentence."
"And now you're mid-lunch," Cass said, already cutting into her sandwich.
"The guacamole is better," Talia said, pulling the bowl closer to her side of the table.
"The guacamole is for the table, Talia," I said, pointing my fork at her.
"And yet here it is, on my side of the table."
"I'm going to need some of that," Milo said, reaching across. "Spy analysis requires fuel."
"The spy analysis is over," Cass said, sliding the guacamole toward the center of the table with one finger.
"The spy analysis is never over. That man is still sitting there. Still wearing the loafers. Still being suspicious."
The conversation drifted after that — the way it does when everyone's full and the sun is doing most of the work. Milo pulled his chair back from the table and stretched his legs out, looking like a man who had no plans to move for the foreseeable future.
"I could fall asleep right here," Milo said, tilting his head back.
"Please don't," Cass said, chin resting on her hand.
"I'm not going to. I'm just saying I could."
"That's how it starts," Talia said, pointing a chip at him. "You say you could, then your eyes close, then we're carrying you back to your bungalow."
"Would you, though?" Milo asked. "Carry me?"
"Absolutely not," Cass said flatly.
"I'd supervise," Talia offered, raising her glass.
"I'd watch from a distance," I said.
"I'd call someone," Renee said, taking a sip of her drink.
"So nobody would actually carry me. Good to know where I stand."
"You're not standing. You just said you wanted to lie down," Cass said, pushing her empty glass to the side.
The server came back and started clearing plates. "Can I get you anything else?"
Talia looked around the table. A few headshakes.
"I think we're good," I said. "Thank you."
"Thanks," Milo said, handing over his plate without sitting up.
The table looked different without all the plates — just drinks and elbows and Talia's sunglasses sitting in a puddle of condensation.
"We should do this again tomorrow," Milo said, leaning forward.
"Do what?" Cass asked, raising an eyebrow. "Sit at a bar and judge strangers?"
"Yes. Exactly that."
"What's the plan for tonight?" Talia asked.
"Dinner. Beyond that, I have no agenda," Cass said, stretching her arms above her head.
"You never have an agenda."
"That is my agenda."
"We could check if there's anything happening at the bar later," Milo said, in a tone so carefully neutral it fooled absolutely nobody.
"You want to come back to the bar tonight," I said, not even bothering to make it a question.
"I'm suggesting it as an option. For the group."
"For the group," Talia repeated, grinning.
"I'm a generous person. I think about the group."
"You think about Nico," Renee said, and the table lost it.
Renee laughed with them — relaxed, unguarded, shaking her head at Milo's expression.
I was watching her do it — watching her be easy, be present — and then I caught myself watching and redirected my attention to my drink with the focus of someone studying a very complicated glass.
"Alright, I think we should head back," Talia said, pushing her chair back. "I need a shower before dinner or I'm showing up as a salt crust."
"You look fine," Milo said, still not moving.
"I have sand in my hair, Milo. Sand. In my hair. That's not fine, that's a geological event."
"We should all probably head back," Renee said.
"Probably," Milo agreed, making absolutely no effort to stand.
Cass was already up, sunglasses on. She looked down at Milo.
"What?" Milo said.
"Nothing. Just waiting."
Talia stood up. "Come on, let's go."
Milo sighed and hauled himself out of the chair.
"You coming?" Talia called back to me.
"I'll finish my drink. I'll catch up."
They headed out in a loose cluster — Talia and Cass arm in arm, Milo trailing with his hands in his pockets. Renee went with them, half-turning as she left to give me a look that was both questioning and understanding — you sure? — and I nodded, and she smiled, and then they were gone.
I was sipping the last of my drink and debating whether to order another when Alina walked into the bar.
She had her notebook peeking out of her crossbody bag, already scanning the room before she'd fully walked in. She spotted me at the table and headed over.
"Adrianna," she said, dropping into the chair next to mine. "Drinking alone? That's either romantic or tragic."
"I was drinking with four other people a couple of minutes ago."
Alina dropped her bag on the empty chair beside her. "How's the trip going?"
"Better than I expected, if I'm being honest." I turned my glass on the table. "Somehow I've ended up with a group that saves me a seat at breakfast and drags me into volleyball games and argues about whether a bartender is flirting with one of them. I didn't plan any of it."
Alina laughed — sharp, appreciative, the laugh of someone who recognized good material when she heard it. "That sounds like a story."
"It's not a story. It's just a vacation."
"In my experience, those are the same thing." She looked at me with a tilted-head attention, always half-composing. "Can I ask you something? Writer to writer?"
"Sure."
"How's the work going?"
I was quiet for a second. The honest answer was complicated — the notebook this morning, the words that had come without resistance, the block that was still there every time I opened the laptop but seemed to lose its grip when I picked up the pen. The thing forming at the edge of my thoughts that I hadn't looked at directly because looking at it might scare it away.
"Weird," I said, which was the most honest single word I had. "Different than I expected."
Alina nodded like she understood something I hadn't said. "My piece is going the same way, actually. I came here to write about the resort — the bungalows, the activities, the whole curated experience. But the more time I spend here, the more I realize that's not the real story."
"What's the real story?"
"The people." She said it simply, like she'd already written the lede and was just confirming it aloud. "I mean — a group of strangers who showed up here from completely different lives and somehow became a unit in a few days? That's the piece. That's what makes a place like this actually work — not the thread count or the cocktail menu. It's what happens between the people who show up." She gestured toward the empty chairs around the table. "Like what you just described. That kind of thing is exactly what I'd want in the article."
"What do you mean?" I said.
"I've seen you guys around," Alina said. "At lunch the other day, around the resort. When people actually like each other versus when they're just killing time in the same place — you can tell. Your group is real. And that's rare when everyone showed up as strangers."
I felt something shift. Like a door I hadn't realized was open suddenly catching a draft.
"You want to write about them," I said, and my voice came out flat.
Alina caught it. She was too good not to. "Not by name. Not invasively. I'm talking about the texture of the place — the way it creates these temporary communities. Your group is a perfect example. It's compelling."
"It's their vacation, Alina."
She looked at me for a moment, and I could see her recalibrating. "I wouldn't use names. Or identifying details. It's a colour piece, not an exposé."
"I know. I know that." I took a sip of my drink and tried to figure out why my shoulders had tensed. She wasn't doing anything wrong. She was doing exactly what I did — watching people, noticing things, turning life into sentences. I'd written five character sketches this morning in a notebook on my bedside table.
But those pages were mine. Private. Written for no one, going nowhere, sitting in a closed notebook in a bungalow on a small island in the middle of nowhere. The difference between that and an article — something published, consumed, turned into content for an audience — landed on me with a weight I wasn't prepared for.
"I get it," Alina said. "They're your people."
"They're not my—" I started, and then stopped, because finishing that sentence would have required me to explain what they were if not that, and I didn't have an explanation that didn't make me sound like I was lying.
Alina smiled — not unkindly. "I'll leave the group dynamic out. I mean it." She stood and slung her bag over her shoulder. "For what it's worth, Adrianna — the way you got protective just now? That's not nothing."
She squeezed my arm lightly as she stood, slung her bag over her shoulder, and headed toward the far end of the bar.
I sat at the table for a while after she left.
The bar was quieting down. Nico was wiping the counter in slow, methodical strokes, and the light had gone amber and long through the open sides of the bar, and I was alone with a half-finished drink and a feeling I couldn't put a name to.
I'd written about them this morning. I'd written about them with ease and affection and specificity, and none of it had felt like exploitation or reduction or material-gathering. It had felt like paying attention. Like caring enough about the people around me to get them right on the page.
So why had Alina doing the same thing bothered me?
These weren't characters. They weren't material. They were mine — the breakfast table, the volleyball court, the running commentary on Milo's love life, the easy silence walking back to the bungalows. All of it was mine in a way that had nothing to do with writing and everything to do with the fact that I'd showed up here expecting nothing and somehow ended up with people I wasn't ready to share.
And underneath all of that, quiet and specific and impossible to ignore, was the fact that one of them was on my mind more than the others, and I didn't want to ask myself why.
I finished my drink, pushed back from the table, and headed back toward the bungalows. The afternoon was cooling off. My brain, unfortunately, was not.

The porch had been there the whole time, apparently. Four days at this place and I hadn't sat on it once — too busy being everywhere else. But this morning I'd run out of everywhere else. The chair was wooden and sun-warm already, even though it was barely eight. The shutters were open and the view through the palms was the kind of still, blue, impossibly calm water that made you feel like the world had been put on pause for your benefit. I didn't trust it, but I sat with it anyway. I had the notebook. I had, theoretically, an idea.
That was the problem with theoretically.
I opened to the last entry — yesterday morning's, the character sketches that had come so easily it felt like someone else was holding the pen. Milo's full-volume everything. Cass's precision. Talia's chaos that somehow always landed upright. And then the turn inward, the part where I'd started writing about the block itself and realized I'd been stealing Renee's language without noticing. Showing up anyway. Staying in the room. Not forcing what isn't ready.
And underneath all of that, the seed. The thing I kept circling like it might bite me if I reached for it too fast: a character who spends her days putting other people back together while quietly, methodically, falling apart herself.
It was good. I knew it was good. I could feel the weight of it sitting in the notebook like something waiting to be picked up.
I put my pen underneath the last line and tried to push it further. She carries other people's weight for a living and — I stopped. And what? I didn't know yet. I crossed it out and tried again. There's a woman who — Worse. The idea was alive when I wasn't looking at it directly, and the second I put my pen on it, it went still.
I closed the notebook and leaned back. The water through the palms didn't have any advice.
I picked up my phone and texted Sasha.
Me: You up
I put the phone down. Picked it up again. The screen sat there doing nothing for long enough that I considered the possibility Sasha was ignoring me, which would be fair at this hour. Then three dots appeared on my screen.
Sasha: Tell me something interesting or I'm going back to sleep
Me: I'm sitting on my porch staring at a notebook that won't cooperate
Sasha: So paradise is going well
Me: Thriving
Sasha: The writing thing. Is it still the same nothing or a different nothing
Me: I have an idea. I think. It won't come out
Sasha: That's better than nothing though right
Me: It's worse actually. Nothing is clean. An idea you can't reach is just frustrating
Sasha: So you have an idea you can't write and you're texting me at this hour. Anything else going on
Sasha: How's Renee
Me: You're not subtle you know that right
Sasha: Last time we talked you said she was different than you thought. I'm following up. Like a good friend
Me: She's fine. She's been hanging out with the group more
Sasha: With you
Me: With the group
Sasha: Right. The group. And you just happen to be in the group
Me: I am literally in the group yes that is how groups work
Sasha: And she's still different than you thought
Me: Can we talk about something else
Sasha: Oh this is going to be so good
Me: Something actually happened last night that I want your take on
Sasha: Did it involve Renee
Me: No. Well. No. There's this travel writer at the resort. She wants to do a piece on the place and she asked if she could write about the people I've been spending time with. Observe them. Use them as material
Sasha: Write about them how
Me: The group dynamic. How strangers become friends at a place like this. She said it would be the heart of the piece
Sasha: That's not a bad idea for an article
Me: I know
Sasha: So what did you do
Me: I said no. Didn't even think about it. Told her it was their vacation and she couldn't just turn them into content
Sasha: Huh
Me: What
Sasha: Nothing. Just thinking about the fact that you've known these people for four days and you went full mama bear on a stranger for them
Me: It wasn't mama bear. It was basic decency
Sasha: You don't do basic decency for strangers Ade. You do basic decency for people you care about
Me: They're not strangers anymore
Sasha: No. They're clearly not
Sasha: You know what I think is the most interesting part of this whole story
Me: I'm scared to ask
Sasha: You cared. Like actually cared. That's new
Me: Shut up
Sasha: I'm being sincere. It's good
Me: Don't make it a thing
I put the phone down and looked at the notebook in my lap. Closed, unhelpful. The idea was in there somewhere between the pages, but the words weren't coming. And behind me through the open door, the laptop on the desk still had its cursor blinking like a passive-aggressive smoke detector.
The group would be at breakfast by now. Milo holding court over something that happened last night. Talia planning an activity nobody had agreed to yet. Cass reading the table with a coffee she'd defend with her life. And Renee, who would be there, because Renee was part of this now.
I wasn't going, and it wasn't that I didn't want to see them — that was the strange part. A week ago, the idea of voluntarily joining a group breakfast four days running would have sounded like a prison sentence. Now the table felt like a place I belonged, which was precisely why I needed to sit alone on a porch for another hour. I had the idea. I had the notebook. I had silence and a view. A writer with fewer excuses would have been typing by now.
None of it was working, though. Maybe it was the chair, or the view, or the fact that handwriting made every failed attempt feel permanent in a way the cursor didn't.
I went inside, grabbed the laptop, and headed for the pool.
The pool was empty — everyone was probably still at breakfast or sleeping off whatever the bar had served last night. I found a lounger in the shade, opened the laptop, and tried to coax the idea from notebook to screen. The notebook version had felt warm. Possible. The cursor turned it into a task.
She had the kind of stillness that made other people want to confess. I stared at it. It was a line about an idea, not a woman. I highlighted it and let it go.
You could tell her anything and she'd hold it without flinching — No. That was a greeting card.
She made you want to be honest, which was the first problem. Closer, maybe, but still just sitting there. Every sentence came out like I was describing the effect of the character instead of writing her.
I tried for twenty minutes. The blank page and the cursor had formed an alliance that was only getting stronger, and they were enjoying themselves enormously. Every time I put a sentence down it sat there looking competent and hollow, like a model home nobody had moved into.
I was mid-deletion when I heard the voice.
"There she is."
Milo. I turned and saw all of them coming down the path from the restaurant like a search party that had decided to enjoy themselves along the way. Milo in front, still chewing something, Talia and Cass a step behind, and Renee at the back, her eyes already on me in a way that made me want to close the laptop faster.
"We thought you died," Milo said, pulling a lounger next to mine without asking.
"That's a perfectly reasonable conclusion after missing one breakfast," I said, not looking up from the screen.
"I was going to send Lyle with a wellness check."
Talia dropped into the lounger on my other side. Cass settled on the arm of Talia's chair. Renee took the one across from me, crossing her legs and saying nothing.
"Why weren't you at breakfast?" Milo asked.
"I'm working."
"You're staring at a white screen. I can see it from here."
I closed the laptop an inch. "I'm between thoughts."
"Is that what we're calling it," Talia said, with enough affection that I couldn't argue.
"Are you okay?" Renee asked. Quiet, direct, like she was taking a reading.
"Fine. Just wanted a quiet morning."
The look Renee gave me sat somewhere between concern and patience, and I didn't have an answer for either. She didn't push. That was the thing about Renee that made her harder to dismiss than the pushers — she left a silence exactly where the honest answer was supposed to go and waited for you to hear it yourself I guess.
"GOOD MORNING, EVERYONE."
"What the fuck —" Milo shot upright so fast his lounger scraped against the deck, hand flat on his chest like he was checking for a pulse.
Talia screamed. Full volume, no words, the kind of sound that sent something rustling out of the nearest palm tree.
"Jesus Christ," Cass said, with the flatness of a woman already composing the complaint.
My laptop slid off my thighs and I caught it an inch from the deck with both hands. "Shit —"
Renee flinched — actually flinched, visibly, her whole body going tight for a second — and then said, "What the hell is wrong with you," in a tone so level it was almost scarier than the screaming.
Lyle stood behind the towel station with his clipboard, whistle, and a grin that said he absolutely meant to do that. "Who's ready for the best snorkeling of their lives?"
"So," Lyle said, flipping a page on his clipboard like he was about to present quarterly earnings. "On the far side of the island, we have a reef. And I don't mean a nice little reef. I mean the reef. The one people come back from and won't shut up about for days."
"Is that a guarantee or a warning," Cass said, without blinking.
"Both. Exclusively both." He didn't miss a beat. "I have personally taken over two hundred guests to this reef. Not a single one has come back disappointed."
"Has anyone not come back at all?" I asked, not entirely joking.
Lyle blinked. "Everyone has come back."
"She's asking if anyone drowned, Lyle," Talia said, patting his arm like she was breaking bad news.
"No one has drowned. No one has ever come close to drowning. We have safety equipment, we have life vests, we have me." He said this like the third item was the most important. "The boat leaves after lunch. Gear is provided. Sunscreen is mandatory — and I will be checking. I checked last time and three people hadn't reapplied and I had to have a conversation with each of them individually and I will do it again."
"He'll do it again," Milo confirmed to no one.
"I will do it again," Lyle said.
"How long are we out there," Cass said.
"Great question. Approximately two hours on the water, including travel time, the snorkeling itself, and a brief debrief on the boat."
"A debrief," I said, turning to Talia because I needed a witness.
"I like to go over what everyone saw. It helps contextualize the experience."
"He debriefs the snorkeling," Talia said to Cass.
"I heard." Cass pinched the bridge of her nose.
"It's optional," Lyle said. "So — who's in?"
"I'm in," Milo said, already standing.
"We're in," Talia confirmed, gesturing at Cass without consulting her.
"Were we?" Cass said.
"We were," Talia said, already done with the discussion.
I looked at my laptop. The cursor was still winning. "I was going to try to work this afternoon."
"Come snorkeling," Milo said, like it was the most obvious solution to every problem I'd ever had.
"I haven't snorkeled since I was a kid."
"It's like riding a bike. Except underwater. And you can't fall off."
"You can absolutely fall off," Cass said.
"You can't fall off water, Cass," Milo said, like he was explaining gravity to a child.
"You can fall off a boat," Cass said, unmoved.
"Nobody's falling off the boat." Lyle looked mildly alarmed, like the possibility of boat-falling hadn't been in his risk assessment.
I looked at Renee. She hadn't said a word about whether she was going, but she also hadn't refused, and I was learning that with Renee the absence of a no was a significant data point. She caught me looking and gave a half-shrug — somewhere between why not and it's just water.
"Come," she said. No argument, no pitch.
It caught me off guard — not the word, but the fact that Renee had bothered to say it. She didn't recruit. She didn't campaign. If you showed up, fine. If you didn't, also fine. So the fact that she'd actually asked was — something. I lost the rest of it because Milo and Talia were watching the two of us with expressions that were trying very hard to be casual and failing completely.
"Fine," I said, glaring at Milo and Talia until they looked elsewhere. "After lunch."
"Excellent," Lyle said, and wrote it on his clipboard like he was ratifying a treaty. "Boat leaves at two. Gear provided. Sunscreen mandatory."
Lyle clicked his pen, flipped the clipboard shut, and walked off toward the main building — already calling something over his shoulder to a staff member halfway down the path.
"So what's the lunch plan," Talia said, pulling out her phone. "We need to eat before two or we're snorkeling on empty stomachs."
"I could eat," Milo said.
"You could always eat," Cass said.
"That's not an insult, that's a lifestyle."
I closed the laptop. "I'm going to head back. Try to get some writing in before we go."
Milo sat up. "No. Absolutely not. You're coming to lunch."
"I'll order room service."
"You'll order nothing and stare at your laptop." He pointed at me. Four days and he already had me figured out.
"You've been having fun the last couple of days," Talia said, and there was something careful in it. "Real fun. Why go back to the screen now?"
"Because I actually have something," I said. "For the first time in months. I just want to try."
The group went quiet for a second. My head was loud enough without the silence, and I needed to be somewhere with fewer people in it.
"Let her work," Cass said. "She'll be there at two."
"Will she, though?" Milo said.
"She'll be there at two," Cass said again, looking directly at me, and it wasn't a question.
I stood, tucked the laptop under my arm, and turned to go. I glanced back once without meaning to — Renee hadn't moved, but her eyes were on me, and she wasn't asking me to stay. She was just watching me choose to leave.
I kept walking. By the time I reached the bungalow the idea of sitting at the desk felt like something that belonged to a different morning. I put the laptop down, kicked off my shoes, and lay on the bed instead.
The ceiling fan turned in slow circles. My brain wouldn't stop. I closed my eyes and told myself it was just for a minute.
I woke up to knocking and Milo's voice through the door. "Ade. It's ten to two and the boat's leaving."
Behind him, Talia: "I told you she'd fall asleep."
I sat up, disoriented, mouth dry, hair committed to a direction I hadn't approved. The clock on the nightstand said 1:48. Shit.
"Coming," I called, already pulling open drawers.
So much for the writing. I was going snorkeling instead — with fins and water and the strong possibility of looking ridiculous in front of people whose opinions I apparently now cared about.
I found the swimsuit — a dark green one-piece I'd packed with no real expectation of wearing — and pulled it on with the speed and grace of someone dressing during a fire drill. I threw the cover-up over it, stepped into sandals, and put on sunglasses that I hoped would hide the evidence of the nap. My hair went back in whatever configuration it would accept without negotiation. I grabbed a towel and opened the door.
Milo looked me up and down. "Forty-five seconds. I'm impressed and concerned."
"Called it," Talia said, already walking. "You owe me five dollars, Milo."
"I was resting my eyes," I said, falling into step beside her.
"Were you," Talia said, without turning around.
"They were very tired eyes."
We walked down the path toward the dock, Milo and Talia flanking me like an escort detail.
"Have you ever snorkeled?" Milo asked Talia.
"Twice. Once in Cancún, once in a cenote that turned out to be mostly mud."
"Was the Cancún one good?"
"The cenote was a war crime." Talia shuddered. "But the Cancún one was gorgeous."
Milo considered this like it was new information about the world. "I've never snorkeled. How hard can it be? You float and you look down."
"You have to breathe through a tube, Milo," Talia said, with the patience of someone who'd already accepted how this would end.
Milo was undeterred. "I breathe through things all the time."
"That's not the selling point you think it is," I said.
Talia pointed at me. "Thank you."
"Cass is going to hate it." Milo was warming to his theory. "She's going to get in the water and immediately want to file a complaint."
"Cass is going to be better at it than all of us," I said. "Out of pure spite."
"Cass has been ready since noon," Talia said. "Cass has opinions about people who aren't ready."
The path curved and opened up and I could feel the heat pressing through my cover-up and the last of the nap burning off, and whatever was waiting at the dock was getting closer whether I was ready for it or not.
We reached the dock and I could see the others already assembled near a white boat with a sun-bleached canopy. Cass sat in the shade, scrolling her phone like she'd been there long enough to get bored of the view. Renee stood near the railing in a black bikini top and shorts, her hair pulled back, having an exchange with Lyle that appeared to involve her nodding once and Lyle talking for thirty seconds.
"She's alive," Cass said, without looking up. "I had my doubts."
"Ade fell asleep," Milo announced to the dock at large. "We physically had to remove her from the bungalow. She put up resistance."
"I didn't put up resistance. I opened the door."
"After we knocked long enough to file a noise complaint," Milo said, still wounded by the ordeal.
"That's a normal amount of knocking," I said, adjusting my sunglasses.
Renee turned from Lyle to face me. "Glad you made it," she said.
Lyle blew his whistle — one sharp blast that made Cass look up from her phone for what might have been the first time all afternoon.
"Gather round, team," Lyle said, clipboard raised. He was in a rashguard that was somehow tighter than his polo. "Safety briefing before we board."
"How long is this briefing," Cass said, already looking back at her phone.
"As long as it needs to be for everyone's safety and enjoyment." Lyle tapped his pen against the clipboard. "Rule one: stay within visual range of the group at all times. If you can't see me, you've gone too far."
"What if we can see you and wish we couldn't?" I said, raising my hand like I was in a seminar.
Lyle considered this with more sincerity than it deserved. "I'm going to move past that. Rule two: do not touch the coral. The coral is alive. It is fragile. It does not want to be touched."
Talia tilted her head. "You're making it sound sentient."
Lyle looked personally wounded. "It's been growing for thousands of years. I think we can all agree that deserves a certain level of consideration and care."
"Rule three," Lyle continued, flipping a page. "Life vests are available. The current is gentle today but currents change and I'd rather you wore one than didn't."
"Are there sharks?" Milo asked.
Lyle lowered the clipboard. "There are no sharks. I have personally led over — many excursions to this reef and no one has ever encountered a shark."
"You answered that very fast," Milo said, not reassured.
"Because it's a common question and the answer is always no." Lyle looked at him with genuine concern. "Are you okay? Do you need a moment?"
Milo looked at the water like he was waiting for it to weigh in.
We boarded one at a time. The boat was open-decked with benches along the sides, a sun-bleached canopy, and an outboard motor that sounded like it was considering retirement. Milo picked the bench closest to the middle and sat down like the water might reach up and grab him.
"You're very far from the edge," Cass said, stepping past him.
"That's where I want to be," Milo said, already holding the bench with both hands.
Talia settled next to Cass. Renee took the bench across from me. I sat down and pulled the cover-up tighter against the wind.
Lyle took the wheel and the motor coughed to life, and then we were moving, the dock getting smaller behind us and the island flattening out into a green line against the sky.
"How deep is the water here?" Milo said, peering over the side without letting go of the bench.
"Great question," Lyle called back from the wheel. "Right now we're passing over about eight feet. As we get closer to the reef it'll drop to twelve, maybe fifteen in some spots. Visibility is excellent today so you'll be able to see the bottom clearly, which I find helps with any anxiety about depth."
"I don't have anxiety about depth," Milo said, gripping the bench harder.
Talia stretched her legs out and tilted her face toward the sun. "Stop asking questions you don't want the answers to."
"I do want the answers. That's why I'm asking."
"Twelve to fifteen feet is very manageable," Lyle added, still going. "And you'll be on the surface the whole time. The reef does all the work. You just float and look down."
"Right," Milo said. "Float. On top of fifteen feet of ocean."
Cass closed her eyes. "Fifteen is the maximum. He said twelve in some spots."
"That's not the comfort you think it is, Cass."
The water changed as we went — cloudy green near the shore, then something clearer, then something closer to glass. The motor hummed and the wind pulled at my cover-up, and when I looked around Talia had her face tilted toward the sun and Cass had her eyes closed and even Milo's grip on the bench had gone slack, like his body had given up the argument his brain was still trying to have.
I looked at Renee. She was watching the water with the ease of someone who didn't need to think about being comfortable around it — just was.
The motor cut out and the boat drifted into silence.
"All right," Lyle said, killing the engine with a flourish. "This is it. Gear's in the bin. Take your time getting in — there's a ladder on the port side."
Everyone started stripping down to swimsuits. Talia had a bright coral bikini that matched her energy. Cass wore a navy one-piece with the efficient air of someone who had selected it in under thirty seconds. Milo had bright orange trunks that were somehow the loudest thing on the boat. Renee pulled her shorts off and adjusted the strap on her bikini top, and the whole thing was so casually, unfairly distracting that I forgot what I was doing with my hands for a second.
I pulled my cover-up over my head and tried to look like I knew what I was doing with the snorkeling gear. The mask smelled like rubber and salt. The fins were slightly too large — my feet slid around inside them, two sizes too big and committed to nothing.
One by one they went in. Talia launched herself off the side and hit the water like she was punishing it. Cass lowered herself down the ladder without a single wasted movement. Milo went in with his arms out and his eyes closed, and the splash he produced was heroic and deeply unnecessary. Renee slipped off the side of the boat and was just — in.
And then it was just me, standing at the ladder in fins that didn't fit, watching four people who'd all managed to get into the ocean without making it look like a decision that required deliberation.
The water was clear enough that I could see the bottom, or at least a version of it — white sand giving way to darker shapes that were probably coral, probably beautiful, probably not interested in my participation. The mask was already fogging. I put one foot on the ladder and my fin caught on the rung and I grabbed the railing with both hands and most of my dignity. Water was not, technically, a solid surface, and my body had just remembered that.
Everyone else was already in and moving toward the reef. I could see Milo's orange trunks bobbing ahead, Talia pulling Cass along by the arm, Lyle already halfway there. I watched them go and took another step down the ladder and my other fin caught and I stopped, one foot in the water, one foot on a rung, both hands on the railing, doing absolutely nothing with any confidence.
Not in, not out, just stuck on a ladder in the middle of the ocean, wondering how every single person I knew had gotten into the water without turning it into a crisis.
I was considering my options — which were limited to going down or climbing back up and pretending I'd never agreed to this — when I noticed Renee had stopped moving, maybe twenty feet from the boat, and was swimming back toward me.
"Put your weight on the balls of your feet, not your heels," Renee said, treading water an arm's length away. "The fin catches if you lead with the heel."
"Okay," I said, which came out sharper than I meant it to.
"You're leading with your heel," Renee said.
She was right. I adjusted. The next step didn't catch. I got down two more rungs and then the water was at my waist and the ladder ended and there was a moment where I had to actually let go and trust that the fins and the vest and the laws of buoyancy would do their jobs.
"Lean back," Renee said. She was treading water an arm's length away. "Don't step off. Lean."
I leaned back and the water took my weight and I was in — graceless, startled, but floating. The mask was still fogging.
"Spit in it," Renee said.
"Excuse me?" I said, still clinging to the idea that snorkeling had standards.
"In the mask. Rub it on the inside of the lens. It stops the fog."
"That's disgusting," I said, holding the mask at arm's length.
"That's physics," Renee said. "Do you want to see the reef or not?"
I spat in the mask and rubbed it on the inside of the lens and put it back on, hating every second of the process. The world through the lens went from blurry to sharp, and Renee nodded once and said, "Breathe through the snorkel. Slow. Don't think about it."
She turned and swam toward the reef, and I followed her because there was nothing else to do except float alone next to a boat I'd already embarrassed myself on, and at least this way I was moving in a direction.
The first few minutes were bad. I breathed too fast and the snorkel made a sound like a straw at the bottom of a milkshake. My arms did too much. My fins felt like someone had strapped planks to my feet. I couldn't find the rhythm that everyone else had apparently been born with. I was the only one still struggling, and I was aware of it in the specific, burning way of someone who is deeply uncomfortable with anything that might make them look ridiculous.
Renee stayed close without hovering. Every few minutes she'd glance back, and once she called over, "Slower kicks. You're working too hard." I wanted to argue but she was right again, and when I slowed down the fins started doing what fins were supposed to do and my body stopped fighting the water and started cooperating with it, and then the reef was underneath us.
I don't know how to describe what I saw down there without making it sound like the brochure I'd mocked at Sorrentino's. But the reef was — it was like someone had taken every color I'd ever seen and made it alive. Fans of coral in purples and oranges that moved with the current like they were breathing. Fish in colors that didn't make evolutionary sense — electric blue, neon yellow, a stripe of black and white that looked hand-painted. Something darted past me that was so bright it seemed like it should make a sound. The sand below was white and rippled, and the sunlight came down through the water in shifting columns that moved across the bottom like searchlights.
I could see Lyle ahead of me, pointing enthusiastically at something near the base of a coral formation. He turned to make sure someone was watching, gave a thumbs-up, and pointed again like someone who had just discovered fire. Talia was near him, grabbing Cass's arm and gesturing at a school of silver fish that turned as one body, like a single thing made of hundreds of pieces.
But the sound — that was what got me. There was no sound. Or there was, but it was so different from anything I was used to that my brain registered it as silence. My own breathing, amplified and close, filling my head in a slow rhythm that left no room for anything else. Just the breathing, and the water, and the fact of being there.
Renee was a few feet to my right, unhurried, completely at home in the water. She pointed at something below us, a starfish sprawled across a rock in a shade of orange that didn't look real, and I looked at it and then I looked at her looking at it and neither of us was trying to be anything. We were just two people suspended in blue-green light, watching a starfish exist.
I stayed out there longer than I expected. The reef didn't end — it just kept unfolding, one formation giving way to another, colors shifting as the light moved. At some point I realized my brain had gone quiet in a way it hadn't in months. Maybe longer. The noise I'd been living with — the constant loop of thinking and overthinking and thinking about the overthinking — had just stopped. And what was left wasn't empty. It was full of something I didn't have a name for yet.
Eventually I saw the others lifting their heads, pulling off masks, starting to swim back toward the boat. Renee tilted her head toward the surface and I nodded. We rose together, and breaking through into air and sun and noise was a shock, the way waking up is when you didn't know you'd fallen asleep.
The boat was thirty feet away. We swam to it, and Renee went up the ladder first, then leaned over and offered me a hand. I took it. Her grip was firm, practical, warm from the sun. I climbed up and she let go.
Everyone else was already on board, scattered across the benches in various states of wet exhaustion. Milo was lying flat on his back with his mask pushed up on his forehead. Talia was wringing out her hair. Cass was sitting very still with her eyes closed, which from anyone else would have looked like rest but from Cass looked like a verdict she'd decided not to appeal. Lyle was at the wheel, starting the motor, already debriefing to nobody in particular about the coral formations and the water clarity and had anyone seen the parrotfish near the south edge?
I peeled off my mask and my fins and sat down on the bench at the stern. The sun was on my shoulders. The motor started and the boat began to move and I was sitting very still, watching the reef get smaller behind us.
It was quiet. Not a wave, not a rush — just a slow unraveling I hadn't braced for. Maribel across the table asking when I'd last done something fun, and my voice lying and saying the writing was flowing. Sasha on the video call telling me I wasn't a person anymore. All of it hitting differently now, on a boat, with the sun on my arms and the reef behind us.
I didn't realize I was crying until I felt it on my face — just a few tears, quiet, arriving before I could do anything about them. I didn't know what they were for. The water was still sliding past the hull and the sun was still warm on my shoulders and I was sitting very still on a bench at the back of a boat, crying for a reason I couldn't fathom.
I looked up and Renee was watching me from across the deck. Quiet, still, and then she turned her head toward the water like something had caught her attention out there. It hadn't. We both knew it hadn't. I wiped my face with the back of my hand and took a breath.
A minute passed, maybe longer. I got my face under control and sat with the engine humming and the water sliding past the hull and the wind drying the last of it from my cheeks, and by the time I looked up again I almost believed I could pass for someone who'd just been squinting at the sun.
"You okay?" Renee said, like she was asking about the water.
"Yeah," I said. "That was — yeah."
Renee nodded once and let it go, and that was the thing that made me feel like I could breathe again.
I let out a breath and looked across the boat and found Cass watching me. She didn't say anything. She just gave me the faintest smile, then turned her face toward the water. Something in me settled, the way it does when someone tells you without words that you don't have to explain.
The boat carried us back. Milo had been staring at the water since we'd pulled away from the reef, which was the longest I'd seen him go without talking, and then he turned to Talia and said, "Did you see the parrotfish?"
Talia pulled her hair over one shoulder. "Which one?"
"The big green one near the coral on the left side. It looked directly at me."
"Fish don't look at people, Milo," Talia said.
"This one did. It stopped swimming and turned its whole body and looked at me with its entire face."
"With its entire face?" Cass repeated, eyes still closed.
"It had intentions," Milo said. "I'm not saying they were good intentions. But they were there."
"Fish don't have intentions," Cass said.
"You didn't see this fish."
I laughed, maybe a beat too loud, the way you do when you're trying to convince everyone including yourself that you're fine. Milo glanced over and grinned at me like he'd been waiting for it, and I realized nobody else had noticed anything.
"What did it look like?" I asked, and my voice came out almost normal.
"Green," Milo said. "And judgmental."
"You just described yourself," Talia said, not missing a beat.
"I'm not green."
The boat reached the dock. Lyle tied off and offered everyone a hand stepping off.
"So what was everyone's highlight?" Lyle asked, and then didn't wait for an answer. "For me it was the water clarity. Today was exceptional. Some days you get a slight current from the east and it affects the visibility, but today was just —"
"Lyle," Talia said gently.
Lyle stopped. "Right. I'll save the rest."
We stood around drying off, the heat already doing most of the work. Milo was still slightly damp and fully converted.
"I need to go back," Milo said, to nobody in particular. "Tomorrow. Or tonight. Can we go at night? Is that a thing?"
Lyle perked up. "Night snorkeling is a thing. I would need to check the tide tables and coordinate with —"
"He's not going night snorkeling," Talia said.
"I might go night snorkeling."
"You were gripping the bench with both hands three hours ago," I said, still toweling off.
Milo waved this off. "That was before the fish and I had a moment."
Cass toweled off her arms. "The coral was impressive." From Cass, that was a standing ovation.
"See?" Lyle gestured at Cass like she'd just proved his entire life thesis. "This is why I do the debriefs."
"That was not a debrief," Cass said, examining her nails. "That was a statement."
"I'm counting it." Lyle was already writing something on his clipboard.
Milo wrung out the hem of his shirt. "I'm starving. Is it too early to talk about dinner?"
Cass checked her phone. "It's four o'clock."
"So that's a yes?"
"Bar at seven?" Talia asked. "I need a shower and a nap before I'm presentable."
"I might sit this one out," I said. "I'm kind of wiped."
Milo looked at me. "Don't disappear on us, Ade."
"I'm not disappearing. I just need a quiet night."
"Come to dinner, Ade," Renee said.
I looked at her and didn't know why my answer changed.
"Okay."

I stood in front of the mirror and tried to remember why I'd let Sasha talk me into this dress. It was green — a deep, almost emerald green, bias-cut, thin straps, hem just below the knee. I'd reached for something safer during our shopping trip — darker, higher neckline, the kind of dress that doesn't ask questions — and Sasha had put it back on the rack and handed me this one instead. Trust me. Sasha had been so confident about it that she'd walked away from me mid-argument, which was her way of saying the discussion was over and I just hadn't caught up yet.
I turned sideways. The dress fit like Sasha had measured me in my sleep. It looked annoyingly good. Good enough that you don't need accessories or attitude or forty-five minutes of mental preparation — you just put the dress on and the dress does the rest. Sasha was never going to hear that from me. She'd have to sense it through the universe the way she sensed everything else about my life — by intuition, by witchcraft, by the fact that she'd known me long enough to know what I looked like before I was willing to.
I put on earrings, checked my makeup, and stood there for a second. I didn't know why I'd said yes to dinner.
Except I did know. Renee had said come snorkeling and I'd gone. Renee had said come to dinner and I was going. If she'd asked me to swim to the mainland I'd probably have asked which direction. Something had shifted in the last few days and I could feel it moving around inside my head — too many thoughts, none of them finished, all of them louder than they'd been a few days ago. I didn't know what to do with any of it, and I wasn't going to figure it out standing in front of a mirror.
I held that thought for a second, gave myself a final look in the mirror, and decided I'd done enough thinking for one evening. Good. Done. Moving on.
I grabbed my purse, pulled the door shut behind me, and walked down the path toward the bar.
The air had cooled just enough to feel intentional, the way the island did everything — on schedule, on brand, insufferably pleasant. I could hear music and voices before I could see anyone, which gave me about thirty seconds to arrange my face into someone who'd meant to show up.
The group was already there, gathered outside the bar, waiting. Milo was mid-story, both hands conducting some kind of elaborate reconstruction that involved pointing at the water and making a shape with his fingers that could have been a fish or a small explosion. He'd gone with another tropical print — hibiscus and palm fronds this time, a shirt that looked like it was moving because Milo never stopped. Talia was facing him with the full-body attention of a woman watching her favorite show, her hair pulled up loosely with a clip that was doing more structural work than it had signed up for. Cass stood beside her in a navy linen shirt, untucked, sleeves rolled, looking like she'd given Milo's story all the attention she planned to about three minutes ago. And Renee was next to Cass, arms folded, shoulders shaking with laughter she was clearly trying to keep off her face and failing. White top, dark jeans, hair down, and I didn't catalogue any more than that because I was already aware I'd been cataloguing her.
I was overdressed. I knew it the second I saw them. Enough that the green slip dress and the bare shoulders and the fact that I'd put on earrings made a quiet announcement I hadn't authorized.
Talia saw me first.
"Ade!" She closed the distance like I'd been gone for a weeks instead of two hours. "Oh my God, that dress. That color on you — where did you get that?"
"Sasha picked it," I said, smoothing the hem like it needed adjusting when it didn't.
"Sasha has taste," Talia said, already touching the fabric at my hip. "This cut, this color — Ade, you've been holding out on me. You've had this in your suitcase the whole time and you've been wearing resort casual like the rest of us? That's offensive. That's personally offensive to me."
"It's a dress, Talia."
"It's a betrayal."
"Excuse me," Milo said from behind her, one hand raised like he was flagging a waiter. "I also dressed up. I also put effort into my appearance. I'm standing right here in hibiscus and nobody has said one word about it."
"It's very you," Cass offered without looking at him.
"That's not a compliment and you know it, Cassandra."
"It wasn't trying to be one."
Talia was still holding my hem when Renee looked at me, and what she said was simple and direct and completely without performance. "You look really good, Ade," she said, and her voice was steady and her eyes were steady and it was the kind of compliment that didn't ask for a response, it just handed you a fact and moved on.
Something in my brain stalled for half a second. Not a blush, not a dramatic internal reckoning, just a brief gap where a thought should have been and wasn't.
"Thanks," I said, and it came out softer than I'd planned, and Renee held my eyes for a second longer than was strictly necessary.
Talia clapped her hands together. "Alright, I need a drink and a table, in that order."
"You could just say you're hungry," Cass said flatly.
"I could, but that's less commanding."
Talia was already walking toward the bar, and the rest of us followed. We grabbed a table with a clear sightline to the bar.
As we settled in, Nico looked up from behind the bar — at our table, or more precisely at Milo — and then went back to drying a glass like he was defusing a bomb. Talia caught it too, because Talia caught everything that happened within a fifty-foot radius of Milo and Nico, and her hand went to Cass's arm and her lips pressed together in suppressed delight that was going to last about four seconds.
"Oh my God," Talia whispered, leaning into Cass like she needed physical support. "Did you see the way he just looked at Milo? That was different. That was not the usual."
"It was a glance across a bar," Cass said. "He does it every time we sit down."
"Exactly. Every time. Cass, the man has a routine now. He has a Milo routine."
"That's not the win you think it is."
"It's absolutely the win I think it is."
Then Milo noticed it — a glass sitting on the far end of the bar, amber, lime wheel on the rim. His drink. Already made, already waiting.
He didn't say anything. He just looked at it, and then looked at Nico, who was standing behind the bar with a towel over one shoulder, watching him right back. Nico didn't look away. And then, barely — so small you'd miss it if you weren't looking, and everyone at this table was looking — he smiled.
Talia made a sound that could only be described as a squeal pressed through clenched teeth.
"Go get your drink," Talia said, gripping Cass's arm hard enough that Cass looked down at her hand and then back up with raised eyebrows. "Go. Right now."
"Be a good dear and get everyone's drinks," Renee added, barely holding back a smile.
"I'll come with you," I said, standing up. I looked around the table. "What does everyone want?"
"Gin and tonic," Renee said without hesitation.
"Bourbon," Cass said.
"Something with mango," Talia said. "Surprise me. Actually, don't surprise me — mango and rum. No wait, surprise me."
"Mango," I confirmed, and walked after Milo, who was already halfway to the bar.
Nico saw him coming and did something I hadn't seen before — he put down the glass he was polishing, turned fully, and waited.
"Hi," Milo said, and the word came out as if it weighed thirty pounds.
"Hey." Nico nodded toward the glass at the end of the bar. "That's yours."
Milo picked it up and took a sip and didn't say anything for what might have been the first time since I'd met him. He just drank and nodded and looked genuinely happy, which on Milo looked like a man trying to contain a parade.
"He doesn't know what to say," I told Nico, settling onto a stool. "This is a medical event. Enjoy it, it won't last."
"I'm right here," Milo said into his glass.
Nico's mouth moved about a millimetre. "Noted."
"Which one of us are you noting?" Milo asked, and Nico just looked at him for a second and then turned back to the bar, and Milo stared at me with his mouth slightly open.
"We also need a gin and tonic, a bourbon, something with mango, and a gin for me — your call on how you do it."
He nodded and got to work.
"So how's your evening going?" Milo asked Nico, leaning on the bar with his glass cradled like a trophy.
Nico didn't look up from the drinks. "Better now that the rush is done."
"You two are painful," I said, and Nico put Renee's gin and tonic on the bar and said, "I've been called worse," and it was maybe the closest thing to a joke I'd heard him make and Milo gripped the edge of the bar like he needed something solid to hold onto.
The drinks materialized quickly after that — Nico worked the way he always did, efficient and unhurried, but something about the pace felt lighter tonight, less walled off. He set Cass's bourbon and Talia's mango daiquiri on the bar and then slid my gin across. "Elderflower and grapefruit this time."
"Branching out from cucumber," I said, already approving before I'd tasted it.
"Didn't want to get predictable."
I picked up Renee's drink and mine. "Bring the rest when you come back," I told Milo.
"I'll be right behind you," Milo said, not moving from his stool.
"Sure you are." I took the glasses and headed back toward the table.
Renee was talking to Cass, and whatever they'd been discussing had Renee more animated than I'd seen her.
"I'm not saying she was wrong," Renee said. "I'm saying she scheduled the appointment for a Saturday and then acted surprised when I wasn't thrilled about it."
"That's called being wrong," Cass said, entirely unbothered.
"It's called having a different definition of boundaries."
"Renee. That's what wrong means."
Renee laughed, and as I reached the table she smiled.. I smiled back and set the drinks down without spilling anything, which I considered a significant personal achievement.
I set Renee's gin and tonic in front of her and sat down with mine. "Elderflower and grapefruit," I said, taking a sip. "He's getting creative."
"Where's ours?" Talia asked, already looking toward the bar.
"Milo's bringing them. He's having a moment."
The table turned in unison toward the bar, where Milo was still on his stool, talking to Nico with the intensity of a man conducting a job interview he hadn't been invited to. Nico was wiping down the bar and not moving away from the conversation, which by Nico's standards was basically a declaration of intent.
"He made the drink before Milo sat down," Talia said, her voice low and reverent, like she was narrating a nature documentary.
"He works at a bar," Cass said, unmoved. "Remembering regulars is literally the job."
"Cass, he started making the drink before Milo walked in," Talia said. "That is not the job. That is anticipation. That is intention."
"That is a man who saw us walking from the path and had a head start," Cass said, though she didn't sound like she entirely believed her own argument.
Renee watched the bar for a second, watching Milo say something that made Nico shake his head without actually stopping the conversation. "He's not moving away," Renee said. "He could've gone to the other end of the bar by now."
"Thank you, Renee," Talia said, gesturing at her with both hands. "Thank you for having eyes."
Milo came back to the table eventually with the remaining drinks, set them down carefully, sat in his chair, took a breath, and said, "I'm going to go back up there in a bit."
"We know," said everyone, more or less simultaneously.
"So," Talia said, leaning forward with both elbows on the table. "Can we talk about the reef? Because I have not stopped thinking about it."
"The reef was incredible," Milo said, momentarily distracted from his Nico agenda. "I was within touching distance of a sea turtle at one point."
"You screamed about a parrotfish for ten minutes," Cass said. "You did not see a sea turtle."
"It was behind me. I sensed it."
"You sensed a turtle," I said, looking around the table to make sure everyone caught that.
"I'm very intuitive in water," Milo said.
"He is," Talia confirmed, nodding firmly.
"Were you even looking at him?" Cass asked, like a lawyer who'd already seen the evidence.
"No," Talia admitted. "But I believe him emotionally."
"And Lyle," Milo said, shaking his head. "The man told us the reef had been growing for thousands of years and deserved our consideration. Like the coral had a lawyer."
"He said it like the coral had feelings," Renee said, and her delivery was so flat and precise that Talia choked on her mango daiquiri and had to be patted on the back by Cass.
I contributed my own impression of Lyle's shark reassurance, which had arrived so quickly in the actual briefing that it created more alarm than it solved. "Nobody asked about sharks," I said. "He brought them up and dismissed them in the same breath. That's not a safety briefing, that's a man confessing to something and hoping you won't follow up."
"To be fair," Renee said, "he's never once been boring."
"That's the most generous thing you've ever said about anyone," I told her, and Renee tilted her head like she was weighing whether to accept the observation or challenge it.
Talia caught a server's eye from across the bar with a wave that left no room for ambiguity. The server came over, handed out menus, and waited.
"What are the specials tonight?" Talia asked, already flipping through hers.
"So we have a pan-seared sea bass with a herb crust, a —"
"I'll do the sea bass," Talia said. "But grilled, not pan-seared. And can I swap the rice for greens? Also is the sauce spicy or just flavoured? Because I want flavour but I don't want heat."
"I can ask the kitchen to —"
"And dressing on the side. For the greens. If they come with dressing. Do they come with dressing?"
The server flipped to a second page of her notepad.
"Are you done?" I asked, already knowing she wasn't.
"I might change the greens back to rice."
"She's done," I told the server, saving both their lives.
"Just the steak," Cass said. "Medium rare. Whatever sides come with it are fine."
"That's so boring," Talia said, like Cass had just asked for plain toast at a five-course dinner.
"It's decisive."
"What would you recommend?" Milo asked the server, chin in his hand, giving her his full attention.
"The sea bass is very popular."
"But what do you personally like?"
"The chicken is —"
"Perfect. I'll have the pasta."
The server blinked. "The pasta?"
"The pasta," Milo confirmed, handing back the menu like he'd just made the decision of a lifetime.
"I'll do the sea bass as well," Renee said.
"Make mine how it comes," Renee said. "No modifications."
Talia opened her mouth and Cass put a hand on her arm.
"The chicken," I said, picking up where Milo had rudely left off.
"I'm going to go check on the drinks situation," Milo said
"The drinks situation?" Cass said, narrowing her eyes at him like she was taking a witness statement.
"There are drinks. At the bar. And I want to make sure they're... situated."
"Go," Talia said, waving him off like she was releasing a bird into the wild.
"He was up there for twenty minutes last time," I said, watching him make a beeline for Nico's end of the bar.
"Twenty minutes is a conversation."
"For Nico, twenty minutes is probably a TED talk," I said, and Renee laughed, and for a split second I found myself watching her a bit too closely. I shook it off; overthinking things would only drive me crazy, and besides, my chicken was about to arrive.
Food started arriving. Talia inspected her sea bass before her fork was even in her hand.
"They did the greens," said Talia, lifting a leaf like she was conducting a quality audit. "But I specifically said dressing on the side."
"Eat your food," Cass said, already cutting into her steak.
My chicken arrived next, and then Renee's sea bass, and then Milo's pasta sat at the empty chair looking abandoned.
"Should we tell him?" I asked, nodding toward the bar where Milo had relocated to a stool directly across from Nico and appeared to be in no hurry to leave.
"Let the pasta go cold," Cass said, not looking up from her steak. "Natural consequences."
"That's cruel," Talia said, though she was already half-standing to wave him over. "Milo! Your food!"
He held up one finger — the universal sign for give me a second from a man who had no intention of making it just a second — and then said something to Nico, who nodded, and Milo walked back to the table like he hadn't just been gone for the entire ordering process.
"What did I miss?" asked Milo, sitting down and pulling his plate toward him.
"Your food arriving," I said, taking a sip of my gin.
"And your dignity leaving," Cass said.
"Both recoverable," Milo said, picking up his fork with the confidence of a man who believed that.
Renee had started eating without waiting for anyone, which I liked. No ceremony, no performance. She tasted the sea bass and gave a small nod to herself, and that was the full extent of her review.
"So what's the plan for the rest of the trip?" Talia asked, looking around the table. "We've done the mixer, the volleyball, the snorkeling — what else is there?"
"We could do nothing," Cass said. "That's an option people forget exists."
"Nothing is not an activity."
"That's exactly what makes it appealing."
"There's the bonfire thing," Milo said through a mouthful of pasta. "Lyle mentioned it on the first day. Some kind of beach night with drinks and music."
"Lyle mentioned everything on the first day," I said. "The man handed us a schedule like it was a court summons. I'm pretty sure there was a pottery class buried on page two."
"I'd do pottery," Talia said, like she'd already signed up in her head.
"You'd talk through the entire pottery class and end up with a lopsided mug you'd call art," Cass said, not looking up from her steak.
"It would be art."
"It would be a mug."
"Same thing," Talia said, grinning, and Cass shook her head but she was smiling too, the way she always did when Talia pushed her just far enough.
Renee was watching the two of them with something I hadn't seen before — not the careful observation from the first few days, not the guarded distance. She was enjoying them. Fully, without filtering it through whatever she usually filtered things through.
I hadn't expected that to get to me, but it did. The reef had done something similar — the stillness of it, the colours, the quiet underwater world that didn't need narration or wit or performance. And then Alina's words, the ones I still hadn't shaken: the material ends up being the people you didn't expect to meet. And now Renee, sitting across from me at a table with people she'd known for a few days, laughing at Cass's delivery, contributing without being asked, present in a way that felt private even though we were surrounded by people.
I still didn't want to think about what any of it meant. I'd been not-thinking about it since the reef, and I was getting good at it, and I wasn't about to stop now. So I ate my chicken and let the evening keep moving.
"Have any of you actually been to the spa?" Renee asked, and the question was so normal and so perfectly timed that I almost laughed.
"I keep meaning to," Talia said. "But then something better comes up."
"Like volleyball with people who can't play volleyball," Cass said.
"We were fine," Milo said.
"You dove for a ball that was already out of bounds and landed on your face."
"I showed commitment."
"You showed the sand what the inside of your mouth looks like."
Milo turned to Renee. "Back me up here."
"You were very enthusiastic," Renee said.
"Thank you."
"Your form was terrible."
"I'm taking back the thank you."
The table was laughing, and I was laughing, and Renee caught my eye across the table and something passed between us that was small and warm and didn't need explaining. She'd made a joke at Milo's expense and it had landed perfectly and she looked almost surprised by how easy it was, and I thought — without planning to, without wanting to — this is what you're like when you stop holding yourself at a distance.
And then the thought was gone and Talia was talking again.
"This might be the best vacation I've ever had," Talia said, and she said it simply, without her usual performance, and the table went quiet for a moment. "I mean it. The resort is gorgeous but it's really — it's you guys."
"It's the mold effect," Milo said. "We show up uninvited and we're impossible to get rid of."
"Beautiful," Cass murmured. "Put that on a greeting card."
"I'm heading out Saturday," I said, and the words came out more quietly than I'd planned. "Few more days and that's it."
"Same," Renee said.
Neither of us said anything for a second. We were on the same clock and neither of us had known it until just now.
"I guess I'm out the same day as you."
"Tragic," Milo said. "I'm going to have to find entirely new people to bother."
"You'll manage," Renee said dryly.
Cass yawned — the first real one of the night — and didn't bother covering it. Talia was showing Milo something on her phone, their heads close together, and the conversation had thinned out to an easy quiet that meant nobody was trying anymore.
"I think I'm going to head back," I said, and pushed my chair out slightly.
"Already?" Talia looked up from her phone. "We were going to see if Milo could get Nico to do a shot with him."
"That was your plan," Milo said. "I was going to maintain my dignity."
"Since when?" Cass asked, without missing a beat.
"I'll let you know how it goes," Milo told me, and I knew he would, in detail, whether I wanted it or not.
Renee set her glass down and straightened up. "I'll head back too. I'm done."
"Both of you?" Talia said, looking between us.
"It's been a long day," Renee said.
"It has," I agreed, standing up before Talia could build a case.
"But —"
"Let them go," Cass said quietly.
"Goodnight, you two," Milo said, and his voice was perfectly normal and his face was perfectly innocent and I chose to believe both of those things because the alternative was acknowledging what he meant by you two, and I wasn't going to do that.
"Night," Renee said. "Don't do anything I wouldn't do."
"That leaves a lot of options," Milo said, with a grin he wasn't even trying to hide.
"It does," Renee agreed, and the way she said it made Milo raise his glass and Talia squeeze Cass's arm hard enough to leave a mark.
We left the bar and started down the path toward the bungalows. For the first thirty seconds or so we didn't say anything. Not an awkward silence — more like the kind that happens when two people transition from a group of five to a group of two and neither of them is sure what frequency they're on yet. The music from the bar faded behind us and the sound of the water took over and I was aware of Renee walking beside me, her stride unhurried, her hands loose at her sides.
"Milo's going to be insufferable now that Nico's actually talking to him," I said, falling into step beside her.
"He was insufferable before Nico was talking to him," Renee said. "Now he has proof."
"Proof is the last thing that man needs."
"He'll have a full case file by Saturday."
Renee laughed, and it sounded different out here without the group around — looser, and more unguarded.
"That was a good night," Renee said, after a few steps of quiet.
"It was."
"You looked like you didn't want to come, earlier. When you first walked up."
I glanced at her. "What gave it away?"
"You were holding your purse like a weapon."
"I was holding my purse like a person who owns a purse."
"You were holding it like someone who hadn't fully committed to arriving," Renee said, and she was right, and I was starting to find that less annoying than I used to.
"I almost didn't come," I admitted, and I wasn't sure why I said it out loud except that the path was quiet and she was easy to talk to when nobody was watching.
"What changed your mind?"
"You asked," I said, and it came out simpler than anything I'd planned to say.
Renee didn't respond right away. We walked a few more steps and I could hear the water somewhere to our right.
"I'm glad you came," Renee said, and she didn't look at me when she said it, which somehow made it land harder than if she had.
The path curved and the bar noise faded behind us.
"I owe you an apology," Renee said, quieter now.
"Hmm?"
"For how I was when we met. All of it." She kept her eyes on the path. "I was dealing with a lot and I wasn't handling it well, and you got the worst of it. I'm sorry."
It was the most unguarded thing I'd ever heard her say.
"I'm sorry too," I said. "I was annoyed and I let it run the show. Held onto it longer than I should have."
"You did hold onto it," Renee said, a flicker of amusement breaking through.
"I did. Impressively so." I shook my head. "I mean, I named you Curbside Karen. That's not a casual level of commitment."
"I remember," Renee said, clearly enjoying this.
"I maintain I was provoked."
"You were provoked by my luggage commentary."
"Severely."
We were both laughing, and somewhere in it the last of whatever had been between us since the airport quietly came apart.
"It feels like that was a different trip," Renee said, once the laughter had settled.
"It feels like that was different people."
"Maybe it was," Renee said, and something in the way she said it made the air between us feel warmer.
We kept walking. The path narrowed slightly and our arms almost brushed and neither of us moved away.
"So what does Ade do when she's not on vacation arguing with strangers?" Renee asked, glancing over at me.
"Argue with people I know. It's a full-time commitment."
"I meant when you're not writing."
"That is when I'm not writing. When I'm writing I argue with myself."
"That sounds exhausting," Renee said, half-laughing.
"You have no idea. I'm a very stubborn opponent."
"I believe that," Renee said, dry enough to make it a compliment.
"What about you?" I asked. "What does Renee do when she's not fixing people's shoulders and making incredibly specific observations about strangers' luggage?"
"I have hobbies."
"Name one."
"I cook."
"You cook," I repeated. "What do you cook?"
"Whatever I feel like. I don't follow recipes. I just open the fridge and figure it out."
"That is the most Renee sentence I've ever heard."
"The most Renee sentence," she said, glancing at me sideways. "How long have you been cataloguing me?"
"I haven't been cataloguing."
"You've been cataloguing."
"I've been paying attention. Reluctantly."
"So have I," Renee said. "You really did look good tonight."
"You already said that."
"I know. It was true before dinner and it's still true now."
I felt my pulse do something unhelpful and I kept my eyes on the path. The quiet that followed wasn't empty. It wasn't awkward either. The quiet that followed wasn't empty. Something was being decided without anyone saying so..
"This is easy," I said, and I hadn't planned to say it. "Walking with you. Talking. It's easy."
"Were you expecting it not to be?"
"Based on our track record? I was expecting property damage."
"The night's still young," Renee said, looking right at me like she meant more than the words.
I laughed, and she laughed, and for a few steps it was just that — the two of us on a dark path finding out that this was something neither of us had planned on.
We reached my bungalow. The porch light was on and I stopped at the foot of the steps and Renee stopped beside me.
"I haven't laughed like that in a while," I said.
"Me neither," Renee said, and she looked at me, and whatever had been building all evening was right there in her eyes. My stomach turned over in a way it hadn't in a very long time.
"Goodnight, Ade."
"Goodnight."
She walked down the path toward her bungalow, and I watched her go for exactly as long as I could justify watching someone walk away in the dark, and then I went inside.
The door closed behind me and I dropped my purse on the chair by the window and fell backward onto the bed and stared at the ceiling fan making its slow, stupid circles. The sheets smelled like clean laundry and I lay there and let the evening settle over me the way the water had settled after the reef — slowly, quietly, all at once.
The reef. The group. The way the whole evening had just worked without anyone trying. Milo at the bar, leaning toward Nico like the rest of us had stopped existing. Cass with her arm around the back of Talia's chair, saying nothing, needing nothing. And Renee, looking at me at the bungalow door like she wasn't ready to walk away.
And underneath all of it, the idea that wouldn't get out of my head. It was still there. But something about today had changed the angle of it. It didn't feel solemn anymore. It felt sharp. Observant. Alive in a way that had fun and humor in it, and the steady attention of someone who'd spent their whole life reading people and didn't know how to stop.
I sat up. The laptop was on the desk where I'd left it. I stared at it for a while, then got up, crossed the room, and opened it.
The screen lit up. I opened a blank document. The cursor blinked at me with its usual passive-aggressive patience, and I sat there with my fingers on the keys and waited for the familiar emptiness to arrive — the one where every sentence I could think of was either hollow or too careful or trying too hard to be something it wasn't.
It didn't arrive.
I started writing.
Nora's apartment had nothing in it that didn't earn its place. One good knife in the kitchen, a cutting board with years of use worn into the grain, a couch that faced the window at the exact angle where the morning light hit without being asked to stay. Everything spare, everything deliberate. It was the apartment of a woman who knew what she needed and had stopped apologising for not needing more.
She was a physiotherapist, which meant she spent most of her waking hours watching people try to do things their bodies didn't want to do yet. Shoulders that wouldn't lift. Knees that buckled at angles that used to be simple. Hands that shook around a coffee cup they used to hold steady. Nora's job was to sit in the room with all of that resistance and not fix it — just stay. Just be the person who showed up and said, again, from the top, whenever you're ready, knowing most people weren't ready and wouldn't be for a while. The patience wasn't saintly. It was practiced. Something she'd built through repetition and stubbornness and the quiet belief that showing up was worth more than most people thought it was.
I read it back.
I read it back again.
It wasn't dead. It wasn't the usual competent, hollow, greeting-card prose that collapsed the moment I looked at it. It was rough. But it was breathing. It had a pulse. The character on the page was specific and real and not a thesis statement about brokenness, she was a person with a job that required the kind of patience that looked boring from the outside and was actually the hardest thing in the room.
I kept writing. The physiotherapist moved through a morning — the apartment, the commute, the first patient. A woman showed up in the waiting room fifteen minutes early with a coffee she wasn't drinking and a voice that filled the space like it was looking for the edges. She talked too fast and said something funny and then looked surprised that she'd said it, as if the joke had escaped without clearance. Nora watched her the way she watched everyone — with her hands still, her attention steady, her first impression forming not from what the woman said but from the way she held the coffee cup she wasn't drinking from, gripping it like a prop in a scene she hadn't rehearsed for.
I didn't stop. The sentences kept coming, imperfect and alive, and some of them were better than others and none of them were dead. It wasn't anything like what I'd written before. It was something I didn't have a category for yet — sharp, grounded, observational, funny in places where I hadn't planned to be funny and honest in places where I would normally have deflected. Nora was taking shape on the page with a specificity that meant I wasn't inventing her, I was transcribing something I'd already been carrying.
I scrolled up. Read from the top. Some of it was raw. Most of it was good. The woman with the coffee showed up again in a second scene — different outfit, same energy, and Nora was watching her and I was writing Nora watching her and something about the whole thing felt right in a way I wasn't going to examine because the last time I examined everything the working came to a screeching halt.
So I kept going. And I didn't want to stop.

I woke up slowly, the ceiling fan turning above me in its lazy, familiar loop. The sheets were warm. Light was coming through the shutters in soft, angled bars that meant the sun was up but hadn't been up long.
And then I remembered.
I'd written last night. Actually written — not the delete-and-retype loop, not the staring contest with the cursor, not the hollow competent sentences that read like someone filling out a form. I'd sat at that desk and words had come out and I'd let them stay.
That was new. Months of opening the laptop with the enthusiasm of someone approaching jury duty, and this morning I was out of bed and across the room before I'd fully decided to move. I sat down, opened the laptop, and there they were.
Pages. Rough, unfinished, full of sentences that were working too hard in places and not hard enough in others. Nora's treatment room. The patient across from her. The conversation she'd started building between them.
I read from the beginning, properly this time, with daylight and coffee-less clarity, and the prose held up better than it had any right to. Some of it needed work — there was a passage near the middle where Nora's patience tipped into something a little too composed, and I'd need to roughen it up, give her edges that cut. The patient's voice was close to right but not quite locked — she was funny in places where I hadn't intended her to be, which meant the character was smarter than what I'd had in my head for her. All fixable. All the kind of problems you actually want to have, the kind that mean something exists to fix.
I closed the laptop and sat there with my hands flat on the desk, doing absolutely nothing, feeling something I hadn't felt since the first draft of My Husband, My Bride.
I wanted to keep going.
I picked up my phone. It was early — earlier than I'd usually willingly be vertical. I opened my messages and scrolled to Maribel.
Me: I wrote something last night.
I set the phone down. Picked it up. Put it down again. Checked the screen. Nothing yet. Of course nothing yet — it was early even by Maribel's standards, and Maribel's standards involved being awake and productive at hours that most people considered still technically nighttime.
I went to the bathroom. Washed my face. Looked at myself in the mirror — Adrian, rumpled and squinting, hair doing something architectural on one side.
The phone buzzed when I was brushing my teeth.
Maribel: How much.
Not "that's wonderful" or "finally" or even "tell me more." Two words. A quantity question. Pure Maribel.
Me: A couple of pages. It's rough.
Maribel: Send them.
Me: They're not ready.
Maribel: I didn't ask if they were ready. I asked you to send them.
Me: Fine. Emailing now.
Maribel: Good.
I spat out the toothpaste, rinsed, and went back to the desk. The email took longer than it should have. I copied the pages in, typed "rough pages — be gentle" in the subject line, and stared at it. Too needy. I deleted it and tried "first draft excerpt — feedback welcome." Too corporate. I deleted that too, sat there for a moment with the cursor blinking in the empty subject field, and typed "pages" with no punctuation and no dignity.
I hit send before the third version could talk me out of it.
The email sat in my sent folder looking permanent and terrifying and done. I closed the laptop and sat there for a moment, hands on the desk, letting the fact of it catch up with me. The pages were with Maribel now. Whatever she thought of them, I couldn't un-send them.
I got dressed without thinking too hard about it — linen top, shorts, hair twisted up against the humidity — and headed out before the nervous energy could talk me into checking whether Maribel had opened the email yet.
The path through the trees was still holding onto the cool of the morning, the ground damp under my sandals.
The restaurant was quieter than I'd ever seen it — just a couple at a far table and a server refilling the coffee carafes who gave me a nod. The buffet was fully stocked and untouched, everything still in neat rows that wouldn't survive five minutes of Milo.
I made myself a plate with more care than I usually bothered with, poured coffee, and picked a table near the railing where I could see the path down from the bungalows. I didn't think about why I chose that particular view. I just sat down.
Just me and the coffee and the morning. I took a sip. Closed my eyes. Let it sit.
I was halfway through my second coffee when Talia appeared at the top of the path, walking like the croissants were running out.
"You're here early." She dropped into the chair across from me and reached for the juice pitcher. "I don't think you've ever beaten me to anything."
"I didn't realize it was a competition."
"Everything is a competition. Ask Cass."
"That is not all you've got," Talia said, pointing her fork at me and squinting like she was deciding exactly how much of that she was going to let slide.
"What am I being volunteered for?" Cass asked, setting her plate down.
"I was telling Ade that she beat me to breakfast," Talia said, somehow making it sound like an accusation. "And that you'd confirm I'm competitive."
"You set an alarm for breakfast," Cass said.
"Preparation isn't competition."
Cass looked at me. "She said, and I quote, 'I want to be there before anyone else so I get the good croissants.'"
"That's survival," Talia said, entirely without shame.
Milo arrived in a shirt that looked like a greenhouse had exploded onto fabric and nobody had bothered to clean it up. He sat down with a plate that defied structural engineering — fruit stacked on toast balanced on something that might have been a pancake — and surveyed the table.
"Morning. Where's Renee?"
My eyes went to the path without my permission — the stone walkway I'd walked twenty minutes ago. The one Renee would come down if she was coming, and she wasn't there.
"Maybe she's sleeping in," Talia said, shrugging like the answer was obvious.
"Renee doesn't sleep in," Milo said. "She probably woke up at dawn and immediately did something productive. Like stretching or being composed."
"Maybe she went for a walk," Cass offered. "She mentioned wanting to try one of the trails."
I took a sip of coffee and didn't say anything. Renee not being here was fine. People skipped breakfast. It happened. There was no reason for me to be cataloguing the empty chair at the table or tracking the path every time something moved in my peripheral vision.
"So," Talia said. "Last night."
"Last night was dinner," I said. "We all ate food. You ordered with modifications that required a separate conversation with the server. Milo disappeared to check on drinks that didn't need checking. It was a whole evening."
"Don't do that," Talia said. "Don't give me the highlights. You and Renee left together."
"We walked in the same direction. Our bungalows are in the same direction."
"Milo said you two looked—"
"Milo says a lot of things."
"—like you were having a moment." Talia was undeterred in a way that was becoming genuinely impressive. "And Milo has excellent moment-detection skills."
"His moment-detection skills are tuned so high they generate false positives." I reached for a piece of toast. "We walked back. We talked. She apologized for the airport thing — the way she was when we first met. I apologized too. We cleared the air. That's all."
"That's not all," Milo said. "Nobody 'clears the air' in the dark while walking someone to their bungalow and calls it a regular evening."
"She wasn't walking me. We were walking in the same direction."
"That is not the point, Ade."
Cass was watching me. Not pushing, not asking — just watching with that quiet precision of hers, the one that saw exactly what was happening and waited for it to arrive rather than digging for it.
"She's different than I expected," I said, and the words came out without the protective layer I usually wrapped them in. "When we first met — the airport, the plane, the transfer — she was all sharp edges and I was all sharp edges back and we just kept cutting each other. But here, with you guys, with the group..." I trailed off, looking at my coffee. "She's warm. She's funny in this different sort of way. She's patient in a way I don't think I've ever been with anyone. She listens like she's actually hearing you. And last night she just — she talked to me like she'd decided I was someone worth being honest with."
The table was quiet.
"Ade," Milo said, and his voice was gentler than I expected. "You know what that sounds like, right?"
"It sounds like I made a friend."
"It sounds like you like her."
The deflection was right there — I had several ready — and for once I let them pass.
"I don't know what it is," I said. "I know she's... not what I expected. And I know I think about that more than I probably should." I picked up my coffee, took a sip that was mostly an excuse to stop talking. "That's all I've got."
"That is not all you've got," Talia said.
"It's all I've got for this table at this hour."
"You're leaving Saturday," Milo said. "She's leaving Saturday. That's three whole days. Why not just — I don't know — let something happen? Have fun with it?"
A bird landed on the railing, assessed the table, and decided we weren't worth it.
I was starting to agree with the bird. "Because I'm not built like that."
"What do you mean?" Talia asked.
I turned the coffee cup in my hands. "The last relationship I had was about a year and a half ago. Her name was Claire." I took a breath that wasn't quite steady. "She was good. We were good for a while. She knew Adrian, she knew Adrianna, and she never made me feel like either one was a problem. But we wanted different things — she wanted to settle, I was still figuring out what settling even looked like for me. And when two people are moving at different speeds long enough, eventually one of them stops waiting." I looked at my coffee. "She stopped waiting. I don't blame her for it. But I haven't really tried again since."
Milo had stopped eating. Talia's hand was resting on the table, still.
"So when you say 'have fun with it,'" I continued, "I hear that. I do. But I don't know how to do that. I don't know how to start something with someone when I already know the end date. I'd rather not start at all than start something I can't finish."
"You're not imagining it," Cass said, without looking up from her plate.
I looked at her. She hadn't spoken in a while, and the sentence landed the way Cass's sentences always did — clean, precise, arriving exactly where it needed to.
"She's warming up to all of us, but with you it's different," Cass continued. "There's something else going on there."
I didn't have a response for that. It was accurate in a way I hadn't let myself think about yet, and accurate was harder to argue with than wrong.
"I'm just saying," Milo said, and the gentleness was still there, which was more disarming than his usual volume, "that nobody at this table is telling you to do something you're not ready for. But if you're not doing anything because you've already decided how it ends before it starts — that's not protecting yourself. That's just being scared."
The word hung in the air, not unkindly, and not wrong either.
I took a sip of coffee and didn't answer, and the table let me not answer, which was its own kind of kindness.
"So," Talia said, clapping her hands together once like she was physically resetting the table. "Lyle caught us on the way here. There's a bonfire on the beach tonight."
"We're going," Milo said immediately.
"Obviously we're going," Talia confirmed. "Everyone's going."
"Everyone meaning us," Cass clarified, "because Talia has already decided."
"There's supposed to be music and drinks on the beach," Talia continued, ignoring Cass entirely. "Lyle was extremely excited about it. I think I aged a year listening to the full rundown."
"Think Renee will be there?" Milo asked, not even trying to aim the question anywhere other than directly at me.
"I'm sure Lyle will find her. Lyle finds everyone."
My phone buzzed in my lap. I glanced down.
Maribel: I've read the pages. We need to talk. When can you do a call?
My stomach did something I wasn't expecting. It felt like standing at the edge of a high dive and looking down — that specific moment where your body understands the height before your brain does and everything in you tightens. The water was there. You just had to jump.
Me: Give me an hour?
Maribel: I'll call you.
"Everything okay?" Talia asked, reading my face.
"My editor. She wants to talk about something I sent her." I slid the phone back into my pocket. "I should probably head back — she'll be calling in a while and I'd rather not take it looking like I just rolled out of breakfast in bed."
"Something you sent her?" Milo asked. "Like work?"
The answer was right there and I almost let it out.
"Just some stuff," I said. "Early stages. Nothing worth talking about yet."
I stood up. "If you see Renee—"
The sentence sat there, unfinished. The group looked at each other. Nobody said a word, which said everything.
"Never mind," I said, pushing my chair back.
"Ade," Milo said gently.
"I'll see you all tonight."
I walked back to the bungalow with the morning settling around me, the phone in my pocket, the weight of several truths I'd almost said sitting alongside the ones I actually had.
I went inside and stood in the quiet of the bungalow for a moment, letting the ceiling fan do its work.
The shower was longer than it needed to be. I stood under the water with my eyes closed and let the morning run off me.
I stood in front of the wardrobe afterward, pulling things out and putting them back with the kind of deliberation that would have made Sasha text me a series of increasingly aggressive question marks. I settled on a loose linen top and shorts — effortless, which took about seven minutes of effort — and twisted my hair up off my neck.
I sat at the desk. The pages were still open from this morning. I stared at them for about thirty seconds. I'd already read them twice this morning. A third time wasn't going to tell me anything new.
The laptop chimed. Maribel's name on the screen. Right on time, because Maribel was always right on time. I hit accept.
Her face appeared in crisp focus — she was at her desk at home, the clean white wall behind her, a coffee cup within arm's reach. She was wearing a coral blouse that would have been aggressively bright on anyone else but on Maribel just looked deliberate.
"You look different," Maribel said, studying me through the screen the way she studied first drafts — looking for what was underneath.
"I've been outside."
"Voluntarily?"
"Mostly."
She picked up her coffee, took a sip, and set it down. I recognized the rhythm — it was the Maribel equivalent of a deep breath before getting down to business.
"So. I read the pages."
"And?"
"And I have thoughts."
"Maribel, if you're about to tell me they're terrible, I'd prefer you do it quickly so I can process the grief in a warm climate."
"They're not terrible." She said it simply, without decoration. "They're rough. You know they're rough. Some of the sentences are overworked, and at least one paragraph where the prose is doing the thing you do when you're trying to be beautiful instead of being honest — you know the one I mean. The window description."
I did know the one she meant. I'd been halfway in love with that sentence and halfway aware that it was showing off.
"But underneath the rough," Maribel continued, "there's something here that I haven't seen from you before. And I want to talk about that, because I think it matters more than whether the prose is polished."
"Okay."
"This character." She paused, not for effect — Maribel didn't do things for effect — but because she was choosing her words. "Nora. The physiotherapist."
"What about her?"
"She's extremely specific. The way she holds herself, the patience, the apartment with nothing in it that hasn't earned its place — you've written women before, Ade. Plenty of them. But you've never written one like this. This isn't a character you assembled from parts. This feels like a character you've watched."
That was the thing about Maribel. She could dress something up as a craft note and slip it past your defences before you realised she'd asked a personal question without actually asking one.
"She just came to me," I said, keeping my voice steady and my eyes on the screen.
Maribel took a sip of coffee and said nothing for long enough to make it clear she'd filed that answer under fiction.
"Okay," Maribel said. "Moving on."
Maribel didn't push, didn't ask "who is she based on?" — she just made it known that she'd seen the truth, chose not to force a confession, and kept going. Which was worse, in a way, because it meant the observation would be sitting in the room for the rest of the conversation whether I addressed it or not.
"The bigger question," Maribel said, "is what this is going to be."
"What do you mean?"
"I mean that you have written five books, Ade. All of them erotica. Your readers know you for a very specific thing. The heat, the tension, the scenes that make people close the book and sit with it for a minute. That's your lane. That's your audience. That's the readership you've built and the expectation they carry into every new book with your name on it."
"I know all of that."
"Good. Then you also know that what you've sent me isn't erotica."
I didn't say anything, because she was right and we both knew it.
"It's not even adjacent," Maribel continued. "There's no heat in these pages. There's warmth — a lot of it, actually, and it's good warmth, it feels earned — but warmth and heat are different animals. What you've written is a character study. Two people in a room, figuring each other out. One of them patient, one of them not. The dynamic is compelling and the voice is strong, but it is not what anyone who bought My Husband, My Bride is going to be expecting from Adrianna Moore's next book."
"Maybe Adrianna Moore's next book doesn't have to be what they're expecting."
"Maybe not. But that's a decision, not an accident, and right now I'm not sure you've made it consciously." She leaned forward slightly — on screen, the gesture was small but unmistakable. "Have you thought about where this goes? Not the plot — I don't care about plot right now. I mean the emotional engine. What's driving it. What makes it a book instead of a character sketch."
The honest answer was no, and for once I didn't dress it up. I hadn't thought about where it went. I'd sat down and written and I'd followed it without stopping to ask where we were headed. For months I'd been unable to produce a single usable paragraph, and last night the words had arrived and I'd been so relieved to see them that I hadn't questioned what they were building toward.
"I don't know yet," I said. "I know who she is. I know who the patient is. I know the dynamic between them. But I don't know what happens."
"That's fine. You don't need to know yet. But I need you to hear what I'm about to say, because it matters for the decision you're going to have to make." She paused. "What you've written here has a quality I haven't seen in your other work. Your erotica is good — it's sharp, it's honest, it's technically excellent. But this is something else. This reads like you're writing from a place you haven't written from before. There's a tenderness in it that your other books approach through sex and this one is approaching directly, without the performance layer. And that's either going to be the thing that makes this book extraordinary or the thing that makes it impossible to sell, and I can't tell you which one yet."
I sat with that. The fan turned above me. Through the window I could see the water, flat and bright in the midday light.
"Shifting genre is a risk," Maribel continued. "I'm not going to pretend it isn't. You lose readers who came for what they knew. The new readers who'd love this — the ones who want the tenderness without the explicit heat — they haven't found you yet. And building a bridge between what you were and what you might be becoming takes time. It takes more than one book, probably."
"You're making it sound impossible."
"I'm making it sound difficult. There's a difference, and you're smart enough to know which one I mean." She sat back. "The risk is real. But so is what's on those pages. And I've read enough first drafts from enough writers to know the difference between someone trying something new because they're bored and someone trying something new because the old thing stopped being true. What you sent me this morning doesn't read like boredom, Ade."
"What does it read like?"
She looked at me through the screen, and for a second the professional composure thinned enough that I could see something underneath it — it wasn't sentiment, but something close to the way she'd looked at me across the table at Sorrentino's when she'd told me I wrote like someone who understood what people were afraid to want.
"It reads like you finally have something to say."
The words landed and I let them land. No joke, no deflection, no scrambling for a response that would let us both pretend the moment wasn't happening. Maribel had said something true and I was going to sit with it, the way I'd sat with her compliment at Sorrentino's — uncomfortable and grateful and unable to fully take it in.
"So where does that leave us?" I asked, pulling myself back to the practical because the personal was too big to sit with.
"It leaves us with you writing. Whatever this is, wherever it goes — write it. Don't worry about the genre question yet. Don't worry about the audience. Don't try to retrofit it into erotica because you think that's what's expected. Just follow the thing that made you sit down and produce actual pages after months of nothing, and we'll figure out what it is when there's enough of it to figure."
"And the deadline?"
"The deadline hasn't moved. But what I care about more than the deadline is that you're writing, and for the first time in months, you are. So I'm going to give you room on this. Not unlimited room. But room."
"That's almost generous, Maribel."
"Don't get used to it."
"I wouldn't dream of it."
She allowed herself a half-second of what might have been a smile — with Maribel, the margin between pleased and neutral was about two millimetres and you had to know where to look.
"One more thing," Maribel said, and something in her tone shifted just enough that I sat up straighter.
"Go ahead."
"The patient character. The one who talks too fast and holds her coffee like a prop."
"What about her?"
"She's good. She's very good, actually — she's the funniest thing in the pages, and she doesn't know she's funny, which is what makes it work. But she's doing something interesting that I don't think you've noticed."
"What?"
"She's you."
I stared at the screen for long enough that Maribel must have seen exactly what that word did to me.
"The way she deflects with humour," Maribel continued, ticking them off with the efficiency of someone reading a grocery list. "The way she can't sit still in a conversation that's getting too honest. The way she performs being fine when she's anything but. That character isn't a patient, Ade. She's a self-portrait."
"She's not—"
"I've worked with you for four years. I know what you sound like on the page when you're writing about yourself, even if you weren't trying to do it intentionally on the page." She picked up her coffee. "I'm not asking you to do anything about it. I'm just telling you I see it. Use it or don't."
"Keep writing," Maribel said. "Whatever this is, keep going."
"I will."
"Take care of yourself, Ade." She said it the way she always said it — like it covered more ground than the words themselves.
"I will."
I sat at the desk after the screen went dark.
The call was over and the quiet felt different now. Heavier. Maribel had said things I wasn't done hearing yet.
She'd called the character a self-portrait. I'd said she wasn't, and Maribel had let that slide with the particular mercy of a woman who knew when to stop pushing. But the word had stayed. Self-portrait. The nervous, funny, deflecting patient sitting across from a physiotherapist who was too specific, too carefully observed, too real to be assembled from nothing.
I knew where Nora came from. I'd known since I wrote the first sentence about her, and I'd been calling it inspiration because inspiration was a safe word. Professional. It meant I was doing my job. It didn't mean anything else had to be true.
Maribel had asked why this wasn't erotica. Why it was warmth instead of heat. I still didn't have an answer I was willing to say out loud. But I could feel one sitting just underneath everything else, quiet and patient and waiting for me to stop pretending I didn't know it was there.
I didn't let myself go any further than that. But I didn't leave the desk either.

Lyle had outdone himself, and I hated that I had to admit it.
The bonfire wasn't a bonfire. It was an event. The stretch of beach past the pool deck had been transformed into something that looked like a catalog shoot for a resort that charged twice what this one did — which, knowing what this one charged, was saying something. Tiki torches lined the path down from the main building, their flames doing that lazy tropical sway. A four-piece band had set up on a low wooden platform near the water — guitar, bass, keys, drums — already working through something acoustic and unhurried, a versatile resort act that could pivot from island covers to pop ballads without breaking a sweat. There were blankets laid out on the sand, low wooden chairs arranged in loose clusters around the fire pit, and a satellite bar staffed and stocked with enough rum to drown a small nation's sorrows.
The fire itself was enormous. Not dangerously so — Lyle was too organized for genuine peril — but tall enough that the heat reached me halfway down the path, carrying woodsmoke and something faintly sweet underneath — whatever had been used to get it started was still burning off. The whole thing felt curated without feeling staged, which was the most dangerous combination.
I'd spent twenty minutes getting ready, which was nineteen more than I'd planned. The green dress from dinner the other night was too much for a bonfire, so I'd gone with something simpler — a wrap top in a color Sasha would have called "terracotta" and I'd call "reddish," loose linen pants, sandals that I could actually walk in on sand. Hair down because the humidity was going to do whatever it wanted anyway and I'd decided to stop negotiating with it. I looked fine. I looked like someone going to a bonfire. I looked like someone who had absolutely not tried on two other things first.
Milo was already down by the fire when I arrived, because Milo was always already somewhere, existing at full volume before anyone else had committed to showing up. He'd claimed a cluster of low chairs near the fire pit and was sitting with his legs stretched out, a drink in one hand and the other gesturing at Talia, who was cross-legged on a blanket next to Cass.
"You're late," Milo said when he spotted me, as if we'd agreed on a time, which we absolutely had not.
"I'm early for me," I said, dropping into the chair next to him. "What are we drinking?"
"Rum punch. The bartender said it's Lyle's recipe, which means it's either incredible or we'll all be dead by ten." He raised his own drink — served in a coconut shell, because of course it was — and pointed me toward the satellite bar.
The satellite bar was a few steps from our cluster, manned by a guy I hadn't seen before — young, cheerful, already sweating slightly from the fire's reach. He had a row of coconut shells lined up like he'd been preparing for a siege.
"Rum punch?" the bartender asked, already reaching for the ladle before I'd opened my mouth.
"Is that the only option?"
"It's the recommended option." He filled a coconut shell with practiced efficiency. "Lyle's recipe. He gave me the instructions three times and a laminated card."
I took the coconut shell — complete with a tiny paper umbrella wedged into the rim — and walked back to my chair.
Talia spotted the umbrella the second I sat down. "He put umbrellas in the drinks. Tiny ones. I love this man. I want Lyle to plan my funeral."
"You want your funeral planned by an activities coordinator?" Cass asked, without looking up from whatever she was doing on her phone.
"I want my funeral to have themed cocktails and a colour-coordinated schedule, yes."
"Noted."
I took a sip. The rum punch was, annoyingly, excellent. Sweet enough to be dangerous, strong enough to remind you that this was not, in fact, a smoothie. I settled into my chair and let the fire do its thing — the warmth hit differently on a beach at night, softer than sunlight, less insistent.
Emmett was making the rounds, stopping at each cluster of guests long enough to make everyone feel personally welcomed without anyone feeling managed. When he reached us, he put a hand on the back of an empty chair and surveyed the group like a man inspecting something he'd built.
"Talia, that kaftan is spectacular."
Talia smoothed the fabric with both hands. It looked like she'd mugged a very stylish grandmother. "Thank you, Emmett. I've been told it's a lot."
"It's exactly the right amount." He turned to the rest of us. "The band's taking requests tonight, by the way. If anyone has something they want to hear."
Milo sat up so fast he nearly spilled his drink.
"Requests. As in, songs. That they will play. Because I asked."
"That is generally how requests work," I said, already regretting that he'd been given this information.
"This changes everything."
"It changes nothing," I said into my coconut shell.
"It changes the entire evening, Ade. I now have power."
Cass finally looked up from her phone. "Please don't abuse it."
"I will absolutely abuse it."
The fire popped and sent a shower of sparks up into the dark. Other guests had settled into their own clusters around the pit — a couple sharing a blanket and a drink, a group of women who'd been at the mixer, a pair of older men leaning into each other without talking, looking at the fire like they'd earned it. The band had shifted into something slower, the guitar carrying a melody that the bass was content to follow. The whole scene had the quality of a night that was assembling itself without anyone having to force it.
"Where's Renee?" Milo asked, scanning the path.
My eyes went to the torchlit walkway before I could redirect them. Empty.
"She'll be here," Talia said.
"You talked to her?" I asked.
"We saw her at the pool this afternoon. She swam, like, forty laps. I'm not even exaggerating — Cass counted."
"I counted twelve before I stopped caring."
"Which in Cass math is basically forty," Talia said, waving it off like a minor detail.
So Renee had been around today. At the pool. Swimming laps. While I'd been at the desk sitting with Maribel's words and the empty path outside my window and a vague, unexamined awareness that the morning felt quieter than it should have.
I took another sip of the rum punch and let that one go.
"More importantly," Milo said, leaning forward with the expression that meant someone was about to have their evening derailed, "Nico is coming tonight."
Talia's head snapped toward him. "What?"
"Off duty. Not working. As a guest." Milo was vibrating at a frequency I hadn't seen before, and I'd seen some frequencies. "Emmett gave the bar staff the night off for the bonfire. He told me twenty minutes ago and I've been processing it ever since."
"How are you doing with the processing?" I asked, watching him squeeze his drink hard enough to threaten the structural integrity of the coconut shell.
"Terribly. What do I do with my hands?"
"The same thing you always do with your hands."
"I don't know what I always do with my hands, Ade. I've never thought about my hands before in my life and now they're all I can think about." He held them up and stared at them with genuine distress.
"Wrap them around your drink," Cass said. "Stop talking about them."
"What if he comes and sits near us?"
"Then you say hello and act like a person," I said, like I was explaining something to a very bright child who had momentarily forgotten how society worked.
"I don't think I can act like a person tonight. I think tonight I'm going to be slightly worse than a person."
"You're going to be fine," Talia said, though her grin suggested she was mostly looking forward to watching him not be fine.
He wasn't fine. Nico appeared about ten minutes later, coming down the path with the unhurried ease of someone who had no idea he was being monitored by four people and a growing sense of communal investment. He'd traded the bar uniform for a fitted dark henley, sleeves pushed to the elbows, and dark jeans. He looked, objectively, like someone who had put in minimal effort and achieved maximum result, which was either infuriating or magnetic depending on your relationship to the situation.
Milo's relationship to the situation was immediate cardiac arrest.
"Oh no," Milo breathed, sinking lower in his chair like he could somehow become invisible through posture alone.
"Oh yes," Talia said, already leaning forward like she was settling in for a show.
"He's wearing a real shirt. That's a real shirt. That's not a uniform, that's a choice he made."
"It's a very good choice," I said.
"I'm going to die. I'm going to die at a bonfire in a pineapple shirt and they'll have to ship my body home."
"Your shirt is fine," Cass said, rolling her eyes, which only made Milo look down at himself with renewed horror.
"My shirt has pineapples on it, Cass."
"Pineapples are festive."
"Pineapples are what you wear when you've given up on being taken seriously as a romantic prospect."
Nico had paused at the bar to get a drink — which, given that he was usually on the other side of one, had a certain satisfying symmetry — and was now scanning the clusters of chairs with the mildly evaluative expression of someone deciding where to sit. His gaze passed over our group, moved on, and then came back like he'd changed his mind about something. He picked up his drink and walked over.
"Room for one more?" His voice sounded different outside the context of the bar — still quiet, still economical, but without the professional buffer.
"Always," Milo said, and then immediately looked like he wished he'd said literally anything else.
Nico took the chair on the other side of Milo and settled in without ceremony. He didn't say anything else, and the fact that he'd chosen this cluster, out of every cluster on this beach, was doing all the talking.
Milo's face was a masterpiece of controlled devastation. I glanced at Talia and she caught my eye immediately, her expression already saying do not intervene, this is the best thing that has ever happened.
And then Renee was there.
She came down the path without hurry, wearing a simple black tank and shorts, her hair down and still slightly wavy. She stopped at the satellite bar first, exchanged a few words with the bartender, and came back with a drink. Then she looked around, clocked our group, and walked over.
"Hey," Renee said to the group, and settled into the chair next to mine.
"Hey," I said back, sitting up slightly straighter before I could stop myself.
The simplicity of it made my earlier hyperawareness of her absence feel slightly ridiculous, which it had been, and I was choosing not to examine that further tonight.
"You missed the Nico situation," Talia stage-whispered to Renee, tilting her head toward the chair where Nico was sitting approximately eighteen inches from Milo.
Renee looked. Assessed. "He chose that chair."
"He chose that chair," Talia confirmed, nearly vibrating on her blanket.
"Good for Milo."
"Milo is currently not breathing."
"I can see that." Renee took a sip of her drink. "He'll figure it out."
The fire had settled into its rhythm — the initial roar burned down to something steadier, warm enough to lean into without flinching. More guests had arrived. Lyle was circulating with the energy of a man whose life's work was being validated in real time, pointing at the fire, pointing at the band, pointing at things that didn't need pointing at but were getting pointed at anyway. Emmett intercepted him at one point and said something close to his ear that made Lyle beam, which was like telling the sun to be brighter.
The rum punch was doing its job. Milo on the other hand had gone dangerously quiet. He was staring at the fire with the fixed concentration of a man who had forgotten how to begin a conversation and was hoping the universe would handle it. The universe, as usual, had other plans.
Nico handled it instead.
"So how long are you here for?" Nico asked, shifting slightly in his chair toward Milo.
"Another week," Milo managed, with the confidence of a man defusing a bomb he'd never seen before.
Talia made a sound into her drink.
"Give or take," Milo added, as if precision might save him. "We got here a few days ago, I think. Time does a weird thing at resorts. Everything kind of blurs."
"It does," Nico agreed easily. "You like it so far?"
"The resort? Yeah, it's — yeah. The beach is great. The water is very..." Milo gestured vaguely toward the ocean. "Wet. Blue. Both."
I took a long sip of my drink.
"The drinks are incredible, though," Milo added quickly, and then seemed to realize who he was talking to. "Which — you already know that. Because you make them. Obviously."
"I appreciate the review," Nico said, something warming in his expression that he didn't seem in any hurry to hide.
"Five stars. I'd give you five stars. If there were stars. For bartending."
"There are, actually. There's a review board in the lobby."
"There's a review board?"
"No."
Milo stared at him. Nico's expression broke into an actual smile — small, but real — and Milo laughed, too loud and too sudden, startled by his own delight.
This was the moment Talia decided to help.
"So Nico," she leaned forward on the blanket with the energy of someone about to conduct a job interview, "Milo was just telling us earlier how much he loves the bar. Like specifically the bar. The actual physical bar and everything behind it."
"I did not say that," Milo cut in immediately.
"You said, and I'm quoting, 'the bar is the best part of this resort.'"
"I said the drinks were good. That's different from declaring a personal obsession with a piece of furniture."
"You also said—"
"Talia." Milo turned to her with his jaw clenched so tight I could see the muscle working. "Thank you. For your input. Which I did not ask for."
"I'm just saying you're a fan," Talia said, settling back on the blanket.
Nico looked between them, reading the table the way he probably read every table — quickly, accurately, and with quiet enjoyment. "It's nice to hear," he said, turning back to Milo. "Most people don't notice the bar itself. I helped Emmett pick the wood for it, actually."
Milo's entire body rotated toward him. "You did?"
"He was renovating last year and wanted something that fit the space. We went back and forth on different finishes, looked at samples for weeks. He's particular about the details."
"That's — I mean, that makes sense. The bar feels like it belongs there. Like it grew out of the floor." Milo paused. "That sounded less weird in my head."
"No, I know what you mean," Nico said, and the ease of it — no rush to fill the pause, no polite redirect — made Milo's shoulders drop about two inches.
"You'd think he studied architecture," Cass said, without looking up. "He's a nurse."
It landed so casually that it took a beat for anyone to register she'd said it at all. But the precision of it was pure Cass — she'd waited for exactly the moment when Milo couldn't pivot the conversation toward anything real about himself, and she'd done it for him, clean and without fanfare.
"Yeah?" Nico turned back to Milo with what looked like genuine interest. "Where?"
"Emergency department." Milo rubbed the back of his neck. "It's less glamorous than it sounds. Mostly it's people who've googled their symptoms and arrived convinced they're dying of something they saw on a podcast."
"That does sound like bartending, actually."
Milo grinned. "People telling you their problems at two a.m.?"
"People telling me their problems at two a.m.," Nico confirmed. "Except mine have had six margaritas and want me to agree that their ex was the problem."
"Mine have had no margaritas and want me to agree that the rash is not cancer."
"Is it ever cancer?"
"It's never cancer. It's always contact dermatitis or anxiety." Milo was leaning toward Nico now, just talking, two people who'd stumbled into a frequency neither of them expected. "But you can't say 'it's not cancer, you're just stressed,' because then they want to speak to your supervisor about your bedside manner."
"I get that with cocktails. Someone orders a martini dirty with extra olives and then sends it back because it tastes like olives."
"People are insane."
"People are completely insane," Nico agreed, and they looked at each other for a second that lasted slightly longer than it needed to.
I glanced at Renee. She was watching them with that quiet almost-smile, and when she caught me looking, she raised her eyebrows just slightly — a wordless well, would you look at that — before turning back to the fire.
Talia was the one who spotted her. "Alina!" She waved with both arms like she was flagging down a rescue helicopter. "Get over here, why are you standing by yourself?"
Alina looked over from the satellite bar, surprised and then amused, and made her way to the group with her drink. She settled cross-legged on the edge of the blanket Talia and Cass were sharing.
"You know everyone?" Talia asked, already moving past the question.
"I think so." Alina gave the group a quick scan, her gaze doing that thing it did — landing on each person just long enough to take a reading before moving to the next. She caught my eye and smiled. "Hey, Adrianna."
"Hey."
"No notebook tonight?" Renee asked.
"Night off," Alina said, and raised her glass. "Even the observing gets exhausting."
She said it lightly, but I noticed she didn't put her phone away. Not that it mattered. Not that I was keeping track.
"So how did you all end up here together?" Alina asked, looking around the group. "You don't seem like a package-deal kind of crowd."
"We met here," I said. "Different rooms, different reasons. Milo was the one who started pulling everyone into orbit."
"That's because Milo has no boundaries," Cass said, not looking up from her drink but timing it perfectly.
"That's because Milo has excellent instincts," Milo corrected from across the cluster, briefly resurfacing from whatever Nico was saying to him.
"And what about you two?" Alina turned to Talia and Cass. "How long have you been together?"
"Eight years," Cass said, her hand still resting on Talia's ankle like the number was nothing remarkable.
"Married for five," Talia added. "But if you count the six months she pretended we weren't dating, it's closer to nine."
"I wasn't pretending. I was being cautious."
"She told her mother I was her friend. Her friend."
"You were my friend. At that point in the timeline, that was accurate."
"I was sleeping in your bed four nights a week, Cassandra."
Cass took a very measured sip of her drink. "Those things aren't mutually exclusive."
"Please tell me there's a story here," Alina said, and she'd made a mistake, because you did not ask Talia for a story unless you were prepared to receive one in full and with commentary.
"Okay, so our third date," Talia said, holding up her drink for emphasis. "I had planned the entire thing. Italian restaurant downtown, candles, the works. I had made a reservation three weeks in advance. I wore the blue dress — you remember the blue dress, babe?"
"I remember the blue dress," Cass confirmed.
"So I show up and she's already there, which — first red flag. Who arrives first to a date they didn't plan?"
"Someone who's punctual," Cass said flatly.
"Someone who's trying to establish dominance."
"I was fifteen minutes early because I took the wrong bus and ended up in the neighborhood ahead of schedule," Cass said. "There was no dominance strategy."
"There's always a dominance strategy. Anyway, she's already there, she's ordered water — not sparkling, still water, like a serial killer—"
"You're comparing me to a serial killer over a water order," Cass said, looking around the group like she expected someone to object.
"Babe, still water at a restaurant is unhinged. You know that, right? You can get still water at home. From a tap. For free."
"I also got still water because sparkling water makes me burp."
"Oh, she's making it worse," Milo announced to no one in particular. "She's actively making it worse."
"How is that worse?"
"Because now you're a serial killer with a burping problem," I said, and Milo nearly fell off his chair.
"I don't have a burping problem. I have a carbonation sensitivity."
"Put that on the dating profile," Talia said, slapping the blanket. "'Cassandra Morgan. Enjoys still water. Carbonation sensitive. Will arrive early and sit with hands folded in total silence.'"
"I wasn't sitting in total silence. I was reviewing the menu."
"She ordered in ninety seconds," Talia told Alina, grabbing her arm. "Ninety seconds. The waiter hadn't even finished the specials."
"I knew what I wanted."
"Serial killers always know what they want," Milo said solemnly, and Nico, who had been watching this entire exchange with the quiet fascination of an anthropologist, laughed — a real, full laugh that made Milo's face do something I was going to remember for a very long time.
"Anyway," Talia said, wiping her eyes and pulling herself back into the story. "So I sit down, I open the menu, and the first thing she says to me — the first thing — is 'I should tell you I don't do well with long menus.'"
"What does that even mean?" Alina asked, looking genuinely delighted.
"It means she panics after eight options and starts making decisions based on font size," Talia said.
"It means I prefer a focused culinary vision," Cass said, with complete seriousness.
"So the waiter looks at me like I've been abandoned. And Cass just sits there, totally calm, sipping her still water, and says, 'Take your time.'"
"I was being considerate."
"You were being terrifying." Talia took a sip. "But somehow, by the end of the night, I was already thinking about date four. She walked me to my car and I asked if she'd had a good time and she said—"
"I said 'I think I'd like to keep doing this,'" Cass said, and this time she was looking at Talia instead of the group.
"And I didn't know what to say back. Which has literally never happened to me." She took a sip of her drink. "So I did what any rational adult does when they're speechless. I went home and called my mom."
"And your mom said?" Alina asked, leaning in like she was watching the finale of something she'd accidentally gotten invested in.
"She said 'marry her.'"
"Your mother barely knew me," Cass said, but she was smiling now.
"My mother is never wrong." Talia kissed the side of Cass's head with the ease of someone who'd done it countless times. "Fourth date she cooked for me. Burned the chicken, undercooked the rice, and the wine was too cold. I was in love by the appetizer."
"The appetizer was cheese and crackers," Cass said. "I can't take credit for that."
"You arranged them on the plate, babe. You arranged cheese on a plate and I thought, this is the woman I'm going to marry."
The laughter that followed was easy and warm — two people who genuinely adore each other telling a story they've told before and still finding each other funny in the telling. Renee was smiling beside me, that subtle half-smile she gave when something landed with her but she wasn't ready to show how much, and I realized mine was doing the same thing.
The laughter settled. The fire crackled. And into the quiet, Milo spoke.
"I want that," Milo said. Simply. Looking at the fire instead of at anyone. "I know I joke about it — the universe owes me a man, the whole thing. But before this trip I was—" He stopped. Started again. "I went to a wedding in April. My friend Marco, good guy, he married this woman who laughs at literally everything he says, even the stuff that isn't funny. And I stood there during the ceremony and I was happy for him, genuinely, and then I went home and I heated up leftover pad thai and I watched three episodes of something I don't remember and I thought — okay. So this is what it's going to be. Me, in my apartment, eating pad thai, forever."
Everyone went quiet. Even the fire seemed to settle for a second.
"Coming here felt like the last stupid thing I could try," Milo said. "Like if the universe was ever going to do something about it, maybe it needed a change of scenery."
Nico, sitting next to him, didn't say anything. But he didn't look away either. He was watching Milo with an expression I hadn't seen on him before — something that had actual attention behind it, stripped of the bar-counter composure. Like he was listening to someone he'd decided was worth listening to.
Talia reached over and squeezed Milo's hand. He squeezed back, and then the moment broke with his own self-rescue — "Also the brochure had a photo of a guy doing yoga at sunrise and I thought, at minimum, I'll come back with better triceps" — and the laughter came back, warmer this time, carrying something underneath it.
Alina, who'd been quiet through most of the group conversation, leaned forward. "Can I ask something? Does anyone else find it hard to be somewhere you actually love without — I don't know — starting to frame it?" She looked around the fire. "Like, I'm sitting here, this is beautiful, and part of my brain is already writing the sentence about it. The fire, the music, the whole thing. And the second I start composing, I stop being here."
It was a good observation. Articulate, specific, and easy to nod along with because you recognized the feeling. And I might have just nodded along with it, except I caught the way her eyes moved while she said it — a quick sweep of the group, landing briefly on Milo, on Talia's hand still near Cass's, on Renee beside me, cataloguing the reactions the way you'd take notes without a pen. She was doing the thing she did. Turning a real moment into content, smoothly enough that you'd miss it if you weren't looking for it.
I was looking for it.
"No. I'm literally just sitting here drinking rum," Talia said, looking genuinely baffled. "That's the whole experience for me."
"I think everyone does that sometimes," I said, and my voice came out more careful than I'd meant it to. "The framing thing. But there's a difference between noticing it and building a career out of it."
Alina's gaze settled on me. Something flickered there — awareness. She knew I'd seen her scanning. "Fair. Though you could say the same about fiction writers."
The comment landed with a precision that I didn't think was accidental. She smiled after she said it, warm and easy, and the moment moved on. But something about the exchange stayed with me — the quickness of her comeback, the way she'd watched the group while pretending to share something vulnerable. I didn't trust it. I didn't trust her.
Beside me, Renee shifted in her chair. Something in her posture had stiffened, and I could tell she'd been listening to every word.
"Where were you today, by the way?" Talia asked, turning to me. "We were all at the pool and you vanished."
"I had a call with my editor. We were just going over some stuff I'd written." I said it like it was nothing, which was my first mistake.
"Stuff you'd written?" Milo swung back toward the group conversation. "As in new stuff? As in you're actually writing again?"
"Something clicked," I said. "Whether it clicks into an actual book is still very much an open question."
"Wait, hold on," Talia said, sitting up on the blanket. "You're writing again? Actually writing? Why are we just hearing about this now?"
"It's just—" I looked at the fire. "I spent three months staring at a blank screen before this trip. Three months of nothing. And people loved the last book — I mean really loved it — but when you can't write a single word for three months, you start thinking, what if that's it? What if I had one good book in me and I already used it? What if everything after that is just me trying to sound like the person who wrote the first one?"
The band played something low and wandering. I hadn't planned to say any of that, and the rum was only partly to blame.
"I've started something new here," I said, and the words kept coming even though the smart move was to stop. "And it feels different than anything I've written before, and I don't know if different means good or if it just means I'm lost in a new direction instead of the old one. I don't know what it is yet. I don't know if it's anything."
The fire crackled and nobody rushed to fill the space after it.
I hadn't looked at Renee while I'd said any of it. Something in me knew that if I looked at her while talking about the writing, I'd see something in her face that I wasn't ready to see. Not yet. Not here.
But Renee was the one who spoke first.
"That doesn't sound like someone who has nothing to say." Her voice was quiet and unhurried. "That sounds like someone who knows exactly what she wants to say and is scared of what happens if she actually says it."
The group went still. A collective settling, like everyone had exhaled at the same time without planning to.
I looked at Renee. She looked back. Her expression was steady — she'd said what she meant and wasn't going to qualify it or walk it back or add a joke to make it easier to digest.
"Maybe," I said.
Renee held my gaze for another beat, and then she looked back at the fire, and the moment released its grip on the evening and let it breathe again.
Milo, bless him, broke the silence by turning toward the band and shouting a request that none of us were prepared for.
"Do you guys know 'Steal My Sunshine' by Len?"
The guitarist looked at the bass player. The bass player shrugged.
"By who?" Talia asked.
"Len. The band is called Len."
"That's not a band name, that's somebody's uncle," Talia said, already looking at the rest of us for backup.
"It's a real band," Milo insisted, straightening in his chair. "They had a huge song in the nineties."
"You just made that up," I said, grateful for the pivot and not caring if it showed. "You made up a band called Len and a song called 'Steal My Sunshine' and you're hoping nobody here is old enough to fact-check you."
"It was on every radio station in 1999!" Milo threw his hands up, nearly launching his drink into the sand.
"Milo, I was alive in 1999 and I have never once heard of a band called Len," Talia said.
"You were also seven."
"I had taste at seven," Talia said, crossing her arms on the blanket.
"It's real," Nico said quietly, and every head turned. "My older sister used to play it in the car. It's a real song."
Milo pointed at Nico with the vindication of a man who had just been acquitted of all charges. "Thank you. Thank you."
"Nico confirming it doesn't mean it's good," Cass said.
"Nico confirming it means I'm not a liar, which is all I needed tonight."
The band, who had clearly never heard of Len either, launched into something else entirely, and the night moved forward.
"I can't believe they didn't know it," Milo said, still staring at the band with the wounded expression of a man whose cultural contribution had been publicly rejected. "It was a number one hit."
"Was it though?" I asked, not even trying to hide the doubt.
"It was top five. Top ten at minimum. The point is it existed and they should know it."
"Milo, they're a resort cover band," Renee said. "They know 'Wonderwall' and 'Hotel California' and whatever people request at weddings."
"'Steal My Sunshine' gets requested at weddings."
"It absolutely does not," Talia said, looking at him with genuine pity.
"It would if people had taste."
"You could always sing it yourself," Cass offered. "Give the people what they want."
"Don't tempt me, Cassandra. I have been told I have a lovely singing voice."
"By who?" I asked, already regretting the question.
"By me. I told myself. In the shower. And I was very convincing."
"That tracks," Renee said, taking a sip of her drink.
"What's that supposed to mean?"
"It means you're your own biggest fan, Milo," I said, nudging his arm with my elbow. "And honestly, that's not the worst quality in a person."
"Thank you, Ade. At least someone here appreciates me."
"I said it wasn't the worst quality. That's not the same as appreciation."
Talia laughed and leaned back against Cass on the blanket. Cass's arm came around her without thinking about it, pulling her closer, and for a moment they just sat like that — Talia tucked against her wife in the firelight, easy and unhurried about it. Talia turned her head and kissed Cass softly, and Cass kissed her back like it was nothing, like it was just what you did when the person you loved was right there and the fire was warm and the night was good.
My eyes went to the fire, to my hands, to everywhere except Renee.
A few minutes later, Cass shifted on the blanket and stood up, brushing sand off her legs.
"Be right back," she said to Talia, squeezing her shoulder once before heading up the path.
I watched her go — and maybe I was the only one who noticed, but she stopped near the band's platform between songs, leaned toward the guitarist, said something brief, and then kept walking.
"I think the band might actually be four session musicians who've never met," Milo said, watching them fumble through the start of a new song. "I think Emmett just hired them individually and hoped for the best."
"That would explain a lot," Talia said, tilting her coconut shell toward the platform.
"They're fine," Renee said, though her expression was doing the opposite of selling it.
"'Fine' is the most devastating thing you can say about a musician," Milo said, wincing like he'd been personally insulted.
"Maybe they're called Len," I said, and Milo pointed at me with deep appreciation.
"See? She gets it."
Cass reappeared and settled back onto the blanket next to Talia without a word. Talia gave her a look. Cass gave her nothing back.
And then the band finished a song and the guitarist leaned into his mic.
"This next one is a special dedication," the guitarist said. "From Cass — to Talia."
Talia's head turned so fast I thought she might have injured something. "What?"
Cass was sitting beside her on the blanket, expression so precisely, aggressively neutral that it could only mean she'd been planning this for a while.
"Did you—"
"Emmett said they were taking requests," Cass said. "So I made a request."
The opening notes of "You and Me" by Lifehouse drifted across the beach, and Talia's face did something I'd never seen it do before. She went completely still. Her eyes were bright, and for a second the woman who always had a response didn't have one.
"Tal," Cass said, standing. She held out her hand. But the way she looked at Talia while she did it — like they were the only two people on this beach, like the fire and the music and the rest of us had been arranged specifically so she could stand up and offer this woman her hand — that was the thing.
Talia took it. She stood without saying a word, which might have been a first, and let Cass lead her toward the open stretch of sand where a few other couples had already started swaying to the music.
I watched them. Cass's arms around Talia's waist, Talia's forehead against Cass's shoulder, both of them moving slowly and without any of the self-consciousness that usually comes with dancing in public on a beach. They'd been together eight years and married for five and they danced like people who had found the one thing that made sense and were smart enough to hold onto it.
Renee was watching too. I could see her in my peripheral vision, her face lit by the fire, her expression open in a way that she usually kept under better management.
"What?" I asked, because she was smiling and I wanted to know why.
She turned to me. The smile didn't change. It just stayed there, warm and unguarded and directed at me.
"Nothing," Renee said softly, still smiling.
The song played. The couples danced. Milo had gone quiet, watching Talia and Cass with the particular tenderness of someone whose own want was very close to the surface. Beside him, Nico was watching the fire — but every now and then his gaze drifted toward Milo, and he didn't seem in any hurry to pull it back.
The water beyond the fire was dark and still. The sky above it had that dense, star-thick quality you only see when you're far enough from a city to remember it looks like that. I turned the coconut shell in my hands and said nothing.
"Do you want to take a walk?" Renee asked, as casually as if she were asking me to pass the salt.
"Yeah," I said. "I do."
We stood up and drifted toward the path. Milo noticed — his eyes tracked us for a second, and something crossed his face that was equal parts knowing and kind — but he didn't say anything.
The path away from the bonfire curved along the edge of the water, tiki torches thinning out until the only light was the moon and the distant glow of the fire behind us. The music faded to something you could feel more than hear, a vibration in the sand under your feet. The air was warm and held that particular quality of late tropical evenings where time stops pretending to be in a rush.
We walked. Not fast, not slow. Side by side, close enough that our arms brushed once and neither of us adjusted the distance.
"Cass surprised me tonight," I said, because someone had to start and the silence, while comfortable, was starting to develop its own gravity.
"She's full of surprises. You'd never guess it because she leads with all that composure, but she pays attention. More than anyone I've met."
"You two talked today?"
"At the pool. She's easy to be around. You can just sit with her and not have to fill every second with conversation."
"High praise from you."
Renee glanced at me sideways. "What's that supposed to mean?"
"It means you don't seem like the kind of person to hand out 'easy to be around' to just anyone."
She laughed. Brief and unguarded, and her shoulders dropped with it. "That's fair. I'm told my vetting process is extensive."
"I'm pretty sure I failed the first three rounds."
"You definitely failed the first three rounds."
We walked a little further. The fire behind us had shrunk to a bright point, the sound of the band just a suggestion carried on the breeze. Ahead of us was dark sand and darker water and the patient sound of waves deciding where to stop.
"Can I ask you something?" I said, bumping her shoulder with mine as we walked.
"You're going to anyway."
"Why physical therapy?" I paused. "And I know what you told me before — the patients, the work, the sitting with people. I mean the actual reason. The one underneath that."
Renee was quiet for long enough that I thought she might not answer. We kept walking. The sand was cool under my sandals.
"My mom had a bad knee," she said finally. "Before she got sick — this was years ago, I was in college. She tore her ACL doing something mundane, I think she was carrying groceries and stepped wrong. And the PT she worked with was this woman named Diana who was — I don't know how to describe it. She wasn't warm in the way you'd expect. She wasn't gentle with my mom. She'd say 'this is going to hurt and you're going to want to stop and I'm not going to let you.' And my mom, who argued with everyone about everything, was never able to argue with Diana."
Renee looked at the water. "I watched my mom get something back that she thought she'd lost. Not just the knee. Something about herself — the confidence that her body would do what she asked it to. And I thought, that's what I want to do. Not the medical part, necessarily. The part where you help someone trust themselves again."
I didn't say anything for a moment, because anything I said was going to be less than what she'd just given me.
"That's a good reason," I said quietly, still walking.
"It's the real one." She paused. "What about you? The writing. Not the publishing, not the career — what does it actually do for you? When it works?"
I thought about it. Not the practiced answer, not the interview version, not even the Sasha version. The real one.
"It makes me less alone," I said, and the words surprised me even as they came out. "I know what people see when they look at my books — the covers, the genre, whatever. And that's fine, I'm not precious about it. But underneath all that, underneath the heat and the plot and the things I assembled for people to consume, I'm just trying to write two people who actually see each other. Two people in a room being real with each other, and neither of them is pretending. And someone, someday, is going to read it and think, yeah, that's what it feels like. And for that one second, we're not strangers."
The waves were the only sound for a moment.
"You sell yourself short, you know that?" Renee said, looking at me like she was stating something obvious I'd somehow missed.
We'd stopped walking without deciding to. The path had curved into a small cove that I hadn't seen before — a stretch of sand sheltered by rocks on one side, the water closer here, the moonlight making the wet sand look like something you weren't supposed to walk on.
"Can I tell you something?" Renee said, turning to face me.
"Depends on what it is."
"When I met you at the airport — when you came around that corner with your luggage and your attitude and that look on your face like the world owed you an apology—"
"It did owe me an apology."
"—I thought, this is the most exhausting person I have ever encountered. And I have dealt with patients who fake their way through physical therapy."
I smiled despite myself. "That's touching."
"And then on the plane, when you were trying to write — slamming the keys like the laptop had personally wronged you — I watched you delete everything you'd written and close the laptop and I thought, she's miserable. Not annoyed-miserable. Actually miserable. And I didn't know what to do with that because I'd already decided you were just difficult."
"I am difficult."
"You're difficult," Renee agreed, and the way she said it made it sound like something she'd made peace with a while ago. "But that's not all you are. And it took me embarrassingly long to figure that out."
We were standing close. Not touching, but close in a way that felt deliberate — like the distance between us was something we were both choosing to maintain and both choosing to notice.
"You want to know what I thought when I met you?" I said, holding her gaze.
"I'm not sure I do."
"I thought you were the most controlled person I'd ever seen. Every word measured, every reaction managed. And I thought — who does that? Who walks through the world that carefully all the time? And then at the railing that first night, when you said 'that's a shame' and walked away—"
"You're still thinking about that?"
"I'm still thinking about that. Because that wasn't controlled. That was you saying something you actually meant and leaving before you could take it back. And that was the first time I thought maybe the control wasn't the whole story."
Renee was looking at me with an expression I couldn't read — or maybe I could read it and I just wasn't ready to say what it said. The moonlight was doing something to her face that the fire hadn't done, something that stripped away every excuse I'd been making not to stare, and I stopped trying.
"What changed?" I asked, and my voice was quieter than I expected. "Between us. Something changed and I don't know when it happened."
"I don't think it was one thing," Renee said. "I think it was a lot of small things. The kayak. The reef. The way you talk to Milo — like he matters, not like he's entertainment. The way you sat on that boat and cried and didn't try to explain it."
"You noticed that."
"I noticed everything." She said it simply, without weight, like she was reading a fact off a list. "I tried not to. It didn't work."
The space between us had gotten smaller. I hadn't moved and she hadn't moved and somehow there was less air between us than there had been thirty seconds ago, which meant either the beach was shrinking or one of us was a liar about not having moved.
"Renee."
"What?"
"I don't know what I'm doing."
"Neither do I."
And then she leaned in, slow enough that I could have stopped her and fast enough that I didn't want to, and we met somewhere in the middle — in the space that had been narrowing for days. Her mouth was warm and she tasted like whatever she'd been drinking — something with lime, something clean — and her hand came up to the side of my face and it wasn't careful. It wasn't measured or controlled or any of the things Renee usually was. It was just her, kissing me, and my brain did the only sensible thing it had done in months and shut the hell up.
I pulled back. Not away — just enough to see her face, to look at her, to make sure this was real and not something the rum and the moonlight and the fire had conspired to invent. Her eyes were dark and steady and looking right at me, and whatever she saw in my expression made her smile — wide and unmanaged and warm and aimed entirely at me.
This is real, I thought. This is actually happening.
I leaned back in. Slower this time. On purpose. With my eyes open until the last possible second, because I wanted to see her — wanted to see the moment she stopped being careful, the moment the last wall came down, the moment Renee Miller stopped deciding and just let something happen.
She met me halfway.
Less surprise, more certainty. Her hand slid from my face to the back of my neck and I felt myself step closer, closing whatever distance was left between us, and the sound of the waves was still there and the music from the bonfire was still there but none of it was as loud as this.

I woke up at 4:47am. I know this because the clock on the nightstand was glowing at me like an accusation, and my brain, for reasons it declined to explain, decided this was important.
I'd slept. Technically. An hour here, forty minutes there, each stretch ending with me surfacing into the dark bungalow, my mind still turning like the ceiling fan over my head, replaying the evening on a loop I couldn't shut off.
The kiss was right there, available for replay at any moment, and my brain had helpfully confirmed this several times across the night. But it was everything around the kiss that kept pulling me back — the walk back along the path, torches thinning out behind us, the bonfire music turning into something you felt more than heard. Renee's arm brushing mine and neither of us adjusting. The way the conversation had gone quiet without going awkward, which was a thing I didn't know we were capable of.
At some point, her hand had found mine. Or mine had found hers. The order of operations was unclear and I'd replayed it enough times that my memory had started editing for narrative effect, which was professionally useful and personally annoying. What I did know: it happened. Fingers lacing together, easy, like we'd done it before. The path was dark enough that it felt private even though it wasn't, and neither of us said anything about it, which made it feel more real than a conversation would have.
My bungalow came first, and we'd stopped at the door. There was a moment where the air shifted and I thought about the last time we'd stood in this exact spot, the goodnight that had felt like the start of something that never quite started. But this was different. There was nothing unresolved about the way she was looking at me. Nothing careful.
"Goodnight, Ade."
She'd said it simply. Smiling. Not the careful Renee smile — the real one, the one that showed up when she forgot to manage it.
"Goodnight."
And she'd kept walking. I'd listened to her footsteps on the path for a few seconds longer than I needed to, then gone inside, closed the door, leaned against it, and said "fuck" to my empty bungalow with a level of feeling that the word had probably never been asked to carry before.
I rolled over. Rolled back. Stared at the ceiling fan. Counted the rotations. Lost count. Started again. My body was done. Fully, completely done — hours of bonfire, a kiss on a beach, a walk home in the dark with Renee's hand in mine, and my brain doing the only useful thing it had managed all day, which was absolutely nothing.
And underneath the exhaustion, something else. A pull. Low and steady, nothing like the anxious static that preceded every failed attempt at the desk — this felt like a frequency I'd been trying to tune into for months and had finally landed on by accident. I recognized it because I'd felt it once before — the night I'd written the first chapter of My Husband, My Bride in one sitting and known, with the specific, irrational certainty that writers pretend doesn't exist, that it was good.
I sat up. Looked at the desk. The laptop was right where I'd left it before the bonfire, closed and dark and waiting.
I could sleep. I could lie here and count ceiling fan rotations and let whatever was pulling at me settle into something I could examine in the morning, at a reasonable hour, like a person who had their shit together.
I got out of bed, grabbed the laptop, and brought it back with me. Propped the pillows against the headboard, pulled the covers over my legs, opened the screen. The glow lit up the dark bungalow and I started typing without deciding what I was going to write, which is either the best or worst way to begin anything.
Nora came out first. Just like last time — already formed, already certain, arriving on the page like she'd been waiting in the wings for me to stop pretending I didn't know exactly who she was. I wrote her on a beach at night. I wrote the water dark and the sand still warm from the day. I wrote someone standing next to her — the one she'd been circling for chapters, who talked too fast and deflected too well and gripped her coffee cup like it was the only thing keeping her upright.
I wrote the kiss.
Nora hadn't planned it. That was the thing she kept coming back to, standing in the kitchen of her apartment three weeks later with a mug of tea going cold in her hand — she hadn't planned any of it. The beach had been a last resort, a nowhere to go when everywhere felt too loud, and Alison had followed her without asking if she should, which was either presumptuous or exactly right. She'd come straight from somewhere — still in the slim trousers and open-collared shirt she sometimes wore when she was being Alistair instead of Alison, the version of herself that stood differently and spoke half an octave lower and made Nora's brain do something inconvenient. They'd stood at the water's edge and talked about nothing that mattered and everything that did, and at some point the talking had stopped and the silence had been a dare that neither of them had the sense to walk away from.
When Alison kissed her, it tasted like salt air and the cheap wine they'd been drinking all evening, and Nora's hand had come up to her jaw on instinct — not gently, not carefully, just the way you reach for something you've been pretending you don't want. Alison made a sound against her mouth that Nora was going to hear in every quiet room for the rest of her life, and the ocean kept doing what it was doing, completely indifferent to the fact that Nora's entire understanding of her own week had just been revised.
I stopped typing. Read it back.
It was — yeah. It was good. It was specific in the way that made sentences stick, the details sharp enough to cut. It was also, unmistakably, the cove.
Something flickered at the edge of it — the salt air, the indifferent ocean, how close it all sat to a night I'd actually lived. But the writing was good, and good writing always comes from somewhere. That's what writers do. We take what moves us and we make something out of it. It's called inspiration.
I kept typing.
The pages were alive. The sentences were moving. The thing that had been locked inside me for months was pouring out, and I wasn't going to stop and ask why the lock had finally opened. Not now. Not with the words still coming.
I wrote Nora at work. A patient who couldn't straighten her arm past ninety degrees, who'd been told by three doctors that it was as good as it was going to get. Nora who didn't accept that, not with argument, but with patience — the boring, repetitive, undramatic kind of patience that nobody writes about because it doesn't make good copy. Two degrees of motion gained over six weeks. The patient crying in the parking lot afterward, not from pain but from the shock of being proven wrong about her own limits.
I wrote Alison watching Nora through the glass door of the clinic, seeing her kneel beside the treatment table with her hand on the patient's shoulder, saying something too quiet to hear. The way it made Alison feel — not jealous, not left out. Something else. Something that had no business being this complicated at nine in the morning while holding a latte she'd bought as an excuse to walk past the clinic on her way to absolutely nowhere.
The light changed. I looked up and the sky through the window had shifted from black to a deep, bruised blue that meant dawn was coming whether I was ready for it or not. I checked the clock. Ten past six. I'd been writing for over an hour.
I scrolled back to the beginning and read the whole thing through. Nora was good. Better than anything I'd written in months. The details were sharp, the scenes breathed, and the pages hadn't fought me for a single one of them.
I closed the laptop and got out of bed.
The shower was hot and I stood in it longer than I needed to, letting the water relax every part of me. By the time I got out, the sky was fully light — pale blue with the kind of early-morning clarity that would burn off into humidity by ten. I dried my hair, which was going to do whatever it wanted regardless, and took less time getting ready than I expected — makeup, earrings, a sundress I didn't have to think twice about.
The morning was already warm. Five days at this resort and I'd stopped noticing the landscaping, stopped reading the little signs along the path that pointed toward the spa and the activity pavilion and the beach access. I knew where I was going without checking, which wasn't something that usually happened to me this fast.
The table was full when I got there. Talia was mid-sentence about something, gesturing with a piece of toast. Cass had coffee and the particular expression she wore when Talia was being Talia.
Renee was sitting on the far side of the table, in a white tank top, hair still damp, cup of coffee halfway to her mouth. She looked up when I walked in and smiled — easy, unhurried, like she'd been waiting without minding the wait.
"Morning," Renee said.
"Morning," I managed, and was aware that the word came out slightly differently than it usually did. Talia noticed. She smiled into her coffee and let it go, which might have been a first.
"You're late," Talia said, pointing her toast at me like it was an accusation.
"I lost track of time."
"You lost track of time," Talia repeated, looking at Renee with the subtlety of a woman who had never once in her life been accused of subtlety. "Interesting."
"I was writing," I said, which was true and also the least interesting version of the truth available.
"She was writing," Cass echoed, to no one in particular, and picked up her coffee.
I went to the buffet, which had nothing to do with being hungry and everything to do with needing sixty seconds where nobody was watching my face. I came back with a full plate and the renewed composure I'd purchased by spending an unreasonable amount of time pretending to choose between croissants. I sat down next to Renee. Her knee was close enough to mine under the table that I could feel the warmth without actual contact, and I didn't move away, and she didn't move away, and we both pretended that we weren't both very aware of the distance between "almost touching" and "touching."
By the time I'd started eating, I'd gotten a better read on the table dynamics. Talia was already dialed up to her default setting. Cass was serene. Renee was present, easy, comfortable in a way that felt new and also exactly right.
And then there was Milo.
Milo was sitting very still, which was the first sign that something cataclysmic had happened. Milo did not sit still. Milo existed in a state of perpetual motion — hands, face, posture, all of it running at a frequency that made hummingbirds look lethargic. But right now he was sitting in his chair with both hands wrapped around his coffee cup, staring at a fixed point somewhere between the salt shaker and infinity, with an expression that I could only describe as post-religious.
"Okay," I said, looking at him over my coffee. "What happened to you?"
The table went quiet in a way that told me this question had been asked before, possibly multiple times, and that the answers had been insufficient.
"He won't give us details," Talia said, with the wounded tone of someone who had been personally denied.
"I gave you details," Milo said, still staring at the salt shaker. "I gave you the relevant details."
"You said 'it happened' and then you sat there like that for ten minutes."
"Those are the relevant details. It happened. That's the detail."
I looked at Renee. She was watching Milo with a particular expression that said she already had a working theory and was waiting to see how long it took everyone else to catch up.
"What happened?" I asked, already regretting it based on the look on his face.
Milo finally looked at me. His eyes were glassy and he clearly had no language for whatever had happened to him. He set his coffee down with great care, like a diplomat about to make a statement to the press.
"After the bonfire," Milo began, in a tone of measured calm that he had clearly been rehearsing. "After everyone left. Nico and I stayed. We talked for a while. And then — and I want to be clear that this was a mutual, organic, adult decision—"
"Oh my God," Talia said, grabbing Cass's arm like she needed physical support.
"—we went back to my bungalow. And we — we spent time together."
"Spent time together," Cass repeated, setting her coffee down like she was going to need both hands free for this.
"Quality time."
"He slept with Nico," I said, cutting through the euphemisms with a knife that was long overdue.
"Ade!"
"What? You were going to circle this for another twenty minutes. I'm saving us all time."
Milo's composure collapsed like a building that had been condemned and was only waiting for someone to sneeze near the foundation. His face went red, which he clearly wanted to be from outrage but was obviously something else entirely, and the grin he'd been fighting broke through despite his best efforts to look scandalized.
"Ade, I am trying to be dignified about this—"
"Dignified?" Talia looked at Cass. "Was this before or after he sat down and forgot how to blink?"
"Before," Cass said. "He blinked once. I noted it."
"I am blinking a normal amount—"
"You were buffering," Renee said. "Like a video on bad Wi-Fi."
"I was not buffering—"
"You were absolutely buffering," Talia said, and the fact that the whole table was piling on at once seemed to short-circuit whatever rehearsed dignity Milo had left.
"Okay. Okay. Fine. We had sex. There. Are you happy? Nico and I had sex!"
"No," Talia said.
"Absolutely not," I agreed, pulling my plate closer like I was settling in for a show.
"Not a chance," Cass added, making the jury unanimous.
Milo looked around the table, searching for a single ally. Renee smiled at him — warm, unhelpful, thoroughly entertained. He rolled his eyes.
"So... how was it?" I asked, grinning at him over my coffee.
Milo took a breath, and whatever restraint he'd been clinging to went with it. "After the bonfire wound down, we stayed. Just sitting there, the fire going out. And he wasn't doing the Nico thing, you know? The quiet, behind-the-bar thing. He was just talking. He told me about his family back home, about why he came to the island."
He paused, looking down at his coffee cup like the next part required a running start.
"And then he walked me back to my bungalow, and at my door he stopped and looked at me and said, 'Tonight was good.' That's it. Three words. The man gave me three words and I almost passed out."
Talia made a sound that was not entirely human.
"And I said — God, this is embarrassing — I said, 'Just good?' Like I was fishing for a compliment. At my own door. At midnight. Like an absolute disaster of a person. And then... he just... kissed me."
The table collectively held its breath for a beat.
"And then what?" Talia asked.
"And then..." Milo paused. He was trying, genuinely trying, to maintain some boundary between what was his and what was the table's. It lasted about four seconds. "He's — okay. You know how he is behind the bar? That thing where every movement is exactly where it needs to be, nothing wasted, nothing rushed?"
"Please don't finish that sentence," Cass said, closing her eyes like she could physically block it from arriving.
"It's the same," Milo said, finishing that sentence. "It's exactly the same. The man is — he has a focus, is what I'm saying. A specificity of attention. An intentionality—"
"He's using SAT words to describe sex," Renee said to me, barely above a murmur.
Milo trailed off. The SAT words ran out, and what was left on his face wasn't funny anymore.
"He stayed," Milo said, quieter now. "I woke up this morning and he was still there. He didn't have to — his shift starts early, he could have left. But he was just... there. Next to me. Awake. Like leaving wasn't something he'd considered."
The table went quiet for a second. Because underneath all the comedy and the SAT words, that was real. Milo had spent days watching a man who spoke in two-word sentences and almost-smiles, reading every micro-expression like it was scripture, and they'd ended up in the same bed and Nico had stayed. That was the thing. Everything else was furniture.
Talia reached over and squeezed his hand. She didn't say anything. Didn't need to.
"So what happens now?" Cass asked, practical as always.
"What do you mean, what happens now?"
"You're still leaving. He lives here. What happens now?"
The word leaving landed on the table like a stone dropped into a still pond. I felt Renee's knee shift a millimeter closer to mine, or maybe I imagined it.
"I don't know," Milo said. "I don't — I haven't figured that part out. I was going to figure it out after I finished processing the part where I woke up and he was still there. He didn't have to stay. He had a shift. He stayed anyway, which means—"
"It means he pays attention," Renee said. Simply. Like a fact.
"He pays attention," Milo echoed, quieter, like he was hearing it properly for the first time.
I looked at Renee. She was already looking at me. And for half a second, neither of us looked away — not in a dramatic, loaded way, just in the way of two people who were both sitting at a table hearing someone talk about what happens when a person pays attention to you, and who both knew, without discussing it, that they were sitting in the same conversation from the other side.
Talia, because she was Talia, chose this moment to speak.
"So," she said, turning to me and Renee with the expression of a woman who had been exercising truly heroic restraint and whose heroism was now at an end. "How was the walk last night?"
"Nice," I said.
"Nice," Renee confirmed.
"Nice," Talia repeated, flat as a pancake. She looked at Cass. "Nice."
"I heard them."
"They went for a walk on a moonlit beach and the adjective they've come back with is nice."
"It was a nice walk," I said. "We walked. On the beach. It was nice. What do you want, a weather report?"
Talia opened her mouth, and Cass put a hand on her arm without even looking, the practiced reflex of a woman who had been intercepting Talia's worst impulses for eight years.
"Leave them alone," Cass said.
"I'm just—"
"You're just leaving them alone."
Talia sat back in her chair with an expression of tremendous, theatrical suffering. But she left it alone. For now. The "for now" was doing about forty pounds of lifting in her silence, and everyone at the table could hear it.
Breakfast continued. Or it would have, if Lyle hadn't appeared.
He materialized at the edge of the table the way he always did — like he'd been standing nearby for several minutes waiting for a gap in the conversation that he'd finally decided wasn't coming.
"Good morning, everyone. I hope the evening's festivities were enjoyable and that everyone is feeling rested and hydrated." He was holding a clipboard. Lyle always had a clipboard. "I wanted to share some of today's scheduled programming, in case any guests at the table might be interested in participating in one or more of the available activities."
"Hit us," Talia said.
"So the first option is a pottery workshop, which will be held in the arts pavilion — that's the covered structure adjacent to the garden path, for anyone who hasn't yet had the opportunity to locate it. The workshop runs from ten to twelve and all materials are provided, so there's no need for participants to bring anything other than themselves and a willingness to engage with clay in a hands-on capacity."
"A willingness to engage with clay in a hands-on capacity," Cass repeated.
"There's also guided kayaking along the western coastline, departing from the main beach at eleven, for any guests who might enjoy exploring some of the smaller coves around the island from the water."
"And finally, there's a group aqua aerobics session at nine-thirty in the main pool. It's instructor-led, set to music, and suitable for all fitness levels."
"No," Cass said.
"It's very popular with—"
"No."
Lyle blinked, recalibrated, and smiled. "Of course. If anyone changes their mind, the sign-up sheet is at the front desk. Have a wonderful day." He moved on to the next table with the steady determination of a man who had never once been discouraged by a flat rejection.
"We should do the kayaking," Milo announced, apparently fully recovered from his emotional disclosure. "But skip the guided part and go further — there's supposed to be a waterfall on the other side of the island you can swim under."
"Yes," Talia said immediately.
"I'll be at the pool," Cass said, as if this had been decided long before the conversation started.
"Cass, there's a waterfall."
"And there's a pool."
"I want to swim," Renee said.
I poured another cup of coffee and my phone buzzed in the pocket of my dress.
Then buzzed again.
Then four more times in quick succession, which meant either there was an earthquake somewhere or Sasha had woken up.
I pulled the phone out under the table and tilted the screen toward me.
Sasha: You alive?
Sasha: Hello
Sasha: If you're dead I'm going to be really annoyed because I have news about my landlord's new girlfriend and it's UNHINGED
Sasha: You're ignoring me which means you're either asleep or something interesting is happening
Sasha: It's interesting isn't it
Sasha: ADRIANNA MOORE
Sasha: I KNOW YOU'RE AWAKE
I bit the inside of my cheek. Seven messages. The escalation pattern was textbook Sasha — casual concern, mild irritation, gossip bribe, accurate read, capitalized threat. She'd gone from "you alive?" to full caps, which was actually restrained for her.
I started typing.
Me: I'm alive. Sorry. Bonfire ran late.
Three dots appeared instantly. She'd been waiting.
Sasha: The bonfire ran late
Sasha: The bonfire
Sasha: Ran late
Me: Yes. There was a bonfire. It ran late. That is a complete and accurate summary of the evening.
Sasha: Babe you have never in your life stayed late at a group event voluntarily. you once left a birthday party during the cake because you said "the social contract has been fulfilled"
That was true and I didn't appreciate being reminded.
Me: It was a nice bonfire. Good music. Rum punch. Fire. You know. Bonfire things.
Sasha: You just used "nice" to describe something which means you're actively concealing information
Sasha: Was renee there
I looked up from the phone. Renee was talking to Cass about something — a restaurant, maybe, or a place to swim. Her profile was catching the morning light and her hair was still damp from whatever she'd done before breakfast, and she was gesturing with her coffee cup in a way that was so characteristically unhurried and precise that I had to look back down at my phone before my face did something that the table would notice.
Me: Yes.
Sasha: AND?
Me: And what? She was at the bonfire. Other people were also at the bonfire. It was a group event.
Sasha: I need you to understand that I can tell you're lying through a screen from thousands of miles away
Sasha: What happened with renee
Me: Nothing happened. We hung out. With the group. At the bonfire. Which I already told you about.
Sasha: Ade
Sasha: You went from "she's different than I thought" to radio silence
Sasha: Something happened
I glanced up. Talia and Milo were in a debate about whether pottery counted as a legitimate vacation activity or was "something people do when they've given up." Cass was refereeing. Renee was watching the argument with visible amusement and hadn't looked at my phone.
Me: We maybe went for a walk.
Sasha: A WALK
Me: After the bonfire. Just the two of us. On the beach.
The three dots appeared, disappeared, appeared again.
Sasha: Adrianna Moore went for a moonlit beach walk with Renee Miller
Sasha: Willingly
Sasha: Just the two of you
Sasha: I am losing my mind right now
Me: It was just a walk.
Sasha: It was not just a walk
Sasha: You don't take walks. you don't even like walking. you took a cab to the grocery store that one time and it was three blocks away
Me: That was raining.
Sasha: IT WAS DRIZZLING
Sasha: Did you kiss her
I stared at the screen. The cursor blinked in the text field, empty and waiting. I could lie. I could deflect. I could type "lol no" and change the subject to Sasha's landlord's girlfriend and spend the rest of breakfast talking about someone else's drama.
"Everything okay?"
Renee's voice, next to me. Quiet enough that it was just for me.
I looked up. She'd noticed. Of course she'd noticed — she noticed everything, that was the whole problem and the whole point. Her eyes moved to the phone in my hand and back to my face, and there was no accusation in the look, just a question.
"Yeah," I said. "Sasha's being Sasha."
Renee smiled — amused by something she'd decided not to comment on. She turned back to the table and left me to it.
I looked back at the phone.
Me: Yeah.
Sasha: YEAH?
Sasha: YEAH AS IN YES?
Sasha: YOU KISSED HER???
Me: She kissed me. Technically. I mean I also kissed her. It was mutual. There was kissing. On a beach.
Sasha: I'M GOING TO PASS OUT
Sasha: ADRIANNA
Sasha: MY GIRL
Sasha: ON A BEACH?????
Me: On a beach.
Sasha: I need details. I need every single detail. I need lighting conditions and who leaned in first and what her mouth tasted like
Me: I'm at breakfast. She's sitting right next to me.
There was a long pause. Longer than any pause Sasha had ever taken in the history of our friendship.
Sasha: She's right there
Me: Right here.
Sasha: And you're texting me about it while she's RIGHT THERE
Sasha: You absolute disaster of a human being
Sasha: I love you so much
Me: I know.
Sasha: So what now?
And there it was. The question I'd been stepping around all morning — through the writing, through the shower, through the walk to breakfast, through the ease of sitting next to Renee and feeling her knee almost-touching mine and pretending that proximity was the same as having an answer.
Sasha: You leave Saturday right
Me: Yeah.
Sasha: And then what
I looked up from the phone. Renee was laughing at something Milo had said — really laughing, the kind that changed her whole face, that she didn't try to catch or control. Milo was glowing from making her laugh, which was making Talia glow from watching Milo glow, which was making Cass look faintly alarmed by the amount of glowing happening at her breakfast table.
Sasha: Ade?
Me: I don't know.
Sasha: Do you like her?
I watched Renee. The laugh was settling into a smile that hadn't fully gone away, the kind that sticks around because the person wearing it has forgotten they're wearing it. She turned her head slightly — not toward me, just shifting — and the morning light caught her profile and I felt something so simple and so clear that it made every SAT word Milo had used and every complicated thought I'd had at 4am and every page of Nora I'd written feel like the long way around to an answer that had been sitting right there, in the chair next to mine, for days.
Me: Yeah. I like her.

Authors Note: Quick heads up before you dive in: next week’s posting is going to be a little off. I’m heading out on my yearly vacation, which means a full week away, and I won’t be back until Sunday next week. That means I’ll miss our usual Friday update, and I feel genuinely terrible about it.
But I’m making it up to you. The very next day, Monday, Chapter 20 goes up. Then that same Friday, right on schedule, you’ll get Chapter 21. Two chapters in one week. Consider it my apology gift for abandoning you for the mountains and the cold weather.
I thought about doing a blog post about this, but not everyone reads those, and I wanted to make sure everyone following along actually saw it. So here it is, tucked right where you’ll find it.
Thank you for your patience, and for reading. See you once I’ve thawed out.
I was still looking at the screen, at the four words I'd just typed sitting there in the text field like a confession I'd accidentally made in a crowded room. Which, technically, I had. Renee was three inches to my left. Milo was mid-sentence about something. Talia was laughing. And I was staring at my own text like it might rearrange itself into something less terrifying if I gave it enough time.
My phone buzzed.
Sasha: I am screenshotting this and framing it above my bed so that every morning when I wake up I remember that miracles are real
Me: Goodbye Sasha
Sasha: MUH GIRL GONNA GIT SUM
I bit the inside of my cheek, locked the phone, and shoved it into the pocket of my sundress with more force than the pocket was designed for.
"You okay?" Milo asked, watching me with the expression of someone who had just finished baring his entire romantic soul to a breakfast table and was now hyper-attuned to anyone else showing symptoms.
"Fine. Sasha's being dramatic."
"About what?" Talia's fork paused halfway to her mouth.
"About everything. Always. It's her core competency."
"That's avoidance," Milo said, pointing at me with a piece of pineapple. "I recognise avoidance. I'm a nurse."
"Those two things are not related."
"Close enough."
Renee reached for the coffee pot without looking up from her cup. "Let her have her phone in peace, Milo."
"I'm not interrogating her. I'm observing. I went to school for this."
Cass set her cup down. "Nobody at this table appreciates nuance. We are five adults on vacation who just spent breakfast extracting details about your sex life."
"That was collaborative," Milo said, straightening in his chair. "Which was emotionally generous of me."
"You were buffering," Talia said.
"We retired that word." Milo pointed at her. "I'm retiring that word."
"It's been retired for eight minutes," Renee said. "That's not long enough to stop being accurate."
The table laughed. Milo went full wounded gazelle, and I used the chaos to finish my coffee and let my pulse come back to something approaching normal. The phone sat in my pocket like a small bomb that had already gone off, and I was pretending the blast radius didn't extend to the woman sitting next to me, whose knee was still close enough to mine that I could feel the warmth of it through my dress.
"So what are we doing today?" Talia asked, aiming the question at the table like a general surveying available troops.
"How about that cooking class?" Milo perked up immediately. "The one with the chef — what's her name?"
"Donna," Talia said confidently.
"Diana," Cass corrected without looking up from her coffee.
"Right. Jerk seasoning, rum cake, the whole deal. It's this afternoon."
"I'm in," Milo said. "Absolutely. Done."
"You want to learn to cook or you want to bring Nico rum cake?" Talia asked.
"Those are not mutually exclusive goals."
Cass raised an eyebrow. "They are if you're involved in the cooking."
"I'll be at the cooking class," Talia said. "Cass?"
"Do I have a choice?"
Talia smiled. "You always have a choice."
"That's a no." Cass looked at Milo. "You're my witness."
"That's a loving no."
"What about the kayaking?" Milo said, gesturing vaguely toward the water. "We never actually decided on that."
"Not today," Renee said. "Cooking class is enough for one afternoon."
"Tomorrow, then. Waterfall, the whole expedition."
"Tomorrow works," Talia said.
Cass said nothing, which Talia interpreted as agreement and everyone else interpreted as surrender.
"Ade?"
I looked up from the table. "Hmm? Yeah. Both. Cooking class, kayaking, whatever."
Milo's eyes narrowed slightly, in the way they did when he was about to say something observational and I was going to wish he hadn't.
"You just agreed to two physical activities in under three seconds. Are you feeling alright?"
"I'm on vacation."
"You're on vacation," Milo repeated, looking at Renee. "She's on vacation."
"I heard her," Renee said, and reached for another piece of fruit without looking at me, but the edge of a smile was there. I could see it from where I was sitting, and I decided very firmly to stop cataloguing her expressions, effective immediately, starting right after this one.
Breakfast wound down. Talia was showing Cass something on her phone. Milo was stretching in his chair like a cat who'd found a sunbeam and intended to live in it permanently. Renee was still next to me, and at some point in the last few minutes her knee had moved from "almost touching" to "actually touching," and we'd both acknowledged this by completely ignoring it.
We pushed back from the table, gathering the scattered debris of a long breakfast — sunglasses, phones, Talia's backup sunscreen that she carried everywhere like a security blanket. The group started drifting toward the path, the plan roughly assembled: pool or beach for a few hours, cooking class at two, tomorrow was the waterfall.
"Adrianna?"
I turned. Alina was standing a few feet from the table, notebook tucked under one arm, a glass of something that looked like iced tea sweating in her hand. I hadn't noticed her during breakfast, which either meant she'd been discreet or I'd been distracted. Given the morning I'd had, both were equally plausible.
"Hey," I said.
"I don't want to interrupt your plans, but would you have a few minutes? I've been wanting to pick your brain about something."
The group was already walking. Milo had launched into something animated with Talia. Cass was following at the pace of someone conserving energy for later. Renee had paused a few steps ahead and looked back.
"Go ahead," Renee said, and it wasn't permission — just acknowledgment. She was going wherever the group was going. I was staying. That was fine.
"Save me a lounge chair," I said.
"No promises."
She turned and walked away, and I watched her go for exactly one second, which I justified as a perfectly reasonable amount of time to watch someone leave a restaurant, and then I turned back to Alina.
We settled at a table closer to the railing where the morning sun came through and made patterns on the wood. The breakfast crowd had thinned to a few stragglers. It was the kind of emptied-out morning space that felt like it belonged to whoever was still in it.
Alina set her iced tea down and opened her notebook to a page that already had something written on it, then closed it again — a reflex, I thought, more than an intention. The notebook was part of her the way my laptop was part of me, always within reach, always half-open.
"Nice morning," Alina said.
"It's been a lot of morning."
"Those are the interesting ones, usually."
"Or the exhausting ones."
"Same thing, in my experience."
She smiled and looked out past the railing for a second. "I've been the same, honestly. I keep sitting down to work on the piece and ending up staring at the same paragraph for an hour."
"That's not writing. That's a hostage situation."
"It is. The piece is evolving but I keep circling and I can't figure out what it wants to be."
"You're stuck."
"I'm not stuck. I have material. I have more material than I've had on any assignment in years. I just—" She turned her glass in her hands. "I keep writing around the thing instead of writing it. You know what that feels like?"
"I wrote around the same thing for months. I know exactly what that feels like."
"What changed?"
"I don't know. Something shifted. The writing started moving again and I don't totally understand what it is yet."
Alina nodded slowly. "See, that's what I keep coming back to. Not the resort. Not the inclusivity angle. It's the writing question."
"What writing question?"
"The one you're living in." She took a sip of her tea. "I cover travel. I interview a lot of people who are doing interesting things in interesting places. Most of them give me the version of themselves they've rehearsed. You're the first person I've met on assignment who I think is more interesting than the version she's offering."
I leaned back in my chair. "That's either a compliment or a very sophisticated way of calling me a liar."
"It's an observation. Writers are allowed to have observations."
"Writers are also allowed to decline being observed."
"They are. But they usually don't, because we're all narcissists who want someone else to tell us what we already know about ourselves."
I laughed. It came out before I could decide whether I wanted it to, which was annoying and also the first sign that this conversation was going to be more than shop talk.
"Okay," I said. "What's the writing question?"
"You write erotica," Alina said. "Successful erotica. Commercially successful. That's not easy to do."
"Thank you."
"But is it the genre you'd choose if you were starting from scratch today?"
The question sat on the table between us like a drink I hadn't ordered. It was a good question. And good questions were the ones that made you want to answer with the rehearsed version and hope nobody noticed.
"I chose erotica because I love writing about intimacy," I said. "It's not a consolation prize for people who can't write literary fiction. It's a form. It has its own discipline."
"I'm not diminishing it. I write travel pieces. People think I describe hotels for a living. I get the genre-respect problem."
"So what are you avoiding?" I asked.
Alina blinked. "Excuse me?"
"You said you keep writing around the thing instead of writing it. You have more material than you've ever had. But the piece won't come together. That sounds like someone who knows what the story is and doesn't want to write it."
She was quiet for a second. Then she smiled.
"Maybe," she said. "The travel stuff is comfortable. I'm good at it. I describe places and people and dynamics and I keep myself out of the frame entirely. That's the deal with travel writing — you're always the observer, never the observed."
"And?"
"And maybe the piece I can't write is the one where I'd have to be in the frame."
I looked at her. She looked back, pleasant and patient but less armored than she'd been two minutes ago.
"Welcome to the club," I said.
"It's a terrible club."
"The coffee's bad and nobody wants to be here."
"And yet."
"And yet."
We sat with that for a second. Two writers who were good at describing other people's truths and less good at sitting with their own.
"So what are you really asking me?" I said. "About the erotica, the genre, all of it."
"I'm asking whether the form is where you live or where you hide."
I leaned back in my chair and let the question sit for a second while I figured out how to respond to it.
"That's a big question for a Thursday morning."
"It's a big question for any morning. That doesn't mean it's wrong."
"I didn't say it was wrong. I said it was big."
"And you deflected."
"I didn't deflect, I contextualized."
"You contextualized by changing the subject to the day of the week. That's deflecting."
"It's stalling," I corrected. "Deflecting implies I have an answer I'm avoiding. Stalling implies I'm building one in real time. Give me credit."
Alina smiled. She seemed like she was genuinely enjoying this. "Fair. Take your time. I'll wait."
I looked out past the railing for a second.
"I think," I said slowly, "that writing bodies honestly is harder than people give it credit for. Most people write sex like choreography — tab A, slot B, everyone finishes at the same time, nobody has an awkward elbow situation. Writing it like it actually feels, the mess and the vulnerability and the way people say stupid things at exactly the wrong moment — that's not hiding. That's exposure."
"Agreed. But it's exposure of a specific kind. You're exposing something universal. Bodies are bodies. The vulnerability is real, but it's also... transferable. A reader sees themselves in it without you having to put yourself on the page."
"You're saying I use other people's intimacy as a shield."
"I'm saying you're very good at writing what people feel with their bodies and I'm curious whether you've ever tried writing what they feel with everything else."
"Everything else is a lot of territory."
"It is. That's what makes it scary."
"Says the woman who can't write her own piece."
Alina laughed. "Okay. Fair. We're both hiding."
"At least I have a genre. You have a notebook full of observations and no thesis."
"I have several theses. They're all wrong."
Alina wasn't doing this to be cruel. She was sitting in the same mess I was, and talking to someone else who understood the mess was easier than sitting alone with it.
It was different when it went both ways.
"At the bonfire," Alina said, and I braced for whatever was coming. "You said something that stuck with me. About writing making you feel less alone."
"I said a lot of things at the bonfire." I'd also kissed someone at the bonfire, but that wasn't on Alina's spreadsheet.
"You did. And most of it was honest. But it's easy to be honest with good rum and an audience that's rooting for you."
"You think there's a worse version?"
"I think there's a harder version. The one you'd write at two in the morning with nobody watching."
I didn't say anything for a moment. The warmth of the morning was doing something complicated — the sun on the table, the quiet of the emptied-out restaurant, and under all of it Alina's question sitting where I couldn't quite reach around it.
"I'm working on something," I said.
"I know. You mentioned it."
"Yeah."
"How's it going?"
"I don't know yet. I was blocked for months, and then something shifted. The writing started moving again. I don't totally understand what it is yet."
"But it feels different?"
"It feels like mine."
Alina nodded.
"Can I ask about something else?"
"You're going to regardless."
"Probably. Milo and the bartender."
I let out a breath that was closer to a laugh than I'd intended. The tonal shift was welcome — like stepping off a highway onto a side street and realizing how fast I'd been going.
"What about them?"
"I've been watching that situation develop all week and I have theories."
"Everyone has theories. Milo's theories about his own situation change hourly. He's given us at least four definitive readings of every single thing Nico has said to him, including the word 'enjoy.'"
"But it worked out. He came to the bonfire."
"Off duty. In a dark henley. Sat next to Milo without being asked."
"And Milo's face when he sat down—"
"Was a medical event that the table is still processing, yes."
Alina laughed. "I love watching people navigate that. The distance between 'I think he likes me' and 'oh God, he likes me.' It's completely different energy."
"It's the same energy at different volumes. Milo's volume is just permanently set higher than most people's."
We sat with that for a second, both of us smiling at someone else's happiness like it was uncomplicated. Which, from the outside, it was.
"And you and Renee?" Alina said, with the careful ease of someone slipping a question into a conversation the way you'd slide a card into a deck — smooth enough that you might not notice until you'd already answered.
"What about me and Renee?"
"The dynamic's different than it was at the beginning of the week. I'm not asking for details, I'm asking as someone who's been watching the group and noticed a shift."
"We get along now. We didn't at first."
"You get along." Alina's expression didn't change, but something behind it did. "She looks at you like you're the only person in the room who isn't blurry."
"She looks at everyone like that. She's a focused person."
"She is. That's not what I'm describing."
"Alina."
"I'm not pushing. I'm observing."
"Isn't that your whole thing?" I leaned back in my chair.
"It is my whole thing. Doesn't make the observation wrong."
I looked down at the table. I tried to think of something to say to that.
"I like her," I said. Quieter than I'd meant to. "That's — yeah. I like her."
The words came out simpler than they had with Sasha. With Sasha there'd been a whole detonation sequence — the buildup, the caps lock, the shock of admitting it through a screen. With Alina it was just a sentence. Offered to a woman I'd known for six days, at a breakfast table after a morning that had already required more honesty than I'd budgeted for.
Alina looked at me for a second. Not surprised. Not not-surprised. Just taking it in.
"Can I say one more thing?" Alina asked. "And then I'll stop."
"That's what journalists always say before the part that makes it into the article."
"This isn't for the article. This is writer to writer."
"Fine."
"You asked me earlier what I was really asking. About the erotica, the genre, all of it." She set her glass down. "I think you already know what you want to write. I think you've known for a while. And I think the reason you keep deflecting isn't because you don't have the answer — it's because the answer means something and you're not sure you're ready for that."
She didn't soften it with a joke or a redirect.
I didn't answer. Not because I was deflecting — I'd run out of those. I didn't answer because the answer was too close to something I'd been circling for days, in notebooks and manuscripts and four a.m. typing sessions, and I wasn't ready to say it out loud to someone who would hear it accurately.
Alina leaned back in her chair. "So is the fish at dinner actually worth ordering, or has everyone just been too polite to say it isn't?"
"The fish is fine. Everything here is fine. It's a resort — they're contractually obligated to make everything fine."
"That's a ringing endorsement."
"I'm a writer. I don't do ringing endorsements. I do qualified observations." I looked at her. "When does your piece need to be filed?"
"End of the month. Plenty of time. Too much, probably — I'll rewrite it six times and submit the first draft anyway."
"That's every writer I've ever met."
"That's every writer who's ever lived."
Alina gathered her notebook and stood up.
"Thanks for the conversation," she said. "I mean it."
"Thanks for the interrogation."
"It wasn't an interrogation. It was a professional consultation."
"It was an interrogation."
"It was a vigorous exchange of perspectives."
"It was an interrogation, Alina."
Alina smiled. "Maybe a little. You held up well."
"I'm a professional."
She left, and the table was just me and the remains of a conversation that I was going to be thinking about for a lot longer than the conversation itself had lasted.
I sat there for another minute. Maybe two. The cooking class was at two. I could write. I could find the group at the pool and let Talia talk at me about tomorrow's kayaking logistics while Cass read her book and Milo updated us all on which angle of the pool provided the best sightline to whatever part of the resort Nico was currently occupying.
I could sit next to Renee on a lounge chair and let the morning carry forward into the afternoon and the afternoon into the cooking class and the cooking class into the evening.
I stood up, pushed my chair in, and walked out into the sun.
The path back was quiet. I walked slowly. The cooking class was hours away. The bungalow wasn't far.
Nothing Alina had asked me was unfair. That was the part that made it hard to put down. And underneath all of it, like a frequency I couldn't tune out — Renee's voice at the table this morning. "Go ahead." Two words. The same way someone says "I'll be right here."
I kept walking.

Sorrentino's was the kind of restaurant that wanted you to know it had opinions about olive oil. The walls were exposed brick, the lighting was warm enough to make everyone look like they were in a perfume ad, and the menu used words like "drizzled" and "nestled" as if the food had been gently tucked into bed before being served. I'd eaten here enough times to know the pasta was worth the pretension, but every time I walked through the door I had the distinct feeling that the restaurant was quietly judging whether I deserved to be there.
The maître d' was a tall man with a neat beard and the kind of rigid stillness that suggested he'd been personally assembled rather than born. He looked up from his podium as I approached and gave me the smile — the one they taught at whatever school produced people who stood behind podiums at overpriced restaurants. Polished. Professional. Absolutely no warmth behind it.
"Good afternoon. Do you have a reservation?"
"I'm meeting someone. Maribel Grant? She's probably already here. She's probably been here since twelve forty-five because she thinks arriving on time is the same as arriving late."
He blinked at me. Just once. A blink that said I am paid to be pleasant to you and I am earning every cent of it right now.
"Right this way."
I followed him through the dining room, weaving between tables of people who all seemed to be having more productive Tuesdays than I was, and there she was. Corner booth. Sparkling water already half finished. Sitting with the composed stillness of a woman who had never once in her life looked at her phone while waiting for someone because she considered it a waste of perfectly good thinking time.
Maribel Grant. Five foot six of absolute certainty in a cobalt blouse that probably cost less than it looked like it cost, because Maribel was the type who found quality on sale and considered it a personal victory. Her short hair was sharp and precise, the kind of cut that said I have things to do and my hair is not going to be one of them. Her posture was, as always, the posture of someone who had been raised by a woman who believed sitting up straight was a moral position.
She looked up as I approached and her mouth did the thing it always did when she saw me — a slight tightening at the corners that could have been a smile or could have been an assessment. With Maribel, it was usually both.
"You're on time," she said, as if reporting a minor miracle.
"I'm three minutes late."
"For you, that's early."
I slid into the booth across from her and set my bag down with the careful nonchalance of someone who was absolutely not nervous about this lunch. I was not nervous. I was a professional. I was a published author with four books and a viral hit and I was here to have a perfectly normal conversation with my editor over Italian food and nothing about this was going to be stressful.
I was very nervous.
"You look nice," Maribel said, and she meant it — Maribel didn't offer compliments she didn't mean, which made the ones she did offer feel like they'd been peer-reviewed. "The blouse is new?"
"Six months old. First time wearing it."
"Saving it for a special occasion?"
I smoothed the sleeve like it owed me something. "Saving it for a day I needed to feel like a person who had her life together."
"And how's that working out?"
"Ask me after the second glass of wine."
Maribel signaled the waitress with an economical hand gesture she'd probably been doing since birth. A young woman appeared almost immediately — dark hair pulled back, crisp white shirt, the eager competence of someone who could probably recite the specials in three languages and was hoping someone would ask.
"I'll have the branzino," Maribel said, without looking at the menu. Of course she wouldn't look at the menu. Maribel had probably decided what she was ordering while she was driving here. Possibly while she was calling me. Possibly last Tuesday. "And another sparkling water, please. Ade?"
I hadn't opened the menu. I'd been too busy trying to look like someone who didn't need to look at the menu, which meant I now had to actually order something without any information whatsoever.
"The, uh —" I scanned the first page with the panicked focus of a student who hadn't done the reading. "The rigatoni. With the —" I waved my hand vaguely at the menu as if the gesture would fill in the details I hadn't read. "Whatever's on it."
"The rigatoni alla vodka?" the waitress offered, with the diplomatic patience of someone who had seen this exact performance before.
"That one. Yes. And a glass of the Montepulciano."
The waitress nodded and disappeared.
Maribel reached for the bread basket and tore a piece off with the efficient precision of someone performing surgery. The butter went on in one smooth pass, corner to corner, no second stroke. I'd been buttering bread wrong my whole life and hadn't known until this moment.
"So my assistant quit," she said.
"Another one?"
"The exit email was passive-aggressive. She said she needed to 'prioritize her growth in a less demanding environment.' As if demanding is an insult."
"To most people, it is." I took a sip of wine with the calm of someone who had never terrorized an assistant in her life.
"To most people, comfort is a career goal. That's why most people don't get anywhere."
"What did you do to this one?"
"I gave her constructive feedback on a filing error."
"Your version of constructive feedback makes most people update their résumé, Maribel."
"I told her that her organizational system looked like it had been designed by someone who alphabetized by vibes. Which was true. The S section had a folder labeled 'Stuff.'"
Third assistant in two years. Working for Maribel was like being an air traffic controller for a woman who believed she was the only plane in the sky. I loved her, but I would sooner chew glass than manage her calendar.
I took a sip of wine to hide the smile. This was the Maribel that people outside her orbit didn't get to see — the one who was genuinely funny when she wasn't trying to be, who could deliver a devastating observation with the same calm tone she used to order fish. The professional world saw the editor, the dealmaker, the woman with impeccable posture and a reputation for being difficult to impress. I got this version — the one who was still difficult to impress but would occasionally let you see her being amused by her own impossibility.
She'd been to a publishing conference in Chicago last month and described the keynote speaker as "the human equivalent of a LinkedIn post." I laughed, and she looked pleased with herself in the restrained way she had — a slight lift of the chin, a flicker of satisfaction that disappeared before it could be accused of being smug.
"How's David?" I asked, because I was genuinely curious and also because every minute we spent talking about her life was a minute we weren't talking about mine.
"David is fine. David is always fine. David has the emotional range of a golden retriever and the same enthusiasm for routine. He's training for a half marathon now, which means I have to hear about hydration strategies at dinner."
"That sounds romantic."
"It sounds like a man who has replaced one obsession with another. Last year it was sourdough. The year before that it was chess. I give the running until March."
The food arrived. My rigatoni was excellent — rich and creamy with just enough heat to justify the price tag. Maribel's branzino looked like it had been arranged by someone with a degree in architecture. She cut into it with surgical precision, ate three bites, set her knife and fork down in perfect parallel, and said:
"So. The book."
And there it was.
"The book," I repeated, picking up my wine glass because holding something felt better than having my hands just sitting there, available for nervous fidgeting.
"Where are we?"
"We're in a great Italian restaurant having a lovely lunch."
"Ade."
"Fine." I took a sip. Then a slightly longer sip. "We're... in the early conceptual phase."
"You told me that six weeks ago."
"And the concept has been developing beautifully. It's ripening. Like a cheese."
Maribel's face did not change, which was worse than if she'd rolled her eyes. An eye roll would have been engagement. What she was doing instead was just looking at me, steadily, with the patient focus of someone who had decided to wait me out and had brought enough composure to do it all afternoon if necessary.
"Okay," I said. "What if I told you I had several strong ideas and I was in the process of narrowing them down?"
"I'd ask you to name one."
"I don't want to jinx it."
"You can't jinx something that doesn't exist."
Fuck. She was good at this.
I caught the waitress's eye and raised my empty glass with the universal gesture for another one, please, and quickly. She nodded. Maribel watched this transaction with the expression of someone making a mental note.
"It's still the afternoon," she said.
"Time is a construct, Maribel."
I twirled rigatoni around my fork and shoved it in my mouth, which bought me approximately eight seconds of chewing time during which I did not have to speak.
Maribel waited. She was content to watch me eat pasta while formulating a lie. She probably found it educational.
I swallowed. "Okay, I don't have a book. I don't have a concept. I don't have a first line. I barely have a genre at this point. Are you happy?"
"I'm not happy. But I appreciate the honesty."
"Great. The honesty feels terrible. Can I go back to lying?"
"No." She picked up her fork again and took another precise bite of branzino. "Tell me what happens when you sit down to write."
"Nothing happens. That's the whole problem."
"Walk me through it."
"I open the document. I stare at it. I type something. I hate it. I delete it. I type something else. I hate that more. I delete it faster. Then I check my email, then I check Instagram, then I read a comment from someone named Brenda who thinks I'm ruining literature, then I compose a ten-paragraph response I never send, and then I close the laptop and contemplate a career in food service."
Maribel cut another precise bite of branzino without looking down at it. "How many words are we talking about? Total, across three weeks."
"Written or surviving?" I asked, already knowing which answer was going to be worse.
"Written."
"Maybe... a few hundred? Across all the attempts?"
"And surviving?"
"Zero. Absolute zero. The heat death of the literary universe."
Maribel set her fork down again.
"Look," I said, leaning forward because I was going to need both hands for the amount of gesturing I was about to do. "I know there's momentum. I know the numbers are strong. I know there's a window and I know windows close and I know every day I'm not writing is a day the algorithm or the zeitgeist or whatever is moving on to the next thing. I know all of this, Maribel. I am excruciatingly aware of all of this."
"Good. Then you also know that what made My Husband, My Bride work wasn't the algorithm. It wasn't the cover, it wasn't the timing, and it wasn't the zeitgeist." She said the word "zeitgeist" the way someone might handle a piece of fruit they suspected was overripe. "What made it work was that you wrote something emotionally specific. Something raw and honest that people could feel. And what I'm watching you do right now is avoid that exact quality like someone's going to grade you on it."
That landed. It landed because it was true, and Maribel had this deeply inconvenient habit of being true in ways that I couldn't deflect with a joke because the joke would just prove her point.
"I'm not avoiding anything," I said, which was itself an avoidance, and we both knew it.
Maribel's fork paused mid-cut. "When was the last time you wrote something that scared you?"
"Chapter fourteen scared me."
"Chapter fourteen was eight months ago. What's scared you since?"
Nothing. The answer was nothing. Because I hadn't written anything since, which meant nothing had the opportunity to scare me, which was — if I was being honest, and I really didn't want to be honest about this — sort of the point. You couldn't be scared of a blank page. You could only be scared of what you might put on it.
"I'm stuck," I said. The words came out quieter than I meant them to. "I'm really, actually stuck, Maribel. I have ideas but none of them have any heat. None of them feel like they could carry a whole book without collapsing halfway through. And the longer it goes on the worse it gets because now I'm not just trying to write a book, I'm trying to write a book that proves the last one wasn't a fluke, and I can't do both at the same time."
I stopped. I hadn't meant to say all of that. I'd meant to say something controlled and professional — something that acknowledged the problem without sounding like I was drowning in it. Instead I'd just laid the whole thing out on the table between the rigatoni and the sparkling water like a body at a crime scene, and now it was just sitting there, being honest, being embarrassing, being true.
I stabbed a piece of rigatoni with more force than the pasta deserved and ate it in silence.
Maribel listened to all of that without interrupting, which was how I knew she'd been expecting it. She picked up her sparkling water, took a sip, and set it back down with the careful placement of someone who was about to say something she'd been planning to say since before I'd walked through the door.
"Can I ask you something that isn't about the book?"
"That depends on whether the something is secretly about the book."
"It's adjacent."
"Adjacent is just 'about' in a nicer outfit."
Maribel pushed her plate forward half an inch — done with the branzino, done with the warm-up. "When was the last time you left your apartment for something that wasn't groceries or a lunch you were dreading?"
"I go places."
"Where?"
"The coffee shop on Seventh." I said it like I was presenting evidence in my own defense. "I tried writing there last week."
"That's four blocks from your apartment."
"It's a different environment. There are plants."
"When was the last time you did something fun? And I don't mean fun like a glass of wine in front of Netflix. I mean actually fun. Something that involved other human beings and at least one moment where you forgot you were a person with a deadline."
"I have fun," I said, and even as the words left my mouth I could hear how unconvincing they sounded. Like someone insisting they were a morning person while yawning.
"Name the last fun thing."
"I went to Sasha's birthday."
"That was in October." Maribel didn't even blink, just let the math do the work.
"It was very fun. The fun has lasted."
"Ade, it's January."
I picked up my wine glass and took a sip that was closer to a gulp. Maribel wasn't wrong. The gap between October and now was three months, and I couldn't point to a single thing in those three months that qualified as actually living rather than just maintaining. I'd been feeding myself, paying my bills, keeping the apartment at a survivable level of chaos, and sitting in front of a laptop accomplishing nothing. That wasn't a life. That was maintenance.
"When was the last time you did something that had nothing to do with writing or thinking about writing or feeling bad about not writing?"
I opened my mouth to answer and then closed it, because the honest answer was genuinely embarrassing. I couldn't remember. Not in a dramatic, I've-lost-all-sense-of-time way. More in a quiet, creeping way — the days had just started looking the same. Wake up, fail to write, scroll, fail to write some more, order food, watch something I'd already seen, go to bed too late, repeat. The apartment had become a holding pattern and I'd been circling in it for weeks without noticing that I'd stopped trying to land.
I looked out the window. Across the street, a woman was walking a dog that was clearly walking her — a big, dopey golden retriever that was towing her toward a fire hydrant with the determination of someone who'd been waiting for this moment all day. The woman was laughing, stumbling along behind it, not caring that she looked ridiculous. Just letting the day happen to her.
I couldn't remember the last time I'd let the day happen to me.
"Ade." Maribel's voice pulled me back. Not sharp — softer than her usual register, which was somehow more alarming. Maribel being soft meant she was genuinely concerned, and Maribel being genuinely concerned meant things were worse than I'd been admitting to myself.
"I'm fine," I said, turning back to her. "I was just watching a dog commit a crime against a fire hydrant. I'm fine."
She looked at me for a moment — really looked, the way she did when she was deciding whether to push or to let something sit. Then she reached into her bag.
What she pulled out was a brochure. Not a business card, not a printed email, not a contract — a glossy, tri-fold brochure with turquoise water on the cover and the kind of palm trees that only existed in places where people went to pretend their real lives weren't waiting for them back home.
She slid it across the table toward me.
I looked at it. Then I looked at her. Then I looked at it again.
"What the hell is this?"
"Pick it up."
"We were just having a serious conversation about my career and you're handing me a —" I picked it up, turned it over. Turquoise water. Palm trees. Italic script. "A vacation brochure? Are you firing me? Is this severance? A tropical island instead of two weeks' notice?"
"Just read it, Ade."
The Whispering Palms at Coral Key. Your Most Authentic Self.
"My most authentic self," I read aloud, in the tone of someone who had been personally insulted by a piece of marketing. "That's what they're going with? That's the tagline?"
I opened the brochure. Inside was more turquoise water — they were really committed to the turquoise — along with photos of sun-drenched bungalows, a beachfront bar with string lights, and a group of people who were laughing in the specific way that people only laughed in stock photos. Adults-only. LGBTQ+ focused. Private island accessible only by boat. The whole thing was dripping with the kind of curated paradise that existed specifically to look good on someone's Instagram story.
There was a quote on the inside flap from a previous guest: "I came for a week and left a different person." Underneath it, in smaller text: "— Sarah M., Portland." Sarah M. from Portland. Thank you, Sarah. Very helpful. Very specific. I was sure Sarah M. had a wonderful time becoming a different person on her tropical island, but some of us were already more than one person on a good day and didn't need a resort to complicate things further.
"It's a resort," I said.
"It's an experience."
"It's a resort that calls itself an experience, which is worse." I flipped the brochure over as if the back might contain a retraction.
Maribel turned her water glass a quarter turn, the way she did when she was about to say something she'd rehearsed. "I know the manager. Emmett Hale. We were at Columbia together — different programs, but we stayed in touch. He built this place from the ground up and he takes the community aspect seriously. It's not a theme park, Ade. It's genuinely a space where people go to be themselves."
"You keep saying that like it's a selling point. 'Be yourself.' 'Your most authentic self.' What does that even mean? I am myself. I'm myself right now. I'm sitting here being deeply, authentically resistant to this idea and I feel very genuine about it."
"People can be themselves anywhere, sure. In theory." Maribel tilted her head, and the question that followed wasn't rhetorical. "But can you? Because from where I'm sitting, you've been locked in your apartment for six weeks being no one at all."
That was mean. That was accurate, but it was mean.
"I've been working," I said, unconvincingly.
"You've been hiding. And the work is suffering because you've forgotten what it feels like to be around actual humans who aren't on a screen saying something you're trying not to read."
I looked at the brochure again. A woman in a sundress was drinking something with an umbrella in it, smiling at someone off-camera with the relaxed ease of a person who had never once in her life stared at a blinking cursor for three weeks straight. Good for her. Good for her and her umbrella drink and her off-camera friend and her complete lack of existential professional dread.
"Coral Key," I said. "Where even is that?"
"Off the Gulf Coast. Small island. You take a boat from the mainland."
"A boat." I said it the way someone might say a root canal.
"A short boat."
"I don't do boats."
Maribel reached for her water, perfectly calm, perfectly aware she'd just drawn blood. "You don't do anything right now. That's the problem."
I put the brochure down. "Maribel, I appreciate the thought. I do. But I'm not going to fix my writer's block by sitting on a beach drinking out of a coconut. That's not how creativity works."
"How does it work?"
"I don't know. If I knew, I'd be doing it."
"Exactly." She leaned back slightly — a rare concession to casualness from a woman who usually sat like she was being painted. "You don't know. You've tried everything you can think of from inside your apartment and none of it has worked. So maybe the answer isn't inside your apartment."
"Maybe the answer is more time. Maybe the answer is patience. Maybe the answer is accepting that the muse works on her own schedule and I can't rush —"
"If you say 'muse' I'm going to —"
"Fine. No muse. But a tropical island, Maribel? What am I going to do there? Sit on a beach and hope the ocean tells me a story? Write erotica inspired by a palm tree?"
"You're going to be around people. Real, actual people who aren't on a screen. You're going to have conversations that have nothing to do with your word count. You're going to eat food you didn't order from the same three delivery apps. And maybe — maybe — you'll remember what it feels like to be a person first and a writer second."
"I don't know how to be a person first and a writer second. I've never done it in that order."
"I know. That might be the whole problem."
I pushed a piece of rigatoni around my plate. "Or maybe the answer is that I'm a one-hit wonder who peaked at twenty-eight and should start looking into careers that don't require creative inspiration. Data entry. Accounting. Something where the blank page doesn't fight back."
"You're not a one-hit wonder."
"You don't know that."
"I do know that." There was no hesitation in it. No performance, no flattery, no professional obligation. Just Maribel saying something she believed with the same certainty she brought to everything else. "I read your first three books before I agreed to work with you, Ade. And I didn't take you on because I thought one of them might go viral. I took you on because you write like someone who understands what people are afraid to want. That's a rare thing. It doesn't disappear because you're having a rough stretch."
The words settled over the table between us. I wanted to make a joke — something sharp and deflective that would let us both pretend the moment wasn't happening. But I couldn't find one. Or maybe I didn't want to find one. Maribel had just said something genuinely kind, in her direct, undecorated way, and undercutting it would have been worse than sitting with it.
So I sat with it.
"You don't have to go," she said, after a moment. "I'm not going to force a vacation on you. But I think getting out of your own head — physically, not just creatively — might remind you what it feels like to actually experience something instead of just sitting in your apartment trying to write about experiencing things." She paused. "And who knows. Maybe something out there sparks something in here." She tapped her temple. "Stranger things have happened to worse writers."
"That's a very diplomatic way of saying I've become a hermit."
"You've become a hermit, Ade."
I picked up my wine glass, took a slow sip, and looked at the brochure sitting on the table between Maribel's sparkling water and the remains of my rigatoni.
Your Most Authentic Self. What a load of shit. What a gorgeous, turquoise, palm-tree-lined load of shit.
I picked it up. Folded it. Slid it into my bag.
Maribel's mouth did the thing again — the tightening at the corners. This time it was definitely closer to a smile.
"Don't," I said.
"I didn't say anything."
"You're being smug. I can hear you being smug. You're sitting there in your cobalt blouse being silently smug and I want you to know that I see it."
"I'm not being smug. I'm being hopeful. There's a difference."
"There really isn't."
"Are you going to think about it?"
I looked at her across the table. Maribel Grant, who had believed in my writing before anyone else had, who had read my first messy manuscript and seen something worth investing in, who was currently sitting across from me with her perfect posture and her half-finished sparkling water and her quiet, stubborn refusal to let me give up on myself.
"I'll think about it," I said. "That's all. I'll think about it."
"That's all I'm asking."
It was not all she was asking. We both knew it. But we let it sit there, the polite fiction that I was still making up my mind, and Maribel signaled for the check with the same decisive gesture she used for everything — one small movement, maximum result.
She paid. She always paid. I'd tried to argue about it once, early in our working relationship, and she'd looked at me with the expression of someone who had been briefly entertained by a puppy trying to open a door. I hadn't argued since.
We stood, gathered our things, and walked out of Sorrentino's into the afternoon sun. The street was busy with the usual Tuesday traffic — people going places, doing things, living lives that presumably involved fewer blinking cursors and existential crises over Italian food.
Maribel stopped on the sidewalk and turned to face me. In the daylight, outside the restaurant's flattering lighting, she looked a little tired herself — a detail I might not have noticed if I hadn't been looking for it. Even Maribel Grant, the most composed woman in publishing, had her own version of a long week. She just wore it better than I did.
"Take care of yourself," she said, and it sounded like she meant it in at least three different ways.
"I always do."
"You never do. But I admire the consistency of the lie."
She gave me a look — warm and pointed and impossible to argue with — and then she turned and walked toward her car with the purposeful stride of a woman who had accomplished what she'd come to accomplish and was already thinking about the next thing on her list.
I stood on the sidewalk for a moment, watching her go. Then I reached into my bag and pulled out the brochure.
Turquoise water. Palm trees. Bungalows with white linens. A beachfront bar. A group of suspiciously happy people laughing in the sun.
Your Most Authentic Self.
"Bullshit," I muttered, and started walking.
The walk home took about twenty minutes, which was twenty minutes of me holding a brochure I had no intention of acting on while my brain did the thing it always did after a conversation with Maribel — replayed every moment, assessed every exchange, and reluctantly admitted that she'd been right about at least seventy percent of it. Maybe eighty. I wasn't going to give her ninety even in the privacy of my own thoughts.
The part I kept circling back to wasn't the resort pitch. It was the other thing she'd said — the part about why she'd taken me on in the first place. You write like someone who understands what people are afraid to want. I'd sat with that at the table and I was still sitting with it now, turning it over, trying to decide whether it made me feel better or worse. Better, because Maribel believed it. Worse, because if it was true, then the block wasn't about skill or ideas or timing. It was about the fact that I'd stopped being willing to go to those places in my own head. The places where the good writing lived. The scary, honest, vulnerable places that made chapter fourteen the kind of scene people had to put their phone down and stare at a wall after reading.
Somewhere along the way I'd decided that those places were too expensive to visit, and I'd been circling the parking lot ever since.
I stopped at a crosswalk and opened the brochure again. The turquoise water glinted up at me from the glossy paper. Sarah M. from Portland grinned at me from her testimonial with the serene confidence of someone who had never composed a furious mental response to an Instagram comment.
An adults-only LGBTQ+ sanctuary where connection, creativity, and self-discovery meet the shore.
Who wrote this copy? Who sat down and typed "self-discovery meets the shore" and thought, yes, that's the one? Someone got paid for that sentence. Someone got paid and I couldn't even write one for free.
I closed the brochure. Opened it again. Read the part about the private bungalows and the beachfront activities and the "curated social experiences designed to foster meaningful connection." Closed it again.
Fuck.
I read it twice before I got home.

I'd never seen Talia move with this much purpose. She was walking like a woman on a mission that had been circled on a printed schedule since day one, and the rest of us were just trying to keep up.
"I read that she trained in Kingston," Talia said over her shoulder, not slowing down. "And worked at a restaurant in London. Or maybe it was Montreal. One of the two."
"Those are very different cities," Cass said.
"The point is she's world-class."
"The point is you don't know where she worked."
Milo was keeping pace with Talia, which was an achievement given that he was also trying to fix his hair using his phone screen as a mirror. "I just want everyone to know that I have two goals today. Learn to cook. And make something for Nico."
"Those sound like three goals," Renee said from beside me. She'd fallen into step with me on the path without either of us deciding it should happen.
"Learning to cook is the vehicle," Milo said. "Making something for Nico is the destination."
"What do you want to make for him?" I asked.
"I don't know yet. Something impressive. Something that says I'm thoughtful and domestic and worth keeping."
"That's a lot to ask of a single dish," Cass said.
The cooking class was in a room on the ground floor of the main building. The door was propped open and the smell hit us before we were through it — garlic, allspice, something smoky and sweet that had been building in the walls for what seemed like years. Inside, the room had been set up with paired stations in two rows, each one its own little island of counter space, a cutting board, a single burner, and ingredients laid out in neat, precise rows.
A few other guests were already there, milling around the stations, reading the laminated recipe cards, looking approximately as confident as I felt about the prospect of operating a knife in public.
And then there was Chef Diana.
She was already behind her demonstration counter at the front, doing something with a mortar and pestle that involved more force than seemed strictly necessary. She was broad-shouldered, mid-fifties, silver-streaked hair pulled back under a bright orange headwrap. She wore a white chef's coat with the sleeves rolled to her elbows.
She looked up when we came in. Looked at all five of us in a single sweep that somehow managed to assess, welcome, and warn us simultaneously.
"Don't touch anything," said Diana, going back to her mortar and pestle. "Find a partner, find a station. Two to a station."
Milo drew a breath and leaned forward, already committed to whatever he'd been about to say.
"And don't talk," Diana added, without looking at him.
Diana's tone landed and Milo's mouth shut on reflex. He looked at us like a man who knew when he was outmatched.
Talia grabbed Cass by the wrist and had them at a front-row station before the rest of us had moved. Around the room, the other guests were already sorting themselves into pairs and drifting toward stations.
Renee looked at me. I looked at Renee. It was the kind of look that lasted about half a second longer than it needed to, and in that half-second we both arrived at the same conclusion without speaking it.
"Station behind Talia and Cass?" Renee said, already moving.
"Works for me," I said, with a level of casual disinterest that would not have fooled a single person in the room.
Milo watched us walk away together.
He turned to find a partner and found that everyone in the room had already paired off. Every station had two people except one at the back row, where a guy in a tucked-in polo shirt and reading glasses stood alone, studying the laminated recipe card with the focus of someone preparing for a certification exam. Milo — the man who had spent six days engineering other people's connections — was the last one standing.
Diana noticed. She looked at him, looked at the guy in the polo shirt, and pointed between them.
"You two." Diana nodded at the back-row station. "Together."
It was not a suggestion.
Milo walked to his assigned station. His partner set the recipe card down with a small, satisfied nod. He did not introduce himself.
"Hi," Milo said. "I'm Milo."
"Keith," the man said, still looking at the recipe card. "Looks straightforward."
Milo looked at us. I mouthed "sorry" and meant most of it.
Diana finished whatever she'd been grinding, set the pestle down with a thud that silenced the room, and looked out at all of us with an expression that split the difference between a hug and a health inspection.
"All right," said Diana. "Listen. I'm going to say this once and I'm not going to say it again, so if you're on your phone, put it away. If you're talking, stop. If you think you already know how to cook because you watched a YouTube video, God bless you, but no. You don't."
Absolute silence. Twelve adults standing at attention behind cutting boards.
"My name is Chef Diana. This is my class. Everything on your stations —" she pointed — "deserves your respect. You are going to learn to make jerk chicken, rice and peas, and fried plantains. You are going to do it the way I tell you, in the order I tell you, and if I catch anyone doing something I didn't ask them to do, I will come to your station and I will fix it, and baby, you do not want me to have to fix it because that means I stopped working on mine."
Talia was staring at Diana with the pure, unblinking adoration of someone who had just found religion.
"The scotch bonnets are on your stations. They are there for the jerk marinade. They are not toys. You do not touch them and then touch your face. You do not touch them and then touch your partner's face. You do not chop them and then rub your eyes and then come crying to me because I will have warned you." She paused. "I will still help you. But I will say I told you so first."
Cass leaned toward Talia without taking her eyes off Diana. "I like her."
"I'm in love with her," Talia whispered.
"You taste as you go," Diana continued, pacing now. "Tasting is how you learn. But you use a clean spoon every time. You do not double-dip. You do not lick the spoon and put it back. This is not your kitchen. This is my kitchen, and in my kitchen we have standards."
I glanced at Milo. He was nodding along like he was taking an oath.
"Now. You're going to start with the chicken. I'm going to show you the marinade, and then you're going to make it yourselves. Watch first. Then do. If you get stuck, raise your hand. If something starts smoking, don't panic. If something actually catches fire, step back and let me handle it."
She looked at us one more time. Her face softened exactly one degree.
"We're going to have a good time," said Diana. "I promise. But we're going to have a good time my way."
She picked up a knife, and class began.
Diana demonstrated the marinade with the economy of someone who could do it blindfolded. Allspice, thyme, garlic, ginger, scotch bonnets, soy sauce, lime juice, brown sugar.
"The sugar isn't sweet," said Diana, crushing garlic with the flat of her blade. "It's balance. You take it out, the whole thing falls sideways. Trust the recipe. We'll freestyle later. First we learn."
She sent us to our stations and the room dissolved into organised chaos.
"Cutting board's yours," Renee said, nudging it toward me.
"How generous."
"I know what happens when I let you near a stove unsupervised."
"You've literally never seen me near a stove."
"I'm extrapolating."
She had a point. Probably.
Renee picked up the garlic and had it peeled and minced before I'd finished identifying which ingredient was the allspice. She worked with her sleeves pushed up and her hair pulled back, moving through the steps with the same unhurried competence she brought to everything physical. She didn't check the recipe card once.
"You said you cooked," I said. "You didn't say you were this fast."
"I've been feeding myself since I was seventeen. You figure it out." She slid the cutting board toward me with the garlic already done. "Your turn. Ginger."
I picked up the ginger root and the knife and looked at both of them with what I hoped was quiet confidence and what was probably visible uncertainty.
"Hold it like this," Renee said, adjusting my grip on the handle so my index finger ran along the back of the blade. Her fingers were warm and sure and they lingered exactly long enough for me to notice they'd lingered. "More control. Less chance of losing a fingertip."
"I wasn't going to lose a fingertip."
"You were holding it like a tennis racket."
From the station ahead of us, Talia had already departed from the recipe card. "What if we add a little more lime? I feel like it needs more lime."
"It doesn't need more lime," Cass said, measuring allspice with a level tablespoon and what appeared to be a deep personal commitment to accuracy. "Diana said two tablespoons."
"Diana said to taste as we go."
"She also said trust the recipe."
"I'm trusting the recipe. I'm enhancing the recipe."
"That's not what enhancing means."
Talia squeezed more lime. Cass exhaled through her nose and went back to the allspice.
At Milo's station, Keith had assembled his ingredients in a neat row, consulted the recipe card one more time, and begun measuring allspice into a bowl with the unhurried precision of a man filling a prescription. Milo was watching him the way you'd watch someone park a car one inch at a time.
"You can just eyeball it," Milo offered.
"I prefer to measure," Keith said, levelling off the spoon with his finger.
"Sure. No, absolutely. It's just — Diana said two tablespoons, and you've been measuring that same tablespoon for about forty-five seconds."
Keith added the allspice to the bowl, picked up the thyme, and began stripping the leaves with methodical, individual attention to each sprig.
Milo looked at the ceiling. Then at me. I gave him a sympathetic face that was doing absolutely no work to hide my amusement.
I went back to my ginger, which was not going well. The root was knobby and uncooperative and I was producing chunks of wildly different sizes, which was not the thin, even slices Diana had demonstrated. Renee watched me for about thirty seconds without comment, and then she stepped behind me.
Her hands came over mine — left hand repositioning my grip on the ginger, right hand adjusting the angle of the blade. She was pressed against my back, her chin close enough to my shoulder that I could feel her breath when she spoke.
"Thinner," said Renee. "Let the knife do the work. You're muscling it."
The knife and the ginger stopped being relevant the moment I registered exactly how much of Renee was pressed against me, the full length of her, her hips against mine, her hands still on my hands, guiding the blade through the ginger in slow, even strokes that produced the thin slices I had been failing to produce on my own.
I stared at the cutting board. I thought very carefully about allspice. I thought about the recipe card. I thought about the periodic table of elements, which I hadn't thought about since high school and couldn't remember past calcium. I shifted my weight forward half an inch, which did almost nothing because she moved with me, adjusting like it was the most natural thing in the world, which for her it probably was because she was teaching me to use a knife and she did not appear to be experiencing a full-system shutdown while doing it.
"See?" said Renee, stepping back. "Thinner's better."
"Yep," I said. "Got it. Thinner. Absolutely."
My voice came out approximately half an octave higher than usual and I was grateful — genuinely, profoundly grateful — that I was facing a cutting board and not the room. I kept slicing.
Diana appeared at Talia and Cass's station, looked into their marinade bowl, looked at Talia, and said, "Baby, how much lime did you put in this?"
"The right amount," Talia said, with full confidence.
Diana picked up the bowl, smelled it, and set it back down. "That is not the right amount. That is enough lime for a family of six. I said two tablespoons."
"I was tasting as I went."
"Tasting is for adjusting. What you did is assault." But she was almost smiling when she said it, and she showed Talia how to rebalance with more brown sugar, and she told Cass, "You — you're doing fine, don't change a thing," and Cass accepted this with a small nod that radiated the satisfaction of someone whose approach had been vindicated by a professional.
Diana moved to Milo's station. Keith was still stripping thyme, one leaf at a time. His garlic was cut into cubes the size of playing dice.
Diana looked at the garlic. Looked at Keith. Looked at Milo, who was gesturing at the garlic cubes with both hands in a silent appeal for intervention.
"Baby," Diana said to Keith, gently. "That's not minced. That's chopped. That's barely chopped. That's insulting my garlic."
"I thought they seemed a bit large," Keith said, cheerfully. He picked the knife back up and began cutting the cubes into slightly smaller cubes.
Milo put his head in his hands.
The stations graduated to the burners and the room got warmer. Diana walked us through the jerk chicken — marinating, searing, finishing in a covered pan. She moved between stations with the fluid authority of someone who had eyes in the back of her head and opinions about everything they saw.
Renee handled the pan. I handled the rice, which felt like a safe assignment until I realized that rice and peas involved coconut milk and timing and a series of steps that required attention I was finding increasingly difficult to give, because Renee was standing close enough that every time she shifted her weight or reached for the salt or turned to check Diana's demonstration, some part of her brushed against some part of me, and every time it happened, I noticed it a little more than the time before.
She'd seasoned the chicken without checking the recipe card, adjusting by smell and taste and what seemed like pure instinct. She gave it one last stir and held the spoon out to me.
"Try this."
I leaned in. The marinade was sharp and smoky and the heat hit about two seconds after the flavour — slow, building, the kind that crept up on you.
"Good," I said, and my voice sounded relatively normal, which I was counting as a personal victory.
"Needs more garlic," said Renee, and added some without waiting for my opinion, which was fair because my opinion on garlic was not going to be useful right now.
Across the room, Milo's station had become a site of genuine psychological distress. Keith tasted the marinade with the cooking spoon and put the spoon back into the bowl.
"Keith," Milo said, with the careful patience of a man operating at the absolute outer limit of his restraint. "That's the cooking spoon."
"Mm-hm."
"That goes back in the food."
"It's my food too," Keith said reasonably, and tasted again.
Milo was living through something he would never recover from. I pressed my lips together and focused very hard on my rice.
Talia and Cass had reached the searing stage and their station was producing the kind of sizzle that drew Diana's attention from across the room. Talia was standing over the pan with a spatula in one hand and a look of pure focus. This was Talia in her element — the chaos was intentional, the improvisation was part of the process, and the results, against all reasonable expectation, smelled incredible.
"Move it," Cass said, reaching past Talia for the tongs. "It's going to stick."
"It's not going to stick, I oiled the pan."
"You drizzled oil on the pan like you were decorating a dessert. That's not oiling."
"It's a technique."
"It's a liability."
But they moved around each other with the unconscious choreography of two people who'd been sharing a kitchen for years — Cass adjusting the burner when Talia forgot, Talia seasoning Cass's rice without being asked, both of them orbiting the same small counter without collision. Cass caught Talia tasting directly from the pan with her finger, gave her a look, and Talia grinned at her without a shred of contrition.
Diana passed their station, looked into the pan, and said, "Whoever's on the chicken — that's the best sear in the room."
Talia's face produced an expression of triumph so pure it was almost spiritual. She turned to Cass. Cass preemptively said, "Don't."
Talia said it anyway: "Best sear in the room."
"I heard her."
"Best. Sear. In the room."
"I'm going to need you to stop saying that."
"I will never stop saying that."
Renee was plating the chicken, transferring it from the pan to a plate with the tongs in a series of clean, precise movements. A strand of hair had come loose from where she'd pulled it back and was falling across her face. She didn't fix it. She was focused on what she was doing, her forearms working, her fingers steady, and I was watching her with the same attention I should have been giving my rice, which was now doing something that sounded more active than rice was supposed to sound.
"Your rice," Renee said, without looking up.
"I know."
"It's bubbling."
"I hear it."
I turned the burner down and stirred and told myself to focus, and then Renee reached across me for the lime and her arm brushed against mine and she smelled like garlic and allspice and something underneath both that was just her, and I stopped stirring for a second that lasted longer than a second should.
She looked at me. I looked at her. The room was warm and loud and full of people — Diana saying something to the station behind us, Milo saying something to Keith — and none of it was registering. Renee was looking at me with her lips slightly parted and the strand of hair still across her face and my mouth had gone completely dry and I was holding a wooden spoon and I had forgotten why.
There wasn't a decision in it. There was just Renee, and the heat from the burner, and whatever was happening on her face that was also happening on mine, and the space between us that had stopped being a space and started being something else entirely —
A yelp from Milo's station cut through everything.
Keith had touched the scotch bonnet. Keith had then, evidently, touched his eye. Keith was now standing very still with one hand over his face making a sound that was equal parts surprise and regret.
"Oh my God," Milo said, backing away from his own station. "Oh my GOD. Keith. KEITH."
Diana was there in four strides. She took one look at Keith, shook her head slowly, and said, "Baby. What did I say."
"Don't touch your face," Keith said, his eye streaming.
"What did you do?"
"Touched my face."
Diana was already running water, already producing a towel, already handling it with the exasperated tenderness of someone who had seen this exact thing happen a hundred times and would see it a hundred more. "Come here. No, don't rub it. Stop rubbing it. Come here."
Milo was standing at his station with both hands pressed against his own cheeks, staring at the scotch bonnet on his cutting board like it had personally betrayed him. "I can't," said Milo to nobody in particular. "I cannot."
I blinked. The wooden spoon was still in my hand. My rice had survived my absence, which was more than I could say for my composure. Renee was already back at the chicken, adjusting the heat with steady hands, as if the last ten seconds hadn't happened.
Except for the very small, very deliberate smile she wasn't quite hiding. That was happening. I saw it. Around us, Diana was still lecturing Keith about the scotch bonnet and Milo was physically incapable of not providing commentary.
I stirred my rice. The rice was fine.
Keith recovered. Diana made him hold a cold, damp cloth over his eye for five minutes and then inspected him with the thoroughness of a field medic before clearing him to return to his station. Milo spent those five minutes alone at their station, finishing the marinade himself with the grim focus of a man who had been through an ordeal.
"He put the spoon back in," Milo said to me across the gap between our stations, keeping his voice low. "Twice. And then he touched a scotch bonnet and rubbed his eye. That's what the universe gave me."
"You survived."
"I'm changed, Ade. I'm a different person than I was an hour ago."
Diana brought us back together for the plating. The plantains came last — she demonstrated the slicing, the frying, the way you waited until the edges went golden-brown and then moved fast before they burned. She fried hers without a timer, without checking, flipping each slice at exactly the right moment by sound alone.
"When it talks to you," said Diana, tilting the pan, "you listen."
Renee fried our plantains. I watched her do it, standing beside her at the burner with nothing to do and no desire to be anywhere else. She flipped each one with a quick, confident motion, and when one came out perfectly — golden, caramelised, the edges curling just right — she held it up on the spatula and looked at me.
"That one's yours," said Renee.
"I didn't do anything."
"You stayed out of my way. That's a contribution."
The room was starting to wind down. Diana circulated for final checks, adjusting, tasting, approving with a nod or redirecting with a firm "more salt, baby" or "turn that down before you ruin it." She stopped at our station, looked at the chicken, the rice, the plantains, and gave Renee a nod that carried real professional respect.
"You've cooked before," Diana said.
"A little," Renee said.
Diana looked at me. "And you?"
"I mostly watched."
Diana patted my shoulder. "Honesty. I like that." She moved on.
Talia was already eating a plantain directly off the cutting board with her fingers. Cass was plating their food with architectural precision, arranging the chicken and rice and plantains in a configuration that suggested she had opinions about presentation. Milo was plating for himself and for Keith, who was still blinking his recovering eye but had returned to his station and was already reaching for the cooking spoon.
"I'll plate," Milo said firmly, when Keith reached for the serving spoon.
"I can help."
"You've helped enough."
Keith accepted this without offence, picked up a plantain with his fingers, and ate it standing up. It was, I had to admit, a power move.
We pushed two tables together near the window and sat with our plates. The other guests from the class settled at their own tables across the room — Keith among them, eating contentedly, seemingly unbothered by either his eye or Milo's trauma. Diana joined the other table, her own plate loaded, already deep in conversation with an older couple who'd produced surprisingly excellent rice.
Talia sat across from Cass. Milo dropped into the chair on Talia's other side. I sat down and Renee took the chair next to mine, close enough that our elbows occasionally touched when we reached for things, and neither of us moved to create more space. It just happened. The way things between us kept just happening.
The food was imperfect and real. The chicken was slightly charred on one side, which was arguably my fault for the period where I'd stopped paying attention to anything in the known universe. The rice was good — Renee said so, and I accepted the compliment with a small, stupid amount of pride. The plantains were perfect because Renee had made them.
"All right," Milo said, fork in one hand, the other hand pressed flat on the table. "I need to process what just happened."
"Keith?" Talia asked, already grinning.
"Keith." Milo set his fork down. "I want to be clear. I am a patient person. I work in an ER. I have held a man's hand while he explained to me, in detail, that he had gotten a LEGO stuck in his ear on purpose because he wanted to know if it would fit. I have patience. I have reserves."
"Had," Cass said.
"Keith broke me. The spoon, Cass. The spoon went back in. I watched it happen twice and I still wasn't ready the third time."
"There was a third time?" I said.
"There was a third time. And then — and THEN — he touches the scotch bonnet. After Diana's speech. After the whole beautiful speech about not touching your face. She looked at all of us. She made eye contact."
"She made very thorough eye contact," Renee agreed.
"And he just—" Milo mimed rubbing his eye with one knuckle, his face collapsing into a re-enactment of the horror. "Finger. Eye. Direct contact. No hesitation."
"Diana handled it well," Cass offered.
"Diana handled it like a saint. 'Baby, what did I say.' I wanted to applaud. I wanted to give her a standing ovation."
"You were pretty loud about it," I said.
"The situation called for volume."
"Can we talk about the fact that I got best sear in the room?" said Talia, as if Milo's trauma was beside the point.
"We cannot," said Cass, knowing full well it wouldn't stop her.
"Diana said it. Out loud. In front of everyone."
"She said it to us, Talia. Not the room."
"Best sear in the room, Cass. Those were her exact words. I need you to sit with that."
"I've been sitting with it. I'm at peace with it. Can you be at peace with it quietly?"
"No," Talia said, with the sincere conviction of someone who would be bringing this up on their anniversary. "I cannot."
Renee reached across to try a piece of Talia and Cass's chicken and nodded. "It's good. The lime was too much but the sear saved it."
Talia pointed at Renee. "Thank you."
"She said the lime was too much," Cass noted.
"She said the sear saved it. I'm taking the win."
I ate my food.
Talia picked up a plantain with her fingers and bit into it without ceremony. Cass looked at her, then at the fork sitting untouched on Talia's plate, then back at Talia.
"We're at a table," said Cass, pushing Talia's fork closer to her plate.
"And I'm eating."
"With your hands."
"With my fingers. It tastes better." Talia took another bite.
"Feral," said Milo, shaking his head at Talia. "Absolutely feral behaviour."
"Efficient," said Talia, licking her thumb.
"You know what the worst part was?" said Milo. "The spoon wasn't even the worst part."
"There's more?" I asked.
"There's so much more. You were all over there cooking and flirting and having a beautiful time and I was in a war zone." He took a breath. "He wiped his hands on my apron. Not his apron. My apron. Reached over and just — used me like a towel."
"He did not," said Talia.
"He did. Without asking. Without breaking eye contact with the recipe card. Just reached across and wiped his hands on me like I was furniture."
"What did you do?" said Renee.
"What could I do? I have never felt more powerless in my life and I once had a patient throw pudding at me."
"To be fair," said Cass, "you were paired with him for an hour. Not a lifetime."
"It felt like a lifetime. Time moved differently at that station. I aged."
"You're being dramatic," I said.
"I am being precise. There is a version of me that walked into that class and a different version sitting at this table and Keith is the reason."
"He seemed happy when he left," said Renee.
"Of course he was happy. He had the time of his life. He learned nothing. He touched a scotch bonnet and rubbed his eye and then went right back to the cooking spoon and you know what he said to me when Diana cleared him? He said 'that wasn't so bad.'"
Talia covered her mouth with her hand.
"'That wasn't so bad,'" Milo repeated. "About rubbing pepper in his own eye. Those were his words. I have to live with that."
"And can we discuss —" Milo waved his fork between me and Renee with absolutely zero subtlety. "The chopping lesson? The hands-on, full-body, behind-the-back chopping lesson?"
I ate a plantain and did not respond.
"Because from where I was standing — and I was dealing with a crisis, so I couldn't give it my full attention, which I resent — it looked very—"
"Educational," said Renee, cutting a piece of chicken.
"Educational." Milo sat back. "Sure. Very educational. Very thorough. Very close."
Talia was smiling at me across the table like she'd been holding it in for hours. Milo was doing approximately the same thing but with less restraint.
I looked at both of them. I rolled my eyes. And I smiled — just a smile, the kind that gave them exactly what they were looking for, which was confirmation that I knew what they knew and I wasn't pretending otherwise.
"Can I just say," said Talia, gesturing at me and Renee's plates, "that your food looks suspiciously good for someone who admitted to Diana that she mostly watched."
"I contributed," I said.
"What did you contribute?" asked Cass.
"She chopped the ginger," said Renee.
"After you showed her how," said Milo.
"She stirred the rice," said Renee.
"Did she?" asked Talia.
"Intermittently."
"Intermittently," Milo repeated, delighted.
"I also handled the cutting board," I said. "I moved it once. I put things on it."
"Diana gave you a pity pat on the shoulder," said Milo. "She said 'honesty, I like that.' That was Diana being kind to you because you had nothing else going for you in that kitchen."
"That's not what happened."
"That's exactly what happened. You got a participation pat."
"She patted me with respect."
"That was a consolation pat," said Talia. "That was a 'bless your heart' pat." Cass actually laughed, which made Talia beam like she'd won a second award.
"For the record," I said, looking around the table for a single ally, "the rice was good. Renee said the rice was good."
"Your rice was supervised," said Renee.
I finished my plantain and didn't argue. There was no winning this and I'd stopped wanting to.
Milo was stealing the last piece of chicken off Talia's plate. Cass had leaned back in her chair with her arms folded.
"Bar?" said Talia.
"I'm up for it," said Milo, already pushing his chair back.
"Could use a drink after that," said Cass.
Renee looked at me. "Bar?"
"Sure," I said.
We walked out together, all five of us, through the corridor and outside. Milo was still talking — he was always still talking. Talia was laughing at something Cass had said under her breath. Renee was beside me, walking at the same pace, close enough that our hands nearly brushed between us.
Renee caught my eye. We smiled at the same time and kept walking. The bar was a five-minute walk and neither of us were in a hurry.

"I'm a fundamentally different person," Milo said for the third time since we'd left the cooking class, steering us toward the bar like he'd been given directions by God. "I have been changed at a molecular level. I will never recover."
"You're going to talk about Keith for the rest of the trip, aren't you," said Cass, already resigned to the rest of her evening.
"I'm going to talk about Keith for the rest of my life. I'm going to tell my future children about Keith. I'm going to work Keith into my wedding vows."
"Bold of you to assume a wedding," Talia said, as if she were offering condolences.
"The universe owes me, Talia. The universe owes me a man and a wedding and a Keith-free cooking experience, and so far it has delivered on none of those things."
Renee was walking beside me, close enough that our arms brushed every few steps without either of us adjusting the distance. She smelled like garlic and allspice and the warm, slightly smoky air of Diana's kitchen, and so did I, and there was something comfortable about that — two people carrying the same afternoon on their skin.
"None?" Renee asked.
Milo considered this. "The man is pending. The wedding is aspirational. The cooking experience was a war crime. So technically none of them."
"Encouraging," I said.
"I'm an optimist."
"You're delusional," said Cass. "But in a way I've grown to respect."
The bar came into view around the bend, half-full in the gap between afternoon and evening. Nico was behind the counter, unhurried as always, finishing a drink for a couple at the far end.
Talia nodded toward the bar. "Pretty sure the universe already gave you the man."
Milo had gone quiet, which was more incriminating than anything he could have said. He smoothed his shirt — Renee and I exchanged a look — and walked the rest of the path trying very hard to be the version of himself that didn't vibrate.
We reached the bar together. All five of us, pulling up stools, officially here for drinks and unofficially here for whatever Milo was about to do to himself.
"Evening," Milo said to Nico, and his voice only cracked slightly.
"Hey." Nico glanced up with a grin that didn't need a translator.
Then he turned back to the bar and started building a drink. Milo watched him work and said nothing, which was its own kind of emergency.
Nico set it in front of Milo. Amber, neat, one ice cube.
"So that's just automatic now," Talia said, settling onto her stool.
"It's not — he's a professional. He remembers orders. That's customer service."
"He didn't ask what you wanted."
"Maybe I'm predictable."
"You are many things," said Cass. "Predictable isn't one of them."
Talia looked between Milo and Nico. "You're both just going to stand there and pretend this is normal?"
"It is normal," Milo said, gripping his glass a little tighter than normal.
Nico picked up a cloth. "I like making it." He started wiping down the bar. "Not a lot of guests make me learn a new drink."
"That was unnecessary," Milo said, very quietly.
"You're welcome," Nico said, and moved along the bar to us.
"It was accurate," Renee said, shifting on the stool next to mine.
I ordered for Renee and me without thinking about it. Gin for me, top-shelf rum with lime for her.
"Did you just order for me?"
"You were going to order it anyway."
Nico brought the drinks. Mine was something with grapefruit and an herb I couldn't place — cold, slightly bitter, immediately good. He set Renee's rum in front of her with the lime already on the rim.
"You know her drink order," Milo said, recovering enough to redirect.
"She's been drinking it all week. It's not investigative work."
"It's a little bit investigative," said Talia, propping her chin on her hand.
Wonderful. The Milo show was over and apparently mine had started.
"How is the rum?" I asked.
"It's adequate."
"She's blushing," Milo announced.
"I am not blushing," Renee said. "It's warm in here."
"It's an open-air bar. There is no 'in here.'"
"We're on a tropical island, Milo." Renee took another sip and set the glass down, composure fully restored. "The entire region is warm. That's the premise."
Cass reached for the bowl of cashews Nico had set down — another small, unprompted thing nobody made a speech about — and lined three up on the bar in front of her, considering them like she was evaluating a legal argument. "I want to acknowledge," she said, "that one week ago, one of you was hiding in a bush."
"I was not hiding in a bush," Milo said immediately.
"Strategically positioned near foliage," I corrected.
"Thank you, Ade."
"And two of you," Cass continued, eating a cashew without rush, "had the warmth of a custody deposition."
Renee shifted on her stool. Her shoulder brushed mine and stayed. "We were establishing boundaries."
"You were exhausting," Milo said. "Both of you. I've never seen two people work that hard to not be in the same conversation."
"It was impressive," Talia said. "Like watching two magnets repel each other in real time."
"I almost took notes," said Cass. "Some of my clients could use that level of commitment to avoidance."
I took a drink. The gin-grapefruit thing was growing on me — Nico had a knack for making you something better than what you'd ordered. "We've evolved."
"Have you," said Cass.
"Significantly," Renee confirmed beside me, her voice so neutral it was practically confrontational. She was close enough that I could feel her arm against mine, warm through the fabric.
"Evolved," Talia repeated. She looked at Cass. Cass ate another cashew and said nothing, which from Cass was practically a standing ovation.
Milo lifted his glass. "We all survived today. Some of us thrived. Some of us were paired with Keith. I'd like to propose a toast."
"To what?" I asked.
"To survival. To growth. To the enduring psychological trauma of watching a grown man put a communal spoon back in a shared bowl and then do it again."
"Twice," Renee added.
"I will carry that with me for the rest of my life." Milo touched his glass to Renee's, then to mine, reached across to clink Talia's and Cass's. "To Thursday. And to Nico, who makes the best drinks on this island and about whom I am being heroically calm."
"Heroically," I agreed.
"Thank you."
Nico was clearing glasses along the bar and paused next to Milo — not long, not performed, just the smallest interruption in his usual economy of motion — and said something too low for the rest of us to catch. Whatever it was made Milo go very still and then very carefully pick up his drink and take a measured sip, staring straight ahead at the bottles behind the bar as if they had suddenly become the most interesting bottles in the Western Hemisphere.
Talia vibrated.
"Don't," Cass warned.
"I'm not doing anything."
"You're about to."
"I'm simply sitting here with my wife enjoying a beverage at a bar on a beautiful island where nothing out of the ordinary is occurring."
Milo set his glass down and turned to us, holding something he wasn't sure was fragile or explosive. "He said he had fun the other night."
"Riveting," said Cass.
"He just said that?" Talia said.
"He leaned over and said it like he was telling me the specials," Milo said, gripping his glass with both hands.
"That's worse," I said.
"That's so much worse," Milo agreed, like a man receiving a diagnosis.
"Or better," said Cass. "It means he's comfortable enough to say it without making it a thing. That's not nothing."
Milo stared at her. Cass being kind without a punchline was uncharted territory and he looked like he didn't know whether to thank her or check for a pulse.
"Or you've broken him down," she added. "Like water on a stone."
I leaned slightly into Renee's shoulder. "We should let him have this."
"Should we?"
"He survived Keith."
"That's fair," Renee conceded, and I could feel the low register of her voice through the point where our arms were touching.
Talia ordered a second round. Then a third. The sun went down the way it does when nobody's paying attention to it, and at some point Nico stopped asking what we wanted and just kept the glasses full, and nobody checked the time for at least an hour. A week ago these people were strangers, and now I couldn't remember what the trip was supposed to feel like without them.
"So the real question," Milo said, waving a cashew, "is whether Keith is going to show up at any other resort activities this week and if so whether I need to file for a restraining order."
"He's a guest," Renee said. "He has rights."
"He put the spoon back in the bowl."
"He did."
"Twice."
"And he was wrong twice. And it's over. Let it go."
"Renee, he wiped his hands on my apron. Without asking. Like I was a piece of furniture."
"You're spiraling about a spoon."
"It's not about the spoon. It's about boundaries."
"You have no boundaries," I said. "You hid in a bush and screamed at someone you'd met in a parking lot."
"That's different. That's warmth." He looked at me like I'd compared a symphony to a car alarm. "Keith had no warmth. Keith had a recipe card and a determination to follow it into the ground."
"He measured allspice for forty-five seconds," Talia said. "I was timing it."
"Of course you were," said Cass.
"I'm a designer. I notice precision."
"You notice everything."
"I notice you, baby," Talia said sweetly, and Cass looked at the ceiling and took a long sip of her drink.
The sun was almost gone — just the last of it sitting on the water, orange and ridiculous — and I'd turned to watch it without realizing I'd stopped listening to Milo.
Renee turned her glass in her hand and looked at me sideways. "You're staring at the sunset."
"I'm not staring."
"You look like you're about to write something down."
I looked at her. She was doing the thing she always did — the flat observation delivered with zero inflection — except now there was warmth underneath it that I wasn't imagining and she wasn't hiding, and the combination of precise and warm was doing something to me I hadn't figured out how to manage. "Maybe I am."
"About the sunset?"
"I was thinking more about the rum."
"The rum."
"Very inspiring. The way it sits in the glass. The cultural significance of lime."
"You should write that down," Renee said, and took a sip with her eyes still on me. "Sounds like a bestseller."
"Working title: Citrus and Feelings."
"I'd read it."
"You'd read it to make fun of it."
"I'd read it," she repeated, and the second time she said it something in her voice shifted half a degree toward sincerity.
Talia made a sound like a balloon losing air very slowly.
"Talia," said Cass.
"I didn't say anything."
"Your face said everything."
"My face is an involuntary response to external stimuli and I won't be shamed for it."
"I just want to point out," Milo said, "that two hours ago, Renee was standing behind Ade with her hands on her hands teaching her how to use a knife, and now they're over here having a conversation about lime as if we're all blind."
"It was a cooking technique," I said.
"It was pornographic."
"It was proper knife safety," Renee said, unbothered in a way that was its own kind of weapon. "She was going to hurt herself."
"I was not going to hurt myself."
Renee turned to me with one eyebrow raised — patient, amused, completely unwilling to let this stand. "You were holding the knife like a tennis racket."
"I have since improved."
"You have since had someone else do all the cutting."
"Delegation. That's leadership."
"That's avoidance."
"I chopped ginger."
"You made ginger confetti." She said it with her mouth doing the thing again, the almost-smile she didn't bother managing, and I was close enough to see the way her eyes changed when she was trying not to laugh.
"At least nobody made us do interpretive movement," Talia said.
Cass set her glass down. "No."
"What?" Milo leaned in immediately.
"Couples' retreat," Talia said. "Sedona. The instructor decided we needed to communicate exclusively through movement for an entire afternoon."
"Interpretive movement," Cass repeated, as if reading charges aloud.
"It was expressive and healing and I was very open to the process."
"You were alone on the studio floor," Cass said. "I was on a rock."
"Doing what?" I asked.
"Reading depositions."
"While your wife danced alone in a studio?" Renee said.
"It wasn't dancing," Talia said. "It was emotional expression through the body."
"It was dancing," said Cass. "And I was working."
"The instructor said it was the most emotionally honest session she'd ever witnessed."
"The instructor was looking at you performing alone on a floor while your wife sat outside reading legal briefs," Milo said. "That is emotionally honest. Just not the way she meant it."
"Non-participation is itself a form of communication," Cass said. "The instructor was simply too enlightened to recognize a protest."
"You rehearsed that," Talia said, poking Cass in the arm.
"I've been saying it for three years. It's gotten better with age."
"That's nothing," Milo said. "I did a wellness weekend. They gave me a roommate named Gerald who gargled apple cider vinegar every morning at six."
"Gargled it?" asked Cass, already regretting the question.
"Gargled it. And referred to his body exclusively as 'the temple.'"
"As in — " Talia started.
"As in 'the temple needs rest.' 'The temple doesn't process gluten.' 'I need to fuel the temple before we begin.'"
"I'd have left," I said.
"I tried. He also did a guided meditation before lights out. Full speaking volume. In the dark. I was lying there trying to figure out if you could legally claim self-defense against a meditation."
"You could not," said Cass flatly.
"I packed my bag after the first night. He saw me and started crying. Said my energy was essential to his healing journey."
"And you stayed," Renee said, already knowing the answer.
"He was crying, Renee."
"He was gargling," Renee said, like that settled it.
"Those things aren't mutually exclusive."
Renee looked at me, confirming a thesis she'd clearly been developing all week. "This is the man you chose as your first friend on this island."
"I didn't choose him. He started talking on a shuttle van and never stopped. Then he hid in a bush and screamed at me."
"You're welcome," Milo said. "Without me, you'd have spent this entire week at a desk producing nothing and talking to nobody and you know it."
He wasn't wrong, and the annoying part was that he knew he wasn't wrong, and the more annoying part was that I was glad he wasn't wrong. A week ago I would've died before admitting that, even to myself.
"You literally had to be dragged into this group," Milo said, waving a hand at the rest of them.
"The thing is," I said, "I'm terrible at anything that involves letting someone else lead."
"I believe that," said Cass, tilting her glass in my direction.
"Sasha signed us up for salsa classes once. Six weeks. Every Tuesday. I lasted all six because she paid in advance and told me quitting was not an option."
"Were you any good?" Talia asked.
"They rotate partners throughout the class. The first guy I got paired with tried to lead and I just — didn't let him."
"You fought him," Milo said, already grinning.
"I didn't fight him. I just wasn't going where he wanted me to go. By week three the instructor had started putting me with Sasha because nobody else would rotate in. She told the class Sasha and I had 'a special dynamic.' She meant I was unpartnerable."
Milo was already leaning forward. Talia had her hand over her mouth.
"Sasha was a natural. Hips, rhythm, the whole thing. She'd be across the room spinning with some guy named Diego and I'd be counting under my breath like I was doing math homework. Out loud. Apparently that's frowned upon."
"How did it end?" Renee asked.
"Week six. Showcase night. Every pair had to do a routine in front of the class. Sasha and I had rehearsed. We had a whole thing planned. I went left when she went right and elbowed her in the face."
Milo put his drink down. Talia grabbed Cass's arm.
"Not hard. But hard enough that her nose bled. In front of the whole class. The instructor ran over and Sasha was on the floor laughing with blood on her shirt and I was standing there apologising to everyone in the room individually."
"Individually," Cass said, like she needed to hear it twice to believe it.
"Every single person. One by one. The instructor. The students. Diego. A woman named Diane who'd been nothing but kind to me for six weeks and who I'd never once been able to follow."
"Was Sasha okay?" Renee asked.
"Sasha still brings it up. Every time I say I'm good at something, she says 'you're good at salsa too' and then does the elbow."
Renee laughed — the kind that changed her entire face and made her lean into me without deciding to.
She caught me looking at her when the table settled. "What."
"You should do that more often."
"Do what?"
"Laugh like nobody's watching."
"I wasn't aware anyone was."
"What would it take for you to do it again?"
"Show me the salsa," she said, and took a sip of her drink.
The evening settled. Talia stifled a yawn against Cass's shoulder, and Cass rubbed the back of her neck without looking.
"We should head out," Talia said. "I set an alarm for sunrise and I'd like to hit snooze at least four times, which requires actually being in bed."
"She sets an alarm to beat the sunrise," Cass said, standing, "and then negotiates with it for forty minutes."
"The negotiation is part of the ritual."
"The negotiation is you saying 'five more minutes' eight times."
"Math was never my strong suit." Talia kissed Cass on the jaw, quick and familiar. "Night, everyone."
"Night," I said.
Cass raised a hand as they turned. "Don't stay up too late."
"That sounded like it was aimed at someone specific," Renee said.
"It was aimed at everyone equally," Cass said, not turning around. "Some people just caught it more than others."
The bar was quieter now, the evening crowd thinning into the late-night regulars — a couple at the far end sharing a dessert, a woman reading alone with a glass of red wine. Milo had drifted. He'd migrated down the bar, drink in hand, until he was on the stool closest to Nico's station. Nico was closing out tabs and wiping down the bar and talking to him in that low, unhurried way of his, both of them leaned in slightly, the distance between them measured in inches, and Milo said something that made Nico pause what he was doing and look at him. Milo just stayed where he was and kept talking.
Renee finished her drink and set the glass down.
"Walk?" she asked.
"Yeah."
We left without saying goodbye to Milo. He wouldn't have noticed if we'd set the bar on fire.
The path from the bar opened onto the beach where the sand was still warm from the afternoon. I slipped my shoes off and carried them, and Renee did the same, and we walked along the water's edge where the tide had pulled back and left the sand cool and firm under our feet. The noise from the bar faded behind us — music, someone laughing, the distant clink of Nico's bottles — until it was just the water and the wind and the sound of our feet in wet sand and the two of us.
"I had a good time tonight," Renee said, and the way she said it made it sound like a discovery, like she was surprised by her own sentence.
"You sound surprised."
"I'm not surprised. I'm — adjusting to it. I don't usually have this. A group of people I actually like being around for more than an hour."
"Your threshold is an hour?"
"Generous estimate," said Renee. "Most people have about forty-five minutes of interesting in them before they start repeating themselves."
"How long have I got?"
She looked at me. We were walking close, and the moonlight was doing something to her face that made it hard to remember what I'd been saying. "Jury's still out."
"Still deliberating after a week?"
"It's a complicated case. There's a lot of evidence."
"For or against?" I asked.
"Mostly for," said Renee, and glanced back at the water, and I could see her smiling.
We walked further. The resort lights were small behind us now, and the beach opened into the stretch beyond the main swimming area where the sand curved toward the rocks and the tree line pressed closer to the water. The sky was getting darker out here, the stars multiplying the way they only did away from the mainland, and the water was flat and calm and silver-black and I could hear it breathing against the shore in a rhythm that wasn't trying to be anything.
"So," said Renee. "How are your knife skills feeling post-class?"
"Exceptional. World-class. I could julienne a carrot blindfolded."
"You couldn't julienne a carrot with a diagram and a support team."
"I had a support team. She was standing behind me with her hands on mine."
"And you still produced ginger confetti."
"The ginger was artistic. It had texture."
"It had chaos."
"Same thing." I kicked at the surf and a spray of warm water caught my ankle. "You're a good teacher, though. Genuinely."
She looked at me. "Thank you."
"Don't let that go to your head."
"I would never."
"You already look smug."
"I don't do smug," said Renee, looking incredibly smug.
"You know," I said, "I'm developing a theory that beaches at night are dangerous for my judgment."
Renee glanced over. "Is that so."
"Empirically supported. The last time I was on a beach at night, I made some very questionable decisions."
"Questionable."
"From a pure risk-assessment standpoint."
"Interesting." She was deciding whether to let me keep going or cut me off at the knees. "I remember those decisions being fairly mutual."
"They were. That's what made them questionable. Mutual questionable decisions are the most dangerous kind. No one's exercising oversight."
She smiled — sudden and warm and given without checking it first. "I think your judgment was fine."
"You're biased. You were the other half of the questionable decision."
"I was the more composed half."
"You leaned in first."
"You leaned back in," said Renee, and the way she said it — simple, undefended, like confirming a fact she'd already filed — made my breath catch in a way I decided to let happen instead of pretend away.
"I did," I said.
"And?"
"And I'd do it again. For the record."
"Good." She said it simply, looking ahead at the dark stretch of beach in front of us. "Because I would too. For the record."
We walked a few more steps in a silence that had nothing uncomfortable in it. The water came up over my feet and retreated, warm and steady, and I could feel the edge of her hand brushing mine as we moved.
"You're quiet," said Renee.
"I'm thinking."
"About what?"
"About whether this is the part of the night where we keep being funny or the part where we stop."
She considered this. "Can we do both?"
"Probably. We're versatile."
"We are," said Renee, and something in how she said it wasn't a joke at all.
We found a spot. A stretch of sand past the rocks where the beach flattened out and the water was close enough to hear but far enough that the sand was dry. I sat down and she sat beside me, close. We looked out at the water for a while and let the quiet take up the space where words had been.
"Tell me something," said Renee.
"What?"
"Just... anything."
I dug my toes into the sand and thought about it. There were a hundred things I could have said — safe things, funny things, things that would have kept us in the register we'd been in all night, easy and warm and not too close to anything that mattered. But we were past the rocks and the bar was far away and she'd asked for something real, and the night felt like it deserved that.
"You remember what I said at the bonfire," I said. "About the block. The three months of nothing."
"I remember."
"It's not nothing anymore. But whatever's coming out now — I don't know what to do with it. I don't even know where it's going."
Renee was quiet. Not the heavy kind of quiet that meant she was formulating a response. The kind that meant she was genuinely listening and wasn't going to interrupt.
"I sat at my desk at home for three months and everything I wrote was dead on arrival. And then I got here and something opened up and I started writing something that actually feels alive, and I'm terrified to look at it too directly because every time I try to understand why it's working I'm afraid I'll break whatever's making it work."
"So you're just writing and not asking questions."
"I'm just writing and not asking questions."
"That sounds like a terrible long-term strategy."
I laughed. "It is. I'm fully aware. But right now it's working. The pages are rough and they need editing and some of it is probably garbage, but it's alive. And after three months of nothing, I'll take garbage with a heartbeat over polished emptiness any time."
She pulled her knees up and rested her arms across them. The moonlight caught the edge of her shoulder and the line of her jaw and the way her hair fell forward when she leaned. "Then write it. Whatever it is, wherever it's coming from. Don't talk yourself out of it."
I wanted to tell her. I wanted to say: you're in it. You're the reason it's alive. I haven't told you because I don't know how to tell you without it sounding like either a confession or a betrayal and I'm not sure which one it is.
I didn't say any of it.
"You make it sound simple," I said instead.
"It is simple. You're the one making it complicated."
"That might be my core skill."
"It might." She looked at me. "Most things are simpler than the person doing them thinks they are. You know what it is. You're just not sure you're allowed to write it."
That was closer to the truth than she could have known.
We sat with it. The water moved in and out, steady and unhurried, and a bird somewhere in the dark made a sound I couldn't identify — something between a question and an answer, repeated twice and then gone.
"Can I ask you something?" I said.
"You just did."
"The wit. Astounding."
"Go ahead."
I picked up a handful of sand and let it run through my fingers, watching the grains catch the moonlight as they fell. "When you came here — what were you actually looking for?"
She didn't answer immediately. With Renee, the quick responses were the deflections. The pauses were where the real answers lived.
"I'd already ended things. You know about my mother. I had this trip booked and I couldn't think of a reason not to come that didn't sound like hiding, so I came. I told myself I needed space and quiet and to not have to be responsible for how anyone else felt." She paused. "That was the plan. Space. Quiet. Figure out who I was outside of the relationship and the grief and the work. Come home with an answer."
"Did you get one?"
"No." She said it plainly, like she was getting the words out before she could decide to keep them. "I got something else instead. I got a group of people who wouldn't leave me alone and a woman I couldn't stand who turned out to be — " She stopped. Looked at the water. "I came here to heal and have time to myself and I don't know what I'm doing anymore."
The silence that followed wasn't uncomfortable. It was two people sitting inside the same uncertainty and recognizing it in each other.
"The relationship that ended," I said. "Was it — did you see it coming?"
"I saw it for about six months before I did anything about it. We wanted different things. She wanted — stability. Permanence. The conversation about moving in together, the shared calendar, the five-year plan. And I wasn't against any of that in theory. I just wasn't sure I wanted it with her, specifically, and I couldn't figure out how to say that without it sounding like I was the problem. So I stayed longer than I should have and then I ended it and she told me I was incapable of letting anyone close enough to matter, and I spent a month wondering if she was right."
"Was she?"
Renee looked at me. Her eyes in the dark, steady and serious. "I don't know. Maybe. I'm careful with people. I take a long time to decide if someone is safe, and by the time I decide, they've usually gotten tired of waiting. And then they leave, and they tell me it's because I never let them in, and I think — I did. I was just slow about it. And slow apparently doesn't count."
She said it without self-pity, like a finding she'd documented and filed under things-that-are-true-about-me. I recognized the clinical precision of it — the physical therapist in her, diagnosing her own patterns with the same steady accuracy she brought to everything else.
"For what it's worth," I said, "I don't think slow doesn't count."
"You've known me a week."
"I've known you a week and you just told me something you probably haven't said out loud since it happened."
She went quiet. The water kept its rhythm. Somewhere down the beach, a wave broke bigger than the rest, and the sound rolled toward us and faded.
"That's a fair point," she said eventually, and I could hear in her voice that she meant it, that the observation had landed somewhere she hadn't expected it to reach.
I pulled my knees up, mirroring her position, our shoulders pressed together. "I did this before too," I said. "Started something knowing it probably had an expiration date. It lasted about a year and a half, and for most of that time it was good — genuinely good. She was kind. She understood me in ways most people don't bother trying to, and she never made me feel like any part of who I am was a problem. But we wanted different things at different speeds, and I knew it early, and I stayed anyway because the good parts were good enough to make the rest feel manageable. Like if I just didn't look directly at the differences, they'd work themselves out." I dug my heels into the sand. "They didn't work themselves out. It ended. And I spent a long time afterward thinking maybe I would've hurt less if I'd just never started."
The waves kept their rhythm ahead of us.
"And now I'm sitting on a beach with someone I like and we both leave in two days and I already know how this math works."
"The math," she repeated.
"The math. Start something, leave Saturday, spend the next however-long trying to figure out if it was the island or if it was real, and either way someone ends up staring at their phone watching the texts get shorter."
"You think about this a lot."
"More than I should." More than I wanted to admit. More than I'd thought about the manuscript, about the block, about every question that was supposed to be the reason I came here. "I came here to write a book and instead I'm sitting in the sand with no shoes on next to a woman I screamed at on a sidewalk six days ago."
"You didn't scream."
"I projected."
"You projected," she agreed.
"How do you know?" I said. "Whether something is real or just — this. The island. The timing. Good rum and warm sand and being somewhere beautiful with someone who happens to be there."
"You're asking me?"
"You're the one who reads people for a living," I said.
"Bodies. I read bodies. People are a completely different problem."
"And yet."
She exhaled — slow, deliberate, like she was making room for an answer she hadn't planned to give.
"I think," she said slowly, "that you can't know. Not from inside it. Not while you're still in the place where it started. You can't take the island out of the equation because the island is where it happened. And maybe that means it's not real and maybe it means the island just gave us the space to actually see each other without all the noise we normally carry around, and those are two completely different things and there's no way to tell them apart."
"That's incredibly unhelpful."
"I know."
"That's the most eloquent version of 'I have no idea' I've ever heard."
"I'm a physical therapist. I'm trained to deliver bad news clearly."
I laughed. She laughed. And then we were both quiet again, and the quiet was different now — heavier, but not in a bad way. Heavy like something that had weight because it mattered.
"I keep waiting for it to make sense," I said.
It came out quieter than I'd meant it to. Less polished than anything I'd said on this trip, including the things I'd typed into a manuscript at four in the morning. It came out sounding like what it was — a question I didn't have an answer to, asked by a person who was used to having answers and had run out.
I could see her face in the dark, the moonlight catching the edge of her cheekbone and the line of her hair against her neck. She looked at me for a while without speaking, and I let her, because whatever she was searching for I wanted her to find it.
"Does it need to?" she asked.
"I keep thinking I should have figured it out by now. I'm a writer. I do this for a living. The part where you find the right words at the right time and the other person understands exactly what you mean."
"Is that how it works in your books?"
"In my books, both people are significantly more articulate and nobody has sand everywhere."
"You have sand everywhere?"
"An unreasonable amount. A geological amount."
She was smiling. Looking at the water, not at me, but smiling in the way I was starting to recognize as her version of feeling something and deciding not to manage it.
"I don't have a plan for Saturday," I said. "I don't know what the math looks like. I don't know if this is the island or if this is us. All I know is I'm here and I want to be here and you're the reason I want to be here and that's everything I've got."
Renee didn't answer right away. She looked at me, and her expression wasn't readable the way it usually was — the composure she kept like armour was somewhere else, and what was underneath it was open and unguarded and maybe a little scared, and I recognized the fear because it was the same one living in my own face.
"That's enough," she said.
Two words. No promise in them, no plan, no resolution to anything we'd spent the last hour circling. Just the decision to stop needing one.
I leaned my shoulder into hers. She leaned back. We sat like that for a while, shoulder to shoulder, looking at the water, not talking. The tide was coming in slowly — the water closer now than when we'd sat down, the wet sand creeping toward our feet. A breeze came off the ocean carrying salt and something tropical I still couldn't identify after a week, and I breathed it in and let the night be exactly what it was.
"Ade," Renee said after a while.
"Yeah."
"Thank you for asking."
At some point — I couldn't have said when — we'd gone from sitting to lying back on the sand. The sky was enormous — the sky you forgot existed when you lived in a city with streetlights and noise and everyone else's life pressing in. The stars were scattered across it in clusters and streams and solitary bright points, and there were more of them than I'd ever seen, and I'd been here a week and they still took me by surprise.
I was aware of her beside me. The sound of her breathing. The warmth along the entire length of my arm where it lay next to hers in the sand.
Her fingers found mine.
Not reaching, not grasping. Just her hand moving across the small distance between us until our fingers touched and then intertwined, and she held on, and I held back, and neither of us said anything about it.
I turned my head.
She turned hers.
She was right there. Inches away. Her eyes steady and open and not looking anywhere else and not trying to.
I kissed her.
It wasn't like the cove. The cove had been a question — nervous, surprising, the breathless uncertainty of a first time. This was something else. Slow and unhurried and warm, her mouth tasting like lime and rum and the particular sweetness of a night that had taken its time getting here and earned every minute. Her free hand came up and touched the side of my face and I leaned into it, and she kissed me back with the steadiness that was the most Renee thing about her — certain, deliberate, present.
When we pulled apart she didn't go far. Her forehead rested against mine for a moment, and I felt her smile, our hands were still tangled together between us in the sand.
Everything I'd said about the not knowing was still true. But then lying next to her, I looked into her eyes — the kind of moment I'd have cut from my own manuscript for being too obvious. It didn't stand a chance.
"Come with me," I said.

The brochure was following me.
Not literally. I wasn't losing my mind. But in the four days since the lunch with Maribel, that glossy tri-fold piece of turquoise propaganda had somehow migrated across my apartment with the quiet determination of something that wanted to be looked at. Day one, I'd dropped it on the kitchen counter next to the mail and the La Croix graveyard, where it could be safely ignored. Day two, it was on the coffee table, which I attributed to having moved the mail. Day three, it was on my desk, leaning against the laptop like a passive-aggressive coworker who'd left a note instead of having a conversation. And now, day four, it was on my nightstand.
I had no memory of putting it there. None. I had not, at any point, consciously decided that the last thing I wanted to see before falling asleep was a stock photo of turquoise water and a tagline that sounded like it was written by a yoga instructor having a spiritual emergency. And yet there it was, propped up between my phone charger and a half-empty glass of water, looking at me with the serene confidence of something that knew it was winning.
I was not interested. I was a grown-ass adult with a career and a deadline and a perfectly functional apartment, and I did not need a tropical island to sort out my professional life. People who needed tropical islands to sort out their professional lives were people who put inspirational quotes on their bathroom mirrors, and I had too much self-respect for that. I had a water stain on my ceiling instead. Much more grounding.
Maribel had texted once, two days after the lunch. Just a link to the resort's Instagram page and a single word: Thinking? I'd replied with Working which was a lie so transparent that I was fairly sure she could see through it from across the city. She hadn't responded, which was worse than if she'd pushed. Maribel's silence was strategic. She knew that leaving me alone with the idea was more effective than arguing for it, because arguing gave me something to push against and silence gave me nothing to do but sit with it.
Four days of not writing. Four days of opening the laptop, staring at the cursor, typing something terrible, deleting it, and closing the laptop again. Four days of checking my sales dashboard and my Instagram and my email and finding nothing in any of them that made the blank page any less blank. It was starting to feel personal — like the empty document wasn't just empty but actively refusing to cooperate, sitting there with the quiet confident patience of a villain who knew the hero wasn't ready for the fight. The routine hadn't changed. The only thing that had changed was that now, every time I closed the laptop, the brochure was somewhere in my peripheral vision, being turquoise and smug.
I'd tried to distract myself. I'd reorganized my bookshelf — by color this time, because alphabetical had stopped feeling like enough and genre was a political decision I wasn't prepared to make. I'd deep-cleaned the bathroom, which was the kind of task I only undertook when avoiding something truly terrifying. I'd watched four episodes of Love Lagoon: Second Chances which was a reality dating show about exes being stranded on an island together, and yes, the irony of watching people trapped on an island while avoiding going to an island was not lost on me. I'd even called my mother, which was how I knew I was genuinely desperate — not because I didn't love my mother, but because calling her inevitably led to the question "how's the writing going?" and I'd used up all my good lies on Maribel.
The apartment was cleaner than it had been in months. My browser history was a graveyard of half-read articles about overcoming creative blocks, each one offering advice I'd already tried ("change your environment," "write badly on purpose," "try morning pages") and none of them acknowledging the fundamental problem, which was that my brain had apparently decided it was done producing words and had not consulted me about the decision. Whatever was sitting on the other side of that blank page — whatever invisible, stubborn thing had parked itself between me and a first sentence — it wasn't budging. And it had more patience than I did.
I was on the couch in sweatpants and an oversized hoodie — the outfit of someone who had officially given up on the day — when my phone buzzed.
Sasha's face filled the screen before I'd even finished accepting the video call. She was in her apartment, cross-legged on her bed, pulling apart a rotisserie chicken with her bare hands over a paper towel like some kind of beautiful, well-adjusted caveperson. Her curly hair was pulled back in the kind of loose knot that looked effortless and probably was, because Sasha was one of those people whose default state was somehow put-together even when they were eating a whole chicken in bed.
"You look terrible," said Sasha, by way of greeting.
"Thank you."
"I mean it. You look like you've been indoors for a week."
"Four days."
"Same thing. When was the last time you went outside?"
"I went to Sorrentino's on Tuesday."
"That was four days ago. Have you left the apartment since?"
I considered lying. Sasha's face made it clear that she already knew the answer and was asking purely so I could hear myself say it out loud.
"I went to the bodega yesterday. I needed cream for my coffee."
"The bodega is downstairs."
"It's still outside. There was wind and everything."
Sasha pointed a greasy finger at me through the screen. "What's going on? And don't say 'nothing' because you texted me three separate times today and one of them was just a picture of your ceiling."
She was right. I had texted her a picture of my ceiling. In my defense, I'd been lying on the floor at the time because I'd read somewhere that changing your physical position could unlock creative thinking, and the only thing it had unlocked was a profound sense of my own ridiculousness and an angle on the light fixture I could have gone my whole life without seeing.
"Maribel wants me to go to a resort," I said.
Sasha's hand paused midway to the chicken. "A resort."
"An LGBTQ+ adults-only resort on a private island somewhere off the coast. It's called The Whispering Palms, which sounds like a spa that's also haunted, and the tagline is 'Your Most Authentic Self' which I'm fairly sure is a threat."
"Hold on." Sasha wiped her hands on the paper towel and held up a hand. "Adults only?"
"Yes."
"LGBTQ+?"
"Yes."
"On a private island?"
"Yes, Sasha. On a private island. In the ocean. Where islands typically are."
"That sounds amazing." Sasha was already grinning.
"It sounds like a place where people go to find themselves and come back with crystals and new dietary restrictions," I said.
"Those things aren't mutually exclusive," said Sasha, tearing off another piece of chicken. "Crystals are pretty and some dietary restrictions are legitimate."
"You're missing the point."
"You're burying the lead." Sasha leaned closer to the screen. "Why does Maribel want you to go to a resort?"
"Because I can't write, and she thinks if I go sit on a beach for a nine days I'll magically become inspired and produce a bestselling manuscript. She knows the manager. A guy named Emmett something. They went to Columbia together. She showed me a brochure with turquoise water and a stock photo of people laughing like they'd just been told the funniest joke in the history of human civilization."
"Back up." Sasha held up a hand. "How was the lunch?"
"The lunch was fine. The lunch was an ambush disguised as Italian food."
"What did she say?"
"She said the usual Maribel things. The window is closing. The momentum needs to be maintained. My emotional specificity has gone missing. She told me I'm avoiding vulnerability like someone's going to grade me on it, which is — okay, it was annoyingly accurate, but she didn't have to say it while I was eating rigatoni."
Sasha's eyebrows went up. "She said that?"
"She said it and then she sat there with her perfect posture and her sparkling water and waited for me to agree with her."
"Did you?"
"I ordered a second glass of wine. So, basically, yes."
Sasha snorted. "And then she pulled out the brochure?"
"And then she pulled out the brochure. Like a magician producing a rabbit, except the rabbit was a tropical island and the magic was making me feel like a dysfunctional hermit over lunch."
"I mean... are you a dysfunctional hermit?"
"That's not the point."
"That's entirely the point," said Sasha.
"Okay." Sasha pushed the chicken aside, which meant she was taking this seriously. Sasha only stopped eating for serious conversations and fire alarms. "And what do you think?"
"I think it's ridiculous. I think you don't fix writer's block by going on vacation. I think I'm not the kind of person who goes to a resort and does — what, group activities? Beach yoga? Trust falls with strangers? I don't do trust falls, Sasha. I have trust issues that preclude falling."
"You have trust issues that preclude a lot of things," said Sasha, like she was reading from a file she'd been keeping.
"That's not helpful."
"It's accurate. Keep going. What else?"
"What else is that it's probably expensive — it's a private island, those things aren't cheap — and it's impractical and I should be here working, not doing trust exercises on a beach and pretending that relaxation is a creative strategy," I said, aware that I was listing objections at a speed that suggested I'd been rehearsing them.
"Are you done?" Sasha asked.
"I might have a few more points."
"You've been thinking about this for four days," said Sasha.
"I have not been —"
"You texted me a ceiling photo, Ade. You're spiraling. You've been sitting in your apartment thinking about this resort you claim you don't want to go to, and the most interesting thing you could share with me was plaster."
I opened my mouth. Closed it. She had me.
"The brochure is on my nightstand," I said quietly.
Sasha's eyebrows went up. Not a lot — just enough to communicate that this was, in her professional opinion as my best friend, extremely telling.
"I didn't put it there on purpose."
"Ade."
"It migrated."
"Brochures don't migrate," said Sasha, with the patient calm of someone talking a stranger off a ledge.
"This one does. I think Maribel gave me a haunted brochure."
Sasha was smiling now — the specific smile she reserved for moments when I was being ridiculous and she loved me for it but was also going to say something I didn't want to hear.
"You want to go," said Sasha.
"I absolutely do not."
"You want to go and you're mad about it," said Sasha, like she was announcing the weather.
"I'm not mad. I'm resistant."
"Ade, you put a brochure on your nightstand. That's not resistance. That's foreplay."
I pulled a throw pillow into my lap and squeezed it, because my hands needed something to do that wasn't picking up the brochure and reading it for the fifth time in four days.
"Even if I wanted to go — and I'm not saying I do — what would be the point? I go sit on a beach for a days. I come back with a sunburn and some photos for Instagram and I'm still the same person who can't write. The location doesn't change what's happening in my head."
Sasha tilted her head. "Maybe the location isn't supposed to change what's in your head. Maybe it's supposed to put something new there."
"That's very philosophical. Did you get that from a podcast?"
"I got it from four days of texts that were either complaints about your toaster or photos of your ceiling. Ade, when was the last time you talked to someone who wasn't me or Maribel?"
I started to answer and then stopped, because the answer was embarrassing enough in my own head and saying it out loud was going to make it real.
"Exactly," said Sasha. "You've been living in a bubble. You, your laptop, your apartment, and the same two people who've been in your life for years. That's not a life, that's a holding pattern. And I love you, but you can't keep pulling from the same well and expecting it to fill back up on its own."
"I'm not pulling from a well. I'm not pulling from anything. That's the problem."
"Right. Because you've been alone. And I don't mean alone like single — I mean alone like isolated. When was the last time you had a conversation with someone who didn't already know you? Someone who didn't know about the book or the block or the apartment or any of it?"
"I talk to people."
"The barista at the coffee shop doesn't count."
"We have a rapport."
"She knows your order. That's not a rapport, that's a transaction." Sasha shifted on the bed, tucking her legs underneath her and leaning forward in a way that meant the chicken portion of the evening was over and the truth portion was beginning. "You used to be the person who could walk into a room full of strangers and walk out with three stories and someone's phone number. Remember that? Remember when you actually let people in instead of sitting in your apartment judging brochures?"
That one landed. I didn't have a joke ready for it, which was how I knew it was true.
"I don't judge brochures," I said weakly.
"You called the tagline a threat."
"It is a threat. 'Your Most Authentic Self' is corporate for 'we're going to make you do something uncomfortable and charge you for it.'"
Sasha leaned back against her headboard, arms crossed, letting the silence do the work she'd already started.
"Go meet people," Sasha said finally. "Not for the book. Not because Maribel told you to. Just — go be around humans you haven't met before. Have a conversation that surprises you. Let someone say something you didn't expect. That's all. Just let some new air into whatever room you've locked yourself in."
"And that's going to fix my writer's block?"
"I don't know. Maybe not." Sasha shrugged. "But it might remind you that you're actually interesting when you're not hiding in your apartment being miserable about it."
"I'm not miserable. I'm... creatively constipated."
"That's the worst thing you've ever said."
"I stand by it."
"Please don't." Sasha laughed — the real one, not the polite one she used when she was being diplomatic. "Look. I'm not going to sit here and pretend I know how to fix your writing. That's not my department. But I do know you. And the version of you that hasn't left her apartment in four days is not the version of you that wrote that book. That version of you was out in the world, talking to people, collecting experiences, being brave enough to feel things and then put them on a page. You can't do the last part if you've stopped doing all the parts that come before it."
"When did you get this wise?" I asked, mostly to stop her before she made me feel anything else.
"I've always been this wise. You just don't usually sit still long enough to hear it."
"Fine. I'm a little miserable."
"And," said Sasha, leaning forward with the grin that meant she was about to say something I was going to hate, "if you happen to meet someone out there who makes you stop thinking about word counts for five minutes... that wouldn't exactly hurt either."
"Oh, absolutely not," I said. "We're not doing that. This is not a romantic comedy. I'm not going to a tropical island and falling in love with some mysterious stranger by the pool."
"I didn't say love," said Sasha, with the kind of grin that absolutely meant love.
"I can see your face, Sasha. I know what that grin means."
"I'm saying go have a conversation with an interesting person. Maybe someone buys you a drink. Maybe you buy someone a drink. Maybe you just sit at a bar and someone says something that makes you laugh and for five minutes you're not Adrianna Moore, blocked writer, you're just a woman having a drink and talking to another human being."
"That sounds suspiciously like the setup to a romance novel," I said.
"Everything sounds like the setup to a romance novel to you because you write romance novels."
"I write erotica, not romance."
"Ade, your characters fall in love. They just also happen to have orgasms while they do it."
I opened my mouth to argue this point and then closed it, because she was right and I knew she was right and arguing would just prove her point faster.
"But fine," Sasha continued. "Go for the sunsets and the self-discovery. Ignore any attractive humans you encounter. Very healthy plan."
"Thank you. I think so too."
We looked at each other through the screen. Sasha was smiling. I was trying not to.
"I haven't even looked at the website," I said, as if this was evidence of something.
"Look at the website."
"I don't want to."
"Look at the website. I'll wait."
"This feels like a trap."
"It's a website, Ade. It's not going to reach through the screen and drag you onto a plane."
I stared at her. She stared back, unbothered, unblinking, radiating the calm patience of someone who had already won this argument and was just waiting for me to catch up.
"Fine," I said, and opened my laptop.
The Whispering Palms had a website that looked exactly the way you'd expect it to look. The homepage featured an aerial shot of the island that made it look roughly the size of a postage stamp in a very large ocean.
"It's a small island," I said. "And you have to take a boat to get there. I already told Maribel I don't do boats."
Sasha squinted at me through the screen. "Since when do you not do boats?"
"Since I found out this place requires one."
I scrolled past the bungalows before they could do any more damage to my resistance.
"There's a philosophical argument to be made that any location you can only leave by boat is functionally a prison with better towels."
"There is not a philosophical argument to be made about that. Show me the rooms."
I clicked on the accommodations page. The bungalows were, objectively, beautiful. White walls, wooden shutters, beds that looked like clouds had been pressured into rectangular shapes. Each one had its own porch — a real porch, with chairs and a little table and a view of either the ocean or the gardens. The kind of porch where you'd sit with a coffee in the morning and feel like a person in a movie about finding yourself.
"Those are nice," said Sasha, leaning closer to her screen. "Those are really nice, Ade."
"They're fine."
"They're gorgeous and you know it."
"They're rooms. They have beds and walls. All rooms have beds and walls."
"Most rooms don't have a view of the ocean and a ceiling fan that costs more than my rent," said Sasha.
I scrolled past the bungalows before they could do any more damage to my resistance.
The beachfront bar had its own page, which felt excessive for a bar but was admittedly well-photographed. Warm wood, open sides, barstools facing the water. The kind of place where you'd order something you couldn't pronounce and pretend you'd been drinking it your whole life.
There was a list of activities: guided nature walks, beach yoga, kayaking, snorkeling, game nights, karaoke, bonfires, cooking classes, and open mic nights.
"Open mic nights," I said aloud.
"Don't."
"An open mic night, Sasha. On a private island. Where you can't leave. So you're just trapped there while someone reads their poetry about the ocean, and you have to clap, and you can't even pretend you need to be somewhere else because you're on an island and there is nowhere else."
"You're spiraling about a hypothetical open mic," said Sasha, clearly delighted by it.
"I'm a writer who can't write. An open mic night is not a fun activity for me. That's a public execution."
"You don't have to do the open mic."
"I know I don't have to do the open mic. I'm not going."
"You're still scrolling."
She was right. I was still scrolling. And the worse thing — the thing I wasn't going to say out loud — was that with every page I scrolled past, the resistance was getting thinner. Not disappearing. Just wearing down, like a sweater you'd washed too many times. The shape was still there but you could see through it if the light hit right.
I stopped scrolling. The cursor hovered over a photo of two women walking along the beach at golden hour, laughing, barefoot, the water catching light around their ankles. It looked warm. It looked easy. It looked like the kind of moment that happened to people who weren't paralyzed by their own expectations.
"What if I go and nothing changes?" I said. The joke was gone from my voice and I didn't bother putting it back.
Sasha's expression changed. The teasing dropped away and what was left was just my best friend, looking at me like she could hear everything I wasn't saying.
"Then you come home with a tan and some good meals and nine or ten days away from that apartment. That's not nothing."
"And if I still can't write?"
"Then you still can't write, and we figure it out. But at least you'll have tried something different instead of staring at the same walls hoping they start talking back."
"What if it's just over a week of me sitting on a different surface being blocked? Instead of my desk chair it's a beach chair. Same problem, better weather."
"Maybe. Or maybe your brain needs something it can't get from your apartment. Different air, different people, different everything. You've been running on the same fumes for weeks, Ade. At some point the tank is empty and you need to go somewhere and fill it back up."
I didn't say anything for a moment. The apartment was quiet around me — the hum of the fridge, the faint sound of traffic from the street below.
"You're going to make me cry and I just did my skin care routine," I said.
"Then cry pretty. You know how."
She was right. She was annoyingly, undeniably right.
"I hate you," I said.
"You love me. Book the trip."
"I'll think about it."
Sasha didn't blink. "You've been thinking about it for four days. Book the trip."
"Goodnight, Sasha."
"Book the trip, Ade."
"Goodnight."
"I swear to god if you don't —"
"Goodnight!"
I ended the call. The apartment felt quieter than before.
I went through the motions of ending the day. Brushed my teeth. Washed my face. Changed into the oversized t-shirt I slept in — the one with a hole in the collar that I refused to throw away because it had reached the stage of softness that only came from years of wear, and finding a replacement would require emotional energy I didn't have. Got into bed. Turned off the light.
I thought about Sasha's words. Your brain needs something it can't get from your apartment.
I thought about Maribel tapping her temple. Stranger things have happened to worse writers.
I thought about the cursor blinking on an empty page, patient and unhurried, taking no responsibility for anything.
I turned the light back on.
I opened the laptop. Clicked on the booking page before I could talk myself out of it.
The page loaded in three seconds. Dates, room selection, payment. A private bungalow for nine days, starting next Friday. The calendar showed availability in green — plenty of open dates, as if the universe had cleared its schedule specifically to accommodate my breakdown.
I selected the dates. A bungalow with an ocean view, because if I was going to run away from my problems, I wasn't going to stare at a garden while I did it. The total appeared at the bottom of the screen and it was enough to make me wince — not enough to use as an excuse, the royalties from My Husband, My Bride had made sure of that, but enough to feel like a significant financial commitment to a decision I wasn't sure I was making.
I filled in my name. My email. My phone number. Each field felt like another step across a bridge I wasn't sure I wanted to be on.
My finger hovered over the confirmation button. My brain offered one last round of objections: this was impulsive, this was avoidance, this was spending money to run away from a problem that would be waiting for me when I got back. This was a woman in an oversized t-shirt with a hole in the collar sitting in bed at nearly midnight about to book a tropical vacation because her best friend told her to and she couldn't think of a good enough reason not to.
That was either the saddest thing I'd ever done or the bravest. I couldn't tell which, and I was too tired to figure it out.
I clicked it.
Booking confirmed. We can't wait to welcome you to The Whispering Palms at Coral Key.
Underneath, in smaller text: A confirmation email has been sent to the address provided. Please review our packing guide and pre-arrival checklist at your convenience.
A packing guide. There was a packing guide. I'd just committed to a vacation that came with homework.
I stared at the confirmation screen for a long time. Then I picked up my phone, screenshotted the email, and texted it to Sasha.
It was 11:47 PM.
Her reply came in under thirty seconds.
Sasha: Tell the island I said you're welcome
Me: I hate you
Sasha: You love me. Goodnight, Coral Key girl.
I put the phone down, turned off the light for the second time that night, and lay there in the dark — relieved, annoyed, and absolutely certain I'd just made either the best or the worst decision of my life.

The apartment looked like it was judging me for leaving.
Not in any dramatic way — the furniture hadn't rearranged itself into a disapproving formation, the velvet loveseat wasn't weeping. But there was something about the stillness of a space you were about to abandon for over a week that made it feel like it had opinions. The coffee machine, freshly cleaned for the first time in a month, sat on the counter looking like a pet that knew it was being left behind. The bookshelves — still organized by color, still the only area of the apartment that reflected a functioning adult — watched from the living room wall like an audience that had already decided how this was going to end.
I was standing by the door in a black shirt dress and flats, hair down, makeup done but not overdone, looking like a woman who had a plan. Which I did. The plan was: get in a taxi, get to the airport, get on a plane, take a boat to a small island in the middle of the ocean, and sit there for nine days hoping my brain remembered how to form sentences. Perfectly normal. Very sane. The kind of thing well-adjusted people did all the time, presumably.
My phone buzzed. The taxi app informed me that my driver, Dmitri, was twelve minutes away. Silver Camry, 4.7-star rating. Good enough.
Three bags sat by the door like they were waiting for a job interview. The tote was manageable — the kind of soft, overstuffed bag that said I am a person who carries things and does not apologize for how many things I carry. Phone, sunglasses, wallet, a few things I'd want on the flight without digging through a carry-on, and a paperback called Tides of Temptation that I'd grabbed off the shelf at the last minute. The cover featured a shirtless man emerging from the ocean with the kind of abs that only existed on book covers and in the imaginations of people who had never been to an actual beach. I'd bought it at a drugstore six months ago in a moment of weakness and it had been sitting on my shelf ever since, silently daring me to open it.
The carry-on was a sensible rolling case that held my laptop, chargers, and a notebook I'd packed with the vague optimism of someone bringing a gym bag to a hotel. The notebook was new — unlined, leather-bound, the kind of thing a person bought when they wanted to feel like a writer without actually having to write anything.
And then there was the suitcase.
The suitcase was a problem I was choosing not to acknowledge. It was a large hard-shell roller in navy blue — a perfectly reasonable piece of luggage that I had owned for years and that had never once given me trouble. The trouble was not the suitcase. The trouble was what was inside it, which was approximately twice as much clothing as any human being needed for nine days, because I had made the mistake of taking Sasha shopping with me.
Taking Sasha shopping had been like inviting a general to a pillow fight. I'd walked into the store with a list — a sensible, curated list of things I actually needed. Lightweight tops. A couple of sundresses. Maybe a swimsuit. Sasha had looked at my list, looked at me, and then put the list in her pocket and never mentioned it again.
What followed was ninety minutes of Sasha pulling things off racks with the decisive authority of someone defusing a bomb, holding them up against me, saying "yes," "no," "absolutely not," or "trust me," and depositing them into a basket I hadn't been consulted about. I'd tried to argue. I'd held up a perfectly nice linen shirt I'd picked out myself and Sasha had taken it from my hands, examined it for roughly one second, said "you'd look like someone's aunt at a vineyard," and put it back on the rack.
She'd pulled bikini tops that were meant to be worn with shorts — the kind that looked casual but were clearly designed by someone who understood that "casual" was just "deliberate" with better marketing. Sundresses in colors I wouldn't have reached for on my own. A wrap dress for dinners that Sasha had called "the closer" and refused to elaborate on. Accessories I hadn't asked for and a pair of sandals that were objectively beautiful and that I was mildly furious about because they were exactly right and I hadn't found them myself.
The result was a suitcase that closed only because I'd sat on it, and that rolled like it wanted me to know it was carrying more than it had signed up for. It made a sound on the hardwood that I chose to interpret as judgment.
I did one last lap of the apartment. Kitchen — coffee machine off, fridge emptied of anything that would become a science experiment while I was gone, countertop wiped to a standard I would never normally maintain but felt necessary when you were leaving for nine days.
Bedroom — bed made with a precision I usually reserved for absolutely nothing. Blinds closed. The fraudulent blackout blinds that had never blacked out a single thing, now tasked with the simple job of existing while I wasn't here to be disappointed by them. They'd probably manage that.
Bathroom — everything I needed was packed, everything I didn't need was in its place, the mirror was clean and reflecting an empty room back at itself. Good. Fine. The apartment was ready to be abandoned. It looked better than it had in weeks, which was the kind of irony I was trying not to think about — that the space looked its best the moment I was leaving it.
My phone buzzed again. Dmitri was seven minutes away.
I walked back to the door and stood there, looking at my three bags and the apartment beyond them. Nine days. Nine days on a tropical island with strangers, because my editor had given me a brochure and my best friend had told me to stop being a hermit and I'd booked a bungalow at midnight like a person making sensible life choices.
I still wasn't entirely sure what I was expecting to happen out there. Not a miracle. I wasn't stupid enough to think that a change of scenery was going to magically unstick whatever had gone wrong in my head. But somewhere underneath the disbelief there was something quieter. Something I wasn't going to examine too closely, because examining things too closely was how you ruined them.
The itinerary was: taxi, airport, plane, boat, island. In that order. One step at a time. That was plenty to think about.
I picked up my phone, confirmed the taxi, and texted Sasha.
Me: Leaving now. If I don't come back, the apartment is yours. Sell the loveseat.
Her reply came before I'd even put the phone down.
Sasha: Don't sell the loveseat. Have fun. Send pictures.
Me: Of what? The ocean? You've seen an ocean.
Sasha: Of you outside. For science.
I pocketed the phone, grabbed the tote, and took a handle in each hand — carry-on left, suitcase right. They rolled behind me like hostages.
That made two of us.
I pulled the door shut, locked it, and walked toward the elevator without looking back — because looking back was for people in movies, and this wasn't a movie. This was a woman in a black shirt dress dragging an unreasonably heavy suitcase toward a silver Camry driven by a man named Dmitri, hoping that a vacation on an island would fix something she couldn't fix in her own apartment.
It wasn't romantic. It wasn't cinematic. But it was, at least, a different direction than the couch.
Dmitri was leaning against the Camry, arms folded, in no particular rush about anything. He straightened when he saw me come through the lobby doors.
"Ms. Moore?" he said.
"That's me."
"Good morning, ma'am. Let me get those for you."
Ma'am. I was twenty-eight. But sure, Dmitri. Ma'am it is.
Dmitri had already taken the suitcase handle from me — smoothly, without asking twice — and was rolling it toward the trunk. He lifted it in with one clean motion and then paused, just slightly, in a way that made me think the weight had registered. He didn't say anything. Professional. I respected that.
The carry-on went in next. He closed the trunk and opened the rear door for me.
I slid into the backseat. It smelled like air freshener — the pine tree kind that hung from rearview mirrors and promised a forest experience that no car had ever delivered. The seats were clean. There was a bottle of water in the cup holder that I was pretty sure was complimentary but wasn't confident enough to open.
Dmitri got in, adjusted his mirror, and pulled away from the curb.
"Airport, yes?"
"Yes. Thank you."
He nodded once, merged into traffic, and for a few blocks the car was quiet, neither of us reaching for conversation. The city scrolled past the window in the gray-gold light of a morning that hadn't fully committed to being sunny. Storefronts with their gates still half-down. A man walking a dog that was significantly more awake than he was. A woman in scrubs waiting at a bus stop, coffee in hand, staring at nothing with the focused blankness of someone conserving energy for whatever was coming next.
"Going somewhere nice?" Dmitri asked, glancing at the mirror.
There it was. The question. Polite, harmless, the kind of thing taxi drivers asked because silence was fine but conversation was also fine and they'd learned to let the passenger decide which one.
"An island holiday," I said.
It sounded ridiculous out loud. In my head I could dress it up with context — the block, the brochure, the combined insistence of everyone I knew. Out loud it was just a woman going on holiday. Like someone who did that sort of thing on purpose.
"That's nice," Dmitri said. "Everyone needs a break sometimes."
"Yeah," I said. "Sometimes."
He left it there. A polite acknowledgment and then back to driving. I liked Dmitri. Dmitri understood boundaries.
The city thinned as we moved toward the expressway. The brownstones and bodegas gave way to wider roads and the kind of low, flat buildings that existed in the transition zone between a city and its airport — storage facilities, rental car lots, a hotel that looked like it had been built in the seventies and hadn't been updated since because no one staying there was doing it by choice. The skyline shrank in the rearview mirror. I watched it go without the poetic wistfulness that a better writer would have mustered. It was just buildings. They'd be there when I got back.
The airport appeared on the horizon the way airports always did — gradually, then all at once, a sprawl of concrete and signage and the particular chaos of a place designed to move thousands of people in different directions simultaneously while pretending to be organized about it.
Dmitri pulled up to the departures curb and put the car in park. He was out and at the trunk before I'd finished unbuckling, lifting the suitcase out with the same smooth motion as before, setting the carry-on beside it.
I got out and stood on the curb with my bags, feeling the familiar airport rush of people and luggage carts and announcements bleeding through the terminal doors.
"Thank you, Dmitri," I said.
He gave me a small nod. "Have a good trip, ma'am."
Ma'am again. I tipped him through the app — generously, for the bags and the silence — and watched him pull away from the curb.
I grabbed a handle in each hand, adjusted the tote on my shoulder, and started toward the terminal entrance. The automatic doors were maybe fifteen steps away.
I made it about four steps before impact.
A hard bump at my shoulder, the ugly crunch of roller bags tangling like they'd decided to elope, and my tote sliding off my arm fast enough to scatter half my life across the pavement.
Sunglasses, wallet, phone, and — because the universe had a sense of humor — Tides of Temptation, cover-up for the whole world to see.
"Oh, for fuck's sake," I said, already crouching.
"I'm so sorry — are you okay?"
I looked up ready to commit a murder. Dark hair past her shoulders, pulled back loosely, a sundress that looked like she'd actually thought about it before leaving the house. Already crouching to help, which would have been nice if she wasn't the reason I needed it.
"I'm fine," I said, in a tone that made it clear I wasn't.
"You sure? That was —"
"I said I'm fine."
She handed me my sunglasses, my wallet. I took them without looking at her. Then she reached for Tides of Temptation.
Time slowed down the way it only did during moments of genuine, soul-deep embarrassment. I watched her hand close around the book. I watched her lift it. I watched her eyes move — briefly, involuntarily — to the cover. To the shirtless man. To the abs. To the title, which was printed in raised gold lettering across his chest like a dare.
She looked at the book. She looked at me. Her expression didn't change, exactly, but something behind her eyes shifted — the faintest flicker of something she had the good grace not to let out.
I pulled the book out of her hand with more speed than the situation required.
"Thank you," I said, in a way that meant the opposite.
"Interesting choice," she said, like she was commenting on the weather.
"It's research," I said, which was a lie so instant and so baseless that I almost impressed myself.
"Research," she repeated, in a tone that made it clear she was not impressed.
I shoved the book into the tote and started gathering the rest of my things with the focused urgency of someone who needed this interaction to end. "You know, most people who knock someone over at least have the decency to look sorry about it."
"I said I was sorry."
"You said the words. There was no feeling behind them. I've heard more convincing apologies from automated emails."
"Would you like me to try again with more emotion? I can add a tremor if it helps."
I stood up, tote back on my shoulder, dignity in the process of being reassembled. She was standing too, roller bag in hand, slightly taller than me — just enough that I had to angle my chin up, which did absolutely nothing for my mood.
"I'd prefer," I said, "if people watched where they were going."
"I was watching where I was going. You just happened to be in the way."
"Oh, I was in your way. On a public curb. At a public airport. Where I was publicly standing. Minding my own business."
"With a lot of bags."
"Excuse me?"
"You had a lot of bags. I'm just saying — the footprint was considerable."
"The footprint was —" I opened my mouth, closed it, opened it again. "Did you just blame the collision on my luggage?"
"I'm saying it was a factor."
"A factor."
"Contributory."
I stared at her. She held it — composed, steady, with just the faintest crack of something at the corner of her mouth that might have been a smile if she'd been a different person in a different situation. She was enjoying this. Not openly, not warmly, but somewhere behind the composure she was absolutely enjoying watching me sputter on an airport curb about luggage footprint.
"You know what," I said. "Forget it. I hope wherever you're going they have a class on spatial awareness."
"I hope wherever you're going they have a luggage limit."
I opened my mouth to respond but nothing came out fast enough.
She tilted her head, just slightly. "Enjoy your research," she said. Then she turned and walked through the doors, roller bag trailing behind her.
I stood there on the curb, tote on my shoulder, handles in my hands, staring at the automatic doors that had just swallowed her.
"Ughhh."
I said it out loud. To nobody. At an airport. Like a person who was having a completely normal start to her vacation.
I closed my eyes, took a breath, and opened them.
Fine. Just a stranger. Just a collision. Just a minor, meaningless interaction with a woman I was never going to see again.
I straightened my tote, grabbed my handles, and walked through the doors.
The terminal was the usual controlled chaos — screens cycling through departures, families moving in confused clusters, a man in a suit walking so fast he was essentially jogging. I scanned the overhead signs, found my airline, and followed the arrows toward the check-in counters, still composing better comebacks in my head. Contributory. Who talked like that? Who used the word "contributory" in a sidewalk argument and walked away like they'd just settled a legal dispute?
The line was eight or nine people deep. I parked my bags and joined it, letting the slow shuffle forward do its work. By the time I reached the front, I'd mentally won the curb argument three times, each version more devastating than the last. None of them had happened. All of them were magnificent.
The agent behind the counter was a woman with her hair in a tight bun and a name badge that read GLORIA. Her smile was professional and well-rehearsed, but not unkind.
"Good morning," Gloria said. "Passport and booking confirmation, please."
I fished my passport out of the tote, pulled up the confirmation on my phone, and handed both over.
Gloria took the passport, opened it, looked at the photo, looked at me. There was a beat — brief, barely a pause, but I felt it the way I always felt it.
"So, Mr. Moo—" She caught herself. Looked at me again. "I'm sorry. Ms. Moore."
"That's me," I said. It wasn't the first time, wouldn't be the last. I was used to it.
Gloria moved on without fuss, tapping at her keyboard, scanning the confirmation. Then she gestured toward the scale beside the counter.
"Could you place your check-in bag on the scale for me?"
I lifted the suitcase onto the scale with confidence. The digital display flickered and settled.
Gloria looked at it. Then she looked at me.
"Ms. Moore, your bag is two kilos over the limit."
"Two kilos? That's nothing. Two kilos is not a character flaw."
"The allowance is twenty-three kilograms and your bag is coming in at twenty-five," Gloria said, unmoved. "The excess charge would be seventy-five dollars, or you're welcome to redistribute some items into your carry-on." She glanced at the rolling case beside me. "It looks like you might have some room."
Seventy-five dollars. For two kilos.
"I'll move some things," I said.
"Of course. Just step to the side and come back when you're ready."
And so began the most dignified moment of my morning. Which, given how the morning had gone, was saying something.
I wheeled both bags to the side, crouched down, opened the suitcase, and started the transfer. The backup sundress went first — because this was Sasha's fault and the sundress was going to answer for it. Then a pair of wedge heels that I'd packed on the theory that I might want to feel tall at some point during my stay, a theory that now seemed wildly optimistic.
I was shoving the wedges into the carry-on, knees on the terminal floor, when I heard it.
"Luggage trouble?"
I knew the voice before I looked up.
She was walking past — same stride, same roller bag, same composure — like the curb incident had been a minor blip in an otherwise seamless morning.
"Just a minor reorganization," I said, without looking up. "Totally normal. Happens to everyone."
"Looks like quite the redistribution."
I looked up. "Do you just circle airports looking for people to comment on, or am I special?"
She almost smiled. Almost. "You're memorable. I'll give you that."
And then she was past me, disappearing into the terminal with her single, correctly weighted bag and her single, correctly weighted opinion.
I stared after her for a beat too long, then looked down at the open suitcase, the overstuffed carry-on, and the wedge heel still in my hand.
"I hate this airport," I muttered.
I zipped everything shut, hauled myself up, and rolled back to Gloria's counter. She weighed the suitcase again.
"Twenty-two point eight," she said. "You're all set."
She tagged the bag, printed my boarding pass, and slid it across the counter.
"Boarding starts in about an hour and a half. Have a nice flight, Ms. Moore."
"Thank you, Gloria."
I took the boarding pass, grabbed my carry-on and tote, and walked away from the counter with whatever was left of my composure.
Security was the usual exercise in organized humiliation. Shoes off, laptop out, belt off — except my belt was built into the dress, which meant it wasn't coming off, which meant I was about to have a conversation about it.
I loaded my carry-on and tote into the bins, slid them onto the conveyor belt, and stepped through the scanner. It beeped. Of course it beeped.
"Ma'am, could you step to the side, please?"
A male TSA agent gestured me toward the secondary screening area. I stepped over.
"We're going to need to do a patdown. Would you prefer a private screening or are you comfortable here?"
"Here is fine," I said. "Could I get a female agent?"
"Of course." He turned and called over his shoulder. "Ramirez, patdown."
Agent Ramirez appeared — a woman in her forties with a no-nonsense ponytail. She pulled on a fresh pair of gloves and gave me a quick rundown.
"I'm going to use the backs of my hands along your torso and waistband. I'll tell you before I touch anything. Sound good?"
"Sounds like a Friday morning," I said.
She almost laughed. Almost. "Arms out to the side for me, please."
I stood there, arms extended, in the middle of an airport security checkpoint, being professionally patted down because my shirt dress had a buckle and the scanner had feelings about it. Around me, other travelers moved through their own screening lanes with the glazed efficiency of people who had done nothing to trigger a beep. Good for them. Good for them and their beltless outfits and their uncomplicated mornings.
Ramirez worked quickly — shoulders, sides, waistband, the belt buckle that had started all of this. Professional, thorough, completely unremarkable. She paused at the buckle, ran a finger along the edge to confirm it was just metal and not whatever else scanners were worried about these days, and stepped back.
"You're all clear," she said, pulling off the gloves. Then she paused, looking at me — not at the buckle, not at the screening form, at me — and her voice dropped half a register, just enough that it became a conversation between two people instead of an agent and a passenger.
"Where are you headed, if you don't mind me asking?"
"A place called The Whispering Palms," I said. "At Coral Key. Which sounds like either a resort or a cult, and honestly I'm still not a hundred percent sure which."
Ramirez laughed. "I'm sure it's the resort." She folded the gloves in her hands. "My niece is trans. She's been wanting to travel for years but she keeps putting it off. The airports, the security lines, the ID checks — it all stresses her out. She worries about moments like this." She gestured vaguely at the screening area. "Good for you for just going."
That caught me off guard. Not the words — the words were simple enough. It was that she'd said them here, in the middle of a security checkpoint, gloves still in her hand, like it was the most natural thing in the world to tell a stranger something that mattered.
"Tell her to book the trip," I said. "That's what my friend told me. Just book it and figure out the rest later."
Ramirez smiled. A real one, not the professional version. "I might just do that."
She gave me a nod — warm, brief, the kind that said everything it needed to without overstaying — and turned back to her station.
I collected my things from the bins, put my shoes back on, and walked into the terminal on the other side of security. I pulled out my boarding pass and checked the gate. B14.
B14 was already surrounded by a growing crowd of passengers — people standing, sitting on the floor, leaning against walls. The departure board said I still had over an hour until boarding.
A café sat across from the gate — one of those airport places with overpriced pastries behind glass and a menu that charged six dollars for what was essentially hot water and a tea bag. I joined the short line, ordered an iced coffee and a blueberry muffin, and paid an amount that I chose not to think about because thinking about it would ruin the muffin.
I found a small table near the window with a view of the gate and sat down. The coffee was cold and sweet and exactly what I needed after the morning I'd had.
I pulled out my phone and texted Sasha.
Me: Made it through security
Sasha: Still alive?
Me: Barely. Some woman literally crashed into me outside the terminal
Sasha: Crashed??
Me: Knocked my tote right off my shoulder. Everything went flying. And THEN she had the audacity to blame ME for it
Sasha: How is that your fault
Me: Apparently my luggage had a "considerable footprint"
Sasha: She said that to you???
Me: With a straight face. Then told me to enjoy my day and walked off like she'd won something
Sasha: I kind of love her
Me: You're supposed to be on MY side
Sasha: I am! But "considerable footprint" is objectively funny
Me: It's not funny when you're the one on the ground. Anyway. Curbside Karen can have the airport.
Sasha: Curbside Karen LOL
Sasha: Was she hot though?
Me: Irrelevant
Sasha: So yes
Me: I'm about to eat my muffin and ignore you
Sasha: Tell Curbside Karen I said hi
I put the phone down and took a bite of the muffin. It was dry. Airport muffins were always dry. I ate it anyway because I'd paid for it and because spite was a valid motivator.
I had an hour. I had coffee. I had a table. I had no excuse. I pulled the laptop out of the carry-on and opened it.
The document was still there. Still empty. The cursor blinked at me with the same patient indifference it had been blinking at me for weeks — unhurried, unbothered, content to wait me out until one of us died.
I put my fingers on the keys.
Nothing.
I shifted in my chair. Took a sip of coffee. Tried again.
She —
I stared at the single word. Three letters. One pronoun. No idea what came after it.
She walked —
No. Walking? Everyone walked. My characters were always walking somewhere in the first line like I was writing pedestrian fan fiction.
Delete.
The —
The what? The morning? The woman? The author, sitting in an airport café, typing single words and deleting them like the world's slowest typist?
Delete.
A man at the next table was watching something on his tablet. Without headphones. The audio leaked across the café — some kind of comedy podcast or YouTube video, punctuated by bursts of his own laughter that arrived at full volume and without warning. He laughed the way some people sneezed: loudly, involuntarily, and with no concern for the people around him.
I looked back at the screen.
The morning had —
Two kids sprinted past my table screaming, one of them clipping the edge of my chair hard enough to jolt my coffee. I flinched, grabbed the cup, and watched them tear across the café like tiny agents of chaos. Their mother appeared three seconds later, moving at the particular speed of a woman who was too tired to run but too responsible to stop.
"Miles! Ava! Get back here right now, I am not playing with you!"
Miles and Ava did not get back there. Miles and Ava had found the pastry display and were pressing their faces against the glass with the focused intensity of tiny art critics evaluating a gallery show.
I looked back at the screen.
The cursor blinked.
The man laughed at his tablet again.
A barista called out someone's name — "Decaf oat latte for Trevor!" — and Trevor did not come, so she called it again, louder, and then a third time with a tone that suggested Trevor's latte was about to become her latte.
Miles ran past again. The man laughed again. The barista called Trevor's name again. The cursor blinked again.
I closed the laptop.
Not gently. Not the quiet surrender of someone who'd accepted the situation. I closed it the way you'd hang up on someone who'd put you on hold for too long — with the controlled force of a person who was choosing not to throw something and wanted credit for the restraint. Everything was on my last nerve and my last nerve was considering a career change.
The PA system crackled overhead.
"Attention passengers. We will now begin boarding for flight 714 with service to —"
Thank god.
I shoved the laptop into the tote. The plane would be better. The plane had to be better. At the very least, nobody on a plane had ever chased a sibling into my kneecap while a stranger provided the laugh track. I tossed what was left of the muffin, grabbed my coffee, and headed for the gate.
Boarding was the usual slow funnel of people pretending they understood the zone system. I waited for my group, shuffled down the jet bridge with everyone else, and stepped onto the plane.
The cabin smelled like recycled air and cleaning solution — the specific combination that said you are now inside a tube that is about to leave the ground, and there is nothing you can do about it. I checked my boarding pass. 24A. Window seat. Small mercy.
I made my way down the aisle, dodging elbows and overhead bins and a man who had stopped in the middle of the row to remove something from his bag with the urgency of someone disarming a device. My row was about two-thirds of the way back. I found it, checked the number twice because I was not about to sit in the wrong seat and add that to the day's list, and started getting settled.
The carry-on needed to go in the overhead bin. I lifted it — or tried to. The thing was heavier than it had been this morning, courtesy of the sundress and wedge heels that were now living in it, and my arms made their opinion known immediately. I got it to chest height, which was not overhead height, and stood there holding it like an offering to a god who was not interested.
"Need a hand?"
The voice came from behind me. I turned. A man — mid-thirties, polo shirt, smile that arrived a beat too fast — was already reaching for the bag without waiting for an answer.
"I've got it," I said.
"It's no trouble." He was already lifting it, sliding it into the bin with the ease of someone who wanted you to notice how easy it was. "There you go."
"Thanks," I said, in a tone calibrated to communicate gratitude and absolutely nothing else.
"Anytime." His eyes lingered a half-second too long. "Traveling alone?"
"With my thoughts. They're very demanding company."
His smile faltered, just slightly — the micro-expression of a man recalculating — and he moved on down the aisle. I slid into my window seat, buckled my seatbelt, and exhaled.
The window showed the tarmac — grey, flat, busy with luggage carts and ground crew in high-vis vests doing whatever ground crew did. Beyond it, the sky was pale and wide and going somewhere I couldn't see yet. I leaned my head back against the headrest and let the noise of the cabin wash over me — the rustle of bags, the murmur of conversations, the distant thud of overhead bins closing one by one.
For the first time all morning, something in me loosened. Not a lot. Just enough to notice. The airport was behind me. The entire morning was behind me. Ahead was just the trip. Ahead was nine days of sun, water, and the possibility, however slim, of something unsticking.
I closed my eyes. Let out a long breath.
Maybe this would be okay. Maybe this was exactly what I needed. Maybe Maribel and Sasha had been right all along and I'd been too stubborn to —
"What the —"
The voice came from right beside my seat. Close. Familiar.
My eyes opened.
I turned.
"Son of a b-."

No.
No, no, no, no, no.
This was not happening. This was absolutely, categorically not happening. I had done everything right today. I had packed my bags, gotten in the taxi, survived the curb, survived the check-in counter, survived security and a dry muffin and a café full of feral children and a man who laughed at his tablet like he was being paid by the decibel. I had earned this seat. I had earned four hours of peace in a window seat with nothing to do but stare at clouds and pretend I was a person whose life was going well. And the universe, having apparently decided that my morning had been insufficiently terrible, had sent her.
Curbside Karen. Standing in the aisle. Boarding pass in hand. Looking at me, and then at the seat next to me, and then back at me, with an expression that made it very clear she was doing the same math I was and arriving at the same answer.
"You," I said.
"You," she said.
We stared at each other. The kind of stare where neither person blinks because blinking would be a concession, and neither of us was in a conceding mood.
"This is a joke," I said. "This has to be a joke. The universe is actively, deliberately messing with me."
"With you?"
"Yes, with me. Every time I start to relax today, you appear."
"I'd say it's been mutual."
"It has not been mutual. It has been targeted. I was sitting here, I was finally — I was having a moment — and then you —"
"I what? Walked onto a plane I booked three weeks ago?"
"You showed up. Again. For the third time today. At what point does coincidence become harassment?"
"Harassment," she repeated, flatly. "You think I'm stalking you. On a commercial flight. That I paid for."
"I think the universe is stalking me and using you as the weapon."
"That might be the most self-centred thing I've ever heard."
"Self-centred? If I'm self-centred, you're the orbit."
She blinked once, quickly, and I watched the composure flicker — just for a second — before she pulled it back into place. She looked at her boarding pass, looked at the seat next to me, and looked back at the boarding pass, as if checking it again might change what was printed on it.
A blonde flight attendant with a neat ponytail and the professionally pleasant expression of someone who had handled worse appeared from a few rows up.
"Ma'am, could I help you find your seat?"
"I've found it," Curbside Karen said. "I was hoping I could switch to a different one."
"I'm sorry — is there a problem with your seat?" The flight attendant looked between us.
"Not with the seat itself," the woman said. "More with the... proximity."
"The proximity," I repeated. "Interesting word choice."
The flight attendant's expression shifted into the particular careful neutrality of someone who was not paid enough for this. "I understand. Unfortunately, this is a completely full flight, so we can't accommodate a seat change at this time."
"Nothing at all? I'm not particular."
"I'm sorry, ma'am. I really can't do anything. I do need you to take your seat so we can keep boarding moving."
"Fine," she said, and exhaled through her nose.
The flight attendant gave us both a smile that was ninety percent professional and ten percent please do not make this my problem for the rest of the flight and moved on down the aisle.
"Proximity," I said.
"Don't."
"Should I put up a sign? A little warning notice on the headrest? 'Caution: difficult seatmate'?"
"Given how this morning has gone, yes. Possibly laminated."
She sat down next to me and buckled her seatbelt.
I stared at her for a second, waiting for something clever to arrive. Nothing did. I turned to face the window. The tarmac stretched out beyond the glass, flat and grey and completely unhelpful. Neither of us spoke. The boarding shuffle continued around us — bags, elbows, the slow parade of people finding seats — and we sat in our little two-seat block like a pair of strangers who had already used up a day's worth of words on each other.
My phone buzzed.
Sasha: Update??
Me: SOS
Sasha: What
Me: Curbside Karen is in the seat next to mine
Sasha: You're joking
Me: Do I sound like I'm joking
Sasha: You sound like you're spiraling
Me: I AM spiraling. This woman is NEXT TO ME for the entire flight
Sasha: This is the greatest thing ever
Me: I hate you
Sasha: You love me. Tell Curbside Karen I say hi
"Curbside Karen?"
I turned.
"Are you reading my messages?"
"You're holding your phone three inches from my arm. It's not reading, it's unavoidable."
"It's private."
"Then close your eyes."
"For the record," she said, "my name isn't Karen."
My face felt warm. I turned back to the window.
Neither of us said anything. The cabin noise filled the gap — bags being stowed, the low murmur of a hundred conversations bleeding into one. I watched her from the corner of my eye. Her jaw was still tight, arms folded, but after a few seconds her shoulders loosened and she leaned back in her seat with her eyes half-closed. Hours. We had hours of this.
The PA system crackled.
"Ladies and gentlemen, the doors have been closed and we are preparing for departure. Please ensure your seatbelts are fastened and all electronic devices are switched to airplane mode."
I put my phone in my lap, leaned back against the headrest, and closed my eyes.
The plane began to move. A slow, heavy roll backward, then a wide turn that pressed me gently into the window. The taxiing was fine. Taxiing was just driving with more optimism. I kept my eyes closed and let the hum of the engines fill the space where conversation used to be, and for about ninety seconds it was almost peaceful. Two strangers sitting in mutual silence, pretending the last twenty minutes hadn't happened. I could do this. I could sit here for an entire flight and simply not engage. I was an adult. I had self-control. I had —
The engines pitched up. The plane surged forward, pressing me back into the seat, and I felt the acceleration in my stomach before I heard it in the cabin. That was normal. That was fine. That was just physics doing its job.
Then the plane shook.
Not gently. Not the polite little rattle you got on most flights, the one that lasted two seconds and made the overhead bins creak. This was a full-body tremor that ran through the fuselage like the aircraft had just remembered it was held together with rivets and optimism. The cabin lights flickered. My hand shot out and grabbed the window ledge with a grip that could have cracked a walnut.
"You can use the armrest if you want," she said.
"I'm fine."
"You're holding the window ledge like it owes you money."
"It does."
"What did it do?"
"Provided insufficient emotional support during takeoff."
She pressed her lips together.
"Do you always fly like that?"
"Like what?"
"Like the plane is personally trying to kill you."
"It shook."
"They all shake."
"This one shook aggressively."
"It shook the normal amount. You grabbed the window like you were trying to take it with you."
The plane levelled out, the engines settled into a steady hum, and the seatbelt sign dinged overhead as if nothing had happened. I released the window ledge, flexed my fingers, and placed my hands in my lap.
Outside the window, the ground was already shrinking away.
The first twenty minutes passed in loaded silence. The engines hummed. The cabin settled into the low, steady rhythm of a flight in progress.
The armrest started it.
Neither of us had claimed it. It had been sitting there between us, neutral territory, since she sat down. But as the flight wore on and we both shifted and resettled, elbows started drifting. Mine found the armrest first. Then hers bumped it — lightly, just enough to register. I held my position. She adjusted. Our elbows touched again. I moved mine forward. She moved hers back. I moved mine back. We collided.
We didn't speak, didn't look at each other — just kept making micro-adjustments, shifting angles, reclaiming half-inches, in complete silence, like two people playing chess without a board.
The drinks cart saved us from whatever that was becoming.
It rolled up the aisle with the slow, inevitable approach of something that couldn't be avoided. The flight attendant, a man with a neat beard and a practiced smile, stopped at our row.
"Can I get you ladies anything?"
"Apple juice, please."
Of course. Decisive, efficient, no browsing. She probably knew what she was ordering before she got on the plane. She probably had a spreadsheet.
"And for you?"
"Coffee, please."
He poured it, handed it to her, and nodded for her to pass it along. She turned toward me and held it out. I reached for it — and the plane jolted. Just a small bump, nothing dramatic, but enough. The coffee lurched in the cup. A few drops spilled over the rim onto her hand.
She looked at me like I'd done it on purpose. Like I had summoned a pocket of turbulence through sheer force of will just to inconvenience her.
"That wasn't me," I said.
"I didn't say it was."
"Your face said it."
She shook her hand once, then held the cup out again. I took it with both hands.
"You're welcome," she said flatly.
I took a sip of coffee. Not great, not worth complaining about, and at this point in the day I'd take any small victory that came in a cup.
The coffee ran out before the silence did. I stared at the seat back in front of me for a while, then at the window, then at my hands, then at the seat back again, and then I ran out of things to stare at.
I still had hours left in this seat and I could either spend them doing nothing or I could do the thing I'd come on this trip to fix in the first place.
I pulled the laptop out of my tote, opened it on the tray table, and started typing before I could talk myself out of it.
She walked into the —
Into the what? The room? The bar? The void of my creative bankruptcy? Delete.
The morning light caught —
Caught what? Her face? Her attention? A bus? Delete.
There was something about the way —
There was something about the way I kept starting sentences I couldn't finish. Very meta. Very unhelpful. Delete.
I tried again. Slower this time.
The hotel room was smaller than the photos had promised. She dropped her bag by the door and stood there for a moment, taking in the bed that swallowed most of the floor, the window that faced a brick wall, and the bathroom that was optimistically described as "ensuite" but was really just a shower with ambitions.
I stopped. Read it back. That was... not horrible. I kept going.
She hadn't planned on being here. The trip had been someone else's idea — her sister's, or her therapist's, or possibly both, she couldn't remember whose voice had said "you need to get away" first because everyone in her life had apparently formed a committee about it.
Two paragraphs. A voice. A character. Something that almost had a pulse. I typed faster, leaning into it, chasing whatever thread had appeared before it disappeared again —
I read the whole thing from the top.
Garbage. Complete, irredeemable garbage. The character was flat, the hotel room could have been in any book written by anyone, and the voice I thought I'd found was just a bad impression of myself.
I highlighted everything. All of it.
Delete.
"Is it supposed to do that?"
I turned.
"Do what?"
"The typing and then the deleting. Over and over. Is that — is something wrong with it?"
"Nothing's wrong with it."
"You've been doing the same thing for ten minutes. You type, you stop, you erase it all. Then you start again. It's like watching someone fill a glass and pour it out."
"It's a process."
"It sounds like a process. A loud one."
"I don't type that loud."
"You type like you're punishing the keyboard for something it did to you personally."
"And you breathe like you're being paid by the inhale, but you don't see me filing a complaint."
I closed the laptop. Firmly. With feeling.
The laptop went back into the tote. The tray table went up. And I was back to having nothing to do, which was becoming the theme of this flight and possibly my entire creative career.
I leaned back in my seat. The cabin had settled into that mid-flight lull where half the passengers were asleep and the other half were staring at screens with the glazed focus of people trying to make time move faster.
I watched the clouds for a while. They were doing nothing interesting but they were better company than the woman next to me.
Then my body made an announcement.
I needed the bathroom.
I looked at the aisle. I looked at the woman between me and the aisle. I weighed my options. There were no options. There was only one way out of a window seat and it went directly through her.
"Excuse me."
She looked up.
"I need to —" I gestured toward the aisle.
She unbuckled her seatbelt and stood up without a word. Efficient. No fuss. She stepped into the aisle and pressed herself flat against the seat in front to give me room, which was generous of her in theory and completely insufficient in practice. The gap between her and the seat was designed for a person roughly the width of a broomstick, and I was not, despite my best efforts in life, a broomstick.
I squeezed through. There was a moment — brief, awful — where we were facing each other in the gap and I could smell whatever she was wearing. Something clean and faintly warm. I did not want to notice that. I filed it under things that were irrelevant and moved on.
"Thanks," I muttered, already walking.
The bathroom was at the back of the plane. Three rows. Then four. Then the little curtained area where the flight attendants kept the cart, and then the door with the green VACANT sign that was the most beautiful word in the English language.
I locked the door behind me and stood there for a second in the tiny fluorescent box that airlines had the audacity to call a lavatory.
I did what I came to do, which took about thirty seconds and involved a flush mechanism that sounded like the plane was swallowing something it disagreed with.
The sink was approximately the size of a cereal bowl. The soap dispenser required the kind of precise hand-eye coordination that should not be expected of anyone at thirty-five thousand feet. I washed my hands, dried them on a paper towel the thickness of a promise, and checked my reflection in the mirror. It was the size of a hardcover book and lit from above with the kind of lighting that made everyone look like they were recovering from something. My makeup was holding up, which felt like a small personal victory given the day I was having.
Still here. Still trapped on a plane with a woman who had opinions about my typing volume.
I unlocked the door and headed back up the aisle. A man in the middle section had fallen asleep with his mouth open and his head tilted back at an angle that was going to cost him his neck for the next three days. A woman near the front was reading to a small child in a whisper that carried further than she probably realised.
I reached my row. Curbside Karen was reading something. She looked up when I stopped, stood without being asked this time, and stepped into the aisle.
I squeezed past again, dropped into my seat, and buckled my seatbelt.
A minute passed. Maybe two. Then I glanced over.
She was deep in the book now. Holding it with one hand, the other resting on the armrest — which she had apparently claimed while I was gone, but that was a battle for another time. Her eyes were moving across the page at a steady pace, and there was something on her face I hadn't seen before. Focus, but a specific kind of focus. The kind where you forgot where you were because the page had pulled you somewhere else.
I looked at the cover.
I looked at it again.
I looked at it a third time because my brain was refusing to process what my eyes were telling it.
She was reading My Husband, My Bride.
My book. This annoying woman was sitting next to me reading my book.
I stared at the cover. The striking image that my publisher had actually invested in. My name — ADRIANNA MOORE — printed across the bottom in clean white letters.
My eyes kept sliding back to the book, to her hands holding it, to the page she was on — which, from the thickness of what she'd already read, looked like she was maybe a third of the way through. Chapter six or seven. Before the good stuff but past the point where most people decided whether they were going to keep going.
She was still going.
I glanced at her again. Then again. I was leaning slightly toward her now, watching her read, and I could feel my face doing something I hadn't authorised. Something smug and satisfied and probably deeply weird-looking from the outside.
"What?"
I blinked. She was looking at me. The book was still open in her hand but her eyes were on my face and her expression had shifted from reading-focus to something more like suspicion.
"Nothing."
"You're staring at me."
"I'm not staring."
"You're smiling and staring. You've been doing it for the last two minutes."
I adjusted in my seat and tried to look normal, but the grin kept creeping back.
"Is that a good book?" I asked, aiming for casual and landing somewhere around transparent.
She looked down at the cover, then back at me. "Why?"
"Just asking. Making conversation. That's what people do on planes."
"We haven't made conversation this entire flight. We've argued."
"Right. And now I'm trying something new. Is it good?"
She studied me for a second. I could see her trying to figure out what I was doing and not liking that she couldn't.
"It's fine," she said.
"Fine?"
"I'm reading it, aren't I?"
"You don't seem that enthusiastic."
"I don't perform enthusiasm for strangers on planes."
"Fair enough." I paused. Then, because I apparently had no self-control: "I wrote that."
She looked at me.
"That book," I said. "I wrote it."
She looked at the cover. She looked at me. She looked at the cover again.
"You wrote this."
"Yes."
"You."
"Me."
"You're telling me you're Adrianna Moore."
"That is what I'm telling you, yes."
She closed the book, keeping her finger in the page, and turned to face me fully. Her expression was something between amused and unconvinced, like I'd just told her I was secretly a duchess and she was waiting for the punchline.
"You're Adrianna Moore. The author of this book."
"The very same."
"The book that's been on every bestseller list for the past four months."
"That's the one."
"And you just happen to be sitting next to me. On this flight. In this seat."
"The universe works in mysterious and deeply irritating ways."
She looked at me for a long moment. Then she opened the book again, found her page, and settled back in her seat.
"Sure you are," she said, and went back to reading.
"I — excuse me?"
"Mm-hm."
"You don't believe me."
"I believe you believe it."
"That's — that is the most condescending thing anyone has ever said to me."
"It's a popular book. I'm sure you're a big fan."
"I'm not a fan. I didn't read it. I wrote it."
"Mm-hm."
"Stop saying 'mm-hm' like that."
"Like what?"
"Like you're humouring me."
"I'm not humouring you. I'm reading." She turned a page. "Or trying to."
I stared at her. She didn't look up. She was already back in the book, turning a page with the calm indifference of someone who had just ended a conversation and felt no need to revisit it.
I sat there for a moment, jaw tight, fingers drumming on the armrest — the armrest she'd claimed while I was in the bathroom, which I was now too irritated to fight over. She was reading my words. Right there. Right next to me. Words I had agonised over, rewritten four times, stayed up until three in the morning getting right. And she had just "mm-hm"ed me like I'd told her I once met a celebrity at a grocery store.
I thought about spoiling the ending. Just casually dropping what happened in chapter twenty-two, watching the words register, watching the book close. But I wasn't that person. I was petty, sure, but I wasn't a monster.
I turned away from her.
Fine. She didn't believe me. That was fine. I didn't need the validation of a woman whose name I didn't even know. I didn't need her to look at me with sudden respect or awe or any of the things that would have been nice but were absolutely not necessary for my continued existence as a human being.
It was fine.
It was completely, absolutely fine.
Neither of us spoke for the rest of the flight. I leaned back, closed my eyes, and let the hum of the engines fill the space where the argument had been.
At some point the seatbelt sign dinged. The captain's voice crackled through the PA — something about beginning the descent, local weather, thanking us for flying with them as if we'd had a say in it. I opened my eyes. The land below had changed — greener, flatter, broken up by rivers and the occasional cluster of buildings that got smaller and more spread apart the further south we'd gone.
The plane began its descent, and I felt the pressure shift in my ears as the ground got closer.
The landing was not gentle. The wheels hit the tarmac with a jolt that sent my stomach somewhere it didn't belong, and everything roared and shuddered as the plane fought to slow down. My hand found the armrest and gripped it. Her arm wasn't there anymore — at some point during the flight she'd given it up, though I doubted it was out of generosity. When the shaking stopped I let go.
We taxied for what felt like longer than the flight itself, rolling past terminals and parked aircraft and ground crew waving orange batons, and then finally the plane stopped and the seatbelt sign dinged off.
The cabin erupted. Every single person stood up at exactly the same time as if a starting pistol had gone off. Overhead bins opened. Bags appeared. A man three rows ahead was already wrestling his suitcase out of the bin like his life depended on it, even though the door was still closed.
I stayed in my seat, and so did Curbside Karen.
She was still reading. The chaos of a hundred and seventy people scrambling to stand in an aisle they couldn't walk down yet, and this woman had found another paragraph she wanted to finish. She turned a page, adjusted the book in her hand, and kept going as if the plane hadn't landed, as if the bins weren't slamming, as if the man three rows up wasn't now holding his suitcase over his head like a trophy he'd earned in combat.
Eventually the crowd thinned and the aisle started to move. Passengers shuffled forward in the slow, stop-start procession of deplaning, and Curbside Karen closed the book, slid it into the bag at her feet, and stood. She stepped into the aisle and merged into the shuffle without looking back. I grabbed my tote, pulled my carry-on from the overhead bin, and followed the stream toward the front of the cabin.
The jet bridge smelled like fuel and warm concrete. I followed the stream of passengers into the terminal, which was smaller than the one I'd left — lower ceilings, fewer gates, the particular energy of a regional airport that knew it wasn't anyone's final destination. Signs pointed toward baggage claim and I followed them.
I found my carousel in baggage claim and joined the crowd already gathered around it, staring at an empty belt with the collective patience of people who had nowhere else to be but would very much like to be there sooner.
Bags were already coming through and people were stepping forward to claim them, one by one, with the satisfied efficiency of passengers whose luggage had not betrayed them. Mine was not among them. The crowd around the carousel thinned as everyone else collected their things and headed for the exit, and I stood there watching the same few unclaimed bags make their slow, sad loop, wondering what I had done to personally offend the baggage handling system.
I spotted her across the carousel. Curbside Karen, standing on the opposite side. Her bag appeared just as I noticed her — because of course it did — and she stepped forward, lifted it off the belt, set it on its wheels, and turned to leave.
She glanced across the carousel, saw me still standing there bagless, and something crossed her face — dry, unreadable, an expression I was starting to associate specifically with her. Then she turned and walked away.
The carousel hummed its way through the last few unclaimed bags, and then finally my navy blue suitcase appeared through the rubber flaps like a student arriving late to class and hoping no one would notice.
I grabbed it, set it on its wheels, and headed for the exit.
The pre-arrival checklist had mentioned a transfer desk inside the terminal. I scanned the signs — car rental, taxi rank, ground transportation — and then spotted it. A small desk near the far wall with a printed sign that read THE WHISPERING PALMS — GUEST TRANSFERS in the same turquoise font that had been haunting me since the brochure.
And standing in front of it, roller bag at her side, was her.
I stopped walking. Because at what point does a reasonable person accept that the universe has a personal vendetta against them? Three encounters at the airport. A four-hour flight. A baggage carousel. And now this woman was standing at my resort's transfer desk like she'd been placed there specifically to test whether I was capable of committing a crime in a public terminal.
I considered turning around. I considered going to the bathroom, hiding for ten minutes, and hoping she'd be gone by the time I came back. I considered emigrating.
Instead I walked up to the desk and set my bag down next to hers, because I was a grown-ass adult and I was not going to be chased out of a transfer desk by a person who thought "proximity" was a valid complaint.
She turned her head. Saw me. Her expression went through three stages in about two seconds — recognition, disbelief, and something that settled into a flat, resigned irritation that I found deeply satisfying.
"Oh, Jesus Christ, not you again," she said.
"Trust me, I'm not thrilled either."
"This is ridiculous."
"The universe is doing this. Take it up with management."
She opened her mouth to respond but before she could get a word out, a young man appeared from a door behind the desk wearing a resort polo in — what else — turquoise, with a name tag that read JASON. He had the tanned, slightly rushed look of someone who'd been doing three things at once and was about to start a fourth.
"Hi there! Sorry for the wait," he said, setting down a clipboard and a set of keys. "My name is Jason. Are you both here for The Whispering Palms transfer?"
"Apparently," I said, at the same moment she said, "Yes."
Jason looked between us, picked up his clipboard, and clicked his pen. "Great. I just need to check you in. Can I get your names?"
"Renee Miller."
Renee Miller. So Curbside Karen had a real name. And it was annoyingly elegant. The universe couldn't even give me the satisfaction of her being called something ridiculous — a Gertrude, a Bernice, anything I could hold over her in my head. No. She had to be a Renee. Smooth, French-sounding, the kind of name that looked good on a wine list. I hated it immediately.
Jason checked something on his clipboard and nodded, then turned to me. "And you must be Ms. Adrianna Moore?"
"That's me."
I looked at her. She was already looking at me — and then at the clipboard, and then at me again. I could practically hear the gears turning.
"Wait," she said. "You're —"
"Mm-hm," I said.
Jason checked something on his clipboard. "Perfect. If you'd both like to follow me, the shuttle is just outside. It'll take us to the marina and then we'll get you on the boat over to Coral Key."
I gave Renee one long look, slid my sunglasses down from the top of my head, and turned to Jason.
"Lead the way," I said, and walked ahead without looking back.
After a moment, I heard the reluctant click of a roller bag behind me.
For the first time all day, the universe and I were on the same page.

The heat was the first thing.
The doors opened and it hit me — the actual, physical assault of a climate that had been waiting for me on the other side of the glass. Thick, wet, immediate — the kind of heat that didn't introduce itself so much as move in and start rearranging the furniture. My sunglasses fogged. My carefully maintained hairstyle, which had survived a four-hour flight and a baggage carousel standoff with its dignity mostly intact, immediately began negotiations with the humidity. I could feel my hair making decisions I hadn't approved.
Jason walked ahead with the easy stride of someone for whom this heat was just another day. He was carrying a clipboard and talking about shuttle timing and marina logistics, and I was absorbing approximately fifteen percent of it because the other eighty-five percent of my brain was occupied with the fact that my skin had decided to become a water feature.
I could hear her behind me. Her bags, the footsteps, the particular silence of a woman who had just found out she'd spent four hours being condescending to the actual author of the book in her lap. It was, without exaggeration, the best walk of my life.
"Adrianna."
I kept walking. My own luggage rolled smoothly behind me across the pavement. The sun was doing something aggressive to the top of my head.
"Adrianna Moore."
That was the full name. She was using my full name like a teacher about to assign detention. I allowed myself a small, private smile behind my sunglasses.
"That's me," I said, without turning around.
"You actually wrote that book."
"You're a writer?"
"What gave it away?" I said, still walking.
"You wrote My Husband, My Bride?"
There it was. The you. She wasn't questioning the book. She was questioning me — whether someone like me, who she'd been stuck next to all day, could have possibly written something worth reading.
I stopped walking. The block flickered somewhere at the back of my mind — weeks of blank screens and false starts, the words I'd written and deleted and written and deleted — and for one brief, awful second, she'd landed a hit she didn't even know she'd thrown.
But only for a second.
I turned around.
"I'm sorry, is there an audition process I missed? Should I have brought references? A writing sample, maybe a dramatic reading right here in the parking lot? Because I'd really love to know what exactly about me says 'couldn't possibly write a book.'"
She opened her mouth and nothing came out. I watched it happen — the false start, the slight press of her lips, the recalibration behind her eyes — and I enjoyed every second of it. Renee Miller, who had spent the entire flight with an answer for everything, was standing in a parking lot in the blazing heat with absolutely nothing to say.
"That's what I thought," I said, and turned to follow Jason.
I didn't rush it. I took my time. I let my luggage roll behind me at a leisurely, unhurried pace, because when you finally win one against a woman who has been out-talking you all day, you don't sprint away from it. You stroll.
Behind me, after a long and deeply gratifying pause, her bags clicked into motion.
Jason led us across the pickup area toward a white minivan with the Whispering Palms logo printed on the side. A minivan. For a resort that charged what this one charged, they really were committed to keeping expectations flexible.
I could feel Renee falling into step beside me as we got closer — not next to me, exactly, but no longer trailing four steps behind either. She'd closed the gap without closing it all the way, which felt like the most Renee Miller thing I'd learned about her so far. Even her walking had conditions.
Jason reached the van first and pulled the sliding door. It stuck halfway. He gave it a second tug — the kind that suggested this was a daily negotiation between him and this vehicle — and it slid open to reveal a man already seated inside, who looked at the two of us like Christmas had arrived early and brought backup.
He was stepping out before Jason could finish his gesture.
"Hi. Hello. Welcome. I'm Milo." He said it like one word — hihellowelcomeimmilo — already extending a hand toward me while the other one gripped the door frame for balance. He was medium build, late twenties maybe, with a smile that took up most of his face and a shirt that looked like a tropical greenhouse had exploded during a sunset. He shook my hand with both of his. "I love that dress. The belt detail? Incredible. You understood the assignment and then some."
I hadn't been complimented with that much conviction since Sasha told me my eyebrows could end marriages. I laughed before I could stop myself.
"Adrianna," I said.
"Adrianna. Beautiful name. Beautiful dress. We're already winning." He let go of my hand and turned to Renee, who had stopped a step behind me with the expression of someone watching a weather event approach. "And you — I'm sorry, are you a model? Because you have a face that makes me want to apologize for mine."
Renee looked at him the way she might look at a stain that had appeared on her shirt in public — not angry, just deeply inconvenienced by its existence.
Most people would have backpedalled. Milo didn't even blink. "Okay, noted, we're not doing compliments yet. That's fine. I come on strong. My therapist says it's because I externalize affection to avoid sitting with my own vulnerability, but I think it's because I have great taste and no filter." He shrugged. "We can revisit the model thing later when you trust me."
Something happened to Renee's mouth. It wasn't a smile. But something in the architecture of her expression shifted about two millimetres in a direction that was not entirely hostile.
Milo saw it. His whole face lit up like he'd found buried treasure.
"Did you see that?" He looked at me. "I almost got a smile. I'm counting it."
Jason gestured toward the van. "If you're all ready, we can get the bags loaded and head to the marina."
Renee turned to follow him without a word. Milo watched her go with his mouth slightly open.
"Excuse me — I called you a model, almost got murdered for it, and we haven't even done introductions?"
Renee stopped. She looked back over her shoulder. "Renee," she said, and kept walking.
Milo turned to me. "She's fun. I can tell."
Jason helped us with the bags while a driver I hadn't noticed before loaded everything into the back. Renee and I ended up on the same row, close enough that I was aware of the space between us, and Milo took the row in front of us, already twisting around in his seat so he could face us both. Jason climbed into the passenger seat, the driver started the engine, and we pulled out of the pickup area.
"So," Milo said, settling into his seat like he was hosting a talk show. "How was everyone's flight?"
"Fine," I said.
"Uneventful," Renee said.
Milo looked between us. "You two fly in together?"
"No," I said.
"Same flight," Renee said, at the same time.
I looked at her. She looked at me.
"We were on the same flight," I said. "We didn't fly together."
"I didn't say we did."
"You kind of implied it."
"I stated a fact. We were on the same flight. That's all I said."
"It's not—" I stopped myself. I was not going to do this. Not here. Not in a minivan. Not in front of a man in a floral shirt I'd known for two minutes.
Milo watched the whole thing without blinking. His eyes moved from me to Renee and back again, slow and delighted, and he pressed his lips together like he'd just been handed a gift he was choosing to unwrap later.
"Okay," he said, nodding slowly. "Okay."
He let it sit just long enough to be polite. Then, deciding to be generous, he moved on.
"So I'm Milo. I said that already but I feel like the first one didn't count because we were standing in a parking lot and nobody was comfortable yet. I'm a nurse. Been doing it six years, love it, wouldn't trade it, but it does mean I spend most of my life around people who are either in pain or heavily medicated, so when I get a vacation I become—" he gestured at himself, "—this. Amplified. Sorry in advance."
"You don't seem sorry," Renee said.
"Oh I'm not, honey. That was performative." He pointed at her with genuine approval. "See, you're paying attention. I appreciate that."
I bit the inside of my cheek to keep from grinning. Milo seemed like the kind of person who walked into a room and rearranged everyone's plans for the evening without asking, and somehow you thanked him for it afterward.
"I've been single for two years," he continued, unprompted. "Which at this point feels like a personal attack from the universe. The first year, fine, I was healing. But this last year? I've just been cute and available and absolutely wasted on nobody, which is frankly a crime. So I'm here because the universe owes me a man, and if it doesn't deliver, I'm filing a formal complaint."
I didn't know if he was always like this or if this was just his vacation setting. Either way, there was something about a man demanding the universe owe him a boyfriend that was hard not to like.
"What about you?" He looked at me. "What do you do?"
"I'm a writer," I said, and the word came out easier than it had any right to, given that I hadn't written anything worth keeping in weeks.
"A writer!" Milo said it like I'd told him I was an astronaut. "What do you write? What's the book? Tell me everything."
"I've written a few novels," I said. "Five, actually. The first four did okay — nothing crazy. But the last one kind of took off."
"Took off how?" Milo said. "Like, your-mom-bought-copies took off, or like, actual took off?"
"Bestseller lists for four months took off."
"Shut up." He slapped the back of his seat. "What's it called?"
"My Husband, My Bride."
"What's it about?"
"It's erotica," I said, and it came out easier than I expected. "It's about a marriage where both people are discovering things about themselves — desires, kinks, parts of their identity they never had language for. And instead of blowing up the marriage, they figure it out together. Messily. Honestly. With a lot of sex."
"Oh, this is the best thing I've heard all month." Milo looked like he'd been personally blessed. "How spicy are we talking?"
I laughed. "Pretty spicy."
"I'm buying it the second I get Wi-Fi."
"Although, funny enough, certain people don't even believe I wrote it. Like I'd just walk around claiming someone else's book for fun. As if that's a thing people do."
I didn't look at Renee. I didn't need to. I could practically feel the eye roll from the seat next to me, radiating off her like heat from a stove.
"People are the worst," Milo said sympathetically.
"They really are," I said, still looking at Milo, still smiling, still not looking at the woman beside me who had gone so quiet you could hear the air conditioning.
Milo let the silence sit for about three seconds, which I was starting to suspect was his absolute limit. Then he turned to Renee.
"Okay, I've been rude. I know your name, I know you're not a model — even though you are — but what do you do?"
"I'm a physical therapist," Renee said.
"Oh, so we have a writer and a healer. This van is full of talent." He looked between us. "And me. I bring the personality."
A physical therapist — so she spent her days telling people what was wrong with them and how to fix it. Figures.
"So have either of you been to this place before?"
"First time," I said.
"Same," Renee said.
"What are you most looking forward to?"
"Quiet," I said. "And maybe some time to work."
"Work?" Milo looked at me. "You're bringing work to a tropical island? Honey, that's depressing."
"I'm a writer. It follows me."
"That's even more depressing. You need to learn how to turn off." He swung his attention to the other end of the row. "And you? What's your big island plan?"
"Peace," Renee said, and offered nothing else.
"Peace. Fun. Relaxation. Sun." Milo counted them off on his fingers. "That's four things that are not work. Take notes," he said to me.
"We'll see," I said.
"That's a yes. That is absolutely a yes disguised as being chill." Milo pointed at me. "You're going to be on a beach with a laptop. I can already tell."
"I have a deadline. The next book isn't going to write itself."
"From what I saw, neither are you," Renee said, still looking straight ahead.
"That's called a process."
"That's called a blank page."
"Oh, so now you're an expert on writing?"
"I know what a finished page looks like. That wasn't one."
Milo's head was swivelling between us like he was courtside at a tennis match. He hadn't said a word in about thirty seconds, which I was learning might be a personal record for him.
"Okay," he said, holding up both hands. "I have a question and I need both of you to not get mad at me."
"That's never a good start," Renee said.
"What is happening between you two?"
"Nothing," I said, too fast.
"Nothing," Renee said. Half a second behind me.
"See, that." Milo pointed at both of us. "You just said the same word at the same time and neither of you looked at each other. I've been watching you two since the parking lot and the tension is giving full-on telenovela. What is going on with you two?"
"We sat next to each other on the flight," I said, as if that explained everything.
"That's it?"
"That's it."
"Really? That's it?" Milo asked.
"I have been through an ordeal today," I said.
"That is wildly dramatic," Renee said.
We looked at each other. She had the audacity to look annoyed — she was annoyed, as if I was the one who'd been impossible all day. I gave her my best "are you serious right now" face, she gave me one right back, and then we both turned toward our respective windows like two people who had absolutely nothing left to say to each other.
Milo clapped his hands together once. "Oh, this is going to be so much fun."
The minivan couldn't get to the marina fast enough. I needed air, space, and approximately two hundred feet between me and the self-appointed skeptic sitting next to me.
We slowed, and through the glass I could see the marina opening up ahead of us — the dock stretching out over the water, the late afternoon light doing something golden across the surface, and a catamaran with the Whispering Palms logo on its hull tied up alongside it. It was mid-sized, white, with an enclosed cabin and an open deck at the back where a row of seats faced the water. We were here.
Renee was on the door side, which meant my escape involved waiting while she gathered her things at a pace I can only describe as deliberate. By the time my feet finally hit the pavement, I had a whole speech prepared.
Then the salt air hit me, and the speech went somewhere I didn't bother following. Cleaner than the airport, warmer, the breeze coming off the water — I stood there for a second and let it settle. The warmth on my skin, the breeze coming off the water, the way everything here seemed to move a little slower than I did. For the first time all day, I wasn't annoyed or anxious or composing a sarcastic internal monologue. I was just standing somewhere beautiful, breathing.
Maybe Maribel and Sasha were right to push me into this. I wasn't going to tell them that. But standing here, salt air in my lungs and the water ahead of me — yeah. Everything was going to be okay.

The moment lasted about four seconds.
Four perfect seconds of salt air and golden light and the kind of stillness that makes you think maybe the universe isn't entirely out to get you. I was standing on the dock, the water stretching out ahead of me, the catamaran rocking gently against its moorings, and for once in my entire adult life I was not composing anything — not a comeback, not a defense, not the first line of a novel I couldn't write. I was just breathing.
Then Milo came out of the van like a man who had been spring-loaded.
"Oh my GOD." He stopped beside me, grabbed my arm, and pointed at the water with the energy of someone discovering the ocean for the first time. "Look at this. Look at it. Adrianna, are you looking?"
"I was looking," I said. "Before you—"
"The color. That's not even a real color. That's what happens when God opens Photoshop and just goes for it." He was already pulling out his phone. "Nobody move. Nobody breathe. I need this for my Instagram."
I had been having a moment. A genuine, unrepeatable moment of inner peace, and this man had walked into it like a marching band through a library. I kind of liked him already but I also wanted to push him into the harbor.
"Milo, I was literally in the middle of—"
"Smile!" He held the phone up, angled it to catch the marina behind us, and took a selfie with my unsmiling face in the background before I could object. "Perfect. You look mysterious and slightly annoyed. Very editorial."
"I am annoyed."
"See? Authentic. That's going to get great engagement."
Jason appeared behind us, clipboard in hand, already moving on to the next item on whatever checklist kept this operation running. "Your luggage will be loaded by the crew," he said, gesturing toward two staff members already unloading the back of the van. "You're welcome to step aboard whenever you're ready. The crossing to Coral Key takes about forty minutes."
One of the boat crew — a woman in a resort polo with her hair pulled back under a cap — was standing at the gangway with the kind of smile that suggested she'd been trained to project relaxation even in a hurricane. "Welcome aboard," she said. "There's seating inside the cabin and an open deck at the stern. Refreshments are in the galley — help yourselves."
Renee had already passed us while Milo was narrating his Instagram strategy. By the time I stepped onto the catamaran she was settled at the far end of the cabin with her legs crossed, bag tucked beside her, and My Husband, My Bride open in her lap.
I watched her turn a page and told myself I didn't care what she thought of it.
Milo and I claimed spots on the cushioned bench near the front of the cabin. He was still looking at his phone, examining the selfie from the dock with the concentration of a man reviewing proofs.
"Okay, the lighting was actually insane back there," he said. "I look incredible. You look like someone told you the resort was cancelled."
"I was having a moment before you destroyed it."
"Moments are overrated. You know what's not overrated? Documentation." He tapped his phone screen a few more times, then looked up and past me toward the back of the cabin. His eyes narrowed. "What's she reading?"
I didn't have to look to know who he meant. "Don't worry about it," I said.
"Don't worry about it?" Milo repeated, in the tone of a man who had just been handed a wrapped gift. "Why would you say 'don't worry about it'? That's the most worrying thing you could possibly say." He craned his neck toward the back of the cabin. "What is she reading? I'm going to go ask."
"Milo, do not—"
But he was already moving, crossing the cabin with the targeted enthusiasm of a golden retriever who'd spotted a squirrel. I watched it happen in real time, unable to intervene, unwilling to look away.
"Hi again," Milo said, stopping in front of Renee. "Quick question. What are you reading?"
Renee looked up from the page with the expression of someone being asked to explain breathing.
"A book."
"What book?"
She turned the cover toward him just enough for him to read it. She didn't say anything. She didn't need to.
I watched it happen from across the cabin — the recognition, the pause, and then Milo's head swiveling between Renee and me as the math clicked into place.
"Oh my God," he said, turning back to Renee. "You're the one who didn't believe her."
Renee's eyes flicked toward me. Just for a second.
"I was enjoying the quiet," she said.
"You sat next to her on the plane, read her book, and told her she didn't write it? That's what happened?"
"That is a dramatic oversimplification."
"How far are you?" He sat down across from her without being invited. "What chapter? Don't spoil anything, I haven't read it yet, but — are you enjoying it? What do you think?"
"I think you sat down without asking."
"Is it good? It's good, right? Tell me it's good. Actually don't tell me, I want to go in fresh, but just — a nod. Give me a nod."
Renee closed the book — carefully, with a finger marking her page — and stood up. "I'll be outside," she said, and walked past both of us toward the open deck at the stern without another word.
Milo watched her go, then turned to me with his eyes wide. "She is amazing."
"She just fled the cabin to get away from you."
"She fled with dignity. That counts for something." He dropped back into the seat beside me with the satisfied air of a man who had accomplished something important. "She's the one, right? The person from the van — 'certain people don't believe I wrote it.' That was about her."
"That was about her."
He leaned back and shook his head slowly. "That's cinema."
Through the cabin window, I could see Renee settling into one of the seats on the stern deck, book already open again, the wind catching the ends of her hair. She looked — I noticed this against my will — completely at ease. As if the rest of us were a weather pattern she'd chosen to wait out.
The engines hummed to life and the catamaran began to pull away from the dock. The marina shrank behind us, and ahead of us there was nothing but open water and late afternoon light. The cabin rocked gently. Milo was already composing what sounded like a review of a book he hadn't read.
"Excuse me — is this seat taken?"
The voice came from a woman who had appeared beside our bench. She clearly had never in her life worried about whether she was interrupting. She was petite, early-to-mid thirties, wearing a patterned wrap dress that mixed at least three prints in a combination that should not have worked but absolutely did. Her smile arrived before her words.
"All yours," Milo said, shifting over.
"Excellent. I'm Talia." She sat down, crossed her legs, and looked at both of us like she'd known us for years. "My wife is getting us drinks. She'll be back in a second with something nonalcoholic and responsible, because Cass doesn't believe in drinking before five, which I think is a character flaw but she thinks is a personality."
She said all of this in roughly four seconds.
"I'm Milo. This is Adrianna."
"Adrianna. Gorgeous name. Are you two together?"
"No," I said. "We met in a parking lot twenty minutes ago."
"Also I'm gay," Milo said. "Like, aggressively, irreversibly gay. Trans women, cis women, all women — gorgeous, all of you, and I could not be less interested. I can admire the craftsmanship but I am not in the market." He looked at me. "No offense, honey."
"None taken."
"I mean you're stunning. Completely wasted on my gayness."
"Yeah, I got that the first time."
Talia laughed — loud and delighted.
"I love you both already," she said. "Okay, but parking lots are underrated. My wife and I met at a dog park. Neither of us had a dog. We'd both gone to look at dogs because we were having bad weeks, and Cass was sitting on the bench looking elegant and miserable and I sat down next to her and said, 'If you had to pick one of these dogs to be your therapist, which one would it be?' And she looked at me like I was insane, and then she pointed at this enormous Great Dane who was just standing there judging everyone, and she said, 'That one. He looks like he'd give you a diagnosis in one session and send you on your way.' And I knew." Talia pressed her hand to her heart. "I just knew."
Milo was staring at her with the expression of a man who had just found religion. "That is the greatest meet-cute I've ever heard."
"Thank you. I tell it at every opportunity. Cass thinks I over-tell it, but Cass is wrong about that specific thing."
A woman appeared beside Talia, carrying two bottles of water with an unhurried calm. She was tall, composed, with warm brown eyes and the kind of quiet self-assurance that didn't need to announce itself.
"I'm not wrong," she said, handing Talia one of the bottles. "I've heard you tell it fourteen times. Eleven of those times, the Great Dane was a different breed."
"I embellish for emotional impact. It's called storytelling."
"It's called unreliable narration." Cass looked at me and Milo with a small, warm smile. "Hi. I'm Cass. She's already told you the dog park story."
"Milo," Milo said, extending a hand. "And it was incredible."
"Adrianna," I said.
"Nice to meet you both." Cass looked at Talia. "Also, she changes the breed every time. Last month it was a Newfoundland."
"The breed is not the point, Cassandra."
Cass sat down beside Talia. "So what brings everyone to Coral Key?"
"We're celebrating our fifth wedding anniversary," Talia said. "Eight years together total. Which is basically a hundred in lesbian years."
"Congratulations," I said, and meant it. Something about the way Talia orbited around Cass — close, constant, gravitational — made the number feel earned.
"Five years. That's amazing," Milo said. "I can't even get a man to commit to a second date. What's the secret?"
"Lower your standards," Cass said.
"She's joking," Talia said. "The secret is finding someone who thinks your worst qualities are funny."
"She's not joking," Cass said. "I genuinely find her worst qualities funny. It's the only reason this works."
Milo was already leaning in, elbows on knees, fully invested. I liked them. I liked them immediately and without reservation, which was unusual for me and probably said something about the kind of day I'd had.
"So what do you two do?" Talia asked, pointing between me and Milo with her water bottle.
"Nurse," Milo said. "Six years."
"Writer," I said. "What about you guys?"
"I'm a graphic designer," Talia said. "Freelance. I do everything — websites, branding, magazine layouts, book covers. Basically if it needs to look good, I'm the one they call when they've already tried to do it themselves and made a mess."
"Book covers?" I said.
"All the time. Mostly indie authors, a few mid-size publishers. I did a sapphic thriller series last year — four covers, each one sexier than the last. By the fourth one my reference folder was basically porn."
"That's oddly specific."
"The sexy cover economy is real, Adrianna. Don't let anyone tell you otherwise."
Milo looked at Cass. "And you?"
"Divorce lawyer," Cass said.
There was a beat of silence that Cass seemed entirely comfortable with.
"I'm sorry," Milo said. "Your wife is out here designing romance covers and you spend your days ending marriages?"
"It keeps things interesting," Cass said.
"She comes home with the worst stories," Talia said. "And I come home with reference folders that would get me arrested. We balance each other out."
"I come home with confidential case details that I don't share," Cass said. "She comes home with softcore on her laptop. Guess which one of us has more fun at work."
"Me," Talia said. "Obviously me."
"So wait," Milo said, turning to me. "Talia designs book covers and you write books. Are we not going to talk about that?"
"We literally just met," I said.
"And? That's how things start. Talia, tell me you're already thinking about it."
"I am absolutely already thinking about it," Talia said.
I looked at Cass for help. She shrugged. "She's already designing it in her head. I can tell."
"Okay," Talia said, sitting up straighter. "But first — what do you write? Fiction, obviously. What kind?"
"Erotica," I said. "My latest is about a married couple figuring out who they actually are. Together and separately. With a lot of sex."
Talia's face lit up. "Erotica. Okay, now I really need to design your next cover."
"You haven't even read it yet," I said.
"I don't need to. I already know the vibe. Married couple, identity, sex — that's moody lighting and close framing. I could do something incredible with that."
"She's not wrong," Cass said. "She's annoying, but she's not wrong."
"So how did the book do?" Talia asked. "Are we talking like, solid reviews? Or actual numbers?"
"Bestseller lists for four months," Milo said, before I could answer.
"Four months?" Cass said, and the slight lift in her voice was the most animation I'd seen from her. "That's significant."
"It did well," I said, understating it in the way you do when saying the real number feels like bragging.
"She's being modest," Milo said. "It took off. She told me in the van. She's famous and she's pretending she's not."
"I'm not famous. The book just kind of went viral and started doing really well."
"Viral," Talia repeated. "Four months on the bestseller lists. And you're sitting here saying it 'did well.' Girl, own that."
"Nobody's recognizing me on the street."
"Yet," Milo said. "Nobody's recognizing you on the street yet. I'm manifesting it for you right now."
He was genuinely the most annoying person I'd met in weeks, and I could not stop finding him funny. It was becoming a problem.
"I mean, people do DM me," I said. "Readers leave comments. Most of them are great — the kind that make the whole thing feel worth it. And then there's the assholes who think writing about sex means you can't actually write." I shrugged. "That's the extent of my fame."
Talia nodded slowly, like she was filing that away. Cass was watching me with a quiet attention I wasn't sure I'd earned yet.
"I'm buying it immediately," Talia said. "Cass, we're buying it."
"I'll read the reviews first," Cass said.
"You will not. You'll read it because I told you to, and then you'll love it, and then you'll pretend you found it yourself. That's our system."
Milo held up his phone. "I'm also buying it. I refuse to be left out."
"That makes two sales on a boat," I said. "My publicist would be thrilled."
"You're not the only one," Milo said, jerking his thumb toward the stern. "Renee back there is already reading it."
Talia's head swiveled toward the stern like a radar dish locking onto a signal. Through the cabin window, Renee was visible on the outside deck, legs crossed, book open, the wind doing things to her hair that a shampoo commercial would have paid for.
"Who is that?" Talia asked.
"That's Renee," Milo said. "We met her at the shuttle. And there is a situation happening between her and Adrianna."
"There is no situation," I said.
"There is absolutely a situation. I was in the van for fifteen minutes and I could have sold tickets." He turned to Talia and Cass. "The tension was so loud I nearly opened a window."
"There was no tension."
"So what happened?" Talia asked, leaning forward.
"It started at the airport," I said. "This woman crashed into me at the curb. My bag went everywhere — phone, sunglasses, everything on the pavement. And instead of apologizing, she commented on my luggage. The size of my luggage. At an airport. Where people have luggage."
"Bold," Talia said.
"Then she vanished. I thought that was it. Over. Done. But no — she shows up in the seat next to me on the plane."
"Same flight?" Cass said.
"Same row. Four hours of her. And at some point I look over and she's reading my book. My book. So I tell her I wrote it, and this woman looks me dead in the face and tells me that's very nice but she's not buying it."
"She didn't," Talia said.
"While holding my book. While sitting next to me. The actual author."
Talia turned to Cass. "This is the best thing I've ever heard."
Cass had been quiet through the whole story. She'd listened with her head slightly tilted, her water bottle resting on her knee, and the expression of someone running a secondary analysis beneath the surface. When the laughter settled, she spoke.
"So you got off on the wrong foot with someone you've been thinking about all day."
The sentence landed with the precision of a dart.
"I haven't been thinking about her all day."
"You remember exactly what she said about your luggage."
"It was a very aggressive comment."
"And you told that story like someone who's been composing it in her head all day."
Talia was grinning. Milo was grinning. I was suddenly very interested in the water outside the cabin window.
"Anyway," I said. "Moving on."
Talia patted my knee. "We can move on. But that is one hell of a story."
"Alright," Cass said. "I think we've thoroughly investigated Adrianna's airport experience." She looked at me with something that might have been an apology, or might have been amusement.
Milo rescued me. "So — fifth anniversary. What's the plan? What are you two doing out here?"
"Everything," Talia said. "Beach yoga. Cocktails. Karaoke. I saw they have a bonfire night and I already know I'm going to be the last one standing."
"What about you?" Milo asked Cass.
"Silence," Cass said. "And a book."
"That's not a vacation," Talia said. "That's a Tuesday."
"My Tuesdays are excellent."
"Oh my God," Milo said, pointing between me and Cass. "There's two of you. You're the same person. You're both going to sit on a beach with books and pretend you're not having the absolute time of your lives."
"That sounds perfect, actually," I said.
"It is," Cass confirmed.
Talia sighed. "Every vacation. I'm out there doing activities, meeting people, living my best life, and she's on a lounge chair not moving for three hours."
"It is relaxation."
"It's reading. Those are different things."
"They really aren't."
"But that's the whole point of this trip," Talia said, softer now. "We barely get time like this. Between her cases and my deadlines, sometimes we go a whole week where the most intimate thing we do is fall asleep on the same couch watching something neither of us picked."
"That happened once," Cass said.
"It happened three times last month. So this holiday is about being together. Actually together. No work, no clients, no deadlines. Just us."
Milo put his hand over his heart. "That is the most beautiful thing I've ever heard."
"She also wants to have a lot of sex," Cass said.
"That too," Talia said, completely unbothered. "I have a whole plan."
"She has a plan," Cass confirmed. "She always has a plan. That's usually where it goes wrong."
"Excuse me?"
"Tell them about Savannah," Cass said.
Talia's face changed. "We don't need to—"
"Tell them about Savannah, Talia."
Talia groaned and covered her face with both hands. "Oh God." She dropped her hands and sat up straight, like she was preparing to testify. "So for our third anniversary I planned this whole trip to Savannah. Romantic bed and breakfast, horse-drawn carriage ride, candlelit dinner at this place with a six-week waitlist. I had the whole thing mapped out. It was going to be perfect."
"It was going to be perfect," Cass echoed, in a tone that made clear it had not been.
"So we get there, and the bed and breakfast is gorgeous. Beautiful. Except the walls are paper thin and the couple next door are having the loudest, most aggressive fight I've ever heard in my life. We're talking screaming, doors slamming, full on soap opera drama. For three hours."
"It was two hours," Cass said.
"It felt like three. So I'm like, fine, we'll go to dinner early. Get out of there. Romantic reset. We get to the restaurant and they've lost our reservation. Gone. No record of it. And I'm standing there with my confirmation email on my phone and the hostess is looking at me like I photoshopped it."
"You did raise your voice," Cass said.
"I advocated firmly. There's a—" She caught herself. "I was passionate about our reservation."
Milo was already laughing.
"We ended up eating at a sandwich shop three blocks away. Which would have been fine, except I'd worn heels for the nice restaurant and by the time we walked there I had blisters on both feet and I was genuinely ready to cry."
"She did cry," Cass said. "In the sandwich shop. Over a turkey club."
"I was grieving the evening I had planned!"
"She was trying too hard," Cass said, looking at me and Milo. "She always tries too hard. The best parts of our vacations are the parts she didn't plan."
Talia opened her mouth, closed it, and then said, "That's annoyingly accurate."
Milo wiped his eyes. "Okay that might be the greatest vacation disaster I've ever heard. But I have one that's worse."
"Impossible," Talia said.
"Mykonos. Two years ago. I met this guy at a bar — tall, dark, gorgeous, spoke four languages, had this jawline that could cut glass. We had three incredible days together. I'm talking beach, sunset, the whole thing. Steamy doesn't even begin to cover it."
"Oh, I need details," Talia said, leaning forward.
"I will spare you the specifics but let's just say the hotel room got its money's worth."
"Don't spare me the specifics."
"The man had stamina, Talia. I'll leave it there." Milo grinned. "And then on day four he told me he was moving to Dubai and that long distance wasn't really his thing. While we were still in bed."
"No," Talia said.
"While I was still catching my breath. He literally rolled over and said, 'So I should probably mention I'm relocating.' Like he was updating his LinkedIn."
Talia was shaking. "That is devastating and hilarious."
"It was both. I cried on the ferry back to Athens and then ate my feelings at a kebab place for two hours." He leaned back. "That was two years ago. Haven't had anything close since. I just want to find my person, you know? Someone who sticks around long enough to fight about where to eat dinner."
It hit differently from when he'd said something similar in the van. There, it had been light — a throwaway line to fill air. Here, with Talia and Cass sitting across from him being proof that it was possible, it landed with more weight.
"You will," Talia said, and she meant it.
"In the meantime," I said, "you have incredible kebab stories."
Milo turned on me. "Oh, she's got jokes now. Miss 'I got into a fight with a stranger before I even boarded the plane.' What's your worst vacation? Come on, share with the group."
"I don't have vacation disasters."
"Bullshit."
"I don't take vacations. This is literally the first one in—" I stopped. "Okay, fine. My friend Sasha and I drove to the Catskills two years ago. Weekend road trip. She was convinced she'd found this incredible cabin on Airbnb."
"And?" Milo said.
"And the photos were from 2015. The place looked like it hadn't been touched since. Peeling wallpaper, carpet that crunched when you walked on it, and the faucet in the bathroom leaked so loud it sounded like someone was slowly clapping all night."
"Stop," Talia said.
"And Sasha calls the owner and asks about it and the guy goes, 'Oh yeah, it does that. Just put a towel under it.' Like that's a solution. Like a towel fixes plumbing."
"Did you put a towel under it?" Milo asked.
"We put three towels under it. It did nothing. And then we tried to go to dinner because the listing said 'great dining options nearby' and the nearest place was this diner that looked like it peaked in 1987 and had been coasting ever since."
"How bad?" Cass asked.
"The menu was sticky. The lighting was yellow. Sasha ordered a burger and it arrived grey. Not brown, not medium — grey. I got a salad that was just iceberg lettuce and a single tomato slice with dressing that tasted like it came out of a bottle from before we were born."
"Did you eat it?" Milo asked.
"Sasha ate the burger. I watched. She said it was fine. Then she spent the rest of the night in the bathroom. We drove home at six in the morning and she didn't speak to me for two days because I was the one who said the Catskills would be fun."
Milo and Talia were gone — leaning into each other, laughing so hard that Milo was slapping his knee and Talia kept repeating "a grey burger" like it was the funniest phrase she'd ever heard. They'd found each other's frequency and they were locked in now, feeding off each other's energy in a way that made the rest of us spectators.
Cass looked at me. "What did we just unleash?"
"I think they might be best friends now."
"God help us," Cass said, but she was smiling.
"Everyone — if you look to your right, Coral Key is coming up."
The announcement came from the crew member at the helm, casual and practiced, but it rippled through the cabin like a current. Everyone shifted. Milo stood up immediately. Talia craned her neck toward the window.
And there it was.
The island came into view slowly — a low green shape against the sky that sharpened as we closed the distance. Lush, dense, fringed with white sand that caught the late afternoon light. The architecture of The Whispering Palms was visible through the palm trees: white walls, dark wood accents, structures that looked like they'd been placed there by someone who understood that a building should get out of the way of the landscape it sat in.
It was beautiful. It was genuinely, absurdly, almost offensively beautiful, and I had been so committed to not being impressed by this place that the feeling caught me off guard.
Milo grabbed my arm. "It looks like a romance novel cover."
"It really does," I said, and meant it.
"This is where your next book should be set. Right here. Tropical erotica."
"First of all, 'tropical erotica' is not a genre. Second, I do not write romance."
"That's the same thing."
"It is absolutely not the—"
"You write about people falling in love but with their clothes off. That's romance just with a lot of sex, honey."
He was grinning at me like he'd just won something. And the worst part was, I had a devastating, airtight, genre-defining response ready — the kind that would have left him intellectually humbled and personally sorry. But arguing with that face felt like kicking a puppy, so I let him have it.
"Fine," I said. "Romance with a lot of fucking. Put that on a bumper sticker."
Renee chose that moment to come in from the stern, passing through the cabin toward the bow to get a better view of the approaching dock.
She glanced at me as she passed. Just for a second — a look I couldn't read. Then she kept walking, and the island kept getting larger in the window.
The catamaran was slowing now. Coral Key filled the view — all of it, everywhere I looked — and the water beneath us had gone from deep blue to the kind of ridiculous turquoise that doesn't exist in real life. Staff in resort polos were already lined up on the dock, ready to do whatever it is boat people do when boats arrive.
Milo was already standing, phone in hand, documenting everything. Talia had grabbed Cass's arm and was pointing at the beach like she'd discovered it personally. Renee was at the bow. I was looking at the island. I was looking at where I'd be spending the next nine days, and I was thinking that maybe — just maybe — this wasn't going to be the disaster I'd been bracing for.

The dock was wider than I expected, built from weathered planks that had clearly seen enough tourists to stop being impressed by them. Staff in turquoise polos were already lined up along the edge — four of them, tanned and smiling, ready to greet us.
"Welcome to The Whispering Palms," the closest one said, a woman with her hair in a low braid and a tray of drinks. Something tall, something pale green, something with a sprig of mint that was trying very hard. "Complimentary welcome cocktails. Passionfruit and coconut."
Milo had a glass in his hand before she finished the sentence.
"Oh, that's incredible," he said, after a sip that could not possibly have been long enough to taste anything. "Is there alcohol in this?"
"Just a splash of rum."
"Then I'll need two." He took a second glass. "One for the journey and one for the arrival. I'm Milo, by the way. I plan to be your favourite guest."
The woman laughed. She'd probably heard some version of that from every guest who'd ever stepped off the catamaran, but Milo said it like he meant it, which was worse.
I took a glass. Sweet, cold, the kind of drink that tasted like an expensive apology for whatever your day had been. I could work with that.
Talia took one and immediately started describing the flavour profile to Cass, who sipped hers in silence — conducting some private evaluation the rest of us weren't invited to. Renee took one too. Didn't comment on it. Just drank it, looking at the island the way she looked at most things — like she was forming an opinion she had no plans to share.
"If you'd like to follow me," the woman said, gesturing toward a row of open-sided golf carts parked on a paved path behind the dock, "we'll take you to reception. Your luggage will be unloaded separately and brought to you there."
Two carts. Three seats across in each. Five people. Somebody was going to end up in a configuration they hadn't chosen.
Talia solved it. "Adrianna, Cass, front cart," she said, already walking. "Let's go."
Cass followed, water bottle in hand, apparently indifferent to the seating politics. Milo and Renee ended up on the second cart — Milo cheerfully, Renee with the expression of someone who had just been assigned a group project partner by a teacher who didn't take requests.
The carts pulled away from the dock and onto a path that wound through the grounds.
The path curved through clusters of actual palms — tall, leaning slightly, throwing shadows across the stone — past open-air pavilions with dark wood beams and white fabric shifting in the breeze. A pool off to the right caught the late afternoon light, the water so still it looked photoshopped, and beyond it the beach stretched out toward a bar sitting right at the edge of it all.
I was not going to get any writing done here. That was immediately clear.
"Okay," Talia said, gripping my arm. "This place — I want to renew our vows here."
Cass leaned forward from behind us. "We've been on the island for ninety seconds."
"And I've already made a decision. That's efficiency."
"It's stunning. It's actually stunning. Look at the bungalows."
The bungalows were scattered among the trees — white walls, wooden shutters, little porches with chairs angled toward the water. I was already mentally ranking it above every apartment I'd ever lived in, which felt disloyal but accurate.
"It's beautiful," I said.
"Beautiful? That's all you're giving me? This place is — I'm going to design a whole brand package for them and send it to the manager uninvited. Cass, I'm doing it."
"Please don't harass the resort staff on our anniversary trip."
"It's not harassment, it's networking."
I glanced back at the cart behind us.
Milo was talking — of course he was — gesturing at the scenery with one hand while the other held his welcome drink at an angle that suggested the laws of physics were a suggestion. Renee was sitting next to him with her arms crossed, staring ahead with the fixed determination of someone trying very hard to enjoy a view while a human foghorn narrated it for her.
Every few seconds Milo would point at something and turn to her, clearly expecting a response, and Renee would close her eyes for just a fraction too long — the kind of blink that was doing the work of a deep breath. Milo would absorb this, recalibrate, and try again with even more enthusiasm. At one point she turned and said something to him — one sentence, from the look of it — and Milo threw his head back and laughed while Renee went back to staring straight ahead, jaw tight, clearly regretting whatever she'd given him.
It was like watching someone try to befriend a particularly elegant cat. The cat was not interested. The cat had made that clear. The man had decided the cat was playing hard to get.
The carts pulled up to an open-air reception area — high ceiling, wooden beams, ceiling fans turning slowly, a long desk made from reclaimed wood, plants climbing every surface they could reach. The kind of lobby that said: we're expensive, but we're not going to be weird about it.
A man was already walking toward us before the carts had fully stopped. Unhurried. Smiling. One hand raised in a half-wave that somehow felt personal even from twenty feet away.
He was solidly built, early forties, tanned deep enough that it had clearly stopped being seasonal a long time ago. Short hair going silver at the temples. The resort polo pressed and tucked, the way some people wear uniforms after long enough — less clothing, more skin.
"Welcome to Coral Key," he said, hand out. "I'm Emmett Hale. I run this place — or it runs me, depending on the week."
Milo shook his hand with both of his. I was starting to understand that was just how Milo shook hands. "Milo. I already love it here. I'm ready to never leave."
"We get that a lot," Emmett said. "We're glad you're here."
He went down the line — handshake, name, eye contact that lasted exactly long enough to feel personal without tipping into weird. When he got to me, I shook his hand.
"Adrianna Moore."
"Adrianna. Welcome."
"Thank you." I paused. "You wouldn't happen to know a Maribel Grant, would you?"
Emmett's face opened up. "Maribel Grant," he said, and there was real warmth in it. "We were at Columbia together. Different programs, same campus."
"She's my editor. She's the one who told me about this place."
"Small world." He shook his head, smiling. "Is she still terrifying?"
"Consistently."
He laughed. "That sounds right. Well, tell her I said thank you for sending you our way. And that she still owes me a visit. Maribel doesn't recommend things unless she means it. I hope we live up to her standards."
"Her standards are unreasonable. Don't worry about it."
He smiled at that, then moved to Renee, who shook his hand with the crisp efficiency of someone completing a required step in a process. "Renee Miller."
"Renee. Welcome."
"Now," he said. "Reception will get you checked in and sorted with your bungalow keys. Quick note — the island operates on WiFi. You'll find the network name and password in your welcome packet at the front desk. Cell service is limited out here, so WiFi is how you'll stay connected." He paused. "Some of our guests consider that a feature."
"I consider it a feature," Cass said.
"That's the spirit." He clapped his hands together lightly. "Let's get you checked in."
Check-in was straightforward. Names, IDs, sign here. The receptionist handed us each a welcome packet and a bungalow key and walked us through the usual — breakfast hours, pool towels, the bar. Milo had three follow-up questions about the bar. I had zero questions but took the packet anyway and pretended to read it while Talia, next to me, was already flagging pages in hers for Cass. Renee took her key, signed her form, and stepped aside. Done. The rest of us were still sorting through our packets when a man came around the corner at a pace that suggested he had somewhere extremely important to be and that place was us.
He was early thirties, toned, with a sunburned nose that looked like a permanent condition and a lanyard around his neck with a whistle on it.
"There they are," he said, like he'd been looking for us specifically. "New arrivals. I can always tell. You've got that look — the 'I can't believe this place is real' look. Love it. Never gets old."
"Lyle Peterson," Emmett said. There was a patience in it that suggested this introduction came with a history. "Our activities coordinator."
"Activities coordinator, chief morale officer, sunset appreciation specialist, and the guy who's going to make sure you have the best time of your life." Lyle was already pulling a stack of papers from a clipboard tucked under his arm. "Which brings me to these."
He pressed a schedule into each of our hands with the reverence of a man distributing sacred texts. Printed in colour. Every day of the week mapped out in a grid of events that would have given a conference planner anxiety.
I scanned mine. Beach yoga, sunrise meditation, guided nature walk, snorkelling excursion, cooking class, cocktail making, game night, karaoke, bonfire night, open mic, couples workshop, sunrise kayaking, sunset cocktails. Every hour accounted for. I was exhausted just looking at it.
"This is... comprehensive," I said.
"That's the goal," Lyle said, beaming. "Something for everyone. You don't have to do all of it — but I will say, the people who lean in tend to have the best time. Last week we had a guy show up saying he was just going to sleep and drink for seven days, and by Wednesday he was leading the karaoke lineup."
"I want to be that guy," Milo said. He was already scanning the schedule. "Wait — cooking class? What are we cooking?"
"Caribbean fusion. Thursday afternoon. Chef Diana runs it. She's incredible. You'll learn jerk seasoning and rum cake and you'll leave a different person."
"I do enjoy a good jerk," Milo said.
Talia snorted. Cass closed her eyes. Lyle blinked once, processed it, and pointed at Milo with his clipboard.
"That's — yeah. Chef Diana's jerk is the best on the island."
"I bet it is," Milo said.
Talia was studying the schedule with the focus of a military strategist. "Cass, look at this. Bonfire night is Wednesday. Karaoke is Thursday. We can do the nature walk Tuesday morning and then the pool in the afternoon and then—"
"We're on vacation, Talia. Not running an itinerary."
"Planning is how I relax."
Cass looked at me. "She's going to have us on a schedule by tomorrow morning."
"I heard that."
"You were meant to."
Renee had accepted her schedule, glanced at it, folded it, and put it in the pocket of her bag without comment.
"What about you?" Lyle said, turning to Renee. "Anything catch your eye?"
"I'll let you know," Renee said, in a tone that meant she would not be letting him know.
Lyle held her gaze for a second, processed whatever he needed to process, and pivoted back to the group with his smile fully intact. "Oh — one more thing. We've got a mixer tonight at seven-thirty over at the main lounge and bar." He gestured down the path behind reception. "You can't miss it. Music, drinks, a chance to meet the other guests. It's casual, it's fun, and I will personally guarantee you a good time or your money back."
"There's no charge for it," Emmett said.
"Exactly. Free good time. No risk."
"We're in," Talia said immediately, grabbing Cass's arm. "All of us. Right?"
"Absolutely," Milo said.
I hesitated. After the day I'd had — the airport, the plane, the van, the boat, and now a man with a whistle telling me about sunset appreciation — I had earned the right to lie facedown on a bed until tomorrow.
"Maybe," I said.
Talia turned on me. "Maybe? We just had the best time on that boat and you're going to ditch us on the first night? That's cold, Adrianna."
I looked at her. She was doing the face. The wide eyes, the slight pout. She'd known me for two hours and she'd already figured out exactly how to make saying no feel like kicking a puppy.
"Fine," I said. "Seven-thirty."
"That's what I'm talking about," Lyle said, and clapped once, loudly, like a man whose faith in humanity had just been restored.
Emmett stepped forward. "Alright — let's get you to your bungalows. If you can identify your luggage over by the carts, staff will load it up and take you over."
I spotted my suitcase and carry-on near the luggage rack and pointed them out to one of the staff.
"Seven-thirty," Talia called out as the carts began to split off in different directions. "Don't be late."
"We won't," Milo said.
I waved, and then the cart turned down a path toward the bungalows and the voices faded and it was just me and a staff member driving in silence through the palm trees. We stopped in front of a small white building with wooden shutters and a porch that faced the water.
"Bungalow fourteen," the staff member said. "Ocean view."
"Thank you."
He carried my bags inside and set them by the closet.
"You're all set. Is there anything else I can help with?"
"No, this is perfect. Thank you."
"Enjoy your stay." He smiled, stepped out, and the door closed behind him.
And then it was quiet. Actually quiet. Just wind and water and nothing else.
The bungalow was bright and airy — white walls, wide windows, late afternoon light pouring in sideways. The bed was ridiculous. White linens, too many pillows, the kind of mattress you look at and think I will never leave this. Two chairs and a low table by the wall. A bathroom through a doorway on the left with tile floors and a deep tub I was already planning my evening around.
And a desk against the far wall, next to a window that looked directly out at the water.
I sat on the bed. The mattress was as good as it looked, which felt unfair. The light was coming in through the windows at a low angle, warm and golden, and the room smelled like clean linen and salt air and I couldn't hear a single other human being. I just sat there for a while. No phone, no laptop, no plan. Just the bed and the light and the sound of the water outside, and the slow, unfamiliar feeling of not needing to be anywhere else.
Then I reached into my tote and pulled out my phone. I hadn't looked at it since before the boat.
The screen was dark. I found the welcome packet on the desk, flipped to the WiFi page, and connected. The messages loaded in a rush.
Sasha. Three texts, spaced about forty minutes apart.
Sasha: Have you landed yet or did the plane crash
Sasha: If you're dead please text me so I know
Sasha: Ade I swear to God if you don't respond in the next hour I'm filing a missing persons report
I smiled. Classic escalation. Love, impatience, threat. The Sasha trifecta.
Me: I'm alive. I'm here. The island is stupidly beautiful.
Her reply came in under a minute.
Sasha: FINALLY. I was composing your eulogy. It was mostly about how you never returned my blue sweater
Me: I returned it. You said it smelled different and gave it back.
Sasha: It smelled like your apartment. That's not the same sweater anymore. Anyway. How is it? Show me the room.
I held up the phone and took a photo of the bungalow — the bed, the windows, the light. Sent it. Then a second one toward the desk and the view.
Sasha: Oh my god
Sasha: That BED. Ade. That bed is obscene.
Me: It really is
Sasha: And that view?? Ade. I hate you. What's the rest of it like?
I lay back on the bed and typed with my phone held above my face.
Me: It's nice. Like actually really nice. I don't want to talk about it because I'll jinx it.
Sasha: Ade giving a compliment without a disclaimer?? The island is already working
Me: Also I made friends on the boat
Sasha: Excuse me???
Me: A married couple, Talia and Cass. And a guy called Milo.
Sasha: You made THREE friends before you even got to the island?? Look at you Ms Moore
Sasha: So you're telling me you got on a boat with strangers and actually talked to them? All of them?
Me: Not all of them. Curbside Karen is here.
Sasha: WHAT
Sasha: AT YOUR RESORT??
Me: Same resort. Same boat. Same universe that apparently won't leave me alone.
Sasha: This is the funniest thing that has ever happened to you
Me: It's really not
Sasha: It really is. You went all the way to a private island to clear your head and trouble followed you through the door
Me: She's not trouble
Sasha: Lol. You are so full of shit.
Me: Goodbye Sasha
Sasha: Rude
I put the phone down and stared at the ceiling. Palm frond shadows moved across the white surface. Outside, the water and the wind and nothing else.
Then I got up and unpacked.
Suitcase first — hanging what needed hanging, folding what didn't. The wrap dress Sasha had called "the closer" got its own hanger. The closet slowly filled up with evidence that I was staying.
Then the carry-on. Chargers on the bedside table. Laptop out. Notebook out.
I carried the laptop to the desk and set it down. It stared back at me like it was waiting for one of us to start writing, and it wasn't going to be the one to go first.
I set the notebook beside it, left them both there, and went to run a bath.
The bathroom was small but good — white tile, frosted glass window, and that tub. I turned the tap and while the water ran I stood at the sink and started peeling the day off.
I found a washcloth, wet it, and wiped the makeup off — all of it, layer by layer, until the face I'd put together that morning in my apartment was gone.
I pulled the clip out and let my hair fall, then gathered it back into a loose knot — the kind that held without effort, the kind I wore when nobody was looking. Unzipped the black shirt dress, stepped out of it, hung it on the hook behind the door.
I looked at myself in the mirror.
Adrian looked back.
Same face, same eyes. Just softer. Less put together. More me.
I didn't linger. I didn't need to.
The water was perfect. I lowered myself in, leaned back, let the warmth close over my shoulders, and for about ninety seconds I achieved something approaching genuine relaxation.
Then my brain started.
You're here. You have a desk. You have a view. You have no excuse. What are you going to write? You don't know. Maribel is waiting. The deadline exists. The blank page will be right there, the same blank page from your apartment, the airport café, the plane—
I sank lower and told my brain to shut up. It didn't. It never did. But at least the water was warm.
My phone buzzed on the tile floor beside the tub. I dried one hand on the towel and checked it.
Sasha again.
Sasha: What are you doing tonight
Me: There's a mixer at 7:30. Drinks and socializing.
Sasha: Are you going
Me: I don't know. I just got here. I'm in the bath.
Sasha: Go.
Me: Sasha.
Sasha: Go to the mixer, Ade.
Me: I've been social all day. Aggressively social. I've exceeded my weekly quota.
Sasha: Good. Keep going. One more event and then you can be a hermit tomorrow.
Me: I'm not a hermit
Sasha: You were a hermit for three months. Go to the mixer. Meet people. Drink something with an umbrella in it. You're on holiday, not serving a sentence.
I stared at the ceiling. The steam was making the room soft at the edges.
Me: Talia wants me to go too
Sasha: See?? I already love Talia. Go. Stop overthinking it. When has staying in ever been the better story?
Me: Fine
Sasha: That's my girl. Now get out of the bath and go be charming.
Me: I'm always charming
Sasha: You're charming when you want to be. Tonight, make sure you want to be.
I put the phone down and sank back into the water. She was right. Annoyingly, persistently, lovingly right. I hated that about her almost as much as I needed it.
I stayed in the bath until the water cooled and my fingers looked like I'd aged thirty years, then drained it, wrapped myself in a towel, and walked back into the main room.
The laptop was still on the desk. The cursor was probably in there somewhere, waiting, patient and accusatory.
I didn't open it.
I picked up the notebook instead. Unlined pages, cream-coloured. I sat on the bed with my legs crossed, opened it to the first page, and uncapped the pen from the welcome packet.
I didn't think about what to write. I just started.
Made it to the island. Bungalow is beautiful. There's a desk by the window and a view that should be illegal and I haven't opened the laptop because I'm apparently allergic to the one thing I came here to do.
Met people on the boat. Talia — graphic designer, talks fast, laughs loud, decided we were friends before I'd finished my first sentence. Cass — her wife, divorce lawyer, quiet, watches everything, said one thing to me on the boat that I'm still thinking about and I'd rather not examine why. Milo — nurse, single, has the emotional volume of a stadium announcer but he's genuine about it. Exhausting in the best possible way.
I paused. The pen hovered.
And then there's Renee. Renee Miller. The woman who has somehow managed to be an annoyance at every single stop of this trip. I don't know what I did to deserve this level of cosmic follow-up but I'd like it to stop. And yet here I am writing about her in a notebook like a lunatic. This is not the creative breakthrough Maribel had in mind.
I stopped writing.
I read the paragraph back. Then I read it again.
I had come to this island to clear my head, and the first thing my head did was fill up with Renee Miller.
I closed the notebook. Then I opened it again, stared at the paragraph, and closed it harder.
I tossed it on the bedside table and sat there for a minute, annoyed at myself. One day. I had known this woman for one day and she was already taking up space in my head rent-free.
And she'd probably be at the mixer tonight. Which was annoying. Or she wouldn't be there, which was — also fine. Completely fine. Irrelevant.
The mixer was at seven-thirty. It was just past six. Enough time to get ready. Talia wanted me there. Milo wanted me there. Sasha had practically issued a court order.
Sasha had told me to go meet people. Maribel had told me to go have fun. Even Cass, who I'd known for an afternoon, had seen right through me on that boat. They'd all been saying the same thing.
And here I was. With people who had decided, for reasons I hadn't fully earned, that they wanted me around.
I opened the closet and stood there.
I had an hour and a half. That was more than enough time to get ready, which meant it was also more than enough time to talk myself out of going.
The wrap dress was too much for a first night. I pulled out a top, held it against myself in the mirror, put it back. Tried another one. Put that back too. I went through four options before I caught myself and stopped. It was a mixer at a resort bar, not a red carpet. Nobody was going to be grading my outfit.
I settled on one of the sundresses Sasha had picked out during our shopping trip — simple, flattering, the kind of thing she'd described as "effortless" while making very clear that the effort had been hers. I laid it out on the bed and went back to the bathroom.
The face I'd wiped clean an hour ago needed rebuilding. Not all of it — but more than I wanted to admit. Foundation, concealer, blending, the whole routine I could do half asleep and still spent too long on. I did my eyes last, kept them soft, and then moved on to my hair, which took longer than everything else combined. Down, then up, then down again. I settled on down, loosely, because "I didn't try that hard" was a look that took about twenty minutes to achieve and I had made peace with that contradiction a long time ago.
I got dressed. Checked the mirror. Adjusted a strap. Checked the mirror again.
It was fine. I was fine. I looked like a person who was going to a mixer because she wanted to, and if that wasn't entirely true yet, the mirror didn't need to know that.
I grabbed my key and my phone, stepped outside, and pulled the door shut behind me. The evening air was warm and still, and somewhere down the path, I could hear music.

The path to the main lounge was lined with low solar lanterns that had just started to glow, casting warm circles on the stone. Somewhere ahead, music — faint, the kind of bass-heavy warmth that reaches you before the melody does.
I was halfway down the path, mentally rehearsing my excuse to leave early, when something moved in the bushes to my left.
"BOO."
I screamed. Not a dignified, controlled gasp — a full, unfiltered shriek that sent a bird out of a nearby tree and probably alerted every guest within a two-hundred-metre radius that someone was being murdered between the bungalows.
Milo stepped out from behind a hedge, hands raised, grinning like he'd just pulled off the heist of the century.
"What the FUCK, Milo?"
"Your face." He was doubled over, one hand on his knee, the other pointing at me. "Oh my God, your face just then."
"I could have had a heart attack."
"You're not exactly elderly."
"Tell that to my cardiovascular system right now."
He straightened up, wiping his eyes, still grinning. "I was walking to the mixer and I saw you coming down the path and I just — the opportunity was right there. I couldn't not take it."
"You were hiding in a bush."
"Technically, I was positioned strategically near some foliage."
I pressed a hand to my chest — my heart was still hammering, for the record — and glared at him. He was wearing a shirt covered in oversized hibiscus flowers that looked like it had been designed by someone who'd lost a bet with a colour wheel. He looked delighted with himself and completely unrepentant.
"You know," I said, starting to walk again, "most people say hello."
"Most people are boring." He fell into step beside me. "Besides, I needed to make sure you were actually coming. You have the energy of someone who would text 'on my way' from inside a locked room."
That was annoyingly accurate but I wasn't going to give him the satisfaction. "I was on my way. Voluntarily. Without the need for a wildlife ambush."
"Sure you were."
"I was."
"Mhm." He nudged my arm with his elbow. "You look great, by the way. That colour is really good on you."
I glanced down at the olive sundress. "Thanks."
"Someone else pick that out for you?"
"How did you—"
"Because you looked down at it like you were checking someone else's homework." He shrugged. "My sister does the same thing when I dress her. You wear it well, though. Own it."
I wanted to argue but he was right, so I just walked faster.
The main lounge came into view through the palms — an open-air structure with a thatched roof, warm wood, string lights crossing overhead in lazy arcs. The whole thing opened onto the beach on one side, and the bar ran along the back wall, bottles lit from behind in amber and gold. There were maybe forty or fifty people already there, clustered in groups, drinks in hand, the volume building the way it does when strangers start deciding to stop being strangers.
Milo stopped walking.
Not slowed down. Stopped. Full halt, mid-stride, like someone had yanked his power cord.
"What?" I said.
He didn't answer. He was staring at the bar with an expression I had only ever seen in romantic comedies and occasionally on nature documentaries when an animal spots its mate across a watering hole.
"Milo. What—"
"I think I'm in love."
I followed his gaze. Behind the bar, a man was making drinks with the kind of practised efficiency that made it look like choreography. Mid-thirties, dark eyes, angular face, sleeves rolled to the elbow. He was shaking something with one hand and reaching for a glass with the other, not looking at anyone, not performing — just working.
"You've been here less than a day," I said, "and you've already fallen in love with a man you haven't spoken to."
"Look at his forearms."
"I'm not looking at his forearms."
"Look at the way he's making that drink. He's not even looking at the glass. He just knows where it is. That's mastery, Adrianna. That's a man who has committed to his craft."
"It's a drink."
"It's a beautifully executed drink."
I looked at Milo. His mouth was slightly open. His eyes had gone soft in a way that would have been endearing if it weren't so immediately, hilariously pathetic.
"You're drooling," I said.
"I'm appreciating."
"You're drooling while appreciating. Come on." I took his arm and steered him toward the bar before he could root himself to the spot permanently. "Let's go get a drink and you can appreciate up close like a normal person instead of standing here like a man who's just seen a religious vision."
We reached the bar. Up close, the bartender was — fine, I could see it. He had the kind of face that didn't ask for attention but got it anyway, composed and unhurried, with the faintest suggestion of a smile that might have been professional courtesy or might have been something he was born with. He was handling three orders simultaneously without any visible strain, moving between bottles and glasses like he'd mapped the whole bar in his sleep.
Milo positioned himself at the counter with the careful deliberation of a man placing his last bet.
"Hi," Milo said. Bright. Warm. Fully loaded with intent.
The bartender glanced up, gave a short nod — acknowledging without inviting — and went back to the drink he was building. "Be right with you."
"No rush," Milo said, leaning on the bar in a way that was clearly rehearsed even though he'd had about four seconds to prepare. "Take your time. We're just — we're here. Whenever."
I watched this happen from approximately eighteen inches away and felt something I can only describe as secondhand devastation.
The bartender finished the drink, slid it across to another guest, and turned to us. "What can I get you?"
"What do you recommend?" Milo asked, in a voice that suggested the answer might determine the trajectory of his entire vacation.
"Depends what you like."
"Surprise me."
The bartender looked at him for one beat — measuring, or maybe just deciding — then turned and started pulling bottles without another word.
Milo looked at me. His face was doing something between triumph and terror. "He's going to surprise me," he whispered.
"He's making you a drink," I said. "That's his job. That is literally what he is paid to do."
"Did you see the way he looked at me?"
"He looked at you the way a bartender looks at a customer."
"There was something there."
"There was nothing there."
The bartender set a glass in front of Milo — something amber with a thin slice of lime balanced on the rim — then looked at me. "And for you?"
"Just a rum punch, please." I paused. "A regular one. No surprises."
He nodded and turned away.
Milo picked up his glass, took a sip, and closed his eyes like a man receiving communion. "Oh, he's talented."
"It's a cocktail."
"It's a statement."
"What is it stating?"
"I haven't decoded it yet but it's saying something." He took another sip. "What's his name? Did you see a name tag?"
I looked. The bartender was already three people down, moving with that same quiet economy, no wasted motion. A small metal pin on his chest caught the light. NICO.
"Nico," I said.
Milo repeated it under his breath, testing the shape of it. Then he nodded once, slowly, like a man who'd just been handed a prophecy.
"I'm going to marry him," said Milo.
"You've exchanged eleven words."
"Twelve. I counted."
My rum punch arrived. I took it and looked at Milo, who was still gazing down the bar at Nico with the unfocused reverence of someone watching a sunset happen to them personally.
"Come on, Romeo," I said. "Let's find a table before you start writing poetry on a cocktail napkin."
We'd barely claimed a high-top near the edge of the bar when I heard Talia before I saw her.
"There she is! Adrianna!"
I turned. Talia was cutting through the crowd with the efficiency of someone who had mapped the room before entering it, a printed wrap in deep blue and gold that somehow worked despite having no business working, her smile arriving a full three seconds before the rest of her. Cass was a few steps behind, hands in the pockets of her linen trousers, looking like a woman who had been brought here under duress and made peace with it on her own terms.
"You're late," I said, when Talia reached the table. "You strong-armed me into coming tonight and then you show up after me."
"We're not late," Talia said, pulling out a stool and sitting down. "We're fashionably—"
"She changed three times," Cass said.
Talia's head whipped around. "Cassandra."
"The first outfit was fine." Cass sat down beside her. "The second outfit was also fine. The third outfit is what we're currently wearing. I lost twenty-two minutes of my life to a skirt and top that was, and I quote, 'giving the wrong energy.'"
"It was giving the wrong energy," Talia said.
"It was a blue skirt and a white top," Cass said.
"It was a sad blue. And the top clashed." Talia turned back to me with the expression of someone who had been deeply betrayed by the person she loved most in the world. "You see what I deal with? No aesthetic sensitivity. None."
"I married you in a custom suit," Cass said. "I have plenty of aesthetic sensitivity. What I don't have is three outfits' worth of patience on a Tuesday."
"It's Friday," Talia said.
"It felt like a Tuesday by the third outfit," Cass said.
I watched this exchange with the quiet satisfaction of a person who hadn't had to live through it.
"So, Adrianna," Talia said, turning back to me. "What did we miss?"
"Ade," I said.
Talia blinked. "What?"
I paused for a second longer than I meant to. "My friends call me Ade."
It came out quieter than I'd intended. Like I hadn't fully decided to say it until it was already out.
"Ade," Milo repeated, testing it. "I love that. That's perfect. That suits you so much better. Adrianna is beautiful but it's a lot of syllables for someone I'm going to be yelling at across a beach."
"Already regretting this," I said.
Milo, who had barely been listening to the outfit debate because his attention was still magnetically fixed on the bar, suddenly tuned in.
"Wait — what did I miss?"
"Talia changed three times before coming to the mixer she insisted everyone attend," I said.
"Three times?" Milo looked at Talia with genuine interest. "What did you reject?"
"A sad blue," Cass and I said at the same time.
Talia pointed at both of us. "I don't like this. I don't like this alliance."
Cass sat perfectly still with the faintest trace of a smile. She'd won, and she knew she'd won, and the best part was that she didn't need to say so.
"Speaking of alliances," I said, and nodded toward the bar, where Milo had been staring approximately ten seconds ago. "Your boy's been having a crisis since we walked in."
Talia followed my gaze. Milo was looking at the bar again, where Nico was building something with crushed ice and a steady hand.
"Who is that?" Talia asked, sitting up straighter.
"The bartender," I said. "Nico. Milo saw him from the path and I thought I was going to have to administer CPR."
"Oh my God." Talia's voice dropped. "He's beautiful."
"He's working," Cass said.
"He can be both." Talia grabbed Milo's arm. "Have you talked to him? What's he like? What did he say?"
"He said 'depends what you like' and then made me this." Milo held up his glass like it was evidence in a trial. "I asked him to surprise me and he did."
"That's flirting," Talia said.
"That's bartending," Cass said.
"No, that's flirting," Talia said. "'Surprise me' and then he just — made something? Without asking? That's a connection."
"That's a cocktail," I said.
Milo ignored all of us and glanced back at the bar. Nico was mid-pour for another guest, head tilted slightly, listening to an order with the patient attention of someone who genuinely didn't mind repeating it. The woman ordering was leaning in, laughing at something she'd said herself. Nico nodded once. Didn't laugh. Turned to make the drink.
"See?" Milo said. "He didn't laugh at her joke. He laughed at nothing with me."
"He also didn't laugh at anything with you," I said.
"Right, but the energy was different."
Talia was watching Nico with the narrowed focus of a woman assembling a case file. "He's got good hands," she said. "Cass, look at his hands."
"I see his hands," Cass said.
"Thoughts?" Talia asked.
"He's making drinks efficiently with them," Cass said. "I'm not sure what verdict you want."
Talia turned to the group with the authority of someone convening a panel. "Okay. Here's what I'm seeing. He made Milo a custom drink without asking a single question, and then moved on like Milo didn't exist. That's either disinterest or very, very controlled interest. We need more data."
"We need to leave the man alone," Cass said.
"We need more data," Talia repeated, as though Cass hadn't spoken. "Milo, you need to go back up there."
Milo straightened. "I was going to wait for a natural—"
"Go get me and Cass a drink. Make eye contact. Report back."
He looked at me. I raised my glass. "Godspeed."
Milo slid off his stool and walked to the bar with the careful posture of a man approaching a customs checkpoint. We watched him lean against the counter, say something to Nico, and gesture at the drinks menu. Nico looked at him, said two words — maybe three — and turned to make another drink for someone else entirely.
Milo stood there for a moment, alone at the bar, his opening gambit absorbed and neutralized with surgical precision.
"Ouch," Talia said.
"He's busy," Cass said, and it was hard to tell if she was being generous or accurate. "He's not ignoring Milo — he's working."
"The timing was bad," I said. "He went in during a rush."
"He'll recover," Talia said, though she looked slightly less confident than she had thirty seconds ago. "He doesn't seem like the type to stay down."
Milo returned to the table with three drinks — a gin and tonic for Cass, something pink and fruity for Talia, and a refill of whatever Nico had made him the first time.
"That was brutal," he said, sitting down.
"What happened?" Talia asked, accepting the drink without acknowledging the bravery of the gesture.
"I handed him the order and he made all three without saying a word. Then when he slid them across he just said 'enjoy' and moved on." Milo stared into his glass. "Do you think he meant the drinks or the evening? Because those are very different levels of investment."
"He meant the drinks," Cass said.
"But the way he said it—"
"Milo." I leaned forward. "He is a bartender at a resort mixer. He is not sending you coded messages through small talk."
"You don't know that," Milo said.
"I do know that."
"Okay." Talia held up both hands. "Official table ruling. Cass — body language assessment. What are we working with?"
Cass, who had apparently been watching Nico with considerably more attention than she'd let on, took a slow sip of her drink before answering. "He tracked Milo when he walked back to the table."
The table went quiet.
"He what?" Milo said.
"When you walked away from the bar just now, he watched you for about two seconds before he went back to his next order. Could be professional — making sure a guest found their party. Could be something else."
Milo looked like someone had just told him he'd won the lottery but they needed to verify the ticket.
"That's promising," Talia said.
"It's promising but inconclusive," Cass said. "And it's going to require patience."
Everyone looked at Milo.
"What?" he said.
"Patience," I said. "Your famous strong suit."
"I can be patient," Milo replied.
"You saw me on a path and couldn't just walk beside me like a person," I said. "You had to hide in a bush first."
"That was spontaneity," Milo said. "Much more charming."
The evening had started to find its rhythm — music up, voices louder, the lounge filling with the particular energy of people who'd been strangers that morning and were now two drinks into deciding they were friends. I was finishing my second rum punch and feeling something I hadn't expected to feel tonight, which was something close to comfortable.
I set the empty glass down and headed to the bar.
Nico was mid-pour when I got there, but he clocked me with a glance and a short nod that said I see you, you're in the queue. I waited. The woman next to me was writing in a small leather-bound notebook with one hand and holding a glass of white wine with the other, glancing up every few seconds to scan the room. She was around my age, maybe a year or two older, with dark hair cut short and practical, and the kind of alert, slightly restless energy that made her look like she was covering a story even when she was just standing there.
I nodded at the notebook. "Working or enjoying yourself?"
She looked up. "Both. Badly."
I liked her immediately.
"Alina. Alina Ortega." She tucked the notebook under her arm and shook my hand. "Travel writer. I'm here on assignment — piece on boutique LGBTQ+ resorts for a magazine. Which means I'm professionally obligated to notice everything and personally incapable of turning it off."
"Adrianna," I said. "Writer. Fiction. Same disease, different symptoms."
"Fiction." Her eyes sharpened with interest. "What kind?"
"The kind with feelings and not enough clothes."
She laughed — short, real. "I respect that. I write about places and end up writing about the people in them. You write about people and, I'm guessing, end up writing about the places they do things to each other in."
"That's a generous summary."
"I'm a generous summarizer."
"Rare quality in a journalist."
"Travel writer. We're the generous ones. The investigative journalists are the ones who'd make you cry."
I smiled. I couldn't help it.
She glanced at her notebook. "So here's my question, writer to writer. Are you here to live something or describe it?"
Nico appeared in front of me, unhurried. "What can I get you?"
"Something with gin," I said. "Dealer's choice."
He nodded and moved away without another word.
I turned back to Alina. "Can't it be both?"
"In theory, absolutely. In practice?" She tapped the notebook. "I've already filled six pages since I got here. I couldn't tell you what the welcome cocktail tasted like because I was too busy writing about the colour of it." She looked at me with the frank self-awareness of someone who'd had this conversation with herself before. "Sometimes the describing gets in the way of the living. Occupational hazard."
"I'm familiar with the hazard."
"I figured you might be." She smiled again — warm, competitive, the kind of smile that said I see you and I think we might be the same kind of problem. "I've got a whole room of material to get to. But I have a feeling we're going to end up talking about this again."
"Probably."
"Good. I could use someone who understands the condition." She raised her glass slightly, turned, and moved back into the crowd, notebook already out again before she'd taken three steps.
Nico appeared and set a glass in front of me — something clear with a twist of cucumber and a sprig of something I didn't recognise.
"Gin, elderflower, cucumber," he said. "Seemed right."
"A man of few words and strong garnish opinions. Noted."
He almost smiled. Almost. Then he turned and walked away.
I picked it up and walked back to the table, thinking that Alina Ortega was going to be either very good company or a very inconvenient mirror. Possibly both.
"Who was that?" Talia asked when I sat down.
"Travel writer. Alina. She's here on assignment, writing about the resort."
"More importantly," Milo said, leaning across the table with the intensity of a man who had witnessed a crime, "did you just make Nico smile?"
"I didn't make him smile," I said.
"I was watching. His face moved. Something happened."
"His face did not move."
"It moved. Cass, tell her his face moved."
"I wasn't watching," Cass said.
"Talia?"
"I was watching you watch him," Talia said. "Does that count?"
"He almost smiled," I said, before I could stop myself. "Almost. It was barely anything."
Milo sat back like I'd just confessed to a felony. "You've known him for two drinks and you got an almost-smile. I've been up there twice and the best I've gotten is 'enjoy.'"
"Maybe try asking for gin instead of flirting," I said.
"I wasn't flirting. I was being personable."
"You were being desperate."
"Those are—" He stopped. Took a breath. "Those are not the same thing."
Talia snorted. Milo looked like he wanted to argue but couldn't find the angle, so he just drank instead.
The mixer was in full swing now, the kind of controlled chaos that happens when you put a room full of strangers in a beautiful setting with an open bar and tell them to mingle. I could see Emmett Hale moving through the crowd with his particular brand of seamless hospitality — a hand on a shoulder here, a laugh at exactly the right volume there, making introductions with the practised ease of a man who had never once forgotten a name in his life. Lyle was a few steps behind him, clipboard in hand, cornering anyone who made the mistake of eye contact.
"Sunrise yoga," Lyle was saying to a couple near the bar, leaning in with the evangelical fervour of a man who believed downward dog could fix the human condition. "Six-thirty on the beach. I'm telling you, the light at that hour? Life-changing. I had a guest last month who said it literally rewired her brain chemistry."
The woman he was talking to looked like she was trying to calculate the minimum number of words required to end the conversation.
"I cried the first time I did it," Lyle added, unprompted. "Full tears. Right there on the mat. The sunrise was just — it was a lot."
I turned back to the table. "If that man comes over here, I'm going to pretend I don't speak English."
"You introduced yourself to him in full sentences during check-in," Cass said. "That ship has sailed."
"Then I'll pretend I've developed sudden-onset amnesia."
"I signed up for the yoga," Milo said.
"Of course you did."
"What? It's good for you. And Lyle seemed genuinely hurt when nobody at check-in signed up immediately."
"So you signed up out of pity."
"I signed up out of solidarity. Pity and solidarity are—" He caught himself. "They're related but distinct concepts."
I saw Renee before anyone else did.
She came into the lounge from the far side, moving through the crowd without hurrying. Dark fitted dress, no embellishment, the kind of thing that relied entirely on the person wearing it — and she knew it, or worse, she didn't. She looked good. I noticed that the way you notice the weather — involuntarily, irritatingly, and with no intention of doing anything about it. She walked straight to the bar, waited for Nico without trying to wave him down, and ordered what looked like a gin and tonic. No browsing, no deliberation. She just stood there and waited for it like she had nowhere else to be.
I looked away before she could catch me looking, which was a choice I made deliberately and then immediately resented myself for making.
"Oh," Cass said, from beside me. "There she is."
I didn't ask who she meant. I didn't need to.
"Renee!" Talia's voice cut across the table before I could stage an intervention. She was waving, both hands, as if flagging down a rescue helicopter. "Renee, over here!"
Renee looked up from the bar. She gave a small wave back. Brief, polite, firmly stationary.
"Talia, she's fine where she is," I said.
"Nobody's fine standing alone at a bar at a mixer. Milo, go get her."
Milo was already standing. "On it."
"She clearly wants to be—"
But he was gone, crossing the lounge with the cheerful determination of a man who had never once in his life accepted a polite decline as a final answer. I watched him reach Renee, say something that made her look at him with the particular blankness she reserved for people who were being unreasonable, and then gesture back at our table with both hands. Renee shook her head. Milo said something else. Renee looked at our table — at me, maybe, or past me, I couldn't tell — and then picked up her drink and followed him back.
"Wonderful," I muttered.
"Be nice," Cass said.
"I'm always nice."
"That's not the same as nice."
Renee arrived at the table with the energy of someone who had agreed to attend a meeting she hadn't been consulted about. She set her drink down and took the last open stool, which happened to be directly across from me.
"Glad you could make it," Talia said, as though Renee had accepted a formal invitation rather than been physically retrieved by Milo.
"I was making it," Renee said. "Over there."
"Over there looked lonely."
"Over there was fine."
"Well, now you're here. And it's better." Talia beamed at her with the particular warmth of someone who has decided you're part of the group whether you like it or not.
Renee took a sip of her drink and settled into the stool without saying anything.
"So, Renee," Talia said, in the voice of a woman who had never met a silence she didn't want to fill. "What do you do when you're not on vacation?"
"Physical therapist."
"Oh, that's amazing. So you fix people."
"I help people fix themselves. It's a distinction I care about more than most people do."
"I'm a nurse," Milo said. "So we're basically in the same world."
"Adjacent worlds," Renee said.
"Adjacent! See, that's practically colleagues." Milo raised his glass toward her. Renee looked at it, then at him, and after a pause that lasted just long enough to be deliberate, raised hers back.
Milo beamed like he'd been handed a trophy.
"Wait — physical therapist," Talia said, leaning forward. "So if I throw my back out doing beach yoga, you're legally obligated to help, right?"
"That's not how that works," Renee said.
"Morally obligated?"
"Also no."
"You're not doing beach yoga," Cass said.
"I might do beach yoga."
"You said, and I quote, 'I will never voluntarily wake up before eight on vacation,'" Cass said.
"People change, Cassandra," Talia said.
"Not by six-thirty tomorrow morning they don't."
"What about you, Ade?" Talia asked. "Any plans for tomorrow?"
"Sleeping," I said. "Possibly aggressively."
"That's depressing," Talia said.
"That's a holiday."
"We should all do something together tomorrow," Milo said. "There's a whole schedule of stuff. Pick something."
"The pool," Talia said immediately. "Afternoon. All of us."
"That's not an activity," Cass said. "That's just sitting."
"Sitting together. As a group. With drinks," Talia said. "That's an activity."
"I'm in," Milo said.
"Renee?" Talia tried.
"Maybe," Renee said. Which from her was practically a blood oath.
Talia opened her mouth to push for a firmer commitment but got distracted by something across the lounge. "Oh God. Lyle's got another one."
We all looked. Lyle had cornered a man near the dessert table — mid-fifties, holding a plate of something chocolate, clearly trying to enjoy it in peace. Lyle was leaning in, one hand on the man's shoulder, the other gesturing at the beach with the passion of a revival preacher. The man was nodding slowly, the way people nod when they've stopped listening but haven't figured out how to leave.
"That man is going to sign up for sunrise yoga just to end the conversation," Cass said.
"He's already signed up," Milo said. "Look at his face. That's the face of a man who's agreed to something he doesn't understand and is too polite to take it back."
"Lyle should sell cars," Talia said. "He'd be terrifying."
"He wouldn't sell cars," I said. "He'd sell the experience of buying a car. He'd stand in the dealership telling you about the sunrise he saw from the driver's seat of a 2019 Honda Civic and how it changed his entire perspective on acceleration, and you'd walk out with a lease you didn't want and a genuine belief that the car understood you as a person."
The table went quiet for a beat.
Milo broke first. Talia grabbed Cass's arm. Cass closed her eyes and shook her head slowly.
And Renee — Renee's mouth did something that was almost, nearly, not quite a laugh. I caught it. Brief, barely there, gone before it fully arrived — but it was real.
I noticed it. I noticed myself noticing it. I found both of these things irritating.
"So what do you do to unwind?" Talia asked Renee. "Outside of work."
Renee looked at her glass. "This."
"This as in the resort? The drink? Sitting at a table with people you didn't ask to sit with?"
"Yes," Renee said.
Talia blinked. "That didn't narrow it down at all."
"It wasn't supposed to."
"Why Coral Key?" Cass asked her, after a pause. "Specifically."
Renee looked at her drink. A moment passed. Then another.
"Quiet," she said. "I came for quiet."
She said it simply. No edge, no complaint. Just a fact about what she'd wanted and what she'd walked into instead.
"Instead you got us," I said.
"Instead I got you."
It should have sounded dismissive. But the way she said it — even, unhurried, looking at the table and not at me — didn't land that way.
Milo stood up. "I'm getting another round. Anyone need anything?"
"You're going to talk to Nico," I said.
"I'm going to order drinks. If Nico happens to be the person making them, that's just how bars work." He was already walking.
He came back a few minutes later with drinks and information. "Three years," he said, sitting down. "He's been working here for three years."
"How did you get that out of him?" I asked.
"I asked how long he'd been here. He said three years. Then he made the drinks and stopped talking."
"A whole sentence," Talia said. "We're making progress."
"But three years," Milo pressed on. "That's commitment."
"Or he's stuck," Renee said.
Everyone looked at her.
"People stay in jobs for all kinds of reasons," she said, picking up her glass. "Not all of them are noble."
It was a perfectly reasonable observation delivered with zero malice, and it landed on Milo like a bucket of cold water anyway. He opened his mouth, closed it, and then turned to me for backup.
"She has a point," I said.
Milo looked betrayed.
"She has a point but it doesn't mean she's right," I added, because the look on his face made me feel like I'd kicked a puppy. "People also stay in places because they've built something worth staying for. Three years here probably says something."
Renee glanced at me. Just for a second. Brief enough that I could have imagined it, except I didn't imagine things like that — I catalogued them.
"Fair enough," she said.
Two words. Directed at me. With no sarcasm, no edge, no qualifier. Just an acknowledgment that what I'd said was reasonable, delivered with the startling economy of a woman who apparently only needed two words to knock me completely off balance.
I took a sip of my drink and said nothing, which was the smartest thing I'd done all night.
Emmett materialized at the edge of the lounge with a wireless microphone and the practised smile of a man who'd done this a hundred times and still meant it.
"Good evening, everyone." His voice carried easily across the space, cutting through the music without competing with it. "Welcome to The Whispering Palms. I hope you've had a chance to mingle tonight — and if you haven't, you're about to."
He paused for the small ripple of laughter that ran through the crowd. Lyle was beside him, holding what appeared to be a small gift basket wrapped in cellophane and tied with a ribbon that matched the resort's colour scheme. He looked like a man who had been waiting for this moment all day.
"We're going to play a little game," Emmett continued. "Simple, classic, impossible to fake if you're bad at it. Two truths and a lie. You give us three statements, the room guesses which one's the lie. We'll do a few rounds, and our activities coordinator Lyle has put together a prize for our most convincing performance."
Lyle held up the gift basket. From where I was sitting I could make out a bottle of rum, something wrapped in tissue paper, and a few smaller items I couldn't identify. He presented it like he was holding the Holy Grail.
"I'm going to win that," Talia said immediately.
"You don't even know what's in it," Cass said.
"Doesn't matter. Winning has prestige."
Emmett started on the far side of the room. The first few rounds were strangers — a woman who'd apparently broken her arm doing something athletic, a couple in matching linen who'd met under circumstances the room couldn't quite believe, a man who claimed to have been on a reality show and was either lying about that or about everything else. The truths were stranger than the lies, which is usually how it goes. People laughed, argued, got it wrong more often than they got it right. Emmett moderated with the easy authority of a man who had run this exact game a hundred times and still found it genuinely entertaining. Lyle kept score on his clipboard, which he'd produced from somewhere — I was starting to suspect he slept with it. The energy in the room had shifted from polite mingling to something looser, warmer, the kind of noise that happens when strangers stop being careful with each other.
Then Lyle pointed at our table.
"Let's hear from this group," he said, with the particular enthusiasm of a man who'd identified his target audience.
Milo went first, because of course he did.
"Okay." He stood up, hands out, commanding the attention of the room with the natural showmanship of someone who had been waiting his entire life for a socially sanctioned excuse to overshare. "Three things. One: I once gave CPR to a man on a cruise ship and he proposed to me when he woke up. Two: I have a twin brother who's also a nurse. Three: I was a background dancer in a Shakira music video."
The room considered this.
"The twin," someone called out.
"The Shakira thing," said someone else.
"The CPR proposal is too specific to be made up," the soap opera woman said.
"The lie," Milo announced, "is the twin brother. Only child. The cruise ship proposal was real — his name was Dennis, he was sixty-three, and we still exchange Christmas cards. And I was in the Shakira video for exactly four seconds. You can find it on YouTube if you freeze-frame."
Talia was already pulling out her phone. "I'm finding this immediately."
"Second row, far left. I'm in yellow."
Talia went next. "One: I once accidentally designed a book cover so explicit that the publisher had to recall the first print run. Two: on our third anniversary, I planned a romantic getaway to Savannah and everything went perfectly. Three: I have a folder on my laptop called 'reference images' that my wife has asked me never to open in public."
Cass closed her eyes.
The room unanimously guessed the Savannah trip, which was the lie. Talia launched into the abbreviated version — the lost reservation, the blistered heels — but Cass put a hand on her arm before she could reach the turkey club, and Talia stopped with the air of someone who'd been gently muzzled.
"The folder is real," Talia added, for the record. "It's for work."
"It's mostly for work," Cass said.
"Cass."
"I'm clarifying."
I went third. I stood up, scanned the room, and felt the particular thrill of performing that I'd been pretending I didn't still enjoy.
"One: I wrote a bestselling novel that spent four months on the charts. Two: I've never been skinny-dipping. Three: I wrote my entire first novel in two weeks."
The room split. Half guessed the bestseller — I looked too young, apparently, or too dressed for a mixer to be a real author, which I chose to take as a compliment. The other half went for the skinny-dipping.
"The lie is number three," I said. "The novel is real, thank you for the doubt. I've never been skinny-dipping. And the two weeks thing — God, no. It took me the better part of a year and most of my sanity."
"Add it to the list," Cass murmured. "Skinny-dipping. Before the week is out."
"Absolutely not."
"We'll see."
Then Talia turned to Renee.
"Your turn."
Renee, who had been watching all of this with the expression of a woman observing a species she hadn't fully classified yet, looked at Talia for a long moment.
"Pass."
"You can't pass," Talia said.
"I just did."
"Renee." Milo leaned across the table. "Come on. Three things. It takes thirty seconds."
"I don't like games," Renee said.
"Everyone likes games," Milo retorted.
"That's demonstrably false."
"Okay, most people like games."
"Then most people can play."
Milo looked at her with the expression of a man who refused to accept a locked door. "One game. Three statements. You don't even have to stand up."
Renee looked at the table. Then at Milo. Then, very briefly, at me — so briefly I nearly missed it — and something in her expression shifted by approximately one millimetre.
"Fine," she said. "One: I can hold my breath underwater for three minutes. Two: I've never read a romance novel before this week. Three: I once got locked out of my apartment and climbed four stories up the fire escape in a dress."
The table went silent for a moment that was slightly longer than the game required.
"The breath-holding," Talia said. "Three minutes is insane."
"The romance novel thing," Milo said. "Everyone's read at least one romance novel."
I said nothing. I was too busy processing statement number two — before this week — which meant she was still reading my book, which meant she'd kept reading after the plane, after the transfer desk, after knowing exactly who wrote it. I filed this information carefully in the same drawer where I kept things I was absolutely not going to think about later.
"The lie is the fire escape," Renee said. "It was three stories, not four. And it was a skirt, not a dress."
"So you can actually hold your breath for three minutes?" Milo said.
"Two fifty-eight. I round up."
"And you'd really never read a romance novel before?" Milo asked.
Renee picked up her glass. "Not my usual genre."
She didn't look at me. She didn't need to. The entire table was doing it for her.
"We should move on," I said, too quickly, and reached for my drink.
The game wound down. Lyle awarded the prize to the woman with the mechanical bull story, who had apparently won the popular vote. She accepted the gift basket with the announcement that she'd be enjoying the rum alone because she was the best company she knew. This received a standing ovation from Milo.
The evening softened after that. The music shifted to something slower, the crowd thinned slightly as people drifted toward the beach or back to their bungalows, and the light from the string lights seemed to settle into something warmer as the night deepened.
Milo had engineered one more trip to the bar — this time to return glasses, which was so transparently an excuse that even Talia didn't bother pretending otherwise. He came back with the report that Nico had said "thanks" when he'd handed back the glasses, and that the "thanks" had been a full two seconds longer than a standard professional thanks.
"Two seconds is within the margin of normal gratitude," Cass said.
"You didn't hear the thanks," Milo said. "It was a lingering thanks."
"There is no such thing as a lingering thanks."
"There is when Nico says it."
I left them to it.
I slipped away from the table. The lounge opened onto the beach on the far side, and there was a low wooden railing where the deck met the sand, the kind of boundary that was more suggestion than barrier. Beyond it, the ocean stretched out flat and dark under a sky that had gone from blue to purple to something I didn't have a word for.
I leaned against the railing and let the sound of the party soften behind me. The air was warm and still and smelled like salt and something sweet from the bar — fruit, maybe, or whatever Nico had been muddling all night.
It was a good night. I'd had a good time. That felt strange to admit, even to myself. I'd come here expecting to put in an appearance and leave early, and instead I'd spent the evening laughing with people I'd known for less than a day, and none of it had felt forced.
"Didn't think I'd see you here tonight."
I turned. Renee was standing a few feet to my left, leaning against the same railing, drink in hand, looking out at the water. She wasn't looking at me. I didn't know how long she'd been there.
"Why not?"
"You seemed pretty set on the whole quiet-and-writing thing." She took a sip. "Figured you'd be in your bungalow with the laptop by now."
"I was strongly encouraged to attend."
"By who?"
"Everyone. Separately. In ways that made declining feel like a federal offence."
Something passed across her face. Not a smile. But not nothing.
I turned back to the water. My heart was doing something annoying that I chose not to examine. "I could say the same about you. You showed up and you let Milo drag you to our table. That doesn't exactly scream 'woman who came for quiet.'"
"I came for quiet. I didn't say I was allergic to people."
"Could've fooled me."
She was quiet for a moment. The waves did their thing — that steady, rhythmic sound that's supposed to be calming and tonight was making me aware of every silence between us in a way I found unhelpful.
"For what it's worth," Renee said, still looking at the water, "you were good in the game. The audience loved you."
I waited for the qualifier. The but you seemed rehearsed. The it must be nice to enjoy attention that much. Something I could push against, something sharp I could catch and throw back.
It didn't come.
"Thanks," I said.
Another silence. This one was different — not combative, not loaded with the next thing either of us was about to say. Just two people standing at the edge of a party, looking at the same ocean, neither of them in a hurry to go anywhere.
Renee finished her drink. Set the glass on the railing.
"You've never been skinny-dipping," she said.
"I've never been skinny-dipping."
She looked at me for the first time since I'd walked over. Her face was half in shadow, half in the warm glow from the string lights, and the expression on it was something I hadn't seen before — not guarded, not sharp, just present. Like she'd set something down and hadn't picked it back up yet.
"That's a shame," she said.
Then she pushed off the railing, picked up her glass, and walked back toward the lounge without another word.
I stood there.
The ocean didn't have any answers. I checked.
I stayed at the railing for another minute, maybe two, listening to the waves and the distant sound of the party winding down and the very specific silence that a person leaves behind when they say something like that and then just walk away.
Then I went back to the table, finished my drink, and told Milo I was calling it a night.
"Already?" he said. "Nico hasn't closed the bar yet. I was going to wait and offer to help him carry things."
"That's called loitering."
"That's called chivalry."
I said goodnight to Talia and Cass. Talia hugged me. Cass gave me a nod that was warmer than most people's hugs. Then I walked back to my bungalow along the same lantern-lit path I'd come down earlier that evening.
The evening air was warm. The music was fading behind me. And somewhere between the railing and the path, Renee Miller had said that's a shame and walked away, and I was going to have to find a way to not think about that for the rest of the night.
I was already failing.

The bed was trying to keep me.
I'm not being dramatic — that mattress had an agenda. Every time I shifted, thinking about sitting up, it reshaped itself around me like some kind of sentient cloud, finding the exact contour of my body and sinking me deeper into whatever horsehair-memory-foam-angel-feather situation the resort had invested in. The sheets were cool and impossibly soft. The pillows — plural, because this place apparently believed in excess — smelled faintly of coconut and something floral I couldn't name and didn't want to because naming it would mean I was awake.
I made it as far as rolling onto my side. That felt like an achievement.
The bungalow looked different in the morning. The sun was pressing through the wooden shutters in fat golden stripes, laying itself across the tile floor and up the foot of the bed, aggressively cheerful, the visual equivalent of a morning person telling you to smile. The ceiling fan turned in its slow, patient circle. Birds were making noise outside, the sort of effortless morning symphony that would've been lovely if I hadn't been lying there bargaining with myself like a hostage negotiator.
Get up.
No.
It's nine o'clock.
The pillow smells like coconut.
That's not a reason.
It's absolutely a reason.
The pillow was winning. The pillow was making an airtight case and I had no rebuttal. But somewhere between the coconut and the ceiling fan and the birds outside doing their whole performance, a thought arrived with the unwelcome clarity of a fire alarm: coffee. Coffee existed. Coffee was somewhere in this resort, probably hot and probably strong, and it was not going to walk itself to my bed. If I wanted it — and I wanted it the way people in deserts want water — I was going to have to get up and go find it like a functioning adult.
I threw the sheet off. That was step one. Step two was swinging my legs to the floor. Step three was sitting up, which my body interpreted as a personal attack. The tile was cool under my feet and the air from the fan moved over my skin and I sat there on the edge of the bed for a full minute, blinking at the room like someone who'd been woken from a coma and was still processing shapes.
Eventually I stood. Shuffled to the bathroom. The mirror was honest but not cruel — I'd slept well enough to look human, which was more than I could say for most mornings at home. The oversized t-shirt I'd slept in had done its job. I brushed my teeth with the kind of mechanical focus that suggested my brain hadn't fully come online yet.
Back in the room, I opened the closet and stared at the options with the decision-making capacity of someone who had been vertical for approximately four minutes. Shorts. A cotton top — something light and simple, the kind of outfit that said I'm on vacation but make it effortless. Makeup was the quick version — concealer, tinted lip balm, done in under three minutes. Not the full production, but enough to feel like myself. Hair up, because the humidity had made its position clear the moment I'd arrived yesterday, and I saw no reason to pretend I could win that fight.
I slipped on sandals, grabbed my phone, and headed out.
I stepped outside and the morning hit me — warm air, salt, the sound of the water somewhere close. The ocean was right there, doing what it had apparently been doing all night without supervision, and for a second I just stood on the porch and let it exist.
The path to the restaurant wound through the resort grounds, lined with the kind of lush greenery that offered plenty of places for a person to hide. I gave every hedge a once-over on the way, because I was not getting ambushed twice in twenty-four hours.
No Milo. Just birds, sunlight, and the distant sound of someone doing something athletic near the water.
I started walking.
The restaurant was open-air, which I was beginning to understand was just how everything worked here. A buffet line ran along the far wall — fruit, pastries, eggs in three different configurations, a waffle station that a man in chef whites was operating with solemn dedication.
Coffee first. Always coffee first. I grabbed the largest cup available and filled it without ceremony, then turned my attention to food. I was midway through adding a second piece of toast to my plate when a voice appeared behind me.
"You look like someone who only functions after caffeine."
I turned to find Cass, coffee in hand, linen shirt and shorts, looking like she'd walked out of a catalogue for people who were good at mornings. I was still catching up.
"That's not an observation, that's just a fact about most adults," I said.
"Most adults don't hold their coffee cup like it's the last one on earth."
I looked down at my hand. She had a point. I loosened my grip.
Cass nodded toward the far side of the seating area. "Talia already has a table. She's been up since sunrise."
"Voluntarily?"
"She set an alarm."
"On vacation."
"I married her." Cass took a sip of her coffee. "I'm aware of what I signed up for."
We walked to the table. Talia was already set up — plate loaded, fresh juice, sunglasses pushed up into her hair — and talking before we'd sat down.
"Morning!" Talia said, with the kind of energy I hoped to achieve by noon. "Did you sleep okay? That mattress is insane, right? I told Cass we need to find out the brand. We need that mattress."
"We don't need it."
"We absolutely need it."
"You slept well, then," I said, sitting down.
"Like the dead. Cass barely moved all night. I checked."
Cass set down her coffee. "She checked."
"I like to make sure you're breathing."
"She watches me sleep."
"Lovingly."
I was halfway through my toast and starting to feel like a person again when there was a commotion. Or, more accurately, when a fully formed human man materialised next to our table as if he'd been teleported there by an uncaring god.
"Good morning, beautiful people!"
All three of us flinched. Talia's juice sloshed. Cass grabbed the edge of the table. I dropped my fork.
Milo stood there grinning, wearing a shirt that appeared to be covered in parrots mid-argument, looking like he'd been awake for hours and had spent every one of them storing up enthusiasm for this exact moment.
I smacked his arm. Not gently.
"You have got to stop doing that."
"Doing what?"
"Appearing. Out of nowhere. Like a goddamn haunted house attraction."
"I walked up. Normally. Like a normal person."
"Nobody who is normal just arrives at a table without making any sound," Talia said, pressing a hand to her collarbone. "My heart is in my throat."
"You all need to pay more attention to your surroundings," Milo said, dropping into the empty chair. "I was right there."
"Where? In which dimension?"
He waved this off and reached for a piece of fruit from Talia's plate. She didn't stop him.
"So," he said, chewing, "none of you went to yoga this morning."
It wasn't a question.
"Lyle was out there at six-thirty. Mat laid out, little Bluetooth speaker playing the kind of music they use in spas to stop people from committing crimes. I went for a walk and saw him setting up. He had the whole beach sectioned off." He shook his head. "I walked past again about forty minutes later and it was just Lyle and two women who looked like they'd been doing yoga since before it was invented. That was it. The man looked personally betrayed."
"To be fair," Cass said, "six-thirty is an act of aggression."
"We should try at least one thing on that schedule," Talia said. "I didn't come here to just lie around."
"I did," Cass said.
Milo looked at me. "Where's Renee?"
The question landed with the gentleness of a brick through a window.
"How would I know where Renee is?"
"You were the last one seen with her." He let that sit for half a second, eyes twinkling with the delight of a man who knew exactly what he was doing. "Cass saw you two at the railing last night."
I looked at Cass. Cass looked back at me with the serene expression of someone who absolutely had seen us at the railing and had drawn every available conclusion.
"We were standing," I said. "Near a railing. At a mixer. Where people stand. Near things."
Nobody said anything. Talia was smiling. Cass was smiling. Milo was definitely smiling. The collective weight of three people smiling at me while I held a piece of toast was more than I was willing to deal with before my second coffee.
"We talked for about thirty seconds and then she left. That's the whole story. That's all the data. There is nothing to process here."
"We didn't say there was," Cass said.
"Your face said there was."
"My face is just my face," Cass said.
The thing was — and I was absolutely not going to say this out loud, because the table was already treating me like a research subject — Renee had been different at that railing. No sharpness, no dry comments designed to make me feel like I'd wandered into an argument I hadn't prepared for. She'd said I was good in the game. No qualifier. And then the skinny-dipping comment, and that's a shame, and she'd just walked away like she'd mentioned the weather.
I took a bite of toast and did the thing I was getting very good at doing: I pushed it out of my head.
Renee hadn't appeared for breakfast. I noticed this. Then I stopped noticing it.
"So," Talia said, leaning forward. "Pool this afternoon?"
"I was actually going to try to get some writing done this morning," I said.
The table looked at me the way you'd look at someone who'd just announced they were going to spend a beach vacation reorganising their sock drawer.
"Work," Milo repeated.
"Yes. Writing. The thing I do."
"On the first full day."
"Inspiration doesn't take vacation days, Milo."
"Ade." He put his hand flat on the table. "You are on an island. There is a pool. There is a beach. There is a very attractive bartender who I have dibs on but who you are welcome to admire from a respectful distance. And you want to sit in your bungalow and stare at a laptop."
"That's a reductive description of my creative process."
"Your creative process sounds depressing."
"Good luck," Talia said, raising her juice glass. "We'll be at the pool when you give up."
"If," I said.
"When," the three of them said, not quite in unison but close enough.
I finished my coffee, stacked my plate, and left them to it. I hadn't made it far from the restaurant when I saw her.
Renee was coming from the direction of the bungalows, heading toward the restaurant. Hair down, white t-shirt, cotton shorts, looking more awake than anyone had a right to.
We spotted each other at roughly the same time. There was a moment where the path was wide enough to just nod and keep walking, and narrow enough that we didn't.
"Morning," I said.
"Morning." She slowed. "Breakfast?"
"Just finished. Coffee's good."
"That's all I need to hear."
We stood there for a second. The morning was already warm, and the air between us had its own temperature. I was aware of last night. The railing, the quiet, the two words she'd said before walking away. And I was aware that she probably wasn't thinking about any of it, which made the fact that I was thinking about it significantly worse.
"I'm heading back to try to write," I said, because I needed to say something that had nothing to do with railings or skinny-dipping.
Renee nodded. "Good luck with that."
I couldn't tell if it was genuine. With Renee, that was always the question.
"Thanks."
She headed toward the restaurant. I headed toward my bungalow.
The bungalow was quiet when I got back. I kicked off my sandals and dropped my phone on the bed. The desk was right there — laptop closed, chair pulled out slightly from where I'd left it. I stood there for a second, looking at it the way you look at something you know is about to disappoint you.
I sat down at the desk and opened the laptop. The screen woke up.
There it was. The cursor.
I thought about the water outside the window. I thought about the light. I thought about the fact that I was sitting at a desk in paradise with nothing between me and the page except every creative fear I'd ever had, which seemed manageable if you didn't look at it directly.
I started typing.
The heat was the first thing. It met her at the door like a wall, thick and wet, and by the time she'd crossed the tarmac her dress was already clinging to her back. The city she'd left was grey and sharp-cornered and running on caffeine and deadlines, and the island operated on a different clock entirely. Slower. Warmer. The kind of warm that got into your skin and stayed there.
I read it back. It was fine. That was the problem — it was fine. It was a paragraph that existed and had sentences in it and none of those sentences were wrong, exactly, but none of them were doing anything either. It sounded like a woman describing a holiday to someone who hadn't asked.
I kept going anyway.
She didn't know anyone here. That was the point — or that was what she'd told herself when she'd booked it, standing in her kitchen at midnight with a glass of wine and the kind of recklessness that only shows up when you've run out of better ideas. Nobody here knew her name or her history or the mess she'd been making of things lately. She could be anyone. She could be the version of herself she kept meaning to become.
I stopped. Read both paragraphs together.
It was worse than bad. Bad would have meant something was happening on the page, even if it was happening wrong. This was just there. Sitting on the screen like a postcard nobody had asked for. Every sentence competent. Every sentence dead on arrival.
I selected everything and held the delete key, watching the words vanish letter by letter — slower and more painful than highlighting and hitting backspace, but it felt appropriately dramatic for the occasion.
I stared at the empty page for another few minutes, then closed the laptop, picked it up, and carried it to the beach. A change of scenery. Maybe that was all I needed — different air, different view, the sound of the water doing something useful for once.
I found an empty lounger on the beach, sat down, and opened the laptop. The cursor was still there. Still blinking.
I watched the water instead.
The ocean was doing what oceans do — rolling in, pulling back, being relentlessly beautiful in a way that felt like showing off. The colour shifted where the reef sat below the surface, turquoise bleeding into a deeper blue that looked like it went down forever. A couple walked along the waterline holding hands, their footprints dissolving behind them. A woman a few loungers down was laughing at something her partner had said, easy and unselfconscious, and I hated her a little for it.
I wrote nothing.
I shifted positions twice. I watched two different couples walk the same stretch of waterline. I checked my phone, put it down, checked it again. The cursor blinked. I closed the laptop and opened it again as if that would change something. It didn't.
By the time I checked my phone for the third time, an hour had passed and the document was still empty.
"There you are!"
Lyle Peterson appeared from behind the tree line, clipboard in hand, looking like a man on a mission.
"Great spot, right?" He gestured at the ocean as if he'd personally installed it. "The morning light on this stretch is really something. We had a guest last year who painted watercolours right here — same angle, everything."
"That's lovely."
"So — just wanted to flag a few things on today's schedule." He consulted the clipboard with the reverence it apparently deserved. "We've got a snorkelling excursion leaving at eleven — the reef on the east side has visibility like twenty metres, it's unreal. At two there's a beach volleyball tournament, teams of four, very chill. And at four we've got a mixology class at the bar with Nico — that one's really popular. You make three cocktails and you keep all of them."
"I appreciate it, Lyle. I'm actually trying to—"
"The mixology class fills up fast. Nico's been running it for about a year now and the drinks are genuinely amazing."
"I'll think about it."
"The snorkelling is also—"
"I'll think about all of it, Lyle. Thank you."
He nodded, smiled, and retreated toward the tree line with the brisk energy of a man who had at least six more guests to find before lunch.
I looked down at the laptop. The cursor looked back.
"Shit," I said, to nobody and to the ocean and to whatever part of my brain was supposed to be producing a novel.
I closed the laptop and stood up, brushing sand off my shorts. An hour on the beach. Nothing. The change of scenery had changed nothing — different view, same empty page.
I walked back toward the bungalow, which meant cutting through the pool area. Cass was on one of the sun loungers with a book propped open against her knees.
"That was fast," she said, without looking up from the book.
"What was?"
"Your morning of productive writing."
I dropped into the lounger next to hers. "I don't want to talk about it."
Cass turned a page. "That good?"
Talia appeared a few minutes later in a two-piece, towel over one arm, bag over the other, looking like a woman who had packed for the pool the way other people packed for international travel. She claimed the lounger on Cass's other side and started arranging her things with a focus that bordered on architectural.
"Ade! I thought you were working."
"I was. Wrote two paragraphs. Deleted both. Moved to the beach. Wrote nothing. That page is my nemesis."
"I thought Renee was your nemesis," Cass said. Still not looking up from her book. "When did it become a Word document?"
I stared at her.
Talia went first — a laugh she tried and failed to smother behind her hand — and it set Cass off too, the two of them doing that thing couples do where they feed off each other's amusement while the subject of the joke sits there contemplating whether assault charges are worth it on vacation.
"That's not funny."
"It's a little funny," Cass said.
"It is funny," Talia said, nodding.
"You know what might actually help?" Cass set the book down and pushed her sunglasses up. "Stop trying. I mean it. You've been here one day. Your brain is still running on city speed. Give it a break. Sit by the pool, drink something cold, let your mind go wherever it wants for a few hours. You can't muscle your way into it."
"She's right," Talia said. "You can't force creativity. It's like when we're trying to pick a restaurant — the more we deliberate, the worse it gets. Our best meals are always the ones we stumble into."
"That's a terrible analogy," Cass said.
"It's a perfect analogy."
"It's about dinner."
"It's about surrendering to the process."
"It's about restaurants, Talia."
I watched them. This was going to go on for a while. There was something genuinely comforting about it — the well-worn grooves of two people who'd been having the same argument for eight years and would probably be having it for another forty.
"What about activities?" Talia said. "We could do the snorkelling."
Cass exhaled through her nose.
"Beach volleyball?"
Cass closed her eyes.
"Or we could—"
"Stop suggesting athletic things," Cass said. "It's our anniversary trip. I didn't come here to spike a volleyball."
"Talia, every time you suggest something, she groans," I said.
"I don't groan," Cass said. "I evaluate audibly."
"What about the mixology class?" Talia said. "Four o'clock at the bar."
That landed differently. Cass opened one eye. I raised an eyebrow.
"Milo will lose his entire mind," I said.
"Oh, absolutely," Talia said, grinning. "Which is reason enough."
I didn't say anything for a second. Milo in a cocktail class run by Nico. An hour of watching that man try to act casual around the bartender he'd barely managed to string a sentence together for at the mixer. That was worth showing up for.
"I can see you about to say you'll think about it," Talia said. "Don't."
"She's doing the face," Cass said.
"Come on, Ade. It'll be fun. All of us, drinks — just come."
There was no arguing with it. Talia said things and then they became facts. It was either a gift or a weaponised personality trait, depending on which side of it you were standing on.
"Fine. But only because watching Milo make a complete fool of himself in front of Nico sounds like the best entertainment this island has to offer."
I spent the next hour by the pool doing nothing productive and feeling only moderately guilty about it. Cass read. Talia applied sunscreen with the methodical precision of someone following a dermatological protocol. I lay on the lounger and let the sun do whatever it wanted to my skin and tried very hard not to think about the two paragraphs I'd written and killed.
Eventually I swung my legs off the lounger and reached for my sandals.
"Heading back?" Talia asked.
"I need a shower before this class I've apparently committed to."
"Four o'clock," Talia said. "Don't be late."
"She means don't flake," Cass said, turning a page.
"I won't flake."
"That's exactly what someone who's about to flake would say."
I left them to it.
The path to the bungalows was becoming familiar now — I knew where the hibiscus thickened, where the gravel gave way to packed sand, where the palm canopy opened up enough to let the sun hit the ground in gold patches. I was about halfway there when I heard footsteps matching mine and turned.
Renee. Walking the same direction at approximately the same pace, as if the universe had decided to synchronise our schedules without checking with either of us first.
She caught up without visibly speeding up — a skill I was beginning to associate specifically with her — and we fell into step together without discussing it.
"Pool?" she asked.
"For a bit. You?"
"Just a walk. Getting to know the grounds."
"And?"
"It's a nice island."
We walked. Neither of us rushed to fill the quiet.
"Plans for the rest of the day?" I asked.
"Quiet. A book. Nothing that involves a schedule or a whistle."
"Lyle found me on the beach this morning."
"My condolences."
I laughed. It came out before I could catch it.
"He mentioned there's a mixology class at four," I said, and I said it the way you'd mention something you'd just remembered and not the way you'd invite someone to something, which is definitely what I was doing, and which I realised I was doing roughly half a second after I'd started. "At the bar. Talia, Cass, and I are going. Milo will likely be there too. Should be fun watching him try to make a cocktail without staring at Nico the entire time."
Renee considered this for a pace or two. "I think I'll pass."
"Yeah. Sure. It's probably just—" I let the sentence die on its own. "Yeah."
I reached my bungalow and stopped. Renee kept walking.
"You're further down?" I asked.
"Twelve."
"Okay. Well. Enjoy your... quiet."
"Thanks."
I went inside, closed the door, and stood there for a second wondering why I couldn't end a conversation with this woman without sounding like I was buffering.
The bungalow was cool and dim, the ceiling fan doing its slow rotation, the bed still unmade because housekeeping apparently came in the afternoon and I was living like someone who deserved nice things regardless of whether she'd earned them today. My phone was on the nightstand where I'd left it. One notification.
Maribel.
I sat on the edge of the bed and opened the thread.
Maribel: Alive?
Ade: Alive. The bungalow is ridiculous. Met Emmett — he says hi.
Maribel: He would. That man greets people for a living. How are you feeling?
Ade: Like a person on vacation who doesn't know how to be on vacation.
Maribel: That's exactly what I expected you to say. Rest. Don't force anything.
Ade: You sent me here to write and now you're telling me not to force it.
Maribel: I sent you there to be a person. The writing will follow.
I put the phone down beside me and stared at the ceiling fan for a while. The blades went around. The writing will follow. She said it like it was a fact, like gravity or weather — something that just happened if you let it. Maribel had a way of making everything sound inevitable, even the things that felt impossible from where I was sitting.
I picked the phone back up. Maribel was good for the truth, but right now I needed someone who would let me complain without turning it into a life lesson.
Ade: Update from paradise: the island is still beautiful, the bed is still trying to absorb me into its structure, and I spent the morning attempting to write and producing absolutely nothing usable.
I dropped the phone on the bed beside me and kicked off my sandals. Looked at the ceiling fan again. The phone buzzed.
Sasha: Shocking. A woman who spent three months staring at a wall in her apartment can't magically write on a beach. Who could have predicted this.
Ade: Your support means the world.
Sasha: I support you by telling you the truth. The truth is you need to chill. You've been there one day.
Ade: Everyone keeps saying that.
Sasha: Everyone is correct. What else is going on? Give me gossip. I need to live through you because my life is boring and I ate cereal standing over the sink for dinner.
Ade: Milo is in love with the bartender. He's known the man about twelve hours and has interpreted every word out of his mouth as a coded love letter.
Sasha: I respect that level of commitment. What about Curbside Karen? She still being awful?
Ade: She's not awful. She went to the beach by herself today. We ran into each other on the path this morning. And then again just now, actually. Renee's in bungalow 12.
I sent it without thinking. Three seconds later, the realisation hit me like a truck with bad brakes.
Sasha: Wait.
Sasha: RENEE???
Sasha: Her name is RENEE now??
Ade: That's her name. That's always been her name. I've known her name since the airport.
Sasha: Ade. I have been calling this woman Curbside Karen since you first told me about her. She was "that woman." She was "the one from the plane." And now she's Renee. With a first name. And you know her bungalow number.
Ade: She told me. It came up. We were walking the same direction.
Sasha: WALKING TOGETHER
Ade: Walking the same direction. Those are different things.
Sasha: They are not different things. They are the same thing with extra words around it. You are walking. Together. To your adjacent bungalows. Where you live. Two doors apart.
Ade: This is a normal thing that happens at resorts where people are staying in the same area.
Sasha: Mhmm.
Ade: Don't start.
Sasha: MHMM.
Ade: I am begging you.
Sasha: You texted me because you wanted to say her name. You wanted to use it and see how it felt and now you have and you can't take it back. RENEE. The woman has been promoted from nickname to government name. This is the biggest development since you called her "not trouble."
Ade: I should never have texted you.
Sasha: You should always text me. Tell me more about Renee.
Ade: There's nothing to tell. She's quiet. She keeps to herself. She said she didn't want to come to the mixology class later.
Shit.
Sasha: You invited her to a mixology class???
Ade: Not invited. Mentioned. In passing. Offhandedly. While walking.
Sasha: TOGETHER.
Ade: I need to take a nap.
Sasha: You need to take a long hard look at yourself is what you need to take.
Ade: Goodbye, Sasha.
Sasha: Say hi to RENEE for me. Your neighbour. Who you INVITED to a COCKTAIL CLASS.
I dropped the phone on the pillow next to me and stared at the ceiling fan. The blades went around. The afternoon light had softened into something warm and slow. The bed was doing its thing again — pulling me down, rearranging itself around me like it had been waiting for me to come back.
I closed my eyes. Just for a minute.
When I opened them, the light in the room had changed. The sun had shifted, the shadows stretched longer across the floor, and I had the specific kind of disorientation that comes from falling asleep in the middle of the day and waking up in a different version of it. I grabbed my phone. Three-fifteen.
I'd slept through lunch.
The mixology class started at four.
I got up, stripped, and got in the shower. The water pressure was absurd — the kind of pressure that felt like the resort believed even basic hygiene should be an experience — and I stood under it longer than I needed to, letting the day rinse off. I washed my hair, considered my life choices, and decided that a day of failed writing, poolside lounging, and napping was still technically a day of creative recovery if you didn't examine it too closely.
I dried off and went to the closet. A skirt — mid-length, lightweight, the kind of thing you could sit on a barstool in without thinking about it — and a spaghetti strap top, simple and fitted, nothing that was trying too hard. Sandals. Makeup was the evening version of the morning routine — concealer, a little bronzer, tinted lip balm, just enough to look like myself without looking like I'd tried. I checked the mirror, adjusted a strap, and called it done.
The walk to the bar took five minutes, and I could hear the group before I saw them.
The beachfront bar had been rearranged — a long stretch of counter space cleared and set up with bottles, shakers, cutting boards, and fresh fruit in neat rows, looking like a cooking show that served alcohol. And behind all of it, moving between stations with the quiet efficiency of a man who'd been born back there, was Nico.
Milo was already there.
Of course Milo was already there. He was standing at the near end of the counter, positioned as close to Nico as it was possible to be while still maintaining the fiction that he was there for the cocktails. His body language was broadcasting "casual interest" with all the subtlety of a neon sign.
Talia and Cass had claimed stools a few seats down. They were watching with the expressions of people who'd bought front-row tickets to something they fully intended to enjoy.
"He's been here since three-thirty," Talia informed me as I sat down.
"The class starts at four."
"He wanted a good spot," Cass said. "The bar is twelve feet long. Every spot is a good spot."
I looked at Milo. Milo was looking at Nico. Nico was slicing limes with the focus of a man performing surgery.
"Has he talked to him?"
"He ordered a water," Talia said.
"A water."
"He walked up there with a plan and what came out of his mouth was can I have some water, please." Cass paused. "Nico gave him water. Milo came back and told us he thought that went well."
"Did it?"
"He ordered water at a bar, Ade."
I glanced around the bar as more guests filtered in — a couple I recognised from the mixer, two women in matching sun hats who seemed to already know everyone. The class was filling up.
And Renee — as she'd said — was not there.
She'd told me she wasn't coming. She hadn't come. That was a person keeping their word. Completely consistent, completely expected, and absolutely nothing worth registering.
I registered it anyway.
Nico tapped the flat of his knife against the cutting board and the chatter softened. He didn't raise his voice. He didn't need to.
"Afternoon." He set the knife down. "We're making three drinks today. I'll show you each one, then you make your own. First up is a classic daiquiri — the real version, not the frozen one. Rum, lime, simple syrup. Balance matters more than anything else."
That was more consecutive words than I'd heard from Nico in total. He spoke the way he moved behind the bar — precisely, nothing extra, every word doing exactly one job. Then he started building the drink, and the bar went quiet.
His hands moved between bottles and tools with the kind of muscle memory that came from doing this thousands of times. The rum poured without a jigger, the lime squeezed and strained in one motion, the shaker handled with a flip that looked effortless and absolutely was not. Forty seconds, maybe. He poured it into a coupe glass, set it on the counter, and stepped back.
"Your turn."
Everyone shuffled into position at the individual stations set up along the bar. Milo drifted toward the end closest to Nico with the gravitational pull of a man who could not help himself.
"Quick question," Milo said, holding the rum bottle at an angle that suggested he had no idea how to pour it. "How much exactly?"
Nico looked at him. "Two ounces."
"Two generous ounces or two precise ounces?" Milo asked, tilting the bottle slightly as if that would help clarify things.
"Two ounces," Nico said, his expression unchanged.
"Right. And when you said balance — between the lime and the syrup, is there like a ratio, or—"
"Make the drink, Milo."
Talia made a noise that she tried to disguise as a cough. Cass studied the ceiling. I focused very intently on my own lime.
We made the daiquiris. Mine was decent — a little heavy on the syrup but drinkable. Cass's was precise, because Cass looked like someone who was precise about everything. Talia's was sweet enough to qualify as dessert, which she blamed on the jigger being "designed for people with steadier hands." Milo's was apparently fine, but he carried it to Nico's station for evaluation with the energy of a student submitting his thesis.
Nico tasted it. Paused. "Good."
Milo floated back to us.
"He said good."
"He did," Cass confirmed.
"That's — I mean, he's probably not saying that to everyone."
"He's said it to four other people since you walked back," I said.
Milo's face didn't fall. Not even a flicker. "But the way he said it to me was different."
The second drink was a mojito — Nico muddled the mint with a quiet intensity that made it look personal — and the third was a mai tai that involved four ingredients and a layering technique that none of us fully mastered but all of us enjoyed getting wrong.
Throughout the class, Milo found reasons. Reasons to ask about muddling pressure. Reasons to need clarification on layering angles. Reasons to carry his glass back for what he called "quality control" and what the rest of us called "another excuse to stand near Nico." Each trip was executed with manufactured casualness and returned from with the kind of forensic debrief usually reserved for post-game analysis.
"He asked if I'd done this before," Milo reported after his fourth visit.
"What did you say?" Talia asked.
"I said does making drinks alone in my apartment at midnight count and he did a thing with his mouth."
"A thing."
"The left side moved. Upward. Briefly."
"One millimetre of mouth movement," I said. "Basically a proposal."
"Mock all you want. I know what I saw."
The class wound down as the sun began dropping toward the water, turning everything gold and amber. We sat at the bar with our drinks lined up — the daiquiri, the mojito, the mai tai — and the easy noise of an afternoon that had been better than I'd planned for.
"Should we find somewhere to hang out for a bit?" Talia said. "It's too nice to go back to the bungalows."
Nobody argued. We took our drinks and went.
We ended up hanging out until the light started to fade, the conversation easy and aimless in a way that didn't need directing. At some point someone mentioned dinner. We got up and started heading toward the restaurant, cutting through the bar area. The open section that faced the beach caught the last of the light, and I glanced out toward the water.
There was a figure at the edge of it. Standing alone, facing the ocean, arms at her sides. Not rigid — just still, like she'd been there long enough to become part of the landscape.
Renee.
The group was ahead of me, already moving toward the restaurant, laughing at something Milo had said.
And Renee was standing at the water's edge, alone, watching the sun go down by herself.
I looked at her for a moment — the outline of her against the fading light, the distance between where I was and where she was.
"Ade." Talia's voice, somewhere ahead. "You coming?"
I watched Renee for one more second. She didn't move. The water came in, pulled back, and she just stood there, like she had nowhere else to be and no one waiting for her to be there.
"Yeah," I said. "Coming."
I caught up with the group. Milo was already debating what to order. Talia was telling him he couldn't have three appetizers again. Cass was walking beside them, quiet and content.
I didn't look back at the beach. But I thought about it all the way to the restaurant.